Susies is located next door to the Daybreak Diner and the Dollar Store is on the other side. When I used to come here it was located on Westerville Rd. The fellow working told me that it had been there for thirty-five years. It's been in it's current location for eight years. I came down here yesterday to get a sub for dinner. I'd been here MANY times over the years but not in a long time. And I really don't remember why. The subs are pretty good. I got the Italian which comes with Italian lunch meat on an Audinos hard roll. For the last few years I've been going to Jersey Mikes. The advantage to Susies is that their subs are toasted where JM's are not. It's a different taste and I don't have any idea why JM's doesn't toast theirs but they don't. Anyway, I'll have to decide if I want to stick with JM's or not. read more

I stopped in the area of Susie's Subs today for another reason, while here I decided to order a pizza for dinner. As with most very small pizza/sub shops, it's a pretty minimal set up inside; They have room for a few people to dine in, but it's not really expected that you will. The atmosphere is designed for the employees to answer the phone, make your order and have you pick it up...not much else. I honestly don't fault them for that at all because, really, who orders pizza to eat it anywhere but in front of the TV? One thing I'm noticing about Columbus pizza shops, for better or worse, they all have the same style of pizza. They all mostly use the straight cut, probably the same pepperoni, etc. Honestly, I probably wouldn't be able to tell the difference between a few of them. If you've had Donato's, that's "Columbus style", although a bit more toned down for the masses. Fortunately for me, I really like the "Columbus style" of pizza. So, the pizza I'm eating right now. Yeah, it's pretty good. It's 3.5 or 4 star pizza, as far as I'm concerned. The price was decent for a medium one topping. I live close enough that I may order again, but not close enough that they'd probably ever be my very first choice. (On the way home, I just noticed a pizza shop a couple of blocks away that I need to try.) read more

Fuck them!! I thought they were good people but when you let someone in front of you order and then say to me well we're a little slow so were shutting down. FUCK YOU AND YOUR SUBS.... read more

Best Subs in the state of Ohio. I will always take a 15 mile detour to get here. The size is huge the Quality is as good as you will find and the price is always great. The Neighbor hood is pretty tough around it but in the lit everything is good. Try the big John it will surprise you. But the meatball sub is lunch changing! There good people doing it right ! read more

Susie's Sub Shop - The Lunch Changing Meatball! - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

This place is the definition of "Mom & Pop". Philly roast beef is amazing. Good pizza too. Will definitely be back.

Susie's feed me every other Friday dinner for most if not all of the 80s. That''s how much my family loved this local staple. The menu is deceptively pizzeria-stock/standard, but every item is unique to Susie's family take passed down through changes in generations and locations. A Linden area must try. read more

Service is not bad but that doesn't make up for the wait on subs I'm ordering 2 Italian subs I don't know if they have to butcher the meat then cure then cook it but it's not rocket science lol but going on an hour don't think they appreciate my money but that's fine this is my first and last time coming you won't be hungry by the time yours food done read more

Susie's Sub Shop - Sitting waiting years for some 2 subs "45 minutes" - Sandwiches Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Do yourself a favor and just try this place. I have had pizza all around columbus ohio and if you like thin crispy crust, fresh veggies and some flavor in your pizza sauce. GO HERE. Now for the sub...The big jon is the way to go. Oven baked with a bunch of meat and topped off with an italian sausage . Im tellin yall right NOW!!! This place should be called Susies Pizza and subs PERIOD!!! read more

This place is the real deal! My sub was one of the best I've had in a long time. Everything was crunchy fresh, the bread was soft on the inside and toasty on the outside. It was almost "what-do-you-want-for-you-last-meal" good! I'll be going back. The reason I didn't give it 5 stars is its location and the ambiance of the restaurant. It's kind of a hole-in-the-wall place mixed in with other businesses with bars on their windows. There are only three little tables inside, so it's mainly a carry-out place. But the food was exceptional! read more

Stopped by to pick up a pizza and a sub for me and a friend a few blocks over the pizza was way under no real flavor either. For what I paid i had bigger hopes. I'd rather pick up a hot and ready for 5 bucks for less with more flavor read more

I was pleasantly surprised at how dam good the was the pizza the bomb the subs they hit it out the park it's like pizza and sub you grew up on great job to all how work there read more

Since my initial visit to the establishment, I have giving it another chance or two or twenty. This place has definitely redeemed itself from my initial review and has become one of my favorite pizza places. I only get pepperoni pizzas, but they are amazing!!! My only gripe would be sometimes when I call I cannot get through which is a huge disappointment when your mouth is set on this. read more

This is a fantastic little pizzeria... I specifically Love it that it is family owned and operated, and they have been in business for a very long time, don't quote me but I think like 50 years. The pizza is absolutely fantastic, nice thin crust with crispy little edges... My favorite happens to be pepperoni sausage and mushroom, it is screaming good! I have tried many items including subs, salad, and everything has always been first rate. You gotta love it that they are huge Buckeye fans. This is really not a dine in so much, More of a carry out... this time I didn't even make it out of the parking lot before I had to tear into it! read more

There is something truly amazing about local food. There is something really awesome about Susie's. Located in the oft misunderstood and neglected North Linden neighborhood, Susie's is everything that a sub shop should be. The bread, plays a big roll in the deliciousness, delivered from local favorite Auddino's it is soft, and chewy on the inside, and has a really nice crunch on the outside when toasted. The ingredients are piled on, and taste very fresh, the amount of food you get for the price is above average. I enjoyed the Big Jon, which was their Italian sub, topped with a fantastic Italian sausage. when toasted a bit of crusty cheese brings it all together, in a fantastic melted sandwich of the gods. The cheesesteak, was also very tasty surprise. it comes topped with a healthy portion of fresh green peppers, onions, mushrooms and swiss. The shaved beef is moist and packs a good flavor. The wife thought it tasted better then cheesteaks in philly Sadly, I think Susie's suffers from its location, a place that is hands and feet above other chains like Jersey Mikes, or Firehouse, it remains tucked on Weber Road just past 71. Everything is prepared when you order, so your toasty warm goodness takes about 10 mins to make, but it is worth it, You can enjoy it there, in a small but sparse dining area, or take it home. Susie's also offers Pizza, and Pasta, but I couldn't speak to those, and I don't think I will ever feel the need to try them, get the subs ! read more

We saw the sign while we were picking up dinner from Fortune City. So...we thought we would give it a try. Later this week, We both ordered hot Italian subs. They were delicious!!! The lady who answered the phone was very nice. When we went to pick up our subs, there were all kinds of cars and trucks pulling into the parking lot! We're planning on trying a pizza soon. If you haven't already, give Susie's a try. I'm pretty sure you won't be sorry ! read more

I'm sorry I didn't discover this pizza shop so many years earlier. The pepperoni pizza was excellent! Guy was nice who took my order and patiently answered all of my questions. Pizza was ready in 20 minutes. I will return. read more

Just visited for the first time today for lunch. The folks working were so nice! They even offered us two subs they had just made for $10 that were extra. Great food, great people! The soundtrack playing was Chris Stapleton, too! read more

We love the pizza at Susies. That is all we ever purchase, so I can't speak for the subs.

Susie subs are the best bar none.I started eating Susie's subs I don't know how many years ago when they were located on Westerville Road at the Westerville and Cleveland Ave split. When we move to the east side I still used to go to Susie's but then I stopped for a while and thought they close down. Until a friend told me they were on McGuffey and Hudson and this was about five years ago. And the subs still taste as great as ever. And their pizzas are pretty damn good too. read more

finally made it over to Susie's Sub Shop to try their sandwiches....Place is small, has a lot of character, big OHIO STATE THEME....very little seating, couple tables, mostly a to go neighborhood sub/pizza joint...let's start with our orders: I ordered a 12 inch Big John which is basically the Italian Sub with Italian Sausage and melted mozzarella.....Partner ordered 8 inch Italian....both sandwiches were up in about 10 minutes (plenty of foot traffic - pick orders from locals), and they looked beautiful : )) the bread/sub roll was perfectly heated/warmed and the contents were absolutely wonderful.....The Big John has lettuce, tomato, banana peppers, onion, salami, pepperoni, mozzarella, provolone, Italian Sausage (Real Italian Sausage, not the fake crumbled sausage)and a delicious house dressing - which didn't overpower or make the bread to the sub soggy (i hate that!!) This isn't your ordinary $6 footlong from subway...honestly I haven't had a sub that tasted this good in a long time...The bread is soft, yet has that nice warm toasted feel as you bite into it....the ingredients are plentiful and fresh...I can't wait to get back, Susie's isn't in my neighborhood, but you can bet I'll be back for another great sub....Also, there pizza looks really good as well....Maybe next time I'll be in for your pie...Thanks for the great sandwiches : )) read more

See all

The pizza is normally good. Idk what or who cooked last night but trust me, my pizza did not look life the pictures and taste like cardboard. It was individual cheese and pep. Well let's just say cheese. There where 6 pep on the pizza. I guess one for every slice. I was really excited to order from the new location. Welp that's over. I could have spent that money at another Regular Pizza Place or ordered a pizza from a bar. read more

ABSOLUTELY THE BEST!!! The Big John is a heart-attack in a bun, but I wouldn't trade it for anything! The staff is friendly and warm. I just wish service were a little faster and that they delivered. But overall, I'd give it 8-THUMBS UP! read more

Best pizza and subs in town. Quality ingredients and reasonably priced. I always order pepperoni pizza with extra cheese on the bottom and cooked well done. read more

I moved in to the area last summer and did a quick search on a quest for a close go-to restaurant near me. Susie's was right down the street and turned up very promising reviews. I can't speak for the pizza as I haven't tried it--obviously subs are their specialty. And they do it well. The prices are right for a sub that always satisfies, never any variance in the quality. I frequent the Italian, and the pizza sub for when money is tight or I want pizza features without committing to a whole pie. The staff is always super friendly. This place is an asset to this amazing and misunderstood neighborhood. There are always other customers waiting, so everyone seems to know it. Worth crossing the freeway for if you're a Clintonville neighbor to North Linden. Worth getting off 71 for if you're a hungry traveler. Worth making regular visits if you live nearby. I love this place. read more

Great stuff. Love all the toppings although a lil short on sauce. Would recommend to anyone.

Easily the best sub I have ever had in my life. You pull into the parking lot and you can smell the toasted bread and cheese. Prices are unbelievable. I got a '12 Italian for $9. I thought it might be dainty for that price, but it was loaded down. I didn't think I was going to be able to eat the whole thing, but it was so damn good that I couldn't stop! I'll definitely be back!! read more

Had a rush order - 7 large pies ordered at 11:15 AM - requested by Noon - All 7 were hot and ready by 12:05. Plain cheese to supreme - all were consistent and very good. Well Done! read more

My wife and I have been going here for years. Every now and then we try subs from other places to make sure we aren't missing out, but Susie's consistantly makes the best subs in town. The Italian is great, but if you like Phillys, give their Philly Roast Beef a try. You will be glad you did. read more

In reading the reviews on this shop it seems like I am in the minority but the only time I tried an Italian sub it took over 30 minutes and was way overcooked with one section of meat that was burned black and hard. the other part of the bun was soaking wet with oil .The edges of the bun were burned. I think the makings of the sub might be good but whoever made it just must .not have cared enough to prepare it properly. read more