This is a unique, fun Mexican place with lucha libre theme. Not sure how long they have been open but I finally tried it. What a great addition in Fountain Square. Inside there are not many tables but they have a nice patio seating area, which would be so nice when it's not cold. I ordered a torta and it was perfect for my appetite level as I was hungry- it had breaded steak (heavy on stomach, I need Tums with it but it's so worth it) and avocado, and more. So tasty. I highly recommend it. Note, they are closed on Wednesdays. However they have specials on other days you should check out. read more

See all

My favorite item to order at a Mexican restaurant is a torta. The menu has quite a few options, however, for the tortas, the majority have pork. I do not eat a lot of pork, so I went with the steak and egg option and it was very good. My friend got the one with turkey, franks and steak, and that one was savory. My other friend Got a chicken burrito and enjoyed it. They brought out three different kinds of sauces, and they all had quite a kick to them, but they were all delicious. The spicy one. I'm assuming had habanero, and that one, if you do not eat a lot of spicy food, Beware. They also have a bar and alcoholic beverages, which we did not try but will next time we come back. They do have their own parking, which is nice, and when it's nicer out, they also have a seating area outside. read more

Super Tortas Lucha Libre - Mexican Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Killer tortas! Couldn't speak higher if the food. So good. It was wrestling trivia night. So the dining room was noisy and crowded. And the staff seemed a little out of sorts. Maybe avoid trivia night. But definitely stop in and try the tortas. read more

Super Tortas Lucha Libre - Mexican Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

I cannot believe I've lived in Indy over a decade and never been here. It's so good, so unassuming, and so delightful. The torta I got (Brazil) was absolutely scrumptious- hands down the best torta I've ever had. The delightful woman serving us was truly pleasant and welcoming. I'll be returning often. This place is a freaking gem. read more

See all

If you theme a thing with wrestling, I'm going to like that thing. This place did not let me down. But to my surprise, it was how good the food tasted more than the decor that won the match for me. Tortas are not my first choice at a Mexican restaurant, but as their name suggests, Super Tortas Lucha Libre knows what their doing. The bread, the bread, the bread... perfectly firm to the hand but soft to the mouth. From there it's really about selecting your favorite ingredients for the inside, and I recommend the Alemana. Breaded steak and chorizo are like the tag team that has different backstories but comes together unexpectedly to win the titles much to the fans' delight! I was also impressed by the elote fries, and I used the salsa verde that came as a side with my torta to balance out the creaminess of the elote fries. The habanero and chipotle salsas were too spicy and smokey, respectively, for my liking. For the non-wrestling fans in my party of five, the Lucha Libre theme was just moderate enough to enhance the vibe rather than distract from it. There's a pretty prominent bar inside and ample patio seating outside to fit whatever size or mood you need. read more

Super Tortas Lucha Libre - Mexican Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

The tortas are fantastic, and if you want to replace the beef with chicken just ask them! The salsas were delicious, bread perfect, and melted cheese crispy and delightful. I tried the dessert; torta with Mexican jello. The texture is absolutely crazy, but it was good. Service was great and atmosphere chill. read more

See all

My friend and I came for lunch today. There was a lunch special for half a torta with fries and a drink. I ordered the Brazil torta which is the breaded steak, pineapple and mozzarella cheese. I enjoyed the torta- the half of it was more than filling. The fries were a little heavily seasoned but I didn't mind them. The inside of the space is nicely decorated with murals. The staff was friendly and helpful. read more

Super Tortas Lucha Libre - Mexican Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

This was a really wonderful experience. Service was top-notch. Food was even better then anticipated. Cool and unique atmosphere. This is a new favor of mine and I will definitely be back. read more

See all

Stopped in here for lunch on a Friday afternoon a while ago. Tacos were amazing and we got the dips to try as an appetizer. I got two steak tacos and my partner got one each of chorizo, steak and chicken. The steak tasted a little off in them like maybe it should have been pitched the day before... but the chorizo was incredible, the chicken had great flavor and the guacamole itself was worth the drive from Greenwood. The Michelada hit the spot, so good! read more

See all

Three cheers for a New Mexican restaurant in Fountain Square! The staff here are wonderful and the service was great! I have a gluten allergy, so I decided to try the some tacos and an horchata. The tortillas were super good and slightly crispy (which I loved)! I ordered a chorizo taco and also a carnitas, based on the recommendation of the guy who took my order. Both tacos were filled to the brim with meat! I could barely finish both tacos. The red salsa was super spicy and the green salsa was less spicy. Both had great flavor and paired well with the tacos. The carnitas meat was good. The chorizo was not my favorite. It was good, but a little on the mushy side. The interior is super welcoming and colorful! read more

See all

We just kind of stumbled upon this place looking for a taco Tuesday spot. They have a cool patio that we parked our bikes under while we went inside. The staff was extremely nice and insisted they would serve us outside with our bikes. The menu board inside showed specials for the day. * 3 tacos and a beer for only $10. The inside was very nice, clean and inviting. read more

See all

The absolutely hands-down best Tortas of my life. The bread is incredible and perfectly soft. The breaded steak is to die for.

Great service with recommendations, the food was hot and delicious. Got the Durango tortas el special. If you're a fan of wrestling this is your place to look around. It feels like you're in the ring of Lucha Libre. Very colorful, masks, art, wrestling posters. Give it a try, the food is great! read more

See all

Walking distance from the SVN deathmatch show I went to in fountain square. Food was banging! Shout out Danny and Sergio the Mario brothers laying pipe and taking shrooms they know how to make a damn torta! Alex helped us at the bar, dude was hilarious and very personable. We went In just for some drinks we got 4 jumex and he convinced us to get the tortas. Being from Miami I got the torta Cubana. Wow that thing is massive! The theme of the restaurant is Mexican luchador and they had AAA and WWE on tv. Super sick. Great experience! read more

Super Tortas Lucha Libre - Super torta sign - Mexican Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Amazing food and service! This is our new go to place for tortas. The Elote Fries are amazing. We love collecting the different luchador tokens in the draft beers also. read more

Super Tortas Lucha Libre - Poblana torta (chicken and chorizo) - Mexican Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

See all

Great food and great employees. Clean and quick service nothing to complain about. The sauces were great and perfect spice level read more

Super Tortas Lucha Libre - Mexican Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Food- triple yummy Service- triple good. He was so nice. Ambiance- love it 3/3, 10/10, bomb read more

The best!! I love this place. Atmosphere is amazing, as a huge wresting fan I loved watching Charlotte Flair suplex Asuka or a La Parka AAA match going on the other TV while I waited for a beer. The food was mind blowing. Alex did a great job serving, you guys are KILLING it. The salsas were great, the atmosphere was somehow equal. Can't wait to come back. read more

Super Tortas Lucha Libre - Mexican Near Me - Indianapolis, Indiana

Great food. Tortas are delicious. Wonky location but worth it. Super nice staff. I have dined in and carried out. Both equally efficient. read more

Wow is all I can say. I had such a great experience here! First of all I absolutely love the theme and decor. There's lucha libre books, pictures, masks, and even playing on the TV! I was immediately greeted and sat when I came in and brought a menu right away. The waiter informed me they are known for their tortas. He was very friendly and told me about what was most popular and what he liked. I went with the Pachuqueña, breaded steak, smoked pork, and mozzarella. It only took maybe 5 minutes to come out. The presentation was nice and he brought me all the salsas to go try with it. I highly recommend getting the torta as is, with all of the fixings! It was incredible. I also got a dessert, which was unique. A pistachio cake on top and flan on the bottom. It was excellent too. Not too sweet and I liked the mixture of textures. I will definitely be back to try more things here. More people need to be talking about this place!! read more

See all

Food was just OK, nothing really special, and pricey for what you get. Service was above average. Ambiance was unremarkable. I won't be returning. read more

Absolutely excellent. One of the best Tortas I've ever had. The place is Lucha themed and really cute. Excellent service as well would recommend. I'll be eating here again. read more

Wonderful and unique dining experience. Interesting menus and quality food and service

Food is awesome, love the atmosphere of this and the Westside location! Long time customer and torta lover. Love

This place is great! I've visited consistently since it opened and have had nothing but good experiences. The tortas themselves are excellent! The bread is nice and warm and the meats/cheese are cooked perfectly. There are many different torta options, so its easy to find something you'll enjoy. I'd recommend getting the Cafe de Olla coffee while you're there as well. The atmosphere is great with luchador art on the walls and wrestling on the T.V. The service is great as well. My only complaint would be that there aren't many options for vegetarian/vegan eaters as far as I'm aware. I think having substitute meat/cheese options available for the sandwiches would make the resturaunt perfect in my mind. read more

OMG- the sandwiches are very good. We go there champion and a Poblano, Elote fries for carry out and they were all delicious. The building is cute and the service was good! read more

Best sandwich I ever had! Had the Poblana with a horchata. Definitely worth a visit.

Excellent food and service! Ambiance nice. Great selection of food. Definitely recommend.