I love this place. The waitresses are hilarious, the food is delicious. The ambiance is old school and may need some updating but I absolutely love this place. I'm surprised that there isn't more people that come here. The prices are great and you get the best bang for your buck. The chicken wings are so good it'll wanna slap your momma Lolol read more

Sutter's Mill - Food is amazing... I'm so surprised this place isn't more packed - Pubs Near Me - Suffern, New York

The BEST American food a No drinks! Of course it's well known for its wings! Also you can cater and they deliver the same quality of food read more

food please reopen!!! this place had the best hamburgers french fries and amazing chicken wings the staff was friendly read more

Stick with the Burgers We just returned after finding out there is a new owner and they were open again. We ordered 2 meals so can only comment of those. Hoping someone posts reviews on other food that they thought was successful. Our meal has a mixed review. I gave it 4+ stars for the cheeseburger, sweet potato fries and onion rings. They were delicous. Burger was perfectly cooked and a generous portion. Onion rings and sweet potato fries were crispy and not greasy. Nice serving. Guiness and house Chardonnay both a good pour. Guiness was particularly good. Now the NOT so good news...1 STAR. We ordered the hot open turkey dinner. Unfortunately it is processed turkey sliced thick with a salty gravy. Greens were under cooked and chewy. Side salad was the best part of the meal. IMO, they should take this off the menu and stick to what they do well. Hoping they make it a success!!!!! read more

See all

Went here for lunch recently. The new owners have completely dropped the ball. Sutters Mill was never anything great, but they had decent burgers, sandwiches and wings. We both had burgers which were ok but nothing worth recommending, service was sluggish with a total of 3 tables. BAD country music playing too loud the entire time. To top it off it was $70 for 2 burgers and fries and 2 iced teas. read more

Amazing flavor, consistent, large portions. Recently redone inside under new ownership and very clean, cozy, brighter than it was. They even offer live music. Large screen TV around to watch a variety of sports events. Had chicken pesto with red peppers and mozzarella over arugula for lunch. Chicken moist, very flavorful. Served with a side of hand cut fries. Server was friendly and kind. Well done! My friend had the diet burger. Served with a salad that is a meal in itself. read more

I am a little late to my review due to being busy. I went here on Tuesday. My aunt and I arrived an hour before closing. We kinda were hesitant since we did feel bad for showing up this late in the day. Although, my aunt loves the food here and always hoped to take me. It was a privilege to go to one of my aunt's favorite restaurants. The staff allowed ups to come in and choose our seating despite it being an hour before closing, which, most places, tend not to even want to take you in. Instead, they welcomed us with open arms. The waitress was super genuine, humble, and over wonderful. It was shocking how, despite myself being torn between two food options, she was able to sense my aura on which one I really wanted. I never had experienced this ever and thought it was pretty fascinating since most people find myself hard to read. The food came out fresh, was quite tasty and rather filling. My aunt ordered the wings, I ordered the Nashville hot chicken sandwich, and we also added in an order of garlic parmesan fries. The environment was rather quiet, and the remaining staff presumed with their regular closing requirements, while our waitress would help out their other coworkers in closing duties, it didn't prevent them from being attentive as well and regularly checking in. In conclusion, my aunt and I overall enjoyed the food, the waitress, the hospitality, and the staff being so through with their routine. ( : read more

See all

Great bar and awesome food. Service is good as well. Used to be one of my favorite watering holes when I lived in NY. Still awesome!

Quintessential dive bar with slightly elevated ambiance and a forgettable menu of pub food that fits perfectly. If you're into hoisting a beer, catching a game and reaching for your ancient tube of Clearasil as an antidote to the grease, what can I say, you're home. Four solid stars. read more

Let's start with the waitress, she was rude and not personable at all. The chicken wings were crispy and good but SO small ... like tiny! The Reuben was rubbery and not eatable, you couldn't even get your teeth through it! The steak sandwich wasn't awful but again over cooked meat and hard to bite through. Not somewhere we will be returning read more

See all

This place is a staple in Rockland for legendary wings and hand crafted burgers that are mouth watering: turkey, beef, bison,... whatever you want! I've been coming here for years and years and the food is still amazing! It's got a full bar and booths on one side of you want to have a quick bite and watch the same and a dining room for family/dates on the other side. Everyone is hospitable and welcoming and it's got the exceptional family restaurant feel that most only see on television. I almost forgot how delicious the wings actually are - in fact, I think I'll swing by there again today! If you're in the area, definitely a top pick. read more

Sutter's Mill - Turkey burger - Pubs Near Me - Suffern, New York

See all

Update 2-28 -25 . Back at Sutters for dinner arrived early 5-ish patrons in bar and dining area. Larry long time bartender back on Saturdays... food is awesome tacos, best burger in county ,choice entrees,, big pours..Tues wings ,wed nachos, Thur sliders... for all you ,former Sutters patrons .come and see for yourself ...I'm upgrading Sutters to 4.5 stars !! read more

Hello, wanted to come on here to complain about the slow service, went here last year with my friend, we're both teenagers and wanted a cheap ish meal. Last year the service was terrible even with 2 tables in the whole restaurant, the server was talking to us as if she was in a rush. The food was bad and it looked like I could make better at home. This year was a new low, the waitress sat us near the wall at a very dirty table. She asked if we're here for wings, I said no we want menus, it took her a solid 10 minutes to get menus; Granted it was busy when we walked in and it was only her. When she came over with the menus I asked her to explain the wing special and she said ¢75 wings while she was walking away, she was obviously in a rush to the next table, I believe this was because me and my friend are still teenagers and she didn't need to pay attention to us. Fast forward to us getting our food, it took 30 minutes to get to us and when we got it, the fries were cold. My friend ordered a medium rare Sutters burger and it came well done, what a bust. When I was going to ask her for the bill I called the waitress over and she snarled wait at me, I work as a busser in a restaurant, if I did this I would get reprimanded. What she should've done was wait for me to give her my request and walked away, even if it wasn't going to be done right away. She came back and asked just the bill? To which we replied yes. After 10 more minutes the bill was ours, $52 for 2 burgers and 2 sodas and 10 wings; Not too shabby the food was good enough. We gave the waitress the bill and requested the change, I'm going to sound nit picky right now but she didn't give us the cents and only the nearest dollar. We got up and left her no tip. read more

please work on the food quality as I am trying to support this place- Wings were so dry and an order is now 16 dollars- can't see how they will stay open at this rate - rest of our food was really awful as well. I had to lower the original rating as I am truly so sad to see this place go so downhill. read more

Usually we go to this place mainly for the French onion soup which is IMO the best one around the area. This time I wasn't as hungry and decided to split wings and a burger. The wings were very small but delicious, and I am not sure why but we needed getting 20 and it came out to be almost $7. As per the burger, I ordered a Burger with cheese and bacon- it was huge but the meat didn't have much of a taste. I also ordered it medium rare and it came out well done. Next time I would skip the burger and try something different. I do recommend it for the wings and French onion soup. read more

Sutter's Mill - Wings- smallest wings I have eaten but delicious. - Pubs Near Me - Suffern, New York

See all

We took a little break from dinner at Sutters but after reading a review about the new kitchen we decided to try it again. Wow! We were NOT disappointed! The burgers were so delicious. They were big, juicy, filling, cooked to perfection. You can add whatever you'd like to create the burger "your way". Yum! Yum! Yum! Sutters will be back in our restaurant rotation. Way to go with the food! The people at Sutters is also what makes this place special! Great wait staff, always friendly faces. We laugh, we eat, we love it! read more

Never noticed this place before, probably because it's on the end of a little strip mall at a busy intersection. It came up on my GPS so I tried it. Service was friendly and food was delicious. I had the French Onion Soup and a cheeseburger with cheese fries. I was completely stuffed but it was all soooo good. I had to laugh because the tagline on the menu says, "Great Food at Old Fashioned Prices" and my lunch with tip was $35! Oh well, it was delicious .... I'll share some pictures. The place was empty when I got there but then filled up before I left. read more

See all

Trashy place. Terrible food! It was inedible. The service sucked to put it bluntly. The ambiance?? There is none! A bunch of nasty drunk men. As a woman, I'm never settling foot in there again. read more

Arty is an ass. automatically assumed I was in his words "fucked up* when in reality my knees are not the greatest and one gave out I bumped into a group of people. Also discriminates against people who suffer from depression who are on medications that you have to take nasely and automatically says he's not serving you because you are high on coke. When in reality it's prescription ketamine for treatment resistant depression yes it does leave a little white residue usually get to a restroom to make sure it not noticable but on this occasion I didn't get the chance to go into the restroom and he automatically accused me of coming into the bar high on cocaine in front of other customers it was very uncalled for. read more

Sutter's Mill - That's arty the ass hole bartender - Pubs Near Me - Suffern, New York

Came here one late night, and had a few drinks. I felt that it was kind of expensive for a dive bar. It has a nice setup with a bar and dining area. Jukebox was playing good hits requested by some patrons. The bar has several TV's for sports events. It is located in a shopping center, so plenty of parking. The bartender got one of the drink refills wrong when he asked himself "want another one?". So I don't know how he messed that one up. Not sure about the food, because it was too late to order anything. FYI: They cut the kitchen food orders at 1am. read more

Ok I enjoyed and craved their wings then I tried their beef brisket couldn't be more tender order the au jus and just enjoy ; have a drink or two read more

"Where's the Beef"???? I haven't been at Sutter's mill is many years! We got seated and noticed not very busy, took a while for a server to come over . We ordered simple hamburger's, my friend had no cheese with onion rings. I had cheese burger with French fries. The onion rings were NOT real just chopped up onion formed to look like an onion ring all frozen....terrible!!! Mine had Fries only about 10 poor amount plus asked for well done were not. The roll was about 3/4 to an inch wider than the burger.....terrible presentation looks like "Where's the Beef" slogan. The server came over we said a little slow here, she commented it's because of Corvid, my friend said probably because of terrible food. She was very surprised and walked away. Like I'm walking away for a very long, long time. read more

I used to come here all the time for wings in my early twenties. Now being in my late thirties this was my first time here in probably 15 years ! Our waitress was terrible , she was very "distracted ". The service was extremely poor ! The food took a big dive since the last time I was here. The wings were still pretty good but as far as ordering anything else I wouldn't.. If you're looking to have wings and a few beers then sit at the bar and enjoy that, but as far as entrees or dinner on the restaurant side I wouldn't do that again.. read more

Today I was craving really good wings and I remembered Sutters Mill! When I was a kid Sutters mill had arguably the best wings in Rockland so I called in an order. When I got home and opened the box I found the smallest grossest looking wings (see the pictures for reference). Until today dominoes had the distinction of the most disgusting wings I have ever had. Congratulations sutters mill you are the new champs. I'm not entirely convinced that these were chicken.....and if they were someone should go check on those chickens! I threw the entire box out! NEVER GOING BACK. read more

Sutter's Mill - As gross as they look. - Pubs Near Me - Suffern, New York

See all

Where to start? From the dingy decor to the awful food & service, Sutter's should be avoided at all costs. The wings were tiny, expensive, and our serving was missing a wing. The wings also lacked any sauce. The burger while decent, had a stale bun and was served with non-seasoned fries. The waitresses were rude and non-personable. Sad to see such a Rockland stable go so down hill. Goodbye for now Sutter's... read more

This is my first time going here. I got the chicken tender basket which was great and the portions were very good as well. My bartender was very friendly and was concerned that everything was good. I would go here again and i recommend. read more

My husband and I enjoyed some Cinco de Mayo specials tonight and I had a glass of sangria. They have a new chef and her food was delicious. I especially enjoyed the freshly cut French fries. read more

They advertised new menu and we believe in supporting local business. This is NOT the Sutters of yesterday. Terrible from start to finish. Bartender dressed like sloppy. Tank top and shorts??? Really?? Sat down and waited 10 minutes for the 1 waitress to help us. Dining room was fairly busy and she was alone. One bus boy didn't pay attention to us. We finally placed our order for drinks. Vodka tonic was flat! I complained only to find out the tap was broken. Wings were over cooked and dry. Holy crap Sutters , you're known for your wings and these were terrible. Little cups of blue cheese dressing? Not even in a dish?? French onion soup was thick, cloudy, and tasted like it was out of a can. Oktoberfest special Roumelade. Different so I tried it. Terrible. Red cabbage was out of a can and mashed potatoes from a box! Yuchhhh. The bus boy didn't even clear our table when bringing our meals. Asked for a glass of Pinot Noir and was served Pinot Grigio. Only to find out they have no Pinot Noir. Ugggg. Bill came and was charged for 2 drinks, and glass of wine. Never going back again. It's a shame because Sutters was a good local spot. No more! Other guests agreed with us. read more

I cannot believe it's been 11 years since I've written a review so here it is! Best wings ever! Also salads are quite substantial I highly recommend Sutters if you're looking for a great home-cooked meal and excellent service! There is a reason why they've been around for so long. read more

When back to sutters today for the first time in 10 months nice new menu and a new chef from spook rock golf course. Had some hamburger sliders and my friend had a turkey burger, all good and nice waitress to boot. Please support them again, thing are looking up for this business! read more

Heard about the New Cook at Sutter's Mill so my friends and me gave it a try..Well first off this place was known for there Cheesesteak Sandwiches (Besat Around) NOT anymore ...Skimpy Steak on the Long roll and shoestring French fries NOT the Good pub fries that they used to serve.. and why fancy the place up by serving the fries in a tiny deep fry basket. PUT THEM BACK ON THE PLATE WITH THE SANDWICH ... this isn't a gourmet Restaurant it's . IF IT AINT BROKE DONT FIX IT !!! read more

Been looking for a great burger since Temptations changed hands. Found it at Sutters Mill, Suffern. Also terrific onion rings Only problem---almost nothing for vegetarians. read more

I can not believe Sutter's has gone down hill as bad as our lunch was today. I have always said those potato skins were the best ever. Today the potato was under cooked and the wings were tiny and over cooked. That wasn't even the worst we ordered a cheese steak and what we got was old chopped meat with zero seasoning with cheese on top. I have gone to Sutter's for years and this has me questioning if I ever go back. read more

Sutter's Mill - Cheese steak? - Pubs Near Me - Suffern, New York

I wasn't expecting great food but I found the food to be bland and the fires overcooked. Service was fine. The decor is pretty plain and the TVs going on every wall are a distraction from talking to friends. read more

Listen up, Punks. I will no longer lay here unclothed, cross-eyed, tongue-twisted and ear-muffed as I stumble upon the reviews of this establishment. Does this place deserve a 5/5? No shot. 4/5? Hey!Stopping pressing me for a score you ungrateful kneecaps, it's not gonna happen. Oh I can't stay made at you... 4.25, it's a 4.25. Yea something like that but I'm no math... math... mathhaaaa.... matheeeeeematician. HuaHua. Let me get to the point, you unjolly ranchers are out here soiling names... so it's time for me to plant some flowers. ~ That was indeed a Gardening joke, if ya don't get it meet me outside Home Depot, tomorrow at 8 AM and be fashionably late. Bring a shovel, wear work boots, and toss on a bucket hat. You also need to be like a 5/10 so don't come if you're below average. By the time I'm done explaining the joke it may be late, don't complain... my process is completely necessary. I pay in experience, not money. My smile is contagious though so you may want to schedule a Botox appointment the day after. Wrinkly lines... Gross. Anyways, as the Australians say "That joke ain't gonna tell itself... nor will the pool clean itself, and additionally the lawn won't mow itself." #TrustTheProcess ~ Ok, back to relevancy. I think we all know where this is going. Any man that's attempting so start this type of movement needs to do a couple things. I've already changed my character and look... and it's time to announce my decision. I'm a fully-committed Australian *read old review to get joke*. So it is time. Every Sunday for the rest of the year I've decided to take a knee. I will be on my right knee, unless injury forces me to switch to the other, all day, every Sunday right outside Sutter's. Explanation: I just don't get you people. Do you not realize where you're eating when you pull up to the joint? Learn to order properly. What are you a child? Goo-Goo-Ga-Ga. GROW UP! Look at my photo... I'm a busty baby and I still know not to order spaghetti and meatballs here. The only confusion I can see happening is that you believed you were coming to a mill.... and if that's the case I have a terrible story to tell, but you'll still read it. I applied for a job here a few years back thinking it was a sawmill. I kept making wood jokes during the interview process. "If trees could kill us... they wood." Lolz. As you could imagine I was thrown out of the place after I continued to insist the place was a saw mill. I tried to take a Saw straight to the bar and that ABSOLUTELY blew 2 varicose veins in that poor ladies skull-piece. Also I didn't know how to use a saw so I kinda trimmed her finger. To make matters worse I demanded to see Mr. Sutter, as she was calling the police and the ambulance. SPOILER ALERT: He's FAKE. Not real. Sham. Dummy. Massive Hoax. Lucky I didn't sue the place. What idiots let me in with a 2 meter chainsaw? Anyways she thought I was mentally on the fritz and told the Cops to leave. We sat down and had a terrific dinner of wings, beer, steak and heartbreak. Oh yeah. You know where I'm heading now. 1 hour in and 2 pints of piss poor beer deep I made one last wood joke. "Hey, darlingsita, looks like we left a tree up... NO WOOD left standing" *Cue Contagious Smile*. Yeeee-aaaa. I laid her out on her back in this "Laid-Back" Tavern... I'll spare you the deets. I will just tell you I'm not allowed back in the place. (Didn't call her back) Now it probably makes more sense to you all why I'm kneeling outdoors, like why would this dude not at least go inside and eat? Yup. The real reason I'm kneeling is to get back in. I just need my baby back *Sad Face*, dot dot dot, Ribs! Muahmuahmuahmuahhhh! Sweetheart, don't hate the Yelper, hate the app. Get the Food for Free by Any Means Necessary! That was a TRUE Linguini Bonotucci Story, Stay tuned for me you dirty curtains. read more

It's a bar with a large menu of food options. The best options are bar food options. Lots of regulars here but lots of tables for dining. You can't go wrong with the burgers and the wings!!! Try the wedge salad or even the broccoli rape. The martini's are pretty fabulous as well!! read more

An old favorite from my days at RCC. Food here is good, but not the best barbecue I've had around here. For the price and service i would always make a trip out here. Also being so close to RCC and always being on a timecrunch this is one of my go to places. read more

Absolutely terrible. I am a first time, and LAST time customer to this diner. I have one question for YOU Sutter's...WHICH "HUNGRY MAN" DINNER DID YOU GUYS HEAT UP AND SERVE ME THIS EVENING??? Steak...awful. Mashed potatoes...brutal. Sauce...eww. I tried feeding it to my pet snail, and HE RAN AWAY! Which brings me to another point -- if anyone see's my pet snail Odie, PLEASE return him safely. Approach with caution, he bites, and PLEASE DO NOT attempt to give him Sutter's, because it will only anger him further, and he will run away ever farther. This was a horrible experience, and I will never order from this place again. Very, very unfortunate, because I had heard a lot of great things about Sutter's, but they were all lies. read more

This is my favorite hamburger anywhere!!! I usually get the Swiss burger, but do change it up once in awhile with other cheeses. I still haven't found any burger that comes close. Nice size. Juicy. Delicious!! I've tried a few other dishes too which are good but most of the time it's for a burger. Gravy fries on the side. Yum. This place is usually quite busy when I'm there and the service is great too. Also a great place if your in a rush and need some takeout. I've introduced this place to several friends and they all love it read more

Sutter's Mill - My delicious burger!! - Pubs Near Me - Suffern, New York

We looked at the menu online before we visited this establishment. I saw a great looking menu with good pricing. What we found was nothing that the online menu matched the actual menu. Needless to say, we just stayed for 2 drinks and wings because there was nothing enticing to keep us to order a complete dinner. Online, they have a great selection of draft beers and ciders. In actuality, the ciders are bottled and they offer the run of the mill drafts. Online there is a great selection of sandwiches, but in actuality the sandwich menu is half of what you are expecting. Online there were some great steak specials starting at $15 but in actuality they only had 1 steak option for $27. Not impressed with what we saw online compared to what was in actuality, we ordered the wings, which were very good, I ordered a Corona, and my wife's Pinot Grigio was anything but. We came to the conclusion that this is just a local bar, shots and beers, some food and the cheapest wine available because they rarely get a wine order. If you see the menu online, don't salivate what you see because that's all it is....a fantasy. Here is the menu page we looked at -- https://www.sirved.com/restaurant/suffern-new_york-usa/sutters-mill/303965/menus read more