Long Islander checking in here! I've lived in the area for a year and a half, and this is THE best pizza I've found from Rincon, Pooler, Port Wentworth or Springfield areas! Runner up was Tommy's Pizza in Rincon. I've gone about 6 times already, and the whole family agrees easily! My two favorites are their sausage & mushroom pizza and the Sicilian pizza may be the best I've ever had! In fact, I know it is! Dynamite! I live 35 mins away, butt I work nearby and grab it on the way home. A few slices get eaten in the car every single time. And I cannot guarantee there won't be a mess by the time I reach my driveway! Please expand to Rincon! read more

I've only been here three times but the pizza is phenomenal! Plus the owner is extremely kind! Definitely better than any pizza joint I've ever been to. read more

We love this place. Wings - my wife and I love the Sweet Chili flavor. They crisp the outside to give the wings a little crunch. Pizza - best pizza in Pooler in my opinion. Sauce, crust and overall snap to the dough. Very good NY style pizza. Jalapeño poppers - could eat them all day. So good! And like the wings, toasty on the outside for a little crunch. I will try their sandwiches next! read more

As a former Bostonian, I've been looking for a pizza shop that reminds me of the ones back home that are on the corner and run by an Italian or Sicilian family. This fills that void for me! I ordered for pick up and the lasagna might be the best lasagna in the greater Savannah area, sans high prices of downtown. The fries, SO GOOD. The garlic knots, top notch. The garlic bread?? Are you kidding me? So good. We also got tiramisu, and it hits the spot. The capri salad could have been better. Maybe more romaine lettuce? But the flavors were defo there. Thank you for opening up here in pooler, and sorry for taking so long to come visit!! read more

See all

The pizza at The Bothers Pizza and Grill is top notch. You can taste the deliciousness in the sauce. The pizza dough is made just right, and the ingredients are fresh. Pizzas are made to order fast. They have great service and specials. The dining room is clean and great for dining in. read more

The Brothers Pizza & Grill - Margherita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Pooler, Georgia

See all

I was greeted upon entry by a gentleman that I later found out was the owner and showed the menu! I looked over the menu and it was so many things I wanted to try but I was just looking for a quick bite so I decided to get a supreme slice. I paid, he grabbed the slice with some tongs and rain it through the oven. It came out crispy and the cheese was melty... I enjoyed my slice! I went to take some pictures of the restaurant and the menu. The owner advised me to use the QR for the menu. I asked how long have they been there and he said I think I took over for my brother about 4 years ago.... The dining room is not big so I can see it filling up quickly. The ambiance is quaint.... I definitely plan to go back & try some other menu items or even to grab a slice.... read more

See all

The food is outstanding! Best Pizza around . They are always welcoming! I order extra wings and pizza to take home as its an hour drive ! read more

The Brothers Pizza & Grill - Wings and pizza are delicious!!!! - Pizza Near Me - Pooler, Georgia

Best pizza and wings in Pooler. The workers there are always pleasant to deal with and appreciate your business.

Being from Long Island New York and living in the Savannah Georgia area for the past 24 years I was truly BLOWN away with my pizza from here the other night that I got delivered to a friend's home. I ordered a large pepperoni and I felt like I was back at home. I've tried most all of the pizza spots around always trying to catch my craving for that true New York style pizza and I found it here. I can't wait to try there other items and I hear a new menu is coming out soon!!!! I myself am a chef for the past 15 years and I recommend Brothers Pizza Joint to anyone looking for the "real deal" New York style pizza !!! Chef Katie Elzey read more

Outfrreakingstanding! Had a large Joes Pizza and a Chef Salad. Super fresh crunchy veggies on the salad and the pizza. I'm from NY originally and this joint is legit. Worth every penny! Best thing about it not greasy at ALL! Owners a super chill guy! read more

The Brothers Pizza & Grill - Chef Salad - Pizza Near Me - Pooler, Georgia

See all

All seemed hopless in finding real NY style pizza. But guess what? You really need to try Brothers Pizza in Pooler. You'll love this real City Island style Pizza. Yummy read more

I was driving through and remembered eating here years ago while visiting Savannah. This visit I got to meet the owner who actually greeted us. He had a pizza place in New York which explains why it reminded me so much of New York pizza. We also had a pin wheel. Something I'd never had before. It was also exceptional. Give them a try. You won't be sorry. read more

Best pizza in the Savannah/Pooler area by a lot. Great job guys you will have my business for as long as we live here

Great food! Very nice and helpful staff. The new pasta bowls are great and you get to pick your ingriedents!

Had Brothers pizza for the first time after living in Pooler for 2 years and realized how much we have missed out on!! Placed an order for a cheese pizza and chicken cheesesteak. Got home and realized we got someone else's order of lemon pepper wings so headed back to return and pick up our sandwich. The owner/manager called us and let us know we got the order wrong and asked us to please keep the wings and he has a fresh sandwich for us to pick up. Thank god the mistake happened because these wings are so good! Crispy and flavorful plus a good sized wing. The pizza is NY/NJ style and the best in the area. The chicken cheesesteak was great too!! Will definitely be the new spot. Great experience! read more

I don't like hours that are posted that arent followed. If you say you close at 9pm yet I attempt to go to your establishment at 8pm and it's closed, your lying about your hours. Needless to say, having to drive all that way for nothing, you lost a customer before you could gain one read more

Decided to have pizza for lunch and decided to try this cute little pizza spot. The friendly staff told me about their lunch special of 2 slices and a drink for $7. I had the pepperoni and phylli slice. Im from NY and a lot of places say New York style but this place Got It Right! And the garlic knots...this is the first time I found a place that made them like home. I'll be back over and over again! read more

Best Pizza in town!!!! Great staff. The owners (brothers) are personable and accommodating. The margarita pizza is fantastic! The house salad is fresh and delicious. Family oriented. Locally owned. Did I mentioned "The Brothers Pizza and Grill" I the best in town. read more

Beat pizza in Pooler! Unfortunately right now not open on Sundays. Call before you go to make sure they are open.

After seeing all the positive reviews, my son and I stopped here on a Friday night. We ordered the special posted on the door - large pizza, 10 wings & a 2-liter. The lady said it would be about 20 minutes for the pizza but she could get the wings out quicker. We sat at the only table that had 2 chairs (large group of small kids & 2 moms were using all the chairs in this small place). 30 minutes later, no pizza or wings. People were coming & going with take-out orders so I inquired about my order. I was rudely told the chef was working on it. A few minutes later we received an undercooked pizza - the cheese was barely melted. We ate a slice each and chunked the rest. After 45 minutes, wings were finally brought out so we took them to go. The wings were on the smaller side with heaps of garlic but the skin was nice & crispy. To top off the bad experience was the yelling and screaming between the counter lady, the chef and two customers. Seems the customer didn't get his entire delivery order so he came to the store to pick it up. The lady was so rude, basically called the man a liar and screamed. Little kids across the room were frightened. Other customers were as shocked as I was. Chef came out and threatened to hit the customer. It was a really bad scene! There are ways to handle customers and this place surely needs some training! read more

We ordered a cheese pizza and a cheesesteak...both were fantastic!! The pizza is a thin, NY style and very good. And the cheesesteak was on a roll that reminded me of Amoroso's in Philly. read more

Stopped in with my family for dinner on a Thursday night. My parents visited the restaurant before but this was my first time, but they told me good things. We decided to order the largest family special (two large two topping pizzas, garlic knots, and a drink). We sat down at a side table and waited. While waiting I noticed the hand painting of a pizza store seemed to be in New York with an American flag. Very cute. Then on the other wall was a wall of customers. That touch made this place special. Very intimate and you can tell the owner appreciates all business not just business of the rich and famous. The owner even came out front to check on us throughout our meal. *Appetizer 1: Garlic Knots For the appetizer six large garlic knots came out. Doused in a buttery garlicky goodness. This literally could have been a meal by itself with marinara on the side. *Entree 1: Ground beef and onion pizza The ground beef and onion pizza was huge. The meat and vegetables seemed fairly fresh and definitely everything was made to order. *Entree 2: Chicken and broccoli pizza The chicken on the chicken pizza could have used more seasoning. It didn't taste like care was placed into the chicken at all. More like an after thought instead of the main part of the meal. Nonetheless, after I dipped the pizza in the garlic sauce from the garlic knots it set the pizza off. I hope the owner decides to make extra garlic sauce as a side... *wink*wink*! Overall this restaurant deserves a B+. The food portions are large, the garlic knots are savory and the garlic seems fresh, the owner is extremely attentive and polite, and the customer pictures make coming back to the restaurant extremely easy. Pitfalls, the pizza itself can use a hint of something extra to bring the pizza over the top. Either way if I have to feed a large crowd I will definitely come back! read more

See all

Small space for eat in. The pizza is really good!! Service is very polite. Hoagies are good. We have returned several times. read more

Ok the only pizza I've had from this place is the Grandma's and I've gotten it at least 6 times now. It's freaking phenomenal!!! Who knew stewed tomatoes could be so perfect on a pizza! The fresh basil and mozzarella are perfect as well. I just can't get away from ordering this pizza so I have no idea what the rest of the food tastes like. If you try this place GET IT! You won't be sorry. read more

This is now Two Brothers Pizza. There are only 8 tables, 2 for 4 people and 6 for 2 people. The real prices are higher than the menu says and the food is mediocre. I had a salad, mozzarella sticks and a small pizza and it cost $33 with water to drink. read more

So, just ordered from there. We order from there a lot and usually get the Special pizza with the mozzarella on it. Anyways, I order wings today and they are disgusting. My cheesecake is also frozen. So I call to let them know and I hear her say to them "this is the third complaint we've had today on the wings" She comes back and gives me attitude telling me I didn't give her the right description to my location and usually they charge $4. Um yal have never charged me for delivery it says free on the menu. Then she was like trying to make excuses about the wings saying they were big so they had to cook them longer. They are the average sized wings. THEN she proceeded to act like she was doing me a favor by not charging me for $4 delivery fee and letting me keep their shitty wings. You've lost my business. Learn some manners. read more

COCKROACH ALERT! I hate to even do this but it is a must. My family and I decided to try it based on the reviews. The cheese pizza was very greasy but good and the kids enjoyed it. We got the meat pizza which was also pretty good. I would NENVER say it is the BEST pizza. HERE LIES THE BIG PROBLEM. The place is a hole in the wall and is old and dirty. It needed to be swept and many areas are in need of paint. As we were finishing up my son picked up one last piece of pizza and lying underneath was a dead cooked COCKROACH! Normally if anything like this were to happen I would say something but my kids had already eaten a few slices as well as had my wife and I. I quickly flicked off the pizza pan before any of them could see it. I did find it next to the table next to us on the floor so I took a picture. I should have done it right away but I didn't want to sicken my family. I boxed up the remains, half a meat pizza and 4 slices of cheese and when we got out of the car I ACCIDENTALLY dropped it. woops. How could I let them eat the leftovers knowing what I knew? I don't eat where cock roaches are found in the food! DISGUSTING! read more

The Brothers Pizza & Grill - THIS IS THE COCKROACH I FLICKED OFF OUR PIZZA PAN FOUND UNDER MY KID'S CHEESE PIZZA. NASTY!!! - Pizza Near Me - Pooler, Georgia

See all

They are right down the road from my workplace and our coworkers always request them for lunches. I love that they are a smaller business feel instead of going with a large chain. Their customer service has always been good and they will deliver! Only downfall for me is I order my catering almost all online to create a paper trail and to help me keep track and they don't have that option. I would love if they got an EZcater account! Then my life would be complete!! read more

Good place for the price and amount of food they offer. Went with a group of like 12 people, and everyone thought it wasn't bad but it wasn't great either. I ordered cheesesteak supreme with extra meat and I liked it ! read more

The Brothers Pizza & Grill - Pic inside - Pizza Near Me - Pooler, Georgia

See all

Two Brothers is the reincarnation of the much beloved Joe's Pizza and manages to keep all of what made the original great: high quality, New York style, thin, crispy crust pizza. The menu is rounded out with plenty of other equally delicious pizza parlor fare like stromboli, calzones, wings, and subs but the pies are the star of the show. Every town needs its go-to Pizza place and in Pooler, GA that place is Two Brothers. read more

See all

Very good Italian meal and friendly service. We ordered garlic knots, tortellini, small pepperoni stromboli and large ground beef, pepperoni and onion stromboli. The tortellini came with 3 garlic knots and the pasta in itself was enough to feed 2-3 people. The stromboli were HUGE and very good as were the garlic knots. Definitely will be back! read more

See all

Stopped at Joe's Pizza on a road trip a while back, and I liked it so much that I made sure to stop by again as I was passing through on my way to North Carolina. I was pleasantly surprised to find that they had moved to a bigger location and had changed their name, but any worry I had was laid to rest once I found out that the food and staff were the same. I've had the cheese pizza, shrimp Caesar salad, and garlic knots here and all were amazing. The Caesar salad was fresh, the cheese pizza rivals that of some nationally renowned pizza parlors I've been to, and the garlic knots are the BEST I've ever had--better than the knots I've had at the aforementioned pizza parlors. Great place and I'll be back on my next trip! read more

While I have not had the experience of dining in, and I never will after this time,I can say the delivery was horrible! The woman answering phones was rude and short. I ordered a sub and fries and she tells me the sub comes with fries. Awesome! Except after waiting an hour and forty five minutes for my food, to my surprise there is no fries. I thought I could at least enjoy my sub but the meat was so burnt it was inedible. Save your money don't eat here!!! read more

I'm happy they are open back again. I used to go to their old location known as Joe's Pizza. That location was farther and I used to drive from South Carolina at least once a week to eat their pizza. I can tell you that I passed quite a few pizza places during that 35 - 40 minute drive. I tried their pizzas. They were never worth going back to. I had to go to Georgia to find NY style pizza that could satisfy me. I went to their new place for the first time yesterday. It's quite an upgrade from their old location. The old place was just carryout. I used to eat the pizza in my car in their parking lot. This place now has seating. It is a very clean and inviting atmosphere. But, of course, I never cared about the seating. It's about the pizza. I ordered their lunch special and was, again, a satisfied customer. No complaints as usual. This is the New York style pizza which reminds me of my childhood growing up in Long Island, NY. There's no place like it, at least not in the Low Country of South Carolina. Also, their prices are reasonable, so, save yourself the trouble of trying to find a quality pizza place. Just eat the pizza here and you will be happy. read more

One the of best Margherita pizza I have ever had. So very good. The perfect amount of basil!

Rating this 5/5 because Two Brother's Pizza is lit like a stick Great Pizza Great Service read more

Pooler is very lucky to have such a great, family owned pizzeria. From their salads to speciality pastas, Two Brothers does Not disappoint. They started on Rogers St as Joes Pizza and have since upgraded their business and renamed it Two Brothers on Pine Barron Rd. I'm from NY and was so tired of chain restaurant pizza. My favorite type of pizza is a Sicilian...but everywhere else calls them a deep dish pizza...two brothers is that authentic. They call their food what it is. If you've never been up north you've never heard of a Sicilian pie, you probably don't know what a garlic knot is, and what in the world is a Grandmas pie?....it's what pizza should be. Fresh mozzarella cheese, tomatoes, garlic, and fresh basil on a thin crispy crust...Two Brothers gets it right every time! The salads are huge, fresh and filling. The calzones are exactly what you should expect from a "real" pizza place and their slice is foldable like it should be. And I can't forget to mention the wings...perfect! The owners are very friendly and I am happy to support Joe and his family. Great Job to you all and thank you for providing amazing Italian food every time!!!!! read more

Stopped by here on a road trip down to Savannah. Staff was friendly and the calzone we split was perfect, you could tell the chefs knew what they were doing. Affordable as well. read more

The Brothers Pizza & Grill - Meat lovers calzone with marinara sauce on the side - Pizza Near Me - Pooler, Georgia

Ordered to go from here because they happened to be on the way back home from our children's daycare and food was awesome! Large quantity and good quality. We ordered spaghetti with meatballs and sausage, it came with garlic knots (which are sooooo good btw). Will definitely be a regular stop now that we discovered it! read more

Amazing food. Garlic knots are a must but the best thing about Two Brothers is the family that owns and operates this great place!!