First time visitor to this highly recommended establishment & I hold them now in high regard. Why you ask? Service! We were a party of 8 and everyone knows larger parties are not easy to wait. Jordan did a phenomenal job showing patience and kindness to our family. All we wanted was a great time and good food at best, but we got 5 star treatment all around. Most of the family ordered filet mignon and loved every bite This is a must have dish if you're a steak lover. Apologies to the manager who assisted and BLESSES us. We noticed what you did for us *insert gold trophy emoji* read more

See all

I ordered a steak at medium and it came back raw. It took over an hour and it still came back like this. I sent the steak back and I got it back at about the same result. I am very disappointed for a restaurant known as a steakhouse. I was with a group of 10 people. I won't be back. read more

Sully's - Hattiesburg - Filet Mignon USDA Prime - Seafood Near Me - Hattiesburg, Mississippi

Okay is the word. Service was great. Price point was really good. Building and area was nice. The burgers were a little dry. The burger combos we tried were just off a little. The black and blue was runny. The cheese on the quesadilla was so runny that you could barely eat it, much less as a have held. I would not run steaming, or go hungry before eating here, but some fine running is needed. read more

Amazing experience at this establishment!. Literally the best steak I've had in my life. It was perfectly cooked, seared, and juicy. I had the 12 oz ribeye cooked medium well. It was flavorful from beginning to end. Paired with their house salad and fries, it was a culinary experience not to be missed. The service was excellent, and although packed, the wait was less than quoted. Jordan was our server and she was phenomenal. I enjoyed a 20 oz beer and a cookie dough cheesecake. Highly recommend this fine eatery if you're in Hattiesburg. The live music was the kicker, making it a perfect night. read more

See all

3 stars (was tempted to give 2) for being the most inconsistent, back-and-forth restaurant I've ever frequented. It's been a complete coin toss every time I've visited as to whether I'm going to have a wonderful or terrible time. On the good days, everything is as expected, service is prompt, the food is good, etc. etc. The steaks are quality, as are the burgers. On the bad days though, it's usually really bad. One notable example I feel I have to give: we arrived at 4:30, were seated immediately, but no one came by for 25 minutes, at which point we flagged down the first server we could find who informed us that "the server for your section isn't here yet" (then why seat us there?????) Then, when someone finally came by to take our order, they brought the wrong appetizer and a ribeye instead of the filet we ordered. The manager eventually stopped by to comp the steak, which is the only reason I'm giving 3 stars instead of 2. This is just one example of many times where either the food, service, or both have been lacking. Needless to say, don't bank on necessarily having a good time here unless you have some kind of good karma going on from helping an old lady across the street or something to boost your odds of a good experience. read more

A client suggested Sully's to me a few years ago, and since then I've eaten here countless times. I can honestly say I've never had a bad experience. The staff is always friendly and attentive, the food comes out hot and flavorful, and the prices are very fair. My go-to lunch dish is the beef tips -- always tender steak with onions, peppers, and rich gravy. Absolutely delicious every time. I've brought coworkers and even my family, and everyone has walked away impressed. Sully's is hands-down my go-to spot in Hattiesburg. read more

Passing through Hattiesburg we stopped at Sully's for dinner-- great choice! Great atmosphere, food, music and service, courtesy of our server, Allyson. My advice: order the crab cakes, some shrimp and some of their insanely delicious cheesecake! You're welcome! read more

Dinner on Monday 12/9/24. On a work trip so this stop was solo. Live music just inside the front door to the left, solo performer was really good! I grabbed an open seat at the bar, it was fairly busy. Bartender was a guy, he was friendly and knowledgeable of the bourbons and food menu. I enjoy the blackened Mahi with a side rice and gravy. Meal was delicious, Mahi cooked perfectly and the blackened seasoning was just right. Rice was also excellently prepared. Closed with a neat pour of Bookers 2024-01. Awesome surprise find in Hattiesburg! read more

See all

If you want a salty prime filet, this is your place. We enjoyed the house dressing as well. Service was top notch. The decor provided a great vibe for our business meeting. Recommend. read more

First time here, traveled about 1.5 hrs, we will make this more frequent. 10000% fantastic place! We have the 16oz prime ribeye, medium rare, a 6oz filet, and a 1/2 order of the sautéed crab claws! I rate it 1000/10! Service was 10/10. Atmosphere was 10/10, if the parking lot is full, park across the street in the gravel lot. Keep up the excellent service! read more

Sully's - Hattiesburg - Sautéed crab claws - Seafood Near Me - Hattiesburg, Mississippi

Great evening with friends on New Year's Eve! Highly recommend the Andouille Sausage and Pepper Pasta and the Pork Chops. Large piece of the smooth cheesecake to finish off a great meal. We'll will be back for more! read more

Great steaks and service. Not too fancy. Relaxed atmosphere. Don't forget to try the desserts

this place is absolutely terrible. When we first got in we had to wait for a table for over an hour-half, then when we finally got to our table, and ordered our drinks and food, our waiter disappeared for over 2 hours and we still didn't have our food yet. I noticed that the table behind us got their food before we did and they only been there for 45 minutes, I'm never coming back .Honestly that's the worse service I have ever had, they even had the nerve to make us pay 35 dollars for drinks. read more

Sat at the bar. Service was great BUT the cook took my medium well request on the hamburger steak to heart and burned it. Was very disappointed since I've heard such good things. My plate alone was $25 so I expect your grill cook to know what they're doing! I've tried this dish at least 3 times before writing this review. read more

I believe Sully's has violated the ADA guidelines by not reserving 5% tables for handicapped & not allowing handicapped to be seated at available tables that are handicapped accessable. It does no good to have handicapped parking but make handicapped patrons walk to the far away bar tables when nearby restaurant tables are empty, clean & available or require handicapped patrons to take high tables with chairs that handicapped patrons cannot climb up on. Obviously, the Management does not care to correct or address what I consider their ADA violations as no one has responded to my written concerns for over a month. read more

Liked my sully burger. Rest of the group had a Serrano sandwich and a quesadilla. Neither of them enjoyed it. Quesadilla was too runny and had to use a knife and fork to eat when normally I think quesadilla is a hand food. read more

The steaks here are the best! Everyone in my party ordered and enjoyed their steaks. The cheesecake sampler for dessert was also a big hit.

Today was a bad day. The food was terrible. From the overcooked filets to the chicken bites that were fried hard. Two Teradactyl pork chops with no flavor. The mashed potatoes that were dry and gloopy with thick gravy that wasn't going to help anything. The only thing I enjoyed was the bang bang shrimp. Of course I bragged and set the bar high before we drove an hour with my parents who had already had a long drive. I thought it would be worth it. Today was not. The service was slow but she more than made up for that with her pleasant personality. She's just one person and she was doing her best. This is my go to restaurant... this is where it's ok to spend the extra money because it's so good. Not today. I'm disappointed. read more

First time eating at Sully's. The food was great. I ordered the Daily special which was a half roasted chicken over roasted vegetables with a cream sauce. So good! read more

Highly recommend this place. One of the better places to go in Hattiesburg. Great food and super service makes this a must do.

We aren't much on steakhouses, but we flat out loved our dinner experience at Sully's! Quite honestly, we were initially enticed by the remarkable history surrounding the 1889 fight nearby that was won by John L. Sullivan, but that is almost incidental compared to the food, service, and atmosphere. My wife had the 6 oz. filet with baked potato and I had the 12 oz. NY strip with grilled asparagus. Both of us commented it was probably the best steak we'd ever eaten: cooked perfectly rare, so juicy, so flavorful. Our sides were also perfect, fresh and tasty. Accompanying salads weren't quite as good, but better than side salads most places. The yeast rolls!!! Because of gluten intolerance my wife couldn't have one, so this is my first chance to rave about them. Very nice bottle of Josh Cabernet Sauvignon with dinner. And Kylah, our server, was just as good as the food she served, friendly, helpful, comfortable, and very efficient. Photos on the walls of the fight and the fighters elevate the feel of being somewhere special. Our tab was $115 before tip, VERY reasonable for the meal we enjoyed and are still talking about 2 days later! read more

The food was really good, Chopped steak lunch special with mashed potatoes and green beans really good for a simple dish Chicken quesadillas were super good and favorable Service was average not great not bad, but it was satisfactory Bathrooms need to be attended to better, but other than that nice lunch stop read more

My favorite place for steak, hands down! I've been to the one on the coast several times and wanted to visit this one so my wife and I went by when we were in town. It is quite popular and stays busy, so if you don't go during an off time, be prepared to wait for a table. The steaks have that perfect amount of char and seasoning that really makes them stand out, and they also have a nice thickness to them. The sides and all are good, but this place is known for its steaks. I also highly recommend saving room for dessert. They offer a variety of cheesecakes and when you order a slice they give you a giant piece meant to be shared. read more

Great food, fantastic atmosphere, good entertainment. I strongly recommend this place. . We sat at the bar, and the service was awesome read more

See all

Probably the best restaurant in Hattiesburg! I was amazed on the portion sizes and the flavor my dish had! It was crowded for a Monday evening so i recommend a reservation. I will be coming back. read more

Sully's - Hattiesburg - Seafood Near Me - Hattiesburg, Mississippi

See all

What a fun, relaxed place--a classic southern roadhouse vibe, but from my first visit a place that attracts all types of folks, ALWAYS a good sign. We arrived for a bit of a late lunch and came away pleased and impressed. Friendly efficient service, much appreciated. Full bar if you are so inclined I ordered from the blue plate specials. Hamburger steak --grilled well and cooked to order. Real mashed potatoes, not lumpy, thank you. Great Lima beans--seasoned with bacon. My spouse went for the "light" burger and had no complaints. Solid onion rings. Very reasonable prices. Needs to work on parking because this joint, just off historic US Highway 11south of the bustle of Hattiesburg, is popular. Deservedly so. read more

Sully's - Hattiesburg - Blue plate special of hamburger steak with Lima beans - Seafood Near Me - Hattiesburg, Mississippi

See all

Great food and service and occasionally they have live music at their Petal location.

Ordered to go on our way home to Gulf Coast. It was awesome. Had Hamburger Steak with Baked Potato and Salad. Perfection even when warmed up. read more

Great service! We had the steak and the specialty (Oreo flavored) cheesecake both were amazing!

Very good dining experience for my family! We had an excellent Mother's Day meal and special time.

I echo the comments of others, my burger was too salty! However, the fries were amazing and so were the staff! Plus there was awesome live music playing. I live out of town and will definitely come back to try different entrees. read more

Delicious food! This makes 2 separate visits with the same great quality service (Kylie was my last waiter) and a great quality taste! When you walk in and see the bar,tables, and waitresses you know you've arrived at a quality restaurant! read more

Sully's - Hattiesburg - The Middle Weight Burger The Middle Weight Burger - Seafood Near Me - Hattiesburg, Mississippi

See all

Sunday in Hattiesburg Good burger,convenient location,great Bartender and live music. That did it for us. We will be back. read more

The ambience which I failed to mention in my prior review is among the top 10 in the state in my opinion once inside. Outside could use some better parking or labeling but inside is dreamy read more

Let me preface this by saying that I usually have good experiences at Sully's and I will be back. This time was just a fluke. CONS: * Sully's needs more interior light. It's a falling hazard for elderly people for sure and can be hard to navigate. It feels like a cave at night. It took a while for my eyes to adjust and the members of my party mentioned that it bothered them as well. *The place was incredibly loud. It sounded like a football stadium in there. I had to raise my voice every time I spoke to someone across our regular size table. It was insanely loud and hard to relax because of the noise. It was really hard to enjoy the meal without asking someone what they were saying three separate times. My party came in at 7:30. Maybe choose an earlier dinner if you want to avoid the extreme noise. *The filet special was really disappointing. I honestly really considered ordering something else, but I didn't as I had already eaten some of it and didn't want to wait for something different. The steak was dry (I got it medium), the potatoes were ehh, and I didn't even try the asparagus. The side salad was nice. It was definitely a letdown from what I expected. It wasn't good. It was also like $45. It was extremely disappointing. I got excited by how it was explained to me and it was a letdown. I also didn't realize that it was so expensive. I would have been much better off with a burger. Skip the filet special. *Prices. Be prepared to pay quite a bit for the food. For a party of four who got two specials, a steak, a normal (cheaper) menu item, and two desserts, the bill was $178 before a tip. (We tipped well, so it was much more than that.) Then again, I didn't think to ask how much the specials were. I will be sticking to the main menu from now on. While the food is good, it is definitely not a place I can afford to go to multiple times a month. (Please remember to tip your server well!) PROS: *Our waitress was FANTASTIC. She frequently filled our drinks, checked up on us, and got us everything we needed. * The flounder special was actually really good. The crust on the flounder was really good and complimented it. Someone at my table said it was a little dry, but not enough to dislike it. I got a bite and loved it. My only issue was the broccoli. It had way too much garlic and I couldn't taste much of the broccoli itself. *The beer rolls are really good. Pair them with cinnamon butter. Just do it. *The Banana Pudding Cheesecake is divine. I get it almost every time I come here. I could eat it all by myself. The slices they give are HUGE, and the cheesecake is delicious. I definitely recommend. My table got the lemon blueberry cheesecake as well, but it wasn't as good. Maybe it's just not for me. The others at the table liked it, but only ate about half. The banana pudding cheesecake was almost gone by the time we left. *Live music. My party was on the side opposite from the bar area, and we could still hear the live music. It sounded pretty good. *Even with the place packed like sardines, for four completely different and complex dishes my party waited only 25 minutes. My party is patient and wasn't in a hurry. I know this may seem like a lot of time to some people, but to me, it was quick service. The place was packed from wall to wall. Kudos to the kitchen staff. ***** Overall, I still recommend this place. Sully's has great food and great service. It honestly just depends on what food you get as to whether it will be good or not. Most of the food is really good and I have not ever really had any problems here. If you're sensitive to loud atmospheres, definitely get here earlier, as the louder and bigger crowds come in later. read more

See all

This was a wild experience from the moment we walked into the door. The manager literally power walked over to us and aggressively got in my face in regards to my very obvious service dog. He proceeded to ask me for papers. There is no such thing as papers. The Americans with Disabilities Act clearly states that and he should have known as the manager. I informed him to look it up but he wasn't really listening and didn't seem to care. He came off very rude and fidgety like he had a power trip, was on drugs or maybe both. Food was extremely over priced for the quality and what you get. We ordered the south of the border egg rolls which were just okay. Longhorn's makes the same type of egg rolls but way better. We ordered the steak poboy at medium temp. It came out extremely under cooked. We ate the ends where it was Med-rare but did not touch the rare center. To claim as being a steak house it's really unfortunate to not be able to cook steak. Ordered the banana cheesecake. It had artificial flavoring and it was really subpar. For the price it should have had fresh banana slices and cream. As we were finishing our meal the table across from us started screaming and the lady got up. A roach crawled onto her while she was dining. Not a great finishing experience after all that happened. The server, bless her, was the only positive I can say about this place. read more

Sully's - Hattiesburg - Supposed to be a medium steak. It is indeed rare. - Seafood Near Me - Hattiesburg, Mississippi

The service was excellent. Their sautéed crab claw appetizer was delicious and It was one of the best steaks I've ever eaten!

Hello, Asked the server, who then asked the cook, and then we were told that the cook does not use separate fryers for fish and fries. I seriously doubt that the owner knows what the cook is doing....unless they stand over them every day. Thank God the cook is honest about how they use the fryers. In addition, we were charged extra for getting green beans with burger instead of fries....that are cooked in same fryer as fish. (ACCORDING TO THE COOK) I messaged the owner in private but the owner never responded. read more

We were meeting my sister at this restaurant for dinner. She had heard of good reviews of this restaurant. After we ate there, we talked about our experiences. My wife ordered the prime fillet butterfly well done with the mashed potatoes when it came out, it was not butterfly. It was only medium rare at best. It was sent back to the kitchen and when it came out the second time it was burnt and still not even well done. After that, she just that wasn't in a mood for it. I ordered the 20oz prime ribeye, it came out cooked correctly. My sister ordered the 16oz prime ribeye, it came out cooked, where it had a lots of fat and parts of it was overcooked. For the money spent, they are asking premium dollar for meat that is not being cooked correctly and a restaurant that is not fine dining. I ate at Southside Cafe the night before in Slidell and had a lot better experience than I had at this restaurant and they cooked it correctly for my wife and I. In Mandeville, Louisiana there is a restaurant called Gallagher's 527 they ask for the same prices of what this restaurant is asking and they are a lot better than Sully's restaurant. My sister ordered asparagus with her meal. She got five pieces of asparagus and it cost over six dollars and they weren't full length, just a little absurd! Female restroom has broken switches on the wall and the male restroom smelt of urine like it hasn't been cleaned in quite some time they need to do a better job of cleaning this place. I do not believe this is the best steak place in Hattiesburg if it is, this is sad. All three of us came to the conclusion before we left. This place is overpriced for the service and what they give you. read more

From the outside a legit dive bar vibe. Inside anything but. This place is awesome. Great food and drinks. Friendly Hometown vibe... Not cheap but excellent value and quality all the way around. read more

See all