The big girl working the cash register was an absolute displeasure and was very gross looking. Said my name once to come grab the order and as I'm grabbing the order complains to her co-worker how I wasn't listening and how long I took to come get it. Also most below average scallion cream cheese I've ever had. Good day, thanks! read more

Very good bagel joint! I had the Frank the Tank on an egg bagel and enjoyed it. I felt like I was in NY, staff was friendly, service was prompt, and bagels were delicious. What more can you ask for? They have a sign out front advertising a new location in Cape Coral coming soon. read more

Stuff A Bagel - Bagels Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

Bagels are top notch-almost as good as it gets. Pricey, but Tuesdays you get 18 for the price of 12 bagels. I freeze them myself. Try to get a Taylor Ham, egg n cheese in SWFL-they look at you sideways! This NY Style bagel store has it. But they should know better than slice the pork roll so thin you could see thru it. Any NY or Jersey THEC shop knows it should be sliced thick. I have gone to Bagel shops from Marco Island to Ft Myers and cannot find homemade, flavored cream cheese. This place has it in 6 varieties. My fiancé gets the strawberry, me the green olive, or maple walnut. Yummy! Really good NY Style Crumb Cake. It's a real WOW and well worth the trip if you just get a piece of crumb cake! Bialy? Who has these in Florida? The bialy here could compete anywhere! NO KIDDING! Looking forward to trying other pastries they have real soon! But it starts with the bagel-and this place is off to a great start! read more

The best bagels in all SW FL they make them as close to an NYC bagel you'll get in FL and they have pork roll which cant find anywhere else in SW FL the place has a cool vibe to it also they rep NYC hard all the workers are great i go there either on Saturday or Sunday read more

Absolutely delicious. The best bagels, homemade cream cheese, and just heaven in your mouth. Staff is very friendly. I would eat here everyday if I could!! The prices are very reasonable for the quality you are getting. I am in love with their asiago cheese bagel with olive cream cheese. I would recommend this place to anyone, it's a must try. read more

Stuff A Bagel - Asians cheese bagel with olive cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Cape Coral, Florida

Great place. Remember the name (not same owners ) from Ny. Prices are normal and the bagels are the best I had in Cape. I go at least once a week sometimes multiple times during the week to grab my egg sandwich with bacon and cheese. I Would and do recommend them. Only reason I didnt give it a 5 star was because it's too small.And when there is a line the door is constantly being opened and flies fly in. It's not there fault as that's part of Florida I guess. But when you add 4 tables and have a line of people coming in and out in a square foot range of 7ft x 15ft it can get a little cramped and uncomfortable squeezing in and out. read more

Finally. New York bagels! I also love the atmosphere. I do not know what other reviewers are talking about. Every time I go in the staff is warm, funny and charming. They banter with each other and seem to have pride in what they do. Go here!! read more

My husband visited Stuff a bagel on 8/25 to get Bagels and coffee.We frequent here often and never normally have any issues but today was a joke.The kid serving him had no idea what he was doing and completely messed up the order.My husband came home with the wrong food obviously someone else's order.He had also ordered 2 coffees one decaf as he has high blood pressure so cant have regular coffee the staff member never told him which one was decaf he had to ask and as the staff member didn't really seem to know what he was doing the coffee went down the sink as could have made my husband sick.Totally unacceptable service and will not be returning and most definitely will not be recommending this location again!!!!! read more

This place is awesome! Super good fresh made to order food worth the wait! Good for breakfast and lunch can't wait to come get stuffed

Good NY style bagels. I stop here every morning on my way to work

No need for a third chance! Check this one off your list and save your money. I am from NYC where we have the best bagels, but have eaten many great bagels around the country...this place is NOT serving them. Bagels are horrible and taste like they were probably frozen. I enjoy a proper lox and bagels, but this place only places a thin strip to save money. No red onion. No tomato. Cheap! Plus no napkins in to go bag and the bagels were not cut. There are better choices in the area for bagels and breakfast. Oui vey! read more

Lady at counter goes between preparing bagels and handling cash with no gloves and zero hand hygiene. On a lesser note, they had no coffee made at 8:30 this morning despite a line out the door. read more

This is a little piece of Long Island dropped rite in the middle of the SW Florida Gulf Coast - NY Deli at its finest! Bagels are made fresh daily in house, with a variety of flavors and cream cheeses to match. My wife and I went in for lunch, looking for some back home flavor - I had the New Jersey Turnpike, which stars Taylor Ham Egg and Cheese on a bagel or roll of your choosing . My wife had a great chicken salad sandwich. Staff was friendly and the food was great. If your looking for a good lunch or NY style bagels, check this place out. read more

Very disappointed. Surely can't be the same owners that were on Del Prado. Bagel sandwiches had little or no bacon and the rolls used for other sandwiches were stale and not a Kaiser roll. Go to publix for your rolls. Won't be going here again. read more

No! I don't think so. No parking. No real service. No good bagels. Been to all of them in SWFL and have to say this place is barley hanging on. I do not expect them to stay open with "imitation NY style bagels" for very long. Sad to say that the location on Del Prado was better only because parking and accessibility was a plus. Inside this joint, and I'm sure the new one opening off of Cape Coral Pkwy, the attitude and customer service will remain the dismal same. Besides, why compete with DD and Starbucks within a 1 mile square radius? read more

Updated review: I am happy to report that Stuff A Bagel has once again gone back to its roots being the best place to get an authentic salt bagel. The jerk that was running the counter on the horrible day back in 2015 hasn't been there in quite some time. I forgot that I even left a review back in 2015 detailing how the customer service at that time had seriously gone down hill. I recently received a note regarding that review stating that it was "false information." It was NOT false information. Why would I take the time to write a false review? Some people may have a negative experience, while others may have a positive experience...that's the point of Yelp. I look at recent reviews to decide if I'm going to try a place...I'm not going to look at a negative review from 2015...anyway...Go to Stuff A Bagel...get their whipped cream cheese. read more

Good place for a quick breakfast or lunch. The bagels are delicious, service is quick and friendly and prices are low. There are a few tables for eating in, and they have a cooler with drinks available. I usually order the "Jersey Turnpike" which is ham, egg, and cheese and is delicious. They also offer omelets and other traditional breakfast options. Keep in mind they close at 2pm! read more

Best Bagels Anywhere, period. Bagels are excellent, service is fast and friendly. If you're in the mood for a breakfast sandwich, make sure you try the "Jersey Turnpike". read more

Had no idea this little NY style bagel was even here! Quick, fresh and delicious morning bagels! Terrific breakfast or lunch option that are reasonably priced! read more

Best Taylor ham egg and cheese sandwich

Best Bagel I've had since I left New York 25 years ago. And real Kaiser Rolls. Gone back a few times, never disappointed.

Best bagels in town! Been going here for many years and they never disappoint. Chocolate chip bagels and the maple walnut cream cheese are my favorites, just not together! You can't beat a buck a bagel and on Tuesdays you buy a dozen and get a half dozen free. read more

The old lady has a bad attitude food is expensive and not that good. Always a problem with my order.

Absolutely wonderful! Hubble had coffee cake-soft, sweet and fresh. I had bagel with maple walnut cream cheese-yum!

It would be nice if someone told the staff on Pine Island/Skyline the importance of washing hands before handling food. I have been there twice. One time the guy behind the counter collected my money, made change and then turned around and made my bagel. Needless to say I through it out. Today my daughter went in there with some friends and the guy making their bagel didn't have gloves on at all. You couldn't pay me to ever step foot in there again. Anyone who goes there, watch how your food is prepared!!!!! read more

Frank the Tank on an everything bagel. Freaking amazing! The owner looks like he is in high school and is as nice as he could be. Smart young man. Eating at locally owned places like this, where they make everything fresh, is why I am glad I moved here. read more

This place had the best breakfast/lunch bagels I. The area!! My dad lives in NJ and the Bagel shops there are amazing! And the bagels here taste just like they do in NJ/NY and the pastries are to die for! Myself and my fiance love the chicken salad here! You can tell its all homemade. The staff is really friendly, the only reason i give it 4 stars is that they have messed up our orders a few times.. So we always double check. But all in all this is a good place :) read more

Bagels are awesome. They open EARLY. The Jersey Turnpike is everything a hungover gut needs. Only reason for 4 stars is that their coffee SUCKS. Bring your own. Other than that, great place, great family that runs it, and 5 stars for their bagels and breakfasts. read more

I feel like an ass. I recommended my family to come here instead of brunch at bonefish.. We walked in and was greeted promptly. As we waited to pay, one on the colleagues decided it was a great idea to pull out the tips, count them, then distribute them to his colleagues who were making our breakfast. First of all, You literally couldn't find anything dirtier to put all over the counter and in the hands of the people making our food. Is this a a joke?!?! Secondly, your customers having to ask to pay for their food isn't an ideal situation as a buisness owner. Get it together. read more

Best Bagel in the Cape. Try a Jersey Turnpike, you will enjoy the Pork Roll! Go Giants!!

I came here for the first time this morning and cannot wait to come back. The people who run this place are friendly, attentive, and generous. They threw in some extra things for me today because they wanted me to try them. Who does that?! Their bagels taste fresh and their cream cheese tastes rich. Next time I come back, I will order their famous pork bagel breakfast sandwich. read more

Great selection, great food, and a slice of home (NY/NJ) atmosphere.

This place has a true Northeast feel. There are not many places in Florida you can get a pork roll, egg, and cheese but this place has it and serves it up right. Breakfast sandwiches are always good and the bagels hit the mark too. Friendly staff with quick service. read more

I'm a huge fan! Very respectful customer service! Joeys #1 in my book! New York New York!

Used to go there all the time I won't go back again rude nasty people working there. I don't care how good thier bagles are the new place on Del Prado is good and great people working there! read more

Amazing :) got a bacon egg and cheese on an everything bagel this AM and I was super impressed

Won't let me give zero stars. :(Walked in and stood there at counter. Lady who watched me walk in didn't say a word and I was the only person in there. Continued to ignore me. Looked filthy and Was not even greeted so I left. Will never go back. read more

Great combo of good food, fair prices and super-friendly service. I stopped by 5 or 6 times over the past few weeks while in Cape Coral on business and every time the guy behind the counter was looking after everyone like they were best friends. If you're in town and looking for a spot for lunch or breakfast, this is it. read more

Horrible experience!!! We ordered and then waited for our order. About 10 people behind us got their order and left, and we were still waiting. The bagels are not that great to worth the waiting. read more

Excellent!! Great bagels! Great service! And the corn beef hash is awesome! This is now my go to place when I have company over for breakfast and I want to have fresh bagels! read more