I took a little time and chose the Sinatra slice and a glass Cabernet, Savignon. The wine pour and the sl read more

Talarico's Pizzeria - Just Beet it - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

I have never in my life not wanted seconds when it comes to pizza...until today. They clearly don't make their pizza fresh. We ordered the 28in for carry out and it was ready in under 20 minutes. A pizza this size would take a lot longer. It's as if they just add toppings to an already cooked cheese pie and call it good. And good is not at all the word I would use to describe it. Crust tastes like canned biscuit dough. Glorified frozen pizza is a great way to describe it. Much better pizza within walking distance to this place. Lastly, staff acted like we were lying when we brought up the fact we had also ordered a drink. They kept saying we didn't since it wasn't on the "ticket". No kidding. Why would it be on the food ticket from the kitchen? It took us showing our receipt for them to even think to check on their end. Also looks like they only reply to those who leave good reviews. $120 life lesson, i guess. You can find better, West Seattle. read more

Very cute place. Dim lightning, twinkle lights, solid wooden booths, and a bar in the middle of the place. Reasonable prices with HUGE 14 inch slices. There are a variety to choose from! It was fun seeing everyone's different pizza slice. The crust was on the thinner side. Our server was friendly and refilled our waters frequently. Although there was a bar, it was still a great place to take our kids. Street parking. read more

Actually went back and had really good experiences both times. Newer staff (I think?) are very friendly and food was quite good. Beet salad and Coppola pizza can't be beat. (No pun.) I normally don't eat pizza crust but did this time - had that great, yeasty, homemade taste. Delicate and lovely. read more

YES! I cannot believe I did not write a review the first time I came here.... So my mom and I are up in Seattle for my yearly birthday weekend and of course had to hit the baker (you ALREADY know what I'm talking about). We wanted to grab a quick lunch and were joking about "remember that one Italian place we found a few years ago...sooo good.... but let's try somewhere new." We we happened upon this place and the menu looked good for both of us (equally picky eaters in our own unique ways). Well... WHATTA YA KNOW... we walk in and BAM- it's the "yummy Italian spot" we were talking about! Of course we stayed! I cannot recommend this place enough. The vibe is great, the food is outstanding, the service is awesome, and although I don't drink- they looked delicious! They offer a variety of options for even the pickiest of eaters (GF, vegan, will sub, split, and modify). Just perfect! They also host events here. If you are on California Ave, or West Seattle in general, do yourself a favor and stop by for a drink, a slice, or a full on good time! read more

See all

Terrible service like wow. The atmosphere is very old modern like and targeted for adults it's not meant for family's whatsoever no kids I wouldn't recommend. If you enjoy mediocre food and very dim creepy bar vibes with most unreflective staff you encounter I would say dine here....However If you prefer a good selection of food and drinks and more so family atmosphere with kinder staff who are normal I would say look elsewhere.! read more

My previous review of Talarico's was 5 stars. Have been going here for 10+ years. Based on pizza quality over past 6 months, bringing it down to 2-stars. The quality has gotten awful. Let me explain. We usually get pizza once a week from the 3 or 4 different parlors at the Junction. Since COVID hit and Talarico's reopened for take out, we immediately noticed the quality had changed. Crust has become dense, versus light an airy as before. Became very greasy and sometimes had a "funky" flavor to them. And these characteristics have become more pronounced recently. Culminating in the last order being inedible. Super strong sour funky aroma. Tons of grease and no sauce. One slice tasted like it had been dropped on the floor - and had pieces of another pizza style on. So Talarico's is off our pizza list. Sad as it was a great go-to. read more

We ended up here on the recommendation of locals. They were not wasting our time. I ended up getting a slice of "South Street" and the mozzarella balls. Both of these things were outstanding. A couple days later, I came back and had the Chicken Parm. Which was very good. The next time I go, I'll stick with the pizza which I can hardly wait to have again. PS - beware there are multiple karaoke nights. So if you're not in the mood for that, get the pizza to go. read more

Great pizza! We went all in and got a whole pie half Coppola and half al pastor. Good size for 4-5 people but pretty cool to have such a large pizza. The slushees are also good! read more

Talarico's Pizzeria - Half Coppola Pizza half al pastor - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

I've been here twice in a month, and it's been awesome. All the staff is attentive AND friendly. I got the West Side pizza, 14 in(awesome price!), and the soup of the day: Marsala, mushroom, and artichoke. Both YUM! The vibe in this place is they have their regulars, and for good reason. Kayla is a sweetheart, and so is Keanu-service with a sweet smile! Angel's Envy whiskey for $13, what??? Yes please! Pricing here is super reasonable. I'm going to join the "regulars" family read more

New to the area and with Covid knocking out all the indoor dining options, I decided to carry out some pizza on my quest to find the best here. Started with Talarico's! I like that you can order slices and those slices are massive! I got two but could only finish one. I got the original and Tarantino. The sauce is salty and can be overwhelming by the time you eat your way to the crust. The cheese is a whopping glob and the fold ability is spot on for the size. The veggies on the Tarantino are big chunks but well cooked and seasoned. I would order again, but hopefully as an indoor diner. read more

Talarico's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

See all

ENORMOUS slices of pizza! Compared to other pizza places, the slices are super inexpensive. The slices measure 14 inches, and are about $7. I've never ordered a whole pie, but I imagine you would need a truck to transport it lol! Other menu items are also very reasonably priced. Large bar, interesting seating options, and quick to-go orders. read more

I came on a Sunday evening and had no wait for a party of two. You can also sit at the bar if you don't want to wait longer for a table. They have booth tables all around the outside surrounding a huge bar area with a lot of TVs. There are some two hour parking spots right outside and there's also paid parking in nearby garages. They have 14" giant slices of pizza (that are also the size of the menu). My friend and I wanted to try a couple different pizzas so we ordered three and asked if they could split it in half. We ordered the swine lovers, the BBQ chicken, and the Drunken Sicilian (all of them are $6.99). Out of all three, my favorites were the BBQ chicken, Swine Lovers, and then Drunken Sicilian. Even split in half it was a lot of food and we were really full afterwards. I'd say my only gripe with the slices were that the toppings on the pizzas were all closer to the middle so they were not spread out evenly throughout and there were some bites where you got no toppings and some bites where you got all toppings. We also ordered the garlic bread with melted mozzarella ($3.99+$1). It wasn't super crispy but I think it's still worth it especially with the melted mozzarella on top. I would definitely come here more often if I lived closer. It's a bit out of the way for me so I'll have to plan my trips around here if I want to come here during their happy hour and try their other pizzas and drinks. read more

See all

I've been coming to this place for many years. It's a casual and clean restaurant and bar right on California Ave that serves up delicious pizza, pasta and drinks! Their pizzas are thin and very large. You can order a whole pizza or order it by the slice (the slices are very big and are typically $6-8 per slice). My go to items are the South Street Pizza Slice, 'Lil Devil Pizza Slice, and the Fettuccini Alfredo with the Blackened Chicken. For drinks the Cherry Limeade cocktail is light and delicious. Similar to a light Shirley temple flavor. It's a large restaurant perfect for large groups. Street parking is free on California Ave. read more

Talarico's Pizzeria - 'Lil Devil, Fettuccine Alfredo, South Street - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

PIZZA BIGGER THAN MY FACE?!!!!! sign me up. finally seattle affordable pizza thats worth your money. I got the kaui (yes i love pineapple on pizza). For the size of the slice the crust was sooooooo crispy if you tapped the bottom you could hear it. Cheese was melty and not skipping any toppings. Another great reason to visit west seattle this summer! read more

Talarico's Pizzeria - Kauai Pie - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

Poor service They keep you waiting for items 20-40 minutes at a time. Really such a downgrade from where they used to be read more

Super good pasta and pizza! My husband got an al pastor pizza slice and I got the pesto penne after asking the waitress what they would recommend. Fast and friendly service read more

Talarico's Pizzeria - Al Pastor pizza - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

See all

BBQ chicken pizza is the way to go! If you order any of the other slices, make sure to ask for it to be well done / extra crispy (the more heavily topped slices tend to get soggy). The chop chop salad is arguably the best salad in Seattle - and I'm not a big salad person but I could easily eat that as my meal and be happy. Be fair warned their pizzas are gimmicky large. Like too large to fit in a car door and has to go in thru the trunk large. Slices are the way to go! read more

First time here tonight. The vibe of the place is awesome. The place used to be a Chinese restaurant and there are still remnants of the old restaurant decor - super eclectic and fun. The service was excellent. The food was amazing. We had the meatballs for an appetizer and I highly recommend! The marinara sauce was fabulous. The pizzas are HUGE. My adult son ordered a slice of the South Street and I swear it was bigger than his head! It was DELICIOUS. A whole pizza seems expensive at first glance (over $50) but it will seriously feed an army. Husband has the fettuccini Alfredo and if was perfectly garlicky. I had the chop chop salad. YUM. Also, the selection of cocktails is super creative. I had the Strawberry Mint Lemonade - made from whiskey flavored with strawberry and mint. It was pretty darn good! We will be back for sure. read more

See all

The staff here is amazing!! I watch them put up with the worst of the worst on some nights and they still smile. Top notch, pizza is great, entree's are great. Sav, Jen, Ashley, Coco, are all great. Don't be an asshole and you are good read more

Talarico's Pizzeria - Talaricos!! - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

Hands down the best pizza I have ever had and it's my favorite pizza shop! Staff is always great and food is always good! read more

See all

The pizza here is HUGE and pretty good. The pasta is tasty however I probably wouldn't order the garlic bread again, wasn't bad but not worth it for me. Would definitely come here again for a late night bite given it's quick and the vibe is chill and relaxed read more

The first time my partner and I ordered slices. I had my usual Pepperoni and Mushroom. My partner told me Talarico's had HUGE slices (14") and HUGE pizzas (28"), but I was unprepared for just how large that was. The slice was bigger than my hand! It was delicious, thin, and perfect for folding. The size made it so only a slice was necessary for me. I can imagine others and me during my hungrier (hangrier) times needing 2 or maybe 3. The second visit my parents were over and we ordered a whole pizza. The pizza was incredibly large. We had leftovers for days and it was fantastic! We ordered half Pepperoni and Italian Sausage, half Pineapple and Prosciutto. I also ordered the Bread Pudding because I can never resist bread pudding. This pizza was as delicious as the last. I loved the sausage, which is usually not a topping I get on a pizza. The Bread Pudding was lovely. It was not too fancy, but it still had a good flavor and satisfied my craving. The caramel drizzle was perfect for it. I would recommend giving Talarico's a try, especially if you are craving a ton of pizza and like thin slice. They have two locations--West Seattle and Fremont. Accessibility: Gluten Free pizza available in 12" pizzas. They do slices and extra extra large pizzas. Available for take out via their website. West Seattle's entrance is accessible but a small area if you are trying to wait for your order. read more

See all

Love the environment is amazing darkish and intimate service and the food quality is good and they have amazing drinks

Busy place on a Friday night but it was delicious! I definitely recommend calling ahead of time and making a reservation. The entrance to the restaurant is small and they have you wait outside for a table if you don't already have a reservation. Reasonable prices, but they do charge extra for nearly everything: ranch, toppings, extra plate etc. loud environment but kid friendly. Full bar. And the slices are huge. read more

Talarico's Pizzeria - The swine lovers - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

So so delicious. Iverson took the best care of us and was so attentive. We love him. Hella good Cesar salad and good vibes and low lighting. Nice to people watch karaoke read more

Never had New York or Seattle style pizza but whatever it is is spectacular. Crispy bottom floppy with great topping choices and great beer choices. Excellent service read more

On 7.18.20 dine in was available. Service was great, very friendly. Pepperoni 14 inch slice $6.74: It's nice that for pizzas you get the option of a 14 inch slice, 28 inch whole pizza, or 12 inch gluten free pizza. We each got individual slices so no worries about having to agree on a type. My favorite spot for just good ole pepperoni pizza is Pizza My Heart in NorCal, so that is my personal standard. Talarico's doesn't quite meet it, but I wouldn't complain if friends wanted to eat here again. ***** My Star Ratings: 1 Star - Terrible. Just thinking about it makes me angry. 2 Stars - Meh. Unlikely for me to return. 3 Stars - OK. Open to coming back, but wouldn't go out of my way to. 4 Stars - Yummy! Will definitely return if I haven't already. 5 Stars - AMAZING!!! Would plan my day or even a trip around eating here. read more

Talarico's Pizzeria - Pepperoni Pizza 14 inch slice $6.74 - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

There's 3 reasons you come here. 1) For some eclectic delicious pizza; 2) Trivia Nights are excellent; 3) To solo at the bar top on a week day night and read a book, watch a game or make a new friend. The vibe here is just right for about any mood. The servers seem to have high turn over, but always make due. read more

I have had to cook the wings at home. Even after cooking for 10 minutes on the stove the center of the wings were red. So gross. They are generally limp and fatty. I am not sure if they had a bad night. So different than previous orders. I threw away most of the shrimp and the last third of the wings. It was really bad. Glad I ordered the salad so that I had something to eat. read more

Amazing pizza, great tap list, plenty of tv's for the sport ball. What else you need to know

Sometimes great sometimes ok. The last two times I went the pizza was undercooked as is doughy. I'm not one to really complain. Im generally ordering a slice of pizza or two and it's a good price. I'm definitely going back at some point I just hope it's cooked long enough. hard to grade because sometimes it's a 4 star and sometimes it's a 2 star. read more

I stopped in today for the first time for lunch, as I had some time to kill before an appointment. I'd normally gone at night, and had their chicken parmesan, which is fabulous! Today I thought I'd try their pizza, and it was pretty tasty! I love how they bring you all of the herbs and spices in a rack. I was able to spice up my pizza, nicely. Just the way I like it! The ambience was wonderful. I absolutely love the vibe of this restaurant. It's very comfortable and inviting in its decor, and the tables are situated in such a way, as to create a very private feel-great for an intimate date setting. My only problem was with the service, unfortunately. This is why I only gave 3 stars. I sat at the bar, and was ignored for most of the time. There weren't many people there for lunch today, so I'm not quite sure why I was left alone the entire time, unattended to. I had wanted an additional drink, and to also let them know about how my pizza was... Because it was really good... but nobody came to really check on me, other than drop the food off, and walk by once when I was taking my first bites. The staff/bartender stayed at the other side of the bar, socializing with one other the entire time. To be honest, I don't think I'll ever go there for lunch again. I had to flag them down, by walking around the bar, getting their attention, for them to bring me my bill. It was like one big social party, and they didn't really seem very interested in helping the customers. I've never given a negative review... but I just had to this time, because I was blown away with how bad the customer service was. I don't believe I'll be going there again during the day, like I said, but if I do choose to, in the future, I'm definitely not sitting in the bar. read more

Great people and food. Always willing to help the kids! Best pizza for sure!! Talarico's size pizza cut into square for the kids

Second time getting food poisoning. I won't be going here ever again. I ordered the ceasar salad. Both times I got sick from it. Don't order this. Day 3 of food poisoning. read more

Great late night spot for huge slices of pizza, drinks, and karaoke. After 11 their happy hour starts so you can get giant slices for only 5$. Generous with the toppings and their crust is thinner and always crispy with a nice chew. I usually get the Westside (pepperoni, marinara, mozzarella, mushrooms) and add extra toppings. Their goat cheese is nice and creamy. read more

Talarico's Pizzeria - West Side with extra mushrooms - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

See all

We went here to fulfill a pizza craving and craving was fulfilled. We went on a Saturday night and were quickly seated at the bar. The restaurant was pretty crowded, but our server was prompt in bringing water and getting our drink order. You can either by a pizza pie or pizza by the slice. The slices are 14" and go for $6-7 per slice. I ordered the BBQ Chicken and my date ordered the Chicken Caprese. Both pizzas were delicious, I enjoyed my slice better. The menu had so many pizza options so I can't wait to go back and try more. They also had a bunch of appetizers and pastas that's looked promising, so I will definitely return here soon. read more

Talarico's Pizzeria - BBQ Chicken Pizza Slice - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

This place is amazing! We are picky about pizza and spaghetti and this place really hit the spot. The meatballs were huge and extremely good. The spaghetti was well cooked and the sauce was excellent. The pizza was topped with SOOOOO much toppings it was amazing. Did I mention the slice was HUGE too? I got this to go and everything was perfect when I got back home. The one complaint was that the pizza seems to be missing some sauce. I think it would have been MUCH better with some extra sauce. read more

Talarico's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

See all

So I guess the Kitchen closes early on Sunday's so I would call to double check. Even then I'm not certain the response you receive is accurate. Drove from Leavenworth just to find out that they closed the Kitchen. read more

these slices define the saying "more bang for your buck" because the amount you get for what you pay is soO worth it. the portion sizes are why this place is well deserving of a 5/5. i would also say that if you are a person WHO LOVESSS heavy toppings, then this is the place for you !! like seriously, if you like to eat heavy i would recommend this place over any other in the west seattle area. average for the cost of a slice as big as your face is $6 so it's technically like 3 slices in one! don't sleep on this restaurant, great prices, nice cocktail menu + karaoke on some nights. also open late read more

Talarico's Pizzeria - chicken caprese pizza, sicila - Pizza Near Me - Seattle, Washington

See all