Overall, it was pretty good. The service was decent. Unfortunately, the food took a really long time to come out. For a pizza and a Greek salad, it was borderline an hour to get both. This was at lunchtime when it wasn't very busy at all. I started to think they had actually forgotten about the order. There was also a pesky fly that just wouldn't go away. When the food came, it was pretty good. The thin crust pizza was very tasty and loaded with toppings. And the Greek salad, which came well after the pizza, was great. Fresh lettuce, Kalamata olives, tomato, feta and abundant Greek dressing on the side. We ordered the $4.95 protein-shrimp on top. Asked for them grilled and they came out beautifully. Correctly grilled and tasty. Large jumbo shrimp, a whopping 9 of them on top of a small salad. I'm guessing they may have been frozen, which is why it took so long to make the food. And perhaps they gave us extra since we waited so long. But the add on process is the same for either a small or large salad, so that could play a role. Overall, the food was tasty but the wait for it (despite ordering almost immediately upon being seated) was very long. Don't risk it if you're in a rush to get back to work! Will give it another try when we have much time to spare. read more

Stags Tavern opened recently in the old Sports Corner Bar & Grill location. I wasn't a huge fan of Sports Corner, but was open to seeing if Stags was any different, especially when I saw they had $4 burgers on Mondays. My family came with and we dined in for dinner. I ordered a cheese burger with an extra patty and sour cream & chive fries, my wife got a cheeseburger with tater tots, my oldest kid got a cheeseburger with regular fries, and my youngest got a grilled cheese with regular fries. We also got cheese sticks and six wings with Jamaican jerk sauce. The cheese sticks weren't huge, but we got eight in the order. The cheese was on the sharp side, so clearly not mozzarella. They were fine, but not my favorite. I vastly prefer rub to sauce on wings, but I'm a sucker for Jamaican jerk flavor so I wanted to try them anyway. There was plenty of heat and some Jamaican jerk flavor, but like the cheese sticks, they weren't my favorite. I wouldn't get this flavor again if I get the wings again at all. The kids grilled cheese looks like it was a good size. He ate it without complaints. The tater tots, sour cream & chive fries, and regular fries were all good. The regular fries seemed like they might have been lightly battered and were my preference of the three. We all thought the burgers were great. The patties seemed like they were hand formed and not out of a frozen box, which is very appreciated. I thought the seasoning tasted like McCormick Montreal steak seasoning, which is fine in small amounts, but can overpower a burger real quick if overseasoned. The Monday deal is $4 for a quarter pound burger and you can add a side for $4 more. Make sure you specify that when you order and don't just say "a cheeseburger with fries" because they will charge you the regular menu price for a larger burger with fries. My wife and oldest son didn't think to specify the $4 burger and the server didn't clarify which size they wanted, so we didn't discover the mix up until we got the bill and it was $10 more than expected. They were able to adjust it for us, so it all worked out in the end. I look forward to coming again on Mondays for the $4 burger deal and checking out their other menu items and specials, especially the Friday fish fry. read more

See all

The daily specials are great especially rhe half price smash burger in Tuesday and tacos on Thursday. Bright clean restaurant with handicap parking and entrance ramp read more

Excellent food and service and was perfect for our whole family!! Fish fry was very good We will be back!

Went last Friday for fish fry. 2 fried cod, 1 baked cod, all with potato pancakes. Also had mac n cheese for the table. Everything was excellent and portions are large. The server was efficient and very pleasant. Prices are responsible. We are all pleased and will return. Stags Tavern is highly recommended. read more

We've tried to give this location multiple chances and it's the same terrible service every time. We sit on the gambling machine and spend a good amount of money. There's no greet from anyone, you go to the bar and the bartender always seems inconvenienced, ask a waitress for a drink and she rolls her eyes and says she guesses she can help and closing out there's no "have a good night!" Or "thanks for stopping in!" It must be a place where you matter if you're known. It's a shame because we live nearby. So we could be regular but the experience is the same every time. read more

Sat there waiting for service on 7/4/25. Watched a gentleman walk in 5-7 minutes after us and get served a beer immediately without even ordering it. One would assume that patron was the bartenders boyfriend as she proceeded to talk with him as well. We decided to leave shortly after and go elsewhere. read more

Amazing food and serious portions! Fish fry and big boss sandwiches were incredible! Will be back again soon! read more

Great tavern!!! Great food, the burgers are delicious!!!! Great company, the kind of place where you just feel welcome when you walk in. We will be back for sure, highly recommended to anyone!! read more

Stags Tavern - Stag over burger and fries with a pickle! 1/2# burger, cheddar cheese, bacon, fried egg and sriracha aioli! Delicious!!!! - Burgers Near Me - Germantown, Wisconsin

After a long Monday, I did not want to cook. I pass this place every day and saw it was a new name & new ownership. Tonight we thought we'd check it out. Totally impressed! We ordered pizza, boneless chicken and sour cream & chive fries. The pizza was absolutely amazing, the food was fantastic!!!  I'm so excited to have a place where the food Is great and a place to hang out with my girlfriends & its close...I am so happy.  This place was remodeled. the food is so good, definitely check it out!!! read more

Stags Tavern - Burgers Near Me - Germantown, Wisconsin

See all

Ended up leaving because after 10 mins no one had come to the table to even acknowledge my existence. Definitely would not return to this place. read more

If the place wasn't so loud, it'd be great. It was packed on a Wednesday at 5:00. We got a table in the bar area, and our server was there 2 minutes later getting our drink order. All night long, the service was friendly and prompt. The food was better than I was expecting. The place has a roadhouse feel to it. I had a gyro and my wife had a chicken sandwich and both were way above average for this kind of place. Great food and service. So what's not to like? It's LOUD! We probably won't come back. But we had a pretty good experience. read more

Tonight was only my second time here, but I will become a regular! Absolutely love the fish fry/baked Homemade potato pancakes absolutely delicious ! We got in right away. Service was phenomenal. It looks like Monday night is ladies night with fun events! Bar manager actually came up and asked how everything was super nice touch!! read more

It brings me great pain to give this establishment only two stars, a rating I have never doled out. CONTEXT: me and my squad went to Sports Corner Bar (what this place was previously) on the reg for piles of hot buffalo wings. Sure it was a dive, but the beers were cold and cheap and the wings were hot and plentiful. STORY: When we saw this place was under new management we were skeptical but hopeful. "Stags Tavern" sounded pretty solid to us, probably going to be the same old experience. Upon walking in we could tell that we weren't in Kansas anymore. This place was really gussied up upon walking in. The ambiance had a real lady's touch now. What has happened to our place which cared little for appearances but much for camaraderie, spirits, bar food? We became skeptical. When we saw the menu, we guffawed, "basic" we thought. I mean, everything seemed nice, but the offerings struck us as anything else one would find on the menu of any millennial-run establishment (full disclosure: we are millennials and do not know the status of new owners). They may be quite tasty but we were only here for wings. Having two sizes of wing orders in its own menu section, with many sauce options, it's surprising none are actually spicy. We ordered wings and asked if their hottest sauce was actually spicy. The young server (not to be mistaken with Bobbi, a true bartender who still graces this bar following its transition) asked if she should bring us Tabasco. "What?" We thought. TABASCO?! RIP to our wing joint. I'm sure this place is great for most things, but it just isn't what it once was. Everyone was very kind and I wish them the best of luck. I'm just a fella who misses his wing joint where memories were made and mouths were lit ablaze. read more

Friendly place. The food was good and so were the drinks. The server was really great about making recommendations for my friend who is a fussy eater. read more

Service was perfect. Food was very poor. My $19 smash burger was ok, but nothing special. The fries although, were soggy the second they came out. My wife had the same problem with her fries, and she didn't even finish the "little" patty melt. Hardly any onions or cheese. We will never go back to Stags. read more

We stopped in eith friends on a whim as there were a number of vehicles in the parking lot which indicates it's a popular place. We weren't disappointed at all. The beers were ice cold, the service was great and the four different items we ordered were large portions and excellent. Will definitely be back! read more

'Great' Atmosphere!, 'Great' Food/Drinks! and 'Great' Activities! Love this place! I'm so glad that they are in our area!

For our first time here, we were not expecting the food or service we received. The food and our server Jessica exceeded our expectations and were amazing! We will definitely be back again! read more

Nothing special, the food is straight out if the freezer jst like most places. Nothing from scratch. The place is clean