We came for a weekend getaway of 20 years together, we wanted a quick snack before a concert, by far the best pizza i've ever had in my entire life. read more

Great food! Excellent pizza. We ordered half BBQ chicken and veggies and was outstanding !!!

For takeout, the Pizza is great IMO. Slices to go are healthy portions that take up a whole plate but dont reheat the best. However prices keep rising and just make the cost not worth it. A 2 slices and can of coke special that used to be $7.50 is now like $11.99. A cheese pizza that used be $13.99 is now $18 after taxes(while still not that expensive compared to others). Which just makes it feel like taking advantage of loyal customers. During Covid this would have made sense, years and years after, not so much. read more

fast , easy service and $6 for a MASSIVE slice of pizza bigger than my head. buffalo chicken slice was delightfully tangy with a crispy crust. highly recommend eating outside at the christian science center! read more

Pretty solid pizza! Pepperoni was delicious. It's a casual sit down spot. I ordered ahead online on a Thursday night and was very easy to pickup in store. read more

Service was efficient however the pizza was very bland. Not much flavor and a bit greasy. Big slices though.

I'm gonna jump on here and say that Supreme serves MY favorite pizza in the Back Bay area. Robbie the owner and his 2 regular employees has always been friendly to me. I lived behind the place for a year, so we got to know each other well. I've had supreme at every hour of the day, consistency is definitely a weak spot, but overall it's always a good quick stop for lunch. The restaurant can be a little dirty sometimes but who cares. It's on Mass ave, what can you really expect. read more

Stopped in for a quick bite. It was basic, boxy restaurant space. Had a slice of pepperoni. It was sufficient. read more

Supreme Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Boston, Massachusetts

This place is fast and open late. If you're looking for good greasy late night pizza with thin crisp crust - this is it. Not the best pizza around but certainly worthy and hits the spot when you need it. read more

Pretty good lunch crowd every time I stop by. Try to avoid going around 12:00pm, that's usually when all the construction workers are there and it's usually hard to find a seat at that time. Best time to visit is after 1:30pm. The Slices are huge and filling. Their fried chicken is pretty good too. But don't go there expecting good NY slice Pizza like they advertise. It's OK at best. I know Dave Portnay gave a pretty good score, but the Pizza is definitely more like a 6.8 The service is great, the guy at the counter is always friendly and quick! I would recommend getting the small pies rather than getting a slice. If you do end up getting a small pie I would recommend the Brooklyn Pie, that's definitely read more

Supreme Pizza - Brooklyn Pie - Pizza Near Me - Boston, Massachusetts

The food was okay. The service was great. Quick order over the phone. Place was clean . Think they had the crushed pepper and cheese chained to the wall tho. read more

See all

Twice the price, half the size, forget about quality. the steak sub was PUNY for $13 and the couple teaspoonfuls of steak was all gristle and sinews. I came here all through 30 years of sc and work in the neighborhood and it was never like this, used to be full. No wonder the place is always empty now. STAY AWAY! read more

At first I thought the sandwich I bought was ok but then I found a quarter inch ball of steelwool in the sandwich.I showed the employees the steelwool and they did acted like it was no big deal.I would definitely avoid this place. read more

3 star rating seems accurate to me. Good for some late night food. Other than that, not so much. Place has average pizza. Not the cleanest. Customer service was good however. read more

See all

if you want a quick slice pizza this place is FINE. it's not terrible, but it's also not great. a bit expensive for a single slice, it'll run you about ~$5 depending on if they decide to give you your tip money back (they didn't). while i was putting some parm and pepper on my pizza my nose burned like crazy and idk what was up with that. anyway, service is okay, there was a hair in my friend's pizza. and the ambiance is just your everyday pizza shop. i'd come here again as a last option, or maybe for a cheeky slice. idk make up your own opinion i'm just a random girl on the internet. read more

Pretty subpar pizza, especially considering the price. Wouldn't go back. Employees were kind though.

Huge, delicious slices! No frills interior. Not cheap, but reasonable for downtown Boston.

Great Pizza served HOT! By the slice is practically a quarter pizza itself! Great service!

Good place to go to after coming home from a bar, since its pretty much the only thing up late in the area (2AM). The pizzas are thin and the very subpar in the flavor. They do give you a lot of pizza though since it takes up two paper plates for a single slice ($4.21). Make sure to bring some cash if you do want to order from here and want a single slice. They wont accept debit or credit unless you reach a minimum amount, which I normally reach with 2 slices. I wouldn't go out of my way to go here but if you're in the area and nothing is open, go for it. read more

Supreme Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Boston, Massachusetts

Everyone reading this. I think that there are 3 things worth considering. 1. Rats 2. Price gouging (if you get a full pizza, there is a 5 dollar box fee) and 3. The food is not good. read more

The food is great. The service is great! great lunch crowd everything on the menu is made to taste great. I really enjoy the good food at Supreme Pizza and the staff is great! read more

I would be lying if I said a perfectly sharp memory of being here. Supreme was the last stop after a long night out before heading back to the hotel. The line moved quickly and the prices were good. The shop itself is about the same size as most city pizza joints. It's in a good place downtown near a bunch of bars and clubs. Ended up ordering a slice of cheese and a slice of buffalo chicken. Both were indescribable. The buffalo chicken might have been the best I've had. The chicken was the good, the drizzling of blue cheese was a plus and both that and the cheese were cooked to perfection and fresh. The slices are also like really big!! I was very satisfied and it was the perfect stop before heading back for the night. Will be coming back when I return to Boston this summer! read more

Supreme Pizza - A slice of cheese and buffalo chicken. As you can see they're BIG slices for cheap. :) - Pizza Near Me - Boston, Massachusetts

The pizza quality here is actually pretty comparable to your run of the mill, satisfying NY slice. I mean that in the best way possible: a decent margherita slice might be pretty easy to find on any random corner of the Upper West Side, but it seems that most higher-quality pizza places in Boston are too gourmet and avant-garde for quotidian cravings. Most other pizza places selling NY style slices in Boston are simply bad (I'm looking at you, Chicago Pizza on Mass Av). We placed a large catering order for about a dozen pizzas, including some margherita pies, as well as a few NY white, veggie and pesto chicken pies for good measure. NY white was probably my favorite of the bunch. The catering was right on time and accurate, so no complaints there. read more

Taste:3 Presentation:3 Value:5 Service:4 Overall:3.75 Taste: the steak and cheese I got had a nice seasoned taste to it but was lacking the cheese of the steak and CHEESE had I known I would've asked for extra cheese Presentation: it was wrapped/rolled up in wax paper ready to go Value: somewhere around $8 bucks it was massive and stuffed Service: took quite a while to make but well worth the wait owner was mopping the floor was very nice everyone seems cool here Overall: next time I'll ask for extra cheese The sub was nice and toasted piping hot can see the heat rising up from the sub it was amazing read more

Served Burnt and cold. Saturday night should be fresh this is really not very good pizza. read more

The main guy in the beard will leave a line of customers waiting while he's standing around talking on the phone. He is incredibly rude and I've seen him swear at customers. The pizza in amazing, which tes you how much I dislike the customer service. read more

Perfectly pleasant pizza place - not anything special but it feels a need of you want a slice or sub. They also ya e decent fried chicken and surprisingly good salads which you can top with grilled chicken, steak, chicken or tuna salad. read more

I still have fond memories of walking through the Christian Science Plaza.. sitting by the reflecting pool and occasionally, when my Aunt would look away, dipping the tips of my fingers into the glossy water to feel the cool against my skin. Then we'd go down the street and buy calzone from this great little place that my nose would detect from 10 meters away. Pavlov had it right. Back then, I looked forward to calzone days like I did presents from faraway lands and Crunch bars. Supreme Pizza was my crack, and anyone who'd bring the goods back home my supplier, on whom my dependency (which back then was called love) would increase with each bite.. and slowly decrease again until the next calzone they brought me. I should've known, just as Crunch bars have stopped tasting so good, that there was a possibility that my love for this fatty drug may have also evaporated with the molding of standards, ideals, and personal preferences that came with experience... I should've known that something was amiss as I stood 1 meter away, waiting for the smell that stood me up, the mouth-watering anticipation that never came... Disappointment greeted me with a cold stare. The calzone was gooey, flavorless, and just plain awful. I couldn't even finish my half. 18 years later and I finally understand what Jeremy must have felt when we told him Santa wasn't real. read more

Supreme Pizza - The Signage [Afternoon, 10/07] - Pizza Near Me - Boston, Massachusetts

Mostly catering to the Berklee College of Music crowd, this place is kinda cool. Really old school tables and chairs, kinda ugly, but functional, like an old school pizza place should be. I generally get slices of veggie and pepperoni. They are tasty, fattening, kinda greasy, but for about $2.50 and $3.50 (per slice, depending on what you get) I get what I expect. The slices tend to be heated up so that the bottom crust is more crunchy, but all in all a cool experience. read more

Chicken tenders were crispy and juicy--exactly what I needed after a stressful day at work! read more

Supreme Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Boston, Massachusetts

Some Berklee students flee to this place to avoid explosive diarrhea they suffer from their *occasionally and potentially* lethal cafeteria food. Needless to say, I used to be one of them. Although I can't say that Supreme Pizza lives up to its name, their service is fairly consistent for a decade. Nothing stands out in their menu, nothing unusual or special. It's just basic. Plainly basic menu of common pizza parlor. Their pizza and sub can't make me go "Mm! Mmm!". But it definitely can make me lean back on the chair, rub my stomach and sing "Like a rock...!"(GM truck jingle) to praise the heaviness in my stomach. Was I satisfied? Yes. Did I regret? Yes. But whatever my thought or feeling may be, it always makes me leave with good grin on my face. This place isn't really worth a trip unless you have some business to do in surrounding area. And it is also good spot for late night craving as late as 2am. read more

I went to this place near the Berklee College of Music with a friend to grab a couple of slices, since we were craving for some pizza. Walking inside, this place looks like a really typical American pizza place from the 1970s or 1980s. My friend got a sausage pizza, while I got a Meat Lover's. The Meat Lover's Pizza consisted of sausage, pepperoni, and bacon as the toppings. The total for the two slices came out as $5.85, which is a somewhat decent price. My pizza was not great, but okay. Pizza was fairly oily, but not too greasy. I thought that they did not put much cheese and tomato sauce, which gave some blandness to the pizza. Pepperoni lacked flavor, sausages tasted okay, and bacon had some crispiness. As for the crust, it was nice and chewy on the inside, but thought it was slightly stale. My friend did not like her sausage pizza that much. The good thing about this place is that it is open until 2:00 AM and it's near Newbury Street and a good walking distance from the Symphony Hall, so it's not a bad choice for pizza after a night out in the city. Overall, despite that it is open late at night, it's not high on my recommendations for pizza, but it's not a bad choice for a few adequate and passable slices. read more

Supreme Pizza - Various pizzas. - Pizza Near Me - Boston, Massachusetts

I was one of two people here, and ordered a calzone. Tipped well, mind you. I waited thirty minutes before they asked whether I was waiting on anything. I said the calzone. Rather than admit they failed to pick up the order, they BS'd me and began making it in the back. Not a single apology, so 1 star warranted immediately. Out of principle, I will not be coming back. read more

So it looks like Supreme Pizza's rating might be lower because of someone complaining about the Door Dash service....that's unfortunate because this food is delicious. It's what you're looking for when you're craving a sub or a slice. I had to stop chewing to write this review it was so shockingly good. Completely satisfied. read more

This place suck! I'm a traveler from California and loved all the other boston and new York style pizza. Expect for this one!! Under baked in the middle and over baked on the crust. The cheese are like liquids in the middle which is so disgusting. I'm so disappointed in them read more

Supreme Pizza - This is what you call a pizza? - Pizza Near Me - Boston, Massachusetts

The pizza wasn't great, the woman was very rude at the counter... and they charged us $1 for a to go box. I don't know why anyone would choose to go here a second time read more

After waiting an hour for the delivery, order was incomplete, pizza was room temperature and mozzarella sticks were cold. Called back for missing items and had to wait over an hour. Representative was very apologetic but it didn't change the fact that I had to wait over an hour for missing items and that the original part of the order was cold. I wouldn't recommend it, I'm sure there's better places in the area. read more

When I got hungry at midnight with room service closed, the hotel reccommended Supreme. I could not find on Yelp a well-rated pizza place that delivered past 11 PM. I think the current three star rating is too low. This place is definitely above average. The crust was the highpoint. It had that perfect crunch and charring with soft cooked dough on the inside of each bite. The sauce and toppings were good but not remarkable. Admittedly, my more enthusiastic review may be because I am from the Land of Sad Pizza - South Florida. I'm sure there is better pizza than Supreme around Boston but I was still very pleased with my traditional pie with meatball (which turned out to be ground beef), pepperoni and mushroom. I recommend Supreme. read more

I am OBSESSED with the pizza here. By far my favorite place in Boston. It is SO crispy and delicious. It's that kind of pizza that you hold up and it doesn't flop over from being soggy - even when it's loaded with buffalo chicken (their best type, in my opinion). They are open late and you can order by the slice!! Great service too. read more

Supreme Pizza - buffalo chicken pizza - Pizza Near Me - Boston, Massachusetts

I love their pizza but the delivery quality is awful. I've waited an hour over my wait time for my pizza and usually it's at least 20 minutes late. Today was the tipping point. My pizza arrived 15 minutes late and was a mess and the crust was burnt. read more

Supreme Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Boston, Massachusetts

See all