Delicious wraps, subs, salads, calzones, strombolis and pizza! Small quaint location right downtown. Excellent service!

Generous portions. Friendly staff. Good beer selection. The Supreme Pizza slices delicious! We'll visit again.

Terrific pizza, and great wait staff. Our family has fallen in love with Sugar Hill. I can't wait to try to cauliflower crust - our family follows a Keto lifestyle - but every time I have tried, they have been out. I've been told it is that good. The BBQ Chicken and the Margherita pizzas are fresh and amazing. I hope Kinston doesn't run this place off, like they are so prone to do with quality restaurants. read more

Food: 4.5 stars. Good NY style pizza. I ordered by the slice, could have used more pepperoni though but slice size was decent for the price. Nice thin and crispy crust. Cannoli are good too. Service: 2.75 stars. Not very well organized. People walk in and stand everywhere. You practically have to sneak up front to place your order. Staff forgot about my cannoli, and a slice of pizza on a colleagues order. There is no wine by the glass but wine appears on menu from what I heard from another colleague. read more

Great Pizza and Wings. Way better that the typical chain restaurant pizzas. Nice seating area just off the front door, able to enjoy dinner out in the fresh air read more

Being from New Jersey, I have had my share of "real" pizza. I must say Sugar Hill is right up there near the top of the list of great tasting pizza. Their garlic knots and calzone are also very good. Looking forward to trying more of their menu items read more

I lived in Chicago for a long time and it don't hold up to sugar hill pizza LOVE there pizza!!!!!! Can't wait to go back love y'all

We were headed home from vacation and decided we wanted pizza. I found Sugar Hill on yelp so we decided to give it a go as it had 4 stars. We were very pleased! It was delicious!! We 3 each ordered individual slices. The waitress brought it out within 10 minutes. I like local Pizzarias and this would be a do again for sure!! Plenty of pepperoni and mushrooms on my pizza slice. Price was very reasonable. Thanks for a great experience Sugar Hill!! Best of luck to you guys!! read more

Best pizza in Kinston, hands down. Great location in downtown beside Mother Earth brewery. They have a great beer selection as well. New York style pizza that is handmade in house. read more

See all

Needed a place to eat during our trip home. Our son asked for pizza. Found Sugar Hill Pizzaria on yelp and decided to give it a try. Very happy we did! The service was quick! Staff very friendly! Great atmosphere! The pizza was delicious! Our son had the basic pepperoni and my husband and I shared the Supreme. Crust was perfection!!! Will definitely return on our trips through! read more

One of the best places to eat in all of Eastern North Carolina. Service is always good, food is always hot and the prices aren't terrible.

Sugar Hill Pizzeria brings authentic, EXPERTLY PREPARED Brooklyn style pizza to a severely underserved area. The pizza is STELLAR! The service is a bit slow, but worth the wait. read more

Sugar Hill Pizzaria - Sugar Hill Supreme pizza is AWESOME,! - Italian Near Me - Kinston, North Carolina

See all

Drove through the city feeling a little hungry. Decided to check the place out. The service was absolutely off the charts. Nice cozy environment, very reasonable prices, clean, and amazing food. What topped it all off was Mrs. MC. She was very welcoming and gave great recommendations. Will definitely be worth my hour drive to come back again. read more

Ok, this is my favorite pizza. We stopped here on our way through Kinston because we called and asked if we could let our dog sit with us in the outside eating area. When I tasted the pizza I was hooked. Can't wait to go back for more. Husband said his steak and cheese sub was great. read more

This place rocks! The pizza was scrumptious...generous toppings and crust just perfectly crunchy! My husband said the chicken parm sandwich was awesome, too! The atmosphere is just great and wait staff very friendly... Yep, I will be back for sure! read more

We LOVE Sugar Hill! A family favorite is the Veggie Pizza. Delish. We also love the mac-n-cheese bites and sweet chili sauce wings.

Cant order specific toppings. 1st time I ate there Pizza was pretty good. Crispy crust etc. The last 3 times were awful, under cooked and the last time so soggy, I took 2 bites, and threw my 2 pieces in the trash. No point in complaining, so I post it here. read more

Great supreme pizza tonight. The crust was just right not too thin or too thick. We thought the price was a bit high. We had two large pizzas as a take out order and the price was just over $43. read more

Garlic knots and sauce are the best thing I've eaten from there. Ordering an entire pizza is mediocre at best. The slices are pretty good, the same size as Brooklyn Pizzeria but not as good. Very expensive! Seems like the cool kids work there and like to chitchat with their friends while people wait to order. Gone twice, probably done. read more

Without a doubt it is probably the best pizza in town. Can be a long wait for a whole pie times, especially on a Saturday. They sell pizza by the slice for a quick lunch or just a snack for on the way home read more

First time loved it, 2nd time bad experience. Husband & daughter got their food right out, I waited & waited for my one slice of pizza, they forgot it, finally brought it out, not worth the wait bottom hot, toppings raw & cold! read more

I was not impressed by the pizza by the slice that I ordered. The crust was paper thin and burned at the edges. The pizza was GREASY. Way too greasy. I had to use 4 napkins to dab up the grease to make it edible. read more

After visiting Kinston for the weekend, my boyfriend and I decided to check out Sugar Hill on a Saturday evening after leaving an event. It had been a good 5-6 hours since we had our breakfast, so we were starved. When we got there, it was kind of busy but we decided on a Greek pizza and a salad and placed our order to go. While we were there, we waited for about 30 minutes and noticed that many people with large orders who arrived after us were getting their food but we were not. After asking about how much longer it would be, our pizza was brought from the kitchen a few minutes later at room temperature. Something that I noticed while I was there, too, was that the door to the kitchen was open and that I could look in. I could see people preparing food and I could see random guests going up to the door to thank the cook. This was very odd to me. We were asked what else we had with our order (which annoyed me because they should know), given our salad and we left. The pizza was actually really good. We ate a couple pieces and had some salad, but then my stomach immediately began to hurt. I tried to sleep, but could not sleep through the pain. It's then when I realized that I had food poisoning. After a long night spent in the bathroom and taking activated charcoal, my weekend was effectively ruined and I had to push back my return flight to go home an entire day and call out of work for the following day. The unfortunate thing is that not only did I get food poisoning, but my boyfriend's mom ended up in the bathroom after eating it and my boyfriend had stomach pain. I'm not sure if the preparation practices were unsanitary, if the food was cooked to the wrong temperature or if one of the toppings on my food was old, but the point is, I will never eat at this business again. They seem to struggle to know what they are doing and the fact that I had to ask if my food was done was a real problem. I had Pizza Hut the week before and although it was flavorless, I didn't get sick. I would suggest Domino's or Papa John's. read more