The cake taste good but the older lady in the front was rude and didn't even say hi when I walked up to the counter. Will not be going back to this establishment read more

This establishment was originally Reister's in West Hempstead for decades. I haven't been there since the new owners took over, but judging by the business they're doing, the quality must be the same. An interesting place to view the different cake designs. They used to have a small restaurant in the back and the food was great. They closed that section years ago. Will be going there soon. read more

It's been a few years since I have walked into the Cake Gallery but tonight we ordered a box full of their absolutely stupendous jelly "donuts" for the holiday. It would be hard to say donut because they are so much more, really like a cronut if that name had not already been taken. It looks like a mid sized croissant covered in regular sugar and loaded with delicious jelly..at 1.50 this is the best rendition and price of any treat I have seen in a while,at a time when fancy donuts are close to 3.50 a piece. These are simply amazing and the owner is always so nice The Cake Gallery has been on Jerusalem Ave in North Bellmore for a decade and is nestled in a small row of stores with ample diagonal parking and a rear lot. It is worth the trip to check them out if you've not been. read more

Lovely little bakery. Tom, the owner, is a pleasure to work with. Easy to reach via phone or email, and easy to communicate ideas with. I had a specific cake in mind for my daughter's 3rd birthday and what Tom made for us was better than what I had imagined. I will be ordering more cakes from The Cake Gallery in the future! P.S: The Irish soda bread is AMAZING read more

The Cake Gallery - The cake was so delicious, super moist and the cannoli cream filling is yummy! - Bakeries Near Me - West Hempstead, New York

See all

The Cake Gallery did not disappoint in flavor or in how beautiful the cake looked. We had a tea for two theme and it tasted delicious. The baker who is also the owner worked for me to make my vision come to life. He helped me figure out how much cake I needed to serve and cupcakes too. He accommodated me by letting me have two different flavors in the cake. We got so many compliments on the cake and the cupcakes. I will be ordering again from them In the near future! read more

See all

This was just a random bakery my family and I spotted in our way to a BBQ. We decided to stop in to get a cake. We ended up getting a cake that looked liked a hamburger! Lol, it was cute! It was pretty delicious too. I loved it. Great find! As for the staff, they were just as sweet! read more

The Cake Gallery - Bakeries Near Me - West Hempstead, New York

Amazing!!! The artistry, the culinary skill all rolled into one! His cake creation was a surprise as a part of a party we held this summer - I sent in the artwork and we discussed the different options. We communicated mostly via email or on the phone - but everything was flawless! The cake was delicious and the surprise was well received ! Ps, I highly recommend Oreo cookie filling! read more

The Cake Gallery - A work of art from The Cake Gallery! - Bakeries Near Me - West Hempstead, New York

I've ordered two cakes from Tom at the cake gallery in the past two months and both cakes tasted just as good as they looked! Everyone loved how cute they came out and couldn't get enough of the delicious the cookies and cream filling! Thank you Cake Gallery! read more

The Cake Gallery - Baby shower cake - Bakeries Near Me - West Hempstead, New York

See all

I ordered a cake from this bakery about a week in advance for my boyfriends birthday. I ordered a funfetti cake with vanilla butter cream frosting and a special decoration on the outside to go with the theme of the party. We picked it up the day of the party and it looked absolutely beautiful and it was just what I ordered. Later on in the day, when it came time to eat the cake, I realized this was not at all the cake I had ordered. It was NOT funfetti cake, but instead it was lemon cake that looked like they had just tossed funfetti sprinkles in the frosting. This was of course disappointing, as it was not what I ordered and no one at the party liked/wanted lemon cake. My boyfriend tried not to let it bother him and I put more than half of the cake aside so I could bring it back. The next morning, I called the bakery and explained the situation to them and they told me to bring the cake in and I would be refunded- they did not indicate that it would be any sort of issue. I drove over 30 minutes to bring the cake back and when I showed them the cake, the man I spoke to was extremely rude and tried to tell me that the FUNFETTI cake I ordered was supposed to have a "hint" of lemon flavor in it- that they use multiple flavors and it was intentional, and could have been from the decorations that were on top of the cake. First of all, this was not a HINT of lemon. This was full blown lemon cake. So much so, that people were assuming I actually ordered a lemon cake. Second of all, I have ordered funfetti cakes and cupcakes from numerous bakeries in the past, and made funfetti cakes myself, and I have NEVER had any that even slightly had any hint of lemon in it, no matter what design i wanted on top (shout out Dortoni- best funfetti cake). When I explained this, the man then offered to give me $50 store credit. To which I said no, I would like a refund. He argued with me for a bit but eventually gave me my money back and told me "don't ever come back here again". (Although he sure wanted me back there 30 seconds earlier when he was prepared to offer store credit) I am still in shock that he spoke to a customer like that!!! I wasn't planning on going back there anyway, obviously, but I still cannot believe the way I was treated by them when it was THEIR mistake in the first place. So, so unprofessional to say the least. I wasn't even going to leave a negative review- I just wanted my money back since I paid $85 for a cake I did not order, nor did we even like it- like I said, over half was still left, it's not like I went back there with a tiny sliver of cake. But when I was told to never come back ever again, instead of receiving an apology that they completely messed up the cake, I decided to write a review. Absolutely unbelievable. They clearly should not be in the customer service industry. read more

The Cake Gallery never ceases to amaze. The incredible cake he designed for my Grandma's birthday was exactly what we wanted. He really can do anything, but the prices are fairly high as you add to the design. This is understandable considering the time and effort required and the final product is worth it for a special occasion. The cake tasted fresh and the fillings were yummy. I would definitely order another cake from here in the future. read more

The Cake Gallery - Amazing Fresh Cake with Yummy Fillings - Bakeries Near Me - West Hempstead, New York

See all

We ordered this cake for a flirty thirty birthday in July. The cake came out fabulous. It was very delicious and everyone loved. Would definitely order again from the cake gallery. Service was exceptional. read more

The Cake Gallery - the 30th birthday cake - Bakeries Near Me - West Hempstead, New York

I cannot rate this place as far as taste is concerned because the baker was so rude as he was taking my order that I just walked out. When I walked inside this bakery I noticed that the display shelves were empty. On one side, they had these Elmo cookies that looked as if they were there for awhile. On the other side they had a few cakes and pastries, but nothing special. The man that was taking orders was rushing me and seemed very impatient. The cake was for my son's first birthday and was told he couldn't draw Disney characters because he didn't have a "copyright" for Disney..and suggested that I find a baker who has one. I'm very big on customer service and believe that without any respect for customers, it can hurt your business. Over all, I would never go back to this place to see if they are even considered a good bakery due to their rudeness. They don't deserve my business. read more

I had a great experience from start to finish, the bakery was so helpful in bringing our s'more cake vision to life and it was PERFECT, a huge hit at our sons birthday party and delicious!!!! We couldn't be happier!!! read more

The Cake Gallery - Perfectly replicated a s'more for the birthday cake - Bakeries Near Me - West Hempstead, New York

Had two cakes made for my sister's and my birthdays and they were just perfect, it was the highlight of the party and tasted even better! Plus their service and pricing are a great bonus read more

See all

Friendly service and convenient hours in the evening. What I tried: Rainbow cookies - one of the good ones I've tried so far. I'm picky about mine (texture, moistness, sweetness, chocolate, etc.), so this means they're good and I'd order again. Jam-filled croissants - a sinful treat. If you like jelly doughnuts, then you'll get the gist of this. A little sweet for me to have more than one, but worth a try. Chocolate chip cookie - no complaints: LOTS of chocolate chunks, consistency is between chewy with a bit of crunch. Something simple made well. Strawberry cake pop - would skip this. Although the cake batter was moist, I don't think I'm a fan of the strawberry flavored cake. Cheesecake - I didn't try this one, but my fiance did and said it was delicious. I saw someone picking up their custom cake and it looked great. I'll keep that in mind if I ever needed a custom cake design. I'd go back. Definitely. read more

I recommend this bakeshop if you want that old time bakery. A taste that I haven't encountered in years.... Growing up my Grandfather who was an old time German baker would bring treats home for me. Especially those giant chocolate chip cookies. Since his retirement I have been searching years for a bakeshop that made that same cookie. You can tell as soon as you walk in, that wonderful smell of quality baked goods. AND YES that chocolate chip cookie is made exactly the way I remember it. If your in the neighborhood stop in and have a cookie you wont be sorry. You will know what I'm talking about once you step foot in this bakeshop. read more

The best jelly donuts ever! The owner is not the friendliest but I guess the product makes up for that. read more

This is a neighborhood spot for myself and I must say everything I've tried is absolutely delicious. BUT nothing beats the jelly croissants. If you haven't had them it's a MUST TRY. It's seriously a piece of heaven in your mouth. read more

The Cake Gallery - Jelly croissants - Bakeries Near Me - West Hempstead, New York

I don't always write reviews but you order a cake here and you can't help yourselves but to write one. I love love love this place. I've been searching for high and low on a place that is not only a piece of art but also taste amazing. After all what is the point of buying a cake for a few hundred dollars and end up getting something that's pretty but dry and tasteless. Making cake pretty and also tasty is an art. An art I would love to learn bc I can decorate or I can bake. I can't seem to be able to do both. Aside from the tasty piece of art work - the customer service of this place is superb. When I needed to order my cake, my kids got sick and I couldn't get to the store. Tom the owner was kind enough to figure it all out with me via email and phone. I needed to stay within a certain price range and he also helped me figure it out. This place is a gem. A gem everyone should know about and a place everyone should order from. I know where we'll be going for all birthdays moving forward. read more

The Cake Gallery - a pokemon poke poke poke poke poke poke poke poke poke poke poke poke poke poke poke poke poke poke poke poke poke - Bakeries Near Me - West Hempstead, New York

See all

Stopped in for my favorite, jelly filled croissants. They were just ok. Been getting them for years but not the same since they joined forces with Hempstead bakery. read more

Coming home from dinner with a friend,googled local bakery and found The Cake Gallery. What a find! The jelly filled fried croissants are awesome, raspberry crumb square awesome, and chocolate chunk cookies awesome. Never knew this bakery existed! We will definitely be coming here for our bakery delights. Hats off to you, and lucky us for this great find. read more

I have come here for many cakes and cookies. Always a great product. Owner is always there working hard.

Excellent, friendly service, beautiful and delicious cakes. I ordered a gender reveal cake and a giant chocolate chip cookie cake (2 items that other local bakeries told me they either don't make or were very rude when I called to inquire about the options/flavors they had). This bakery was recommended to me by a friend and I will be using them for every cake/dessert in the future. Very reasonably priced and had my order done on time (with less than 4 days' notice.) read more

The Cake Gallery - Bakeries Near Me - West Hempstead, New York

The Cake Gallery is simply the best place to get a birthday cake. I got a cake for my mother's 70th Birthday Party and is was absolutely fantastic. Everyone raved about the cake. It is the perfect consistency of soft icing and fresh cake. I highly recommend anyone that needs a cake to go here. Make sure you go at least a week early to order the cake. I waited till last minute but I was accommodated but to make it easier on the establishment order early. read more

This website features beautiful cakes and creations, but their cookies and pastries are amazing! The small but immaculate bakery smells of butter and sugar the second you open their door. The chocolate chip cookies are so good my hubby almost weeps when eats them. I always stop there before heading to a holiday dinner because their offerings are always beautiful, creative and incredibly delicious! read more

The person was very kind to spray color the cup cakes and the kids loved them plus they had cream inside quite delish they said

Last weekend, Tom created three amazing cakes for my daughter's christening, mom's birthday, and husband's birthday. The cakes looked better than I could ever imagine and were absolutely fresh and delicious. My guests couldn't stop raving over how wonderful the cakes were. I have never been so pleased with bakery cakes before and Tom and the Cake Gallery have found a return customer. Plus, all of my guests wanted to know exactly where the cakes came from. Tom, thank you so much for making our celebration so special! Marie read more

Bought 12 "jelly donuts".....and I say that lightly ....had to buy a minimum of 12 if it was not a fri sat or sun . Ok...i was fine with that .. when my husband brought home the box i was a bit stunned on how they possibly fit 12 donuts in this small box ..opened it and i really dont know what the hell they were ...some croissant shaped thing , stuffed with so much jelly you couldn't even taste the pastry , not that you would want to anyway ...they were soooooo greasy, u could see it and smell it ..and soooo small.... the paper in the box was grease covered....THEY WERE DISGUSTING...so disappointed....actually , didnt even deserve one Star. But I liked the string that tied up the box .....I'm sure Dunkin donutd up the block could show them how to make a jelly donuts...they should ask for lessons read more

Cakes are moist, decorated to perfection, and worth every penny! Their irish soda bread is the best i've ever had. I love the cookies and cupcakes as well! More recently I had the croissants filled with jelly, fried and dusted with cinnamon sugar. ADDICTIVE! read more

We ordered a cake for my sons first birthday . The owner is a really nice man and bakes all the cakes himself. Not only was the cake beautiful and not nearly as expensive as other bakeries in the neighborhood it was excellent. So Fresh and delicious . I won't be going any where else for specialty cakes again . read more

The Cake Gallery - a mickey mouse cake - Bakeries Near Me - West Hempstead, New York

The best cakes on long island. So moist and delicious. They may seem a little pricy, but worth every penny. We use them for every family members birthday. Never any left overs either. Huge hit every time. Has never said No to our last minute requests. read more

Thank you Tom for a wonderful and professional experience with your shop. Our wedding cake was absolutely beautifully done and everyone complimented the flavor! read more

The Cake Gallery - My weddign cake (photography by christinealyssa.com) - Bakeries Near Me - West Hempstead, New York

Horrible service. The owner is the rudest person on earth. He stole my money and didn't deliver the cake as ordered.

I agree with an earlier review someone wrote. Although I am sure the cakes are delicious the owner was beyond rude. So in my opinion customer service is far more important. The owner seemed annoyed that I was only giving him two weeks notice and didn't want to speak on a Saturday. It was as if HE was doing ME a favor, I was about to order a pricey cake! How about taking down my number to call me on Monday and/or hiring some more staff to take orders?!?! I went to Dortoni where they had friendly staff while still having about 30 people waiting- they took 30 minutes plus reviewing my cake with me, let me text them pictures and didn't rush me even with all of those people waiting...not to mention the cake was around $300 less that the rude owner quoted me from this shop when he quickly gave me a price before I left. I have a job where I am pulled in 50 directions but relax and breathe- without customers you don't have a business! read more

I just bought the Irish Soda Bread for the first time. It is delicious. I can hardly wait to buy another one. Also, Tom makes a "Coops" cake which is out of this world. I've been going to this place for 10 yrs. and I will continue to be a customer. Everything is delicious.....Pat Gorman read more

Best cookies and cream cake ever! Cake pops and rainbow cookies are the best around! A lil pricey though...but goooood stuff!

I have never in my entire life had a chocolate chip cookie that good! They surpassed perfection. I haven't tried anything else but I liked watching the guy assemble the fondant on a cake read more

This place is AMAZING!!! The cupcakes, brownies and cookies are like the old time baked goods. Like a pro grandma would make. Incredible! But that magic cookie is ridiculously good. Love this place. read more

Can't even give this place one star. Total waste of time. Guy tells my wife to come in to sample stuff. He comes out the back with an attitude. He wanted no part in helping us. I walked out of the place. Guys a jerk. His staff is useless, they just sit and stare off. read more

The most beautifully detailed and exquisite cakes I've seen. True artistry. Even better, they are moist, delicious and utterly divine. He made an Eiffel Tower cake for me for my mother-in-law who is obsessed with Paris. The Napoleon cake was delectable and the 3 foot Eiffel Tower on it, completely edible. I'm so sorry I don't have a photo, but it should have been in a magazine! read more