The pizza was a great option if you are looking for New York style. Little pricey but by the base so that was expected. Didn't rate it higher because they make it weird to dine in. They have a limited option on drinks and are pretty rude if you ask for Parmesan Cheese or Red Pepper. Definitely a take out sometimes kinda place. read more

I want to preface this by saying I'm Italian. I wanted some good authentic spaghetti and this place seemed to be so hyped up, so I wanted to give it a go. Ordered 2 things of spaghetti for me and my husband. Spent 42 dollars btw. It was the nastiest spaghetti that I've ever had. I don't even think I could trust the pizza. I make better spaghetti using cheap pasta sauce. Wouldn't recommend this place if you want authentic. read more

Pizza reminds me of home only good pizza in hinesville. Good service quick and easy. The place is just like pizzerias back in Jersey.

Oh my. Delicious fresh made pasta. I had the Baked manicotti and it was to die for! My hubby had the pasta with sausage. Again very good. We split a Ceasars salad also. Very clean and cooked to order! read more

That's Italian Pizza & Pasta Hinesville GA - Baked manicotti. - Pizza Near Me - Hinesville, Georgia

What a hidden gem in Hinesville. The food is exceptional. Nothing I have tried was not a very pleasant experience. Everyone who I have introduced to this restaurant has loved it. Real Italian cuisine. Seating is limited and beverages are not a very diverse. Highly recommend!!!! read more

We got delivery and this pizza is the best pizza I've had in a while! The service was excellent on delivering to our house in a reasonable time. Can't wait to order pizza from here again! read more

Food was great. Service was quick. It wasn't too busy which I liked! I got a slice of the hot honey pizza (which is also for sale by the whole). Purchased an XL one topping pizza and 4 sodas, total came out to about $40ish. A bit pricey but worth it! Will be making it my regular lunch spot. read more

Service was ok. Walked up to the counter and there was no in the back. Waited for 5 mins and someone finally came up from. Orders the Hot Honey Pepperoni Pizza. I get home and open the box and there are some pepperonis on a cheese pizza. I would expect pepperoni all over the pizza. Not on some of the pizza read more

That's Italian Pizza & Pasta Hinesville GA - Hot Honey Pepperoni Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hinesville, Georgia

They are so good but they are never open! The times on the website are wrong They barley answer calls or online orders read more

the food is out of this world this place has become my go to it's beyond incredible. the environment inside is super nice you can tell it's a small local business and all the employees are super friendly and amazing. read more

Surprisingly good pizza for the pizza connoisseurs out there! It's the closest thing to Jersey Pizza you'll find around the area. The mozzarella sticks were okay, but I would definitely recommend their garlic knots. The perfect blend of soft, doughy goodness mixed with the right amount of fresh garlic. Not overpowering, just right. Ordering online is quick and easy, highly recommend it. They come in a bit earlier than the order time. read more

Everything was delicious true Italian food excellent, staff was great. We will be back. Clean place and atmosphere.

They have the best pizza we've found here in Georgia. The crust is thin and tasty. The choice of toppings was outstanding. The lady at the counter was so nice, answered our questions and recommended a great combo. read more

Was in the area on the tail end of a long day. Had a cheesesteak sandwich to go and it was terrific.

Was in the mood to try some different pizza, so I decided to try them out. With a name like "That's Italian" my hopes and expectations were pretty high. Unfortunately I was disappointed. Not a fan, service wasn't great, and the service matched the pizza. read more

Okay first of all TERRIBLE! I usually come here for just the lunch special or a small cheese kids meal. Something simple. But today I chose to get something for the family. I called , the guy who answered cleared was annoyed with what he had going on ... he was very brief, short and was snippy. I was not rude at all. I ordered originally a kids pep and bacon pizza , 2 pineapple, beef , onion green pep and tomato pizza and 10 wings . Total - $37 the RUDE man who answered told me it would be cheaper to get the pizza a large I said okay well the small kids pizza and then the 2nd and 3rd pizza I was going to get , make those one large and then add the wings ... he said okay $34. Okay cool I'm thinking okay yea I saved $3. I get to the restaurant he didn't add my pep and bacon small pizza and didn't apologize or acknowledge the inconvenience that he caused . So I had to pay even MORE money. Total cam out to be $47!!!!!! I should of just kept my 3 small kids pizzas for $34 ! Again , no apologies or anything ! Then the food was thrown together , hardly any cheese and the wings looked like premature wings . Just TERRIBLE! read more

That's Italian Pizza & Pasta Hinesville GA - Wing .... WTF is that - Pizza Near Me - Hinesville, Georgia

See all

A good thin crust pizza can be found here! I'm not a big fan of thick crust so this pizza killed the hunger pains. Additionally, my hubby ordered cheese sticks which is their pizza dough oozing with a lot of cheese goodness and served with a side of pizza sauce. We could have made the cheese sticks our meal! They have quite a large menu. I could tell on this early summer evening that call ahead 'Take Out' pizza keeps this spot hopping! They have a small dining room of mostly booths, but they also have a small outdoor patio dining area. read more

See all

We got take out and they were prompt with pickup. Although Very pricey, the food is very good! Large portions!

Absolutely amazing. Highly recommended . I promise you after one visit you will definitely be going back and not want pizza from anywhere else but here . Hidden Gem indeed. Made with the freshest ingredients and made to perfection . read more

To Customers who are not informed properly - this restaurant is busy with lunch catering, on-line orders and phone order, wrapping to go and delivery orders and no they're not Burger King or dominos - mostly all items are modified cooked to order and made fresh, pizza slices are often prepared with FRESH PEPPERONI, THANKS - and they're not slow but busy preparing for other customers regardless who's in the restaurant- no contradiction here! If you feel your observations and mockery are justifiable, I suggest you put on an apron buddy - BTW you get this weeks Also once the pizza leaves their hands with delivery, who are given 20-35 minutes through App, where driver usually waits or comes directly on time, or in some cases drivers do not have a pass for base, it's very rare there are issues, but a careless driver may mess up your pizza - fresh shredded mozzarella or fresh mozzarella grande cheese does move, GMO does not! Thanks, The Lady at the counter And thank you but 20 wings are not $9.00. The menu offered here on yelp is a fraudulent menu, but what would one expect, call the restaurant @ 912-432-7552 or online SLICELIFE.COM for proper reviews and a full proper menu. Yelp eliters are as if one is ordering jumbo shrimp! Anthony Bourdain read more

The customer service was terrible. We got there around 845, they told us that we wouldn't be able to order from the whole menu. The server was like "yeah we close at 10 so you can't order that anymore" He was more worried about closing in time than the customers. They served us our food in take out boxes. The food was just ok. The garlic knots were probably the best part. I don't really see this as a dine in restaurant. I don't recommend eating here. read more

This place and the management is awful. They were two hours late. During the process, we called twice to get an update and kept being told inaccurate statements. They even marked our order complete an hour before it was ever done. We received terrible, destroyed, and cold food. I called back to explain what was received and the manager Tanner was rude and very unhelpful. When I said, if you don't have the time & can't provide quality service, it's your responsibility to pause the delivery apps. His response was "oh so you'd rather not receive your food at all?" And to call doordash and figure it out. They tried to blame doordash which was obviously not the case and after spending quite a bit of time on the phone with doordash, we found out that the restaurant uses their own delivery drivers! We are disgusted and we were treated terribly. Don't go here! read more

That's Italian Pizza & Pasta Hinesville GA - This is how our pizza came. Destroyed, cold, ruined. We are so bummed out. - Pizza Near Me - Hinesville, Georgia

See all

We ordered subs, pizza, chicken parm and cannolis. Everything was prepared and seasoned just right. Authentic Italian that tastes great and fills you up... Fugetaboutit. read more

That's Italian Pizza & Pasta Hinesville GA - Cannolis - Pizza Near Me - Hinesville, Georgia

Quick lunch and great food, I wanted to have both and me stopping here accomplishes that. The lunch special of two pepperoni slices and a drink kicks butt. Fast food is what I need so I came here the first time and got hooked. The really good part is that the locals pile in from all over so I am not alone when I tell you to go give this place a try. read more

I was just at this location horrible Cust service I sat down right in front of the counter no hello can I take your order or anything. The older lady looked us right in the face and ignored us. After sitting there an additional 10min we left. I really hope this had nothing to do with my skin color. The place was empty except for a young man sitting in the corner eating his meal. read more

Ordered pickup well in advance. Got the notification that the order was ready while I was on my way. Waited an additional 15 minutes. Was initially ignored by staff and the employee just walked away when I asked a question. saw a bunch of employees sitting around in the back. Opened my pizza and it had a whole pile of cheese off to the side of the pizza, like a pile of cheese was just thrown in without a care. The pizza wasn't even cut. I usually have long wait times with them but today was the last straw after being ignored and being told my order was ready when it wasn't. read more

That's Italian Pizza & Pasta Hinesville GA - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Hinesville, Georgia

The food is excellent for the price and you genuinely get a lot for it too. We like to consider this one of our go to's for dinner in my household. The service has always been nice to us and it's nice to sit down and eat there too. It's very clean, but very small so I could never imagine a crowd lol. read more

For a small little Italian Pizza & Pasta restaurant this place packs a PUNCH!! I had driven by this place a couple of times on our way to and from base from our Hotel... so finally A co-working and I stopped by to get a bit to eat after work. As I walked in the restaurant I noticed that it wasn't your typical Italian place... this place is small and seats about 30 at Max capacity. But don't let that discourage you.... the food is AWSOME!!! My co-worker ordered the spaghetti & MeatBalls and I ordered the Eggplant Parmesan w/penne pasta and took our seat at a small table. The waitress came out and brought us some Bread Rolls with melted butter in to-go containers... WOW!! The bread was fresh and warm and tasted great!!!! A couple of minutes later she brings out our plates... HUGE portions!!! The Eggplant Parm was mouth watered and the Penne Pasted was cooked perfect and smothered with fresh tomato sauces... My co-worker couldn't even finish his meal and grabbed a to-go box... This is a MUST try restaurant so Please don't let the outside of the place fool you ... the food is GREAT!!! read more

That's Italian Pizza & Pasta Hinesville GA - Spaghetti and Meatballs - Pizza Near Me - Hinesville, Georgia

See all

From now on, when I have a pizza craving, it goes away unless I can make it to That's Italian, because nothing seems as appetizing as the slices here. My go to? Two jumbo slices of pepperoni pizza. These are the slices that are thin enough to make you crave the authentic and not chain affiliated Domino's, Pizza Hut, etc businesses, (although I am fans of both) and are large enough to fill you up after just two slices. The lunch deal (two slices and a drink for $6) is a great value. If you can stop in at that time, then do so. I've never had a bad experience with customer service, and I never wait more than five minutes for my meal. Parking is never an issue either. I know I will go out of my way to eat here again! read more

That's Italian Pizza & Pasta Hinesville GA - Got too hungry - Pizza Near Me - Hinesville, Georgia

Food was good, but customer service wasn't great and the older gentleman was a little rude, especially to his workers.

If you are looking for some good pizza in Hinesville this is the place! They also have a great Caesar salad... I Highly recommend That's Italian.... read more

That's Italian Pizza & Pasta Hinesville GA - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Hinesville, Georgia

My husband and I recently PCS'd here from Italy, and have been craving Italian food so bad. We went in here for dinner, and it's probably one of the worst Italian restaurant I've ever been to. All the workers are teenagers and they don't take their job seriously. They're goofing off, running around, being loud. We ordered pasta, which was store bought and the marinara sauce is so watery and tasteless. VERY low quality. The pictures they use on here are from google and don't represent their food at all. On top of that. It's expensive as hell! Just for a bottle of water was 1.60. You can cook better Italian at home! Don't waste your money. read more

That's Italian Pizza & Pasta Hinesville GA - Pizza Near Me - Hinesville, Georgia

Customer service, customer service, customer service... There were at least 6 people working, yet a lot of confusion with orders being placed correctly. Customers were waiting 15-20 min to place an order inside the restaurant because an employee continued taking phone orders. Even orders placed 30-40 mins prior won't completed for pick or even started. There needs to be organization. read more

Great food and good deals. I LOVE the food here. Best pizza I've found in this area. I love New York Style pizza and this has been my favorite while I've been here. They only have canned drinks but the service is fast and the prices are fair so that has never been a problem for me. However the last time I was there a male employee was supposed to be taking my order and instead was on the phone socializing saying things like "now people decide to come in". When he got off the phone and took my order he was short and rather rude. Finally as I was waiting for my pizza he was screaming and cussing about someone being on his Bluetooth. He was yelling at an employee on break, making threats, and hitting things. The entire experience made me not want to go back to this location. Next time I want That's Italian Pizza I'll be going to the one in Richmond Hill. read more

So first we got there and the owner was unwilling or I guess not able to tell is what he recommended or what's his restaurant is known for. The food we ordered I see why he didn't say anything. One of the cashier girls there left to go get Macalister's and went inside the restaurant and set down and ate it in the restaurant lol. read more

That's Italian Pizza & Pasta Hinesville GA - So far so good we ordered and are now taking a seat. - Pizza Near Me - Hinesville, Georgia

See all

The one star is for the food which was how I describe "ehh". I've been to plenty of authentic Italian restaurants and still am baffled on how a small bowl of past Alfredo with chicken is $20. Half their online menu pictures are like a catfish on Facebook. The owner was rude, especially when he tried to correct me 3 times on wanting the Fried Cheese Ravioli and then served me baked. The one worker was sweet and nice, but the owner had to consistently shadow him and put him down on everything he did. Overall, I had a horrible experience in that mediocre sauna of a Italian restaurant. Probably should stay in New York. read more

Was craving pizza and decided to try this place with 3 of my friends . When we walked in there were 3 people (one table) and 1 person in front of us. For some reason the lady on the cash register was extremely slow and she was going back and forth to do other things but take our orders. We waited for approximately 15 min on line just to place our order and mind that it was only the 3 of us. During that time they were 3-4 people that walked in but ended up walking out because of the wait. We placed our orders and it took forever to come out. My friend ordered two slices of pepperoni pizza but he got cheese instead. We saw her taking the slices back and just throwing some pepperoni on top and bringing it back.I got the stramboni, wings and water but they for some reason charged me for a soda after asking me what kind of water I wanted when she was ringing me up. Overall the food was mediocre and expensive, service was extremely slow and orders will be messed up! read more

Disgusting, the owner is a foul man who treats his workers like garbage. Poor customer service, the food was cold and terrible. The kitchen is absolutely horrifying, I remember watching as they hired professional cleaners to come in and the owner actually insisted that they clean around the workers WHILE THEY WERE STILL COOKING AND SERVING FOOD. I will never set foot in this establishment ever again. read more

Stopped by for a quick lunch. I got the 2 jumbo slices of supreme and a canned drink. It came out quickly and hot. I liked that the crust was on the thinner side and the tomato sauce was sweeter than other places. Clean establishment, friendly lady on the register, and quick service. read more

Best pizza and wings around hinesville hands down. Service is good. Don't sleep on the hot wings.