Taylor&#x27;s Pizza House

My fiancé stopped for pizza recently and raved about it, so he decided to bring me to Nick's for…read moreour monthly date out. We went in and were sat right away around 5 PM. The restaurant has a clearly Italian, comfortable yet professional vibe. I got chicken parm (GF) and loooved it, and my other half got the sausage parm with spaghetti. We didn't save room for coffee!

Pizza is good. But it did take a while. Prices are fairly priced. Service was very friendly. The…read moreplace was pretty clean. The atmosphere was cool and it felt a little like Italy.

Gluten free chicken parmesian

Garlic Knots.

See all

Light Year Fermentation

4.8(17 reviews)

5.7 mi

Want a cool place to hang? This is a place you must try. Atmosphere is great, both inside and…read moreoutside. The beers, ciders and wines are fantastic . Im a stout girlie, but it is the wrong season for that. But... I made out fine with a tart cider. Since they brew their beer themselves- makes perfect sense to focus on ipas and lagers right now. The food is amazing. Hubby and I got a cheesesteak and the Don Don, honey chicken sandwich. We've gotten them before. By far, in our opinion, the best stuff on the menu. But everything is freaking good. Friends, we were with, had a pizza, and other sandwiches. Everybody raved about what they got. Menu is big enough for a great variety. Seriously FOMO is real. You are missing out if you haven't gone. If the weather is cooperating throw a captain chair in your car and experience the kinda late spring in Bingo. So happy this place is here and that the owner is a cool dude.

Fun place! I love the vibe and food. Very busy last Saturday night at 5:30. I line had formed but…read moreit went pretty quickly. It's good to have your order ready for when it's your turn. We decided on the classic pizza with sausage, roasted red peppers and onions. For the sandwich we tried the chicken cutlet with hot honey and ricotta. The pizza was very good with a thin pastry crust. The sandwich was very light on the hot honey but was tasty. The beer selection is small (micro brewery with small batches). I liked the IPA they had on tap (Yweeprise) and also tried the polish style (Godzilla). The Godzilla tasted like polish sausage!! Everyone who worked here were so friendly that I will definitely come back again when I'm the area. Also follow them because they have bands and outside seating.

Love the decor!

Chicken cutlet sandwich

See all

Love the Star Wars and Grateful Dead theme!

Joey's Pizzeria & Italian Ice

4.1(82 reviews)

Joey's was the only pizza place in the area with GF crust, so we ended up here by default. I'm glad…read morewe did though! Both the GF crust and the normal crust pizzas were super yummy, and the staff was all very friendly. Definitely would recommend for pizza.

Took my two young daughters to Joeys tonight, very disappointed. The chocolate ice cream was not…read moreworking, I get it stuff happens. So we ordered a vanilla ice cream cone for my 7 year old and I shared a custard with my 15 month old. After paying I asked for a second bowl / dish for my childs cone as it was almost 85 degrees out and I knew her cone would melt before she ate it, I was promptly told no, a second dish could not be given to me. I went as far to ask if I could pay for the second dish and was still told no. Needless to say before my kids ice cream cone was finished her and I were both covered in melted vanilla ice cream. Joeys could have given or sold me a second dish / cup and my headache would have been avoided. WILL NOT BE GOING BACK TO JOEYS AGAIN.

Outdoors

Garlic parmesan wings - they look unassuming, but fantastic! Dip your pizza crust in the leftover garlic butter!

See all

Eggplant Parm Sandwich w/ Potato Salad

Original Italian Pizzeria

4.2(21 reviews)

Great pizzas and Stromboli, the price was good, and location is perfect. The staff was also very…read morepolite and helpful.

Love going there! Good people, fast service! Too! But please don't go down there! ( Just kidding)…read more Know what you're going for and enjoy!

Plain cheesy pizza!

Calzone

See all

Front desk

Rossi's Pizza - Endicott

3.3(54 reviews)

I was in Johnson City, NY this past week for work. I went out to a crappy Thai Restaurant of which…read moreI did a review for as well, in which case I was still not satisfied as I was still hungry that evening. I Googled local pizza places near me and I chose this place due to what it offered on the menu. An "Old World" Pizza. That's similar too a Sicilian style, I ordered a medium pizza with pepperoni and anchovies. God Bless America, the flavor was Amazing!!! Thin crust everything was Perfect. When I'm in that area again, I will order another Pizza from Rossi's. I enjoy giving the Local venues the credit they deserve, Thank You for satisfying my late dinner craving. Outstanding Quality and Taste, give Rossi's a try if you're in Johnson City, NY you won't be disappointed!

Just got a pizza with pepperoni and extra cheese. What should I expect for how many slices of…read morepepperoni on this? El cheapo on pepperoni and inconsistent sauce and even topping on pizza. For the price I would expect more than some lazy kid making it.

Half dozen suicide wings.

Steak n cheese so greesey and soggy ... gross

See all

Half sheet of pepperoni.

Tony's Italian Grill

3.6(183 reviews)

0.6 mi

Understaffed so we sat at the bar. Excellent fresh pasta, perfectly steamed broccoli, warm bread…read moreand attentive service by Gabriel. Nice Manhattan, but you need Luxardo cherries, not maraschino. Bar seating is always fun for engaging other patrons

For starters, I'm not a huge fan per se of Italian food and I'm not the type to typically set time…read moreaside to post reviews. Outside of Pizza, don't care much for spaghetti, or meatballs, or Lasagna or Penne A La Whatever. But, these guys? Just set the standard and made me a fan of Italian food at the ripe age of 54. The Spaghetti Ai Frutti Di Mare, good gosh, unlike anything that I have ever tasted before. Absolutely amazing is all I can say. My wife I believe had haddock, gave me a bite, melts in your mouth. My step daughter has the chicken marsalla, another knock out. The atmosphere was decent, family oriented, nice lighting, I'd say 7 out of 10. Parking lot gets full quick around dinner time (understandable truthfully). But the food??? 15 out of 10. I wanted to order another Spaghetti Ai Frutti Di Mare to go, but my wife protested and said for me to stop being greedy.

Front of restaurant. No sign by the road would miss it unless you're looking for it. It's nice inside though!

Pizza

See all

Fiddleheads IPA

Consol's Family Kitchen

3.6(114 reviews)

Consol's has been a staple in Endicott's north side since 1946. Apparently it's been through…read moreseveral owners and is still there says something as does the full parking lot. The restaurant is in a non-descript building but the interior is pleasant and inviting. I've always said you can judge a restaurant by their calamari and Consul's was horrible. Fishy smell, very chewy and too heavily breaded. Everything else was good. The homemade spaghetti was excellent as was the sauce. The mixed drinks were excellent! Generous pour and not expensive. The bar tender and staff were excellent as well. It's a fun local Italian joint and I'll be back, just not for the calamari

Consol's is back! Food is just as good as what we've enjoyed there for years again. Marinara and…read morepizza are same as 10 years ago. Chicken parm or chicken cutlet are not pounded as thin as in the past but still tasty. If you haven't been there in a while give it another try. Worth it. Second time this month and great both times.

View from the new patio.

Grilled chicken pizza

See all

Margarita pizza

Langland's

4.1(18 reviews)

3.1 mi

Had a few slices of their pizza the other week. Guess what..it was really good. Can't wait for it…read moreto warm up it eat on their great covered deck. The parking lot is now paved.

Mediocre at best. Maybe because a bunch of young kids are running it ??? I Was kind of disappointed…read moreconsidering all of the hype for this place. Items that were ordered : spiedie sub, meatball parm , and buffalo chicken sub . Speidies were dry and just soaked in Italian salad dressing, yuck . Do not come here for the spiedies. Go to Lupos for authentic delicious spiedies. Meatball parm was mediocre. Rossi's in Endicott has the best hands down. The buffalo chicken was good but not outstanding. The fresh bread was also good, reminded me of an unsweetened donut . Desserts were good but tasted like they were semi homemade with boxed cake mix. Unfortunately it's not a place I would likely return to. However, The outside seating area and the lush green view was very nice

Jim Roma’s Bakery

3.2(39 reviews)

2.1 mi

Stopped in to grab a loaf of bread for Christmas Eve dinner, still hard to beat it. Not nearly as…read morebusy as it was back years ago when I lived here, and with them not actually baking I missed that wonderful smell.

Bread was hard and had mold on on it. The lady was very mean and couldn't understand nor speak…read moreEnglish. Never again. also very filthy.

Spoiled coleslaw

See all

Burned Pizza

Rogers Pub

3.5(2 reviews)

2.1 mi

Not a good place to play darts. There are two girls there all the time. Can't play darts! But…read morestand there and talk. While your throwing. And while there throwing. Ruins the game. No fun for me.

Great environment, cool owners, chill atmosphere, clean bar. Wish they had food, but you can bring…read moreit in from the outside. Service was speedy. Overall, I had an amazing time for a first time. Would definitely come back.

See all

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

3 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

R G.

0

19

12

7 years ago

Just tried Taylor's Neighborhood Pizza & Sandwich Shoppe on Watson Blvd. in Endwell, NY...When I lived here I was a Freschott Pizza customer in Johnson City and while the J.C. location was good, George and Patti have really raised the bar!...Every recipe is new and based on fresh ingredients...His thin crust round pie will surprise even the most jaded NY style thin crust aficionado...Next time it's going to be one of the calzones - or maybe a sub...They do a new special menu item regularly too. Thanks for a great lunch! read more

Matt C.

0

2

0

7 years ago

I'm very happy when I eat here. Waiters are VERY respectful. They know my family when we walk in to the door. Their subs are amazing! Their pizza is very tasty! I would recommend Taylor's to everyone I know! I highly recommend this place. read more

Tom M.

0

5

0

1 year ago

Literally world class pizza. George and him family have been doing this for a long time and it shows.

Taylor's Pizza House - pizza - Updated September 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Endicott, New York Restaurants near Taylor's Pizza House

BEST of Endicott, New York Things to Do near Taylor's Pizza House

BEST of Endicott, New York Coffee near Taylor's Pizza House

BEST of Endicott, New York Desserts near Taylor's Pizza House

BEST of Endicott, New York Breakfast near Taylor's Pizza House

BEST of Endicott, New York Dinner near Taylor's Pizza House

BEST of Endicott, New York Shopping near Taylor's Pizza House

BEST of Endicott, New York Burgers near Taylor's Pizza House

BEST of Endicott, New York Thrift Stores near Taylor's Pizza House

Best of Endicott

Things to do in Endicott

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Taylor's Pizza House also viewed

Paul & Sons Pizza

4.7

(85 reviews)

Delicious. Kind. Reasonable pricing. They don't have the easily accessible restrooms, but they let…read moreme use the employee restroom.

The best pizza in at least the Binghamton area, south of Utica Area!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!read more

Piccolo's Pizzeria

3.1

(7 reviews)

Have been there several times since they opened, tried something different and enjoyed everything…read morewe have ordered. Baked Ziti Sicilian, Baked Ziti Vodka Sicilian, plain cheese pie, half cheese half pepperoni and garlic knots... don't forget the knots. Being a bit of a pizza snob and waiting anxiously for this place to open I was not disappointed. Happy to have found a little slice of home (metro NY) right here in Vestal. Great food, great staff, great location.

Paid 16 dollars for 3 slices and a drink and they couldn't head up the slices properly. They were…read moreall cold in the center and the overall quality was average.If you cannot get a simple thing as temperature correct, I am not surprised you cannot produce a good pizza.

Brozzetti's Pizza

3.9

(122 reviews)

Yes, very good. Totally different taste. Sometimes I crave this for something different. A sweeter…read moredough.

I was recently talking about bad pizza with my daughter whose husband is from the Binghamton area…read moreand I mentioned how Terrible the pizza was at Brozzetti's. Her reaction was "OMG my husband swears by the place, they all love it". This actually reminds me of friends from Taylor/ Wilks-Barre PA that swear by the greatness of Old Forge Pizza. Let me be clear, this pizza is glorified ELLIO's frozen pizza. While visiting Johnson City i was told by acquaintances, I must have the pizza at Brozzetti's. "It's Life Changing". This is tasteless generic pizza. I could have chewed on the cardboard box with some sauce and not noticed the difference. I would travel to New Haven, Brooklyn, Chicago, even Phoenix (which i hear has excellent pizza), and I appreciate different styles like Detroit style pizza, But I'm glad I didn't make the trip to Johnson City purposely for Brozzetti's. I can't believe I am saying this, go down the street to Dominos if you need pizza.

Langland's

4.1

(18 reviews)

Had a few slices of their pizza the other week. Guess what..it was really good. Can't wait for it…read moreto warm up it eat on their great covered deck. The parking lot is now paved.

Mediocre at best. Maybe because a bunch of young kids are running it ??? I Was kind of disappointed…read moreconsidering all of the hype for this place. Items that were ordered : spiedie sub, meatball parm , and buffalo chicken sub . Speidies were dry and just soaked in Italian salad dressing, yuck . Do not come here for the spiedies. Go to Lupos for authentic delicious spiedies. Meatball parm was mediocre. Rossi's in Endicott has the best hands down. The buffalo chicken was good but not outstanding. The fresh bread was also good, reminded me of an unsweetened donut . Desserts were good but tasted like they were semi homemade with boxed cake mix. Unfortunately it's not a place I would likely return to. However, The outside seating area and the lush green view was very nice

Pizza On the Plaza

3.5

(19 reviews)

Last night was first time I ordered take out ( also my last). My order was a large pizza - half…read moreplain half sausage and extra brown on the crust & a half order chicken parm wings. Picked up order got home and the pizza was half pepperoni and not crispy or brown crust and the wings under fried, not crispy skin on the " flat" wings just soft skin . Now I forgive the wrong pizza meat as maybe I just got someone else's order but the only thing that was good with the entire order was that the amount of cheese they use is ample which most places are just short. If you order extra cheese you're chewing on rubber bands. It seems no one ever gets that right .. they're all being cheap and skimpy. The sauce on this pizza was bitter, like eating paste, not thinned a little bit & it was horrible and the crust chewy and soft. Pizza is my life long love. I've had pizza my entire life from living downstate, MD, VA and here. This ranks high on the bad ones. Reading the reviews I was somewhat hopeful but then again, seeing reviews from here is a crap shoot as so many praise places I think are inferior and wouldn't eat there. Some seem to get praised more for length of time in business rather than on food taste, quality etc. So for my family I'm sad to say Pizza on the Plaza is a bust!

Recently reopened under new owners. What a great little…read morelocal gem! The pizza is fantastic. The menu for a start up is small but everything I've had so far is fresh and delicious. The more support and business they get, the better the chance of them asking more options. Our last order they made a mistake. Not only did they fix it but they sent us home. With more than double of what we had originally ordered! You won't get better customer service! Give them a try, give them a referral, give them a review! You won't regret it. Dine in it's small and cozy or get takeout. You can't go wrong.

Kelli's Deli

4.3

(6 reviews)

Love their subs / hoagies (steak and cheese, chicken spiedie, hamburger, crispy chicken) and pizza…read more(red sauce with pepperoni, white garlic with chicken spiedie). The bar/restaurant is nice, tho I usually do takeout. They've had an online presence for over 20 years, and it's easy to order (you can customize with your special requests!). Kelli is very friendly and down to earth.

A quaint remarkable deli. Kelli the owner Is down to earth. Friendly warm and can make you up a…read moredelicious order from the establishment. From pizzas, nachos, subs and whatever fancy's your tastebuds on the menu. So everyone needs to give all our small businesses a try and you just might be surprised what the places can make.

Aiello's Restaurant

4.2

(250 reviews)

I know it was only take-out but what an amazing experience!…read more The online ordering through the restaurant website was really easy and it gave me a coupon for $5 off a purchase of $30. I was shocked at the 45 minute wait time for some chicken wings but, I saw how busy they were when I go there. I loved the atmosphere when I walked in. It was busy at the bar and restaurant but no one was waiting for a seat. That's a great sign. Immediately, I was asked if I had an order. I told the gentleman I could wait but he went back and put a rush on the wings. Within 10 minutes I had the wings, and an apology for how long it took. Although, it was well before my 45 minute pick up time. The parking lot is a bit cramped but there's not much room to expand. Besides, they have been there since I was a kid. The wings were so good. They came with blue cheese, celery, and carrots. Overall, this place is well above 5 stars. I can't wait to dine in and visit the bar side. Great service and I hope they stay open for another 40+ years.

Active and well behaved clientele. Wonderful Italian kitchen fragrances. Attentive wait staff…read more Wonderful flavors.

Soprano's Italian Mkt

3.8

(56 reviews)