Good pizza, calzones and pizza by the slice. The food was very good, seating was limited but they do have extra tables outdoors.

Downtown was jammed, so to auggies we went. The reviews were all strong, easy call. Couple slices of grandmothers pizza. Very good, very good. Could have eaten more, than the slices. Shall return to the Augs. read more

I live in California and I was visiting my niece that attends Flagler College and we ordered pizza from here. I am not a huge fan of pizza so I was very pleased with the pie we ordered. My niece likes pepperoni and sausage so that is what we ordered. I normally only eat one piece of pizza; I had three and enjoyed all of them so much. Great place to get food from. read more

Excellent large yummy cheesy pizza, delicious mozzarella sticks- delivery man 10/10 HOT!! Will always order pizza from this place because the food was excellent but "the view" was FABULOUS!!! Considering ordering pizza again tomorrow.... read more

Went to visit my boy at school and grabbed some pizzas from here. Very good pizza at about the price you would expect for good pizza.

I love this place! And yes, i drive all the way from Jacksonville just for the pizza! Thank you for another awesome visit..and thank you for the rice balls for Jenn!! read more

I was with a party of 5 in total and we were scavenging St. Augustine for open restaurants to go or for pick up preferred. This was one of the closer more decently priced easy to pick up locations in a limited area where most restaurants were closed by 6 if not definitely around 9 when we were searching. We decided on this pizza place after their numerous good reviews showed good potential. We ordered a large half pepperoni half cheese, garlic bread and some drinks. The pizza was good and a great size but overall for the flavor of things it was pretty average. That said we ordered a pretty average dish, so I would like to try their food another time and give it another go. read more

The pizza and garlic knots were awesome. I loved that you could buy a whole pizza or pizza by the slice. Will come back here for pizza when we are in the area again. read more

Not sure if it was an off night or what, but our 2 pizzas were mediocre at best last night. Ordered light cheese on our meatball pie and it seemed like it had extra cheese. The crust on both pizzas were oddly uneven, perfectly thin in the middle and terribly thicker as it got to the edge. I hope this was a one time experience. read more

Real New York style pizza! Excellent customer service! Delicious food and a relaxed atmosphere

Delicious pizza at a fair price. Small dining area so we ate outside on King Street. Service was fast. If you want to pick up a couple of slices then this is the place! read more

Ordered food at 8:30. They accepted the order. Gave us a delivery time of 9:45. We waited. After 10 pm we contacted the restaurant, and what do you know - they were closed. Yes. Closed. No feedback. We're waiting for food it's almost 10:30. Yelp explained they would refund our money. Ok. That's good to know. Now what? My family is still hungry. How irresponsible is this for a business? Whether it's miscommunication from one place to another. This is unacceptable. There was NO contact made to use until Yelp called us at 10:15. Advice for management - take it or leave it... if there is a miscommunication and paying customers did not get the food they paid for and you lost money from a return - you lose every time. This is a communication problem and guess who owns it... Management. I had no issue ordering Five Star pizza. No communication with there. Maybe you need to talk to the competition on how to communicate properly with expectations. read more

Only in town for one night and didn't feel like dealing with the Historic area. Read some Yelp reviews and decided to give St. Augie's a go. Pizza was exccellent, folks were friendly, hassle was non existant. Felt like we were having pizza in Augie's home. Very relaxed and comfortable. And the pearls were a nice touch! read more

Pizza was great and service was friendly. Definitely recommend. Best New York style pizza way south.

Please please PLEASE do not waste your money here. Called in an order for 3 pizzas with light cheese requested. ( price 70$ total) went inside to pick it up and the pizza was literally cheese bread there was no Sauce on any of the pizzas! Asked why there was no sauce and the cashier said "you asked for light cheese so I figured you want light sauce too". Obviously I didn't order or request that, and I don't think it's right to make something the customer didn't even request. On top of that she said she couldn't even refund the full amount and gave me half of my money back! This place is the worst and I would NEVER recommend going here, save your money and order from dominos or Pizza Hut at least you actually get sauce on the pizza. 1 star, save your money!! read more

Very good, crust was chewy but a bit "bready", however honest good New York pizza like you get in NYC. Would go again.

Stopped in just to try one slice and give it a rating. I highly recommend this pizza. It was very good and I wish I would've gotten more.

Amazing White Spinach Pizza (I added garlic). Excellent hand tossed crust, generous toppings. Best pizza in a long time read more

Pizza was never delivered...waited 2 hours. Called and was basically told once the pizza leaves their restaurant it is not their problem. Horrible experience don't order pizza from here read more

Delish!!! Accidental find and so glad it was! Folks are nice and service was quick. Parking available in front of the restaurant as well.

Never fails to satisfy me. Amazing food and great owners and happy environment. Pizza is out of this world

It was good, we ordered take out as we were staying in Vilano and craving some pizza but wanted to be at our nice Airbnb. I am glad we chose home though because it is kind of small inside and not the best looking spot. Pizza was good and staff was nice so I would choose it again for to go! read more

Very fast service if your hungry! Pizza good-not the best I've had. Good deals! Nice ambience-very relaxed! Very nice place & excellent service! read more

St. Augie's Pizza - Front counter - Italian Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

This is great NY style pizza! I took everyone's suggestions and tried grandmas which was burnt so that's the only reason for the loss of a star otherwise fantastic flavor and clearly a family straight from NYC very authentic experience! Keep up the great work read more

Good pizza. Wasn't crowded when we get there. Do yourself a favor and get the garlic bread also.

Wow, this was some surprisingly good NY style pizza. We also got garlic knots and they were good as well (just not as good as the pizza). It was a thin crust that wasn't floppy but also wasn't crispy. It was soft but firm enough to not flop much (if that makes any sense). The sauce, cheese, and pepperoni were on point. The sauce was just the right amount of spicy. The cheese was exactly what it needed to be (gooey and delicious), and the pepperoni wasn't overly greasy. The whole family loved this place. Aside from the food, the service was very accommodating and the prices were great. It's something of a hole in the wall, but in all honesty, most good pizza joints are. We will most definitely be back when we are in town and a pizza craving strikes. Big thumbs up for this spot! read more

St. Augie's Pizza - Italian Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Ordered delivery - an 18" pizza and garlic knots. Garlic knots were really good! Pizza was excellent - my folks have had a hard time finding pizza they like in the area, and they loved it. Menu is a bit small (not a lot of apps), and toppings were expensive ($3.50 each - so our pizza ended up being something like $35). But overall we were really happy! read more

Recommended by the @St Augustine Distillery and they were right. Sweet little family friendly place with slices and pies to order read more

St. Augie's Pizza - Pizza just like we like it. Thin crust with good stuff and sauce! - Italian Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

Excellent pie. I'll pay the extra $$ to eat here. Nice owners. Parking available. I wish they had A/C turned up a tad more.

Delicious pizza - the dough was a bit chewy but very tasty! Hot wings tasty but not super hot like hubby likes them. Salad was excellent - super fresh!! It was a delivery order and we didn't receive any disposable utensils or napkins - but I always bring some when we travel so no big deal there. Overall good food. Just an FYI the code you gave me for free delivery with Bite Squad didn't work - it said it had already been used. Update - we reheated leftover pizza the next day in the microwave (because in a hotel that's all we have) and wow!!! Still so yummy!! Would definitely order your pizza again - DELICIOUS read more

The service was great. Pizza was very good but very light on toppings. Be sure to request extra of the toppings you particularly like. Would order again read more

Stopped here while on our family trip with the kids. The pizza was AMAZING!!! One of the best pizzas we've had! Cute little pizza shop and the employees where very nice and friendly. Great service. Whenever we decide to visit st. Augustine again we will definitely stop here! read more

This spot looks amazing but it got me really sad when I walked inside the place and the cooks were no wearing the mask. We really wanted to try their pizza, but thought it was disrespectful that they were not following CDC guidance read more

Great pizza. Friendly staff. Accommodating to dietary restrictions, including gluten and dairy free.

It's now been 2 1/2 years that I've been using this pizzeria I keep trying different things the other night I had a pizza which is always excellent and I ordered an eggplant Parmesan hero it was phenomenal the owners the workers of this place are fantastic if you haven't tried this place yet I suggest you do. it is the best pizza out of all the pizzerias that I've been to in Florida and I'm from New York so I know what pizza supposed to taste like. Thanks read more

Absolutely authentic NY style pizzeria! With slices in the case. Awesome for just popping in for a few slices and a drink when your in a hurry. No hustle and bustle of the downtown parking. The garlic knots and stuffed broccoli pie slices are unbelievable! I recommend you check this up and coming pizza joint out. St Augustine's next big secret is pu read more

St. Augie's Pizza - Talk about Creative AND delish!!! Happy Valentines Day at St Auggies pizza tonight - Italian Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

First stop upon arrival to ST Augustine and won't be the last. Delicious food especially the pinwheels!!! Friendly and helpful staff.

It's nice to have delicious NY-style pizza in town! I haven't had a bad slice yet, and it doesn't matter which one I choose. The flavor and consistency of the crust is perfect for pizza. (I saw Augie making fresh dough today. It doesn't get any fresher.) The cheese and tomato sauce are also good quality. This is how pizza should taste. read more

St. Augie's Pizza - Stuffed veggie pizza with a side of marinara. Delish! - Italian Near Me - St. Augustine, Florida

See all

I happened to be reading about another pizza place struggling, and read this new place pitched and and donated cheese and sauce to help...I thought that was pretty classy, so decided my next pie had to be here. Read some reviews, and comments...sounded good...well let me tell you, it isn't good, its great! For those familiar with St Augustine, its rough finding a really really good pie...pizza Time, on st George st was the closest to perfection, but with heavy tourist traffic, a cash only, high prices, and a genuinely rude owner, I was due for a change...found it here. Crust, perfectly done, precise balance between cheese and sauce. (I should point out I always judge the merits of a good pizza based on plain cheese). THIS PLACE IS EXCELLENT! I'll go back again, and again and again... read more

I happened to stumble upon this place as a college student one day after class, I have been hooked ever since! They serve not only cheap pizza, but amazing food here! This place is a NY style pizza gem. Atmosphere: Limited seating, but mostly a packed restaurant from open to close, lots of locals love. Service: Excellent even ordering phone service. They are always friendly, and the food always comes out within 15 minuets. Food itself: I have tried so far a large cheese pizza, and the ziti with Meatballs, and Garlic Knots (Two separate occasions). Man, I have no idea how they make their sauce but it really reminds me of some New York places. It's perfect pizza. The cheese is not too melted, but melted just perfect. The Garlic Knots basically reminded me of home. Awesome. The Ziti was also wonderful. Cheesy, and real italian! This is one of the few real Italian joints in town. LOVE. Prices: Inexpensive but worth it for your dollar. Interesting information: Student discounts offered, They deliver within 3 miles (Yes they will deliver to residence halls) Good for: Lunch, Dinner, a quick snack while walking with starving family. Would i come here again: Well i guess i am sort of a regular now, so yes i would come here again. They treat students wonderfully and i really love the food. Waaaaay better than Camillos. Cheaper too. read more