Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    The Cake Gallery

    4.2 (46 reviews)
    Open 6:00 am - 6:00 pm

    The Cake Gallery Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - The Cake Gallery

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    The cake was so delicious, super moist and the cannoli cream filling is yummy!
    Arooj R.

    Lovely little bakery. Tom, the owner, is a pleasure to work with. Easy to reach via phone or email, and easy to communicate ideas with. I had a specific cake in mind for my daughter's 3rd birthday and what Tom made for us was better than what I had imagined. I will be ordering more cakes from The Cake Gallery in the future! P.S: The Irish soda bread is AMAZING

    Shafeena K.

    This was just a random bakery my family and I spotted in our way to a BBQ. We decided to stop in to get a cake. We ended up getting a cake that looked liked a hamburger! Lol, it was cute! It was pretty delicious too. I loved it. Great find! As for the staff, they were just as sweet!

    Teapot cake

    The Cake Gallery did not disappoint in flavor or in how beautiful the cake looked. We had a tea for two theme and it tasted delicious. The baker who is also the owner worked for me to make my vision come to life. He helped me figure out how much cake I needed to serve and cupcakes too. He accommodated me by letting me have two different flavors in the cake. We got so many compliments on the cake and the cupcakes. I will be ordering again from them In the near future!

    A work of art from The Cake Gallery!
    Sarah H.

    Amazing!!! The artistry, the culinary skill all rolled into one! His cake creation was a surprise as a part of a party we held this summer - I sent in the artwork and we discussed the different options. We communicated mostly via email or on the phone - but everything was flawless! The cake was delicious and the surprise was well received ! Ps, I highly recommend Oreo cookie filling!

    Baby shower cake

    I've ordered two cakes from Tom at the cake gallery in the past two months and both cakes tasted just as good as they looked! Everyone loved how cute they came out and couldn't get enough of the delicious the cookies and cream filling! Thank you Cake Gallery!

    Amazing Fresh Cake with Yummy Fillings
    Ally B.

    The Cake Gallery never ceases to amaze. The incredible cake he designed for my Grandma's birthday was exactly what we wanted. He really can do anything, but the prices are fairly high as you add to the design. This is understandable considering the time and effort required and the final product is worth it for a special occasion. The cake tasted fresh and the fillings were yummy. I would definitely order another cake from here in the future.

    the 30th birthday cake
    Noreeen J.

    We ordered this cake for a flirty thirty birthday in July. The cake came out fabulous. It was very delicious and everyone loved. Would definitely order again from the cake gallery. Service was exceptional.

    Birthday cake !
    Afia A.

    Had two cakes made for my sister's and my birthdays and they were just perfect, it was the highlight of the party and tasted even better! Plus their service and pricing are a great bonus

    Perfectly replicated a s'more for the birthday cake
    Didem D.

    I had a great experience from start to finish, the bakery was so helpful in bringing our s'more cake vision to life and it was PERFECT, a huge hit at our sons birthday party and delicious!!!! We couldn't be happier!!!

    Jelly croissants
    Christian D.

    This is a neighborhood spot for myself and I must say everything I've tried is absolutely delicious. BUT nothing beats the jelly croissants. If you haven't had them it's a MUST TRY. It's seriously a piece of heaven in your mouth.

    a pokemon poke poke poke poke poke poke poke poke poke poke poke poke poke poke poke poke poke poke poke poke poke
    Cheryl N.

    I don't always write reviews but you order a cake here and you can't help yourselves but to write one. I love love love this place. I've been searching for high and low on a place that is not only a piece of art but also taste amazing. After all what is the point of buying a cake for a few hundred dollars and end up getting something that's pretty but dry and tasteless. Making cake pretty and also tasty is an art. An art I would love to learn bc I can decorate or I can bake. I can't seem to be able to do both. Aside from the tasty piece of art work - the customer service of this place is superb. When I needed to order my cake, my kids got sick and I couldn't get to the store. Tom the owner was kind enough to figure it all out with me via email and phone. I needed to stay within a certain price range and he also helped me figure it out. This place is a gem. A gem everyone should know about and a place everyone should order from. I know where we'll be going for all birthdays moving forward.

    See all

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Thomas S.

    Thomas S.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of ray a.
    129
    7
    0

    12 years ago

    We have had 3 different Birthday Cakes all were awesome, moist, beautifully decorated!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Thomas S.

    Thomas S.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - The Cake Gallery

    Review Highlights - The Cake Gallery

    I have never been so pleased with bakery cakes before and Tom and the Cake Gallery have found a return customer.

    Mentioned in 7 reviews

    Read more highlights

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Bakeries 12,360 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Riesterer's Bakery - Dry Napoleon

    Riesterer's Bakery

    3.6(105 reviews)
    0.0 mi
    $$

    I don't shop at here often. However, every time I do have to order a cake. I am never disappointed…read more My daughter specifically said she wanted a cake from Riesterer's Bakery......well actually she said she wants a pudding cake for her birthday. LOL. I knew what she wanted because I always order a cake with half choc. pudding, half custard for my Job when we have an event and they get it from here. Anyway I digress. I placed an order for my daughter's 21st bday and I have a vision cake that I created with the help of AI. The first picture. The person taking my order was very transparent and informed me that because I used AI the cake will not be exactly as I I visited but they would do their best........DROP THE F'&$*! MIKE!!!!! (Photo 2) Needless to say Riesterer's did not disappoint once again.

    What used to be a go-to place for the last over 40 years has declined greatly. There is too much…read morecompetition to keep going to a place who sells napoleons with dry filo dough and old cupcakes. I'm not clear on why a business would sell or even keep expired food. Cupcakes are supposed to be light, fluffy and moist. This was hard as a brick. Why would you sell this to a customer? When an 8 year old won't even eat it...... Should I also mention taking cash and working the cash register and then touching food without washing hands or gloves? Unsanitary Childhood memories destroyed.

    Photos
    Riesterer's Bakery - And Just Like That... A Fluffle  My surprise baby shower cake

    And Just Like That... A Fluffle My surprise baby shower cake

    Riesterer's Bakery - Old Napoleon. Dry filo

    Old Napoleon. Dry filo

    Riesterer's Bakery - Dry

    See all

    Dry

    Buttercooky Bakery - Tres leche latte

    Buttercooky Bakery

    3.3(950 reviews)
    3.5 mi
    $$

    Food: This bakery is a small chain and seems like a local favorite in Long Island. I am not from…read morethe area but came here for a wedding cake tasting recently and also picked up a few items. There was a constant long line of customers during our wedding cake tasting. Bakery items are fresh and good quality. My favorite item was the hazelnut eclair and chocolate eclair with vanilla cream. Both were delicious! Service: Staff were friendly and helpful during our cake tasting. Ambiance: This is a pretty large bakery with a few tables and chairs for eating. Tables are small and each fit 2-3 people at most. Overall, I would recommend this bakery!

    Visiting Buttercooky Bakery on 6/25 and 6/28 brought about an increase in stars and better…read moreexperience. Stepping inside of this magnificent dessert emporium I became perplexed by the variety of desserts and pastries that were very desirable and readily available. In the words of Vinnie Barbarino, I'm so confused (IYKYK). It's a different setup that causes the line to move faster than it used to, I see the improvement. The ordering is done in one place and cashing out is next to it, in the same area. You still walk in and head straight to the display cases where you pick you pleasure. I did not pick my names sake only because it slipped my mind due to me being focused on breakfast. No, I don't eat cakes for breakfast. I picked up a couple croissants, apple turnover, a couple of cheese Danishes, and an almond croissant. Service was prompt and the employees were attentive as well as pleasant. I like how they approach the counter and inquire about your status versus staring at you letting you try to figure out if someone is going to help you or not. At the check out, there's the coffee station or tea. I ordered 2 French Vanilla coffees, to say the least the French vanilla flavor seemed distant to none. On the second trip it was exact same coffee request with the same results. An improvement needed is to have different sweetners for the coffee. Not everyone wants white sugar or sweet n low. Since the vanilla syrup is not sweet enough, another liquid sweetener can work. Nonetheless this was such a sweet experience! Inspire more, Yelp more!

    Photos
    Buttercooky Bakery - Pineapple Upside Down

    Pineapple Upside Down

    Buttercooky Bakery
    Buttercooky Bakery

    See all

    Sydney's Sweets - Wedding Cake at Ophelia Castle

    Sydney's Sweets

    4.6(152 reviews)
    0.4 mi
    $$

    I wanted to get an incredible cake for the gf and her friends for her birthday and fired up my…read morehandy dandy Yelp app. While scrolling through some great options, I saw Sydney's Sweets pop up in the list and was so glad I did. Now I've known about them for a while but this was my first actually ordering from them. I called on a Saturday at about 3pm and Jermaine answered the call, both literally and figuratively. I nervously mentioned I needed a cake for the evening.. by 6pm, as I needed to be in Williamsburg by 7:15pm. He responded not to worry as they had a beautiful 10'' double chocolate, oreo cookie, multi-layered cake that would fit the occasion perfectly... my heroes! The gf and her friends absolutely loved the cake and were wow'd by how pretty, big and delicious it was. We had 7 people at the table and even after some folks took big pieces to go, we had nearly half the cake to take home!

    Very pleased with Sydney's Sweets. I had a vision, and they nailed it. They were professional and…read moreresponsive, communication was great, and they understood the assignment. The cake was at the venue before I arrived, so I didn't have to worry about delivery, which was particularly helpful since the party was in Manhattan. The cake was a huge part of our 50th birthday celebration, and I'm so glad we used them. Not only was the cake flawless, but it also tasted good - it was red velvet with cream cheese frosting. I would definitely use this company again, you won't be disappointed.

    Photos
    Sydney's Sweets - First Communion Dessert Table

    First Communion Dessert Table

    Sydney's Sweets - 5 Tier Wedding Cake

    5 Tier Wedding Cake

    Sydney's Sweets - Baby Smith Dessert Table

    See all

    Baby Smith Dessert Table

    The Cake Gallery - bakeries - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...