Best breakfast burritos I've ever had! Service is great employees are courteous and quick. Food choices are fresh highly recommend.

This might be the most rude group of people I've ever had to deal with at a coffee shop. I've gone in there for three straight days, buying a cuppa coffee, something to eat, and as I went up to the counter to get a refill, always asked towards a charge for the refill. Answer was no great. On the fourth day went in same sequence ordered coffee paid for food and then went to get a refill. Coffee was told that would be $3.75 cost of a new cup of coffee which took me my surprise of course I love people know that I've been there for three straight days and it was never the policy, and they literally started laughing at me looking at one another, not looking at me insane. I think I got lucky literally insulting me to my face and behind my face. Never offering any type of explanation or anything of the sort test literally laughing at me. So if you want to be laughed at if you want to be insulted, if you want to make an explanation about how the rules changed this is the place to go how ignorant some people should not be in the Service business, and everyone behind the counter should not be in the surface business read more

You can tell how fun the vibe is at The Coffee Potter as soon as you walk in. All of the baristas seem like friends, and are smiling and having fun behind the counter. I liked this and thought it made the vibe really inviting. The only thing is that they were super busy between the counter and the drive-thru, so my coffee took a while. This is fine because it's a fun place to hang out, but may not be great if you're in a rush! I listened to the baristas rec and ordered the Iced White Mocha. It was more like a dessert than a coffee, but delicious nonetheless! The also added some whipped cream for me which made it even more indulgent. I'd love to come back to order another and stay a bit longer! read more

The Coffee Potter - Iced White Mocha - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Long Valley, New Jersey

The Coffee Potter has a really cute rustic-chic atmosphere and feels like the kind of coffee shop where you could easily spend a few hours working. The space is welcoming, offers free Wi-Fi, and the staff members were incredibly warm, kind, and helpful. One thing I appreciated was how dog-friendly they are. Dogs are welcome inside while ordering, though they ask that you sit outside afterward. Fortunately, there is plenty of outdoor seating available. We visited on a beautiful summer morning, so sitting outside was so pretty and scenic. They also offer a drive-through, though it's very popular so be prepared for a long line during the morning rush! We visited around 9:15 AM on a weekday and the drive-through was very busy. The prices were surprisingly affordable, especially compared to many coffee shops today. The drinks themselves didn't quite wow me. I found the espresso a bit mild, and our drinks leaned more milky than coffee-forward. I also wish there were more gluten-free food options. The only gluten-free items available were a brownie and a walnut chocolate chip biscotti. Unfortunately no gluten-free breakfast or pastry options. I did try the gluten-free biscotti and it was just okay, but it wasn't anything particular special. Overall, The Coffee Potter has a great atmosphere, friendly staff, reasonable prices, and a convenient location. While I probably wouldn't make a special trip just for the drinks, I'd absolutely stop by again if I were in the area or looking for a coffee before heading out on the trail. read more

See all

Cute spot with a wonderful outdoor seating area, plus plenty of indoor seating if you prefer. They also have a convenient drive-thru, which is a nice bonus! I ordered a vanilla iced latte with oat milk. For my taste, it was a bit too sweet and a little too light. I prefer a stronger coffee flavor. That said, the atmosphere was great, and I'd come back to try other drinks on the menu. read more

The Coffee Potter - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Long Valley, New Jersey

See all

Dear Yelp, I was in the area and made it a point to stop in as I've heard wonderful things. Service was friendly and fast. My daughter enjoyed her frozen hot chocolate with whipped cream. My husband had a vanilla frozen latte with oat milk and an added shot of protein. He said it was good but he felt very jittery afterwards. I had the frozen cafe latte. It was very milk-shake-esque. It was good, but didn't really give off frozen latte vibes. I'd like to go back and try something hot next time. Love, Nicole read more

The Coffee Potter - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Long Valley, New Jersey

Okayyyy service was slow but that's okay I'm just glad this place has a drive thru which is convenient, it was busy for it to have been 4 PM guess everyone needed a caffeine pick me up. Outdoors seems to have some seating unsure about indoor as I was in my car, the crumb cake was delicious very big ate a half and the rest I have to my mother. The toasted almond latte unfortunately wasn't my preference... it wasn't too strong the taste just wasn't good in my opinion. read more

See all

Stopped in for a hot coffee while in the Long Valley area and wow a Local Hotspot offering great coffee drinks and much more. The service is amazing and a very comfortable experience both inside and plenty of outdoor seating as well! read more

The Coffee Potter - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Long Valley, New Jersey

See all

The coffee here is amazing! I'm not a coffee person but really enjoyed the flavors and customizations. The food selection was very limited. I think if they had more than one vegetarian options it'd be a big hit. I was surprised I didn't hear about it earlier but I enjoyed it! I'd probably stop by again if they had some stronger food options. read more

Arrive here in the morning after my morning walk, ordered a cappuccino. The environment was calm but was there 1 hour after they are open on a weekend so I can't describe too honestly. The staff were friendly and got my order with great efficiency. read more

Been to The Coffee Potter many times. They have good coffee and tea drinks. They have breakfast and lunch burritos along with cookies and other baked goods. The prices are reasonable. This is a good place for coffee. read more

Just adore this place. I use the drive thru AND the cafe area and both are excellent. The care and concern for not just the food but the experience is something I TRULY appreciate. read more

They have the best coffee and fresh muffins. When I am in the area I always stop by. There was a line but it moved fast. You can sit inside or there are chairs outside if the weather is nice. They also have a drive thru. read more

Great coffee spot right next to the trail! Quick, easy and convenient. Definitely recommend!

Bustling but chill. Loud but a whole vibe. No frills but contemporary. My coffee was spot on. Perfectly bold and delicious. Prices were very decent. Bathroom was nice... that matters to me. Why the 4 stars? I was a little put off by the wait to put in my order. I understand how incredibly busy they were on a Sunday morning but I was never acknowledged with a greeting nor was I told why there was a hold up. They could've made up an excuse like the register was glitchy or I'm waiting for the system to reboot but I got nothing. A very nice worker saw me standing there a bit & asked for my order until the original cashier stopped her. Neither gave an explanation. I just stood there til they were ready. read more

See all

While I was I originally on my way to Wawa for a quick morning coffee before work. I saw this small shop and decided to pull in. Glad they had a fast drive through made it super convenient even more then Wawa. Similar to CFA they had someone outside taking orders making the process as smooth as it can be. She let me know the vegetarian and vegan options available as well as details on the ingredients. I ended up ordering the hot caramel latte as well as the vegetarian burrito. Honestly I would give this shop a 5 star based on hospitality alone. All the workers I had the pleasure to interact with were incredibly sweet and gave the best energy. Will come back again, if not to try other yummy options then for the friendly smiles. read more

See all

This is such a cute cafe! The inside is just the right size, pretty spacious. The additional drive through was nice to see as well as I have not seen many small coffee shops have this feature. The drinks here are very tasty, plenty of options and also a variety of baked goods as well. Alternative milks are provided here as well! The drinks came out pretty quickly. Definitely recommend stopping by if you are in this area! read more

A staple stop indeed to bring home their classic crumb cake please & thank you. The most delicious coffee & tea creations keep one returning when in Long Valley. read more

I love everything, I love the warmed up croissant on the grill, me and my kids love this place read more

The Coffee Potter - Best place to eat and great customer service - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Long Valley, New Jersey

See all

Honestly one of the best local coffee shops I've ever been too and I'm very lucky to live near by this special one. The interior is great, it shows the history of the surrounding town and its people. The service is great, it's very quick with both walk in and drive through and the coffee itself is top tier. For being such a small local coffee shop, this place is perfect. read more

The Coffee Potter - White mocha - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Long Valley, New Jersey

Besides the great customer (staff is so friendly and patience is key when working the counter and they have patience) service coffee and tea selection is so delicious.... It is such a perfect beginning and end of day treat.. it really is the best location for those who want to take their bikes and the walking trails are so peaceful... read more

Its a great local coffee shop with th best service and food and it has a fun and cool atmosphere.

Been going here for years! Fun location Schooley's Mountain Rd. Always flavorful coffee. Their mochas are to die for. Sundays until 5pm too. Don't miss it read more

The Coffee Potter - Caffe Mocha - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Long Valley, New Jersey

See all

Here's the deal : this place looks to be a transformed bank into the nicest coffee /pastry shop. It has a drive up window & someone taking orders on an iPad to help expedite the line! The coffee potter Is secret to the locals on the area. There are Adirondack chairs outside to enjoy ur drink & enjoy the sunshine ! The inside has a cozy vibe if you want to find a corner to read a book or crack open ur laptop and surf the web. Stop here grab ur drink and head across the street to the columbia trail for a nice stroll!!! Finally OMG THE CRUMB CAKE is a must !! read more

The Coffee Potter - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Long Valley, New Jersey

Went here all the time when I was little and it was some of the greatest food I had. I would have it almost every day when I would go to school and I never would regret it. read more

As a runner and caffeine addict, I plan some of my runs around where I'm going to get coffee afterward. After a run down the Columbia Trail, I stopped at The Coffee Potter for an iced vanilla latte. I walked in with a group of girls who just came from a Pilates class and I loved how the staff was so welcoming and remembered all of them! Oh and they even have a drive through and burritos which I will have to try the next time I stop by! read more

The Coffee Potter - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Long Valley, New Jersey

See all

the frozen hot chocolate is SO GOOD the cookies are warm and very yummy the staff is so sweet the vibe is so cute as it's a little coffee shop the outside area is very well decorated with flowers and benches i love going here and then walking on the trail afterwards love you coffee potter read more

Love TCP!!! Coffee is always amazing and the breakfast wraps are delicious as well. Inside is cozy and a good coffee shop to study or chat at. Staff is always kind and community vibe here. Absolutely go for coffee if you're in the area! read more

There's a drive through!!! Very conveniently located in town. Ordered a breakfast burrito and lunch burrito (pulled pork) and large iced green tea. Total was about $18.50. They serve the lunch and breakfast burritos all day apparently! Will I be back to try their pastries? Yes. read more

The Coffee Potter - Breakfast burrito w sausage egg and hash brown - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Long Valley, New Jersey

I've gotten matcha and coffee from this place before and both times they decided to give me a cup of almond milk with a pinch of my desired drink... if you like this place you don't know what a good coffee is. read more

Get: Crumb Cake! It's everything a crumb cake should be! The cake is buttery and soft and the crumbs on top are huge! Boulders on top of the cake. What an amazing treat. The Coffee Potter is a unique cafe located right by a bike trail and alot of parks! It has a drive thru, which I havent seen for a coffee place except for like Starbucks and DD. The inside is on the smaller side, a handful of tables but there is a separate room with couches - a better spot for convos. The wooden pews along the wall are a nice touch. It's warmly decorated and has a small town feel to it. Service here was friendly. But they are so busy its pretty much order and then you are on your way. I did like that when a regular walked in the baristas knew them by name and their order. Vanilla latte was good just ever so slightly sweet. I had it with oatmilk. It was good..nothing outstanding here. The second beverages I asked what their recommendation would be for a hot latte, they said their TCP mocha latte was very popular its made with white mocha and caramel. I got it without whip and with oatmilk...OOF tasty but owww so sweet lol. It's more a dessert then it is coffee. Not exactly what I was looking for but it was good. While I was studying here, I kept hearing "buffalo chicken" so I had to get the buffalo chicken wrap on my way to go. It was good but not the best I've had. All in all, it was a nice visit but not sure if I'll be back. read more

The Coffee Potter - Coffee cake and vanilla latte - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Long Valley, New Jersey

See all

Cozy coffee spot with a drive-through?! Say less. I got the Vanilla Spice Latte and it was delightful. They had a large selection of treats as well. I can't wait to try one next time! read more

The Coffee Potter - Vanilla spice latte - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Long Valley, New Jersey

I prefer little cafes over chains like Starbucks and Dunkin' so I gave this place a shot. It's Sunday today and a lot of other places by me close early so I took a little drive to The Coffee Potter. Great ambiance and it was well staffed so there was almost no wait, but the coffee was very underwhelming. I ordered an iced latte and long story short, the latte tasted mostly like milk which leads me to believe that either their espresso shots are smaller than what's considered "standard" or they didn't make the latte properly. I feel like lattes are kind of difficult to mess up but I come across poorly made ones more often than not and feel like I've developed a baseline for what's acceptable. Now, this review is not meant to rip into this particular establishment but rather hopefully provide some constructive criticism and help others make informed decisions and set their expectations. With that said, if I'm ever in the area again and in need of an iced beverage, I may consider giving this place a second try, but I might also have to ask for an additional shot, which really shouldn't be necessary but sometimes you just have to make do with what's available. read more

The Coffee Potter - Iced latte - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Long Valley, New Jersey

We visited Ort Farm and the Coffee Potter happened to be there. As someone who loves Lattes, I could not wait to try a Chia Latte. The service was amazing! The owner was so nice! We will be back. 10/10 read more

I honestly feel horrible leaving a bad review about this place, because they are so friendly and personable! However, the food was horrendous. I ordered the egg white burrito, and a blueberry muffin and my husband ordered the chocolate croissant. Unfortunately, the burrito was cold in the middle, no flavor and after one bite, that couldn't swallow it and just couldn't eat it. The muffins and croissants tasted like store bought and unable to eat them. We brought everything to the back, to return the dishes, and their face was all confused on why nothing was eaten. I preferred just to say thank you and walk away. I really wanted to like this place, but sadly won't be coming back. The matcha almond milk tea was OK and my husband had a hot chocolate, which was good. read more

A charming coffee shop with a warm vibe ( &&drive up window!) -The Occasion: Coffee Fix -The Atmosphere: Be careful when you're pulling into the parking lot, as the gorgeous Columbia Trail is directly to your right (pedestrians)! You currently have the option to park and order inside or utilize the drive-up window. I normally choose the drive-up window... there's something nice about it! They have a staff member taking orders on a tablet outside so when you pull up to the window, you order is usually ready. If the line is long, I typically listen to one of my podcasts and relax! -The Menu: They have all the coffee things... and bakery things!! I've recently grown fond of their iced dirty chai with 2 shots. Simply amazing! Their lattes, iced coffee and cappuccinos are also delicious. I've tried their scones and muffins, too... great stuff! -The Service: The entire staff (from order to pick up) is extremely friendly and helpful! They always have excellent recommendations for beverages or eats if you're unsure of what to order. -The Total: A medium beverage and something to munch on will cost about $7. -The Experience: TCP has become a part of my weekend routine. Tasty coffee, delicious treats, and a staff that is always friendly and smiling (at least I assume they're smiling under their masks!). If you're ever in the area, I highly recommend stopping by for some coffee and a sweet treat! read more

The Coffee Potter - a cup of coffee on the dashboard of a car - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Long Valley, New Jersey

OBSESSED. They had delicious drip coffee and one of the best muffins I've ever had. They've also decorated the place so nicely and it has that great coffee shop aesthetic I was craving. The baristas were super friendly and welcoming. All around a great experience. Will definitely be back! read more

The Coffee Potter - Muffin and coffee - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Long Valley, New Jersey

See all

Traveling through to Ort Farm, stopped by and the food, service, and ambiance is great!!

Coffee was excellent. Nice spot, prices are good, and has a nice vibe. For a coffee spot, this place hits all the right notes. read more

The Coffee Potter - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Long Valley, New Jersey

Amazing coffee from a little drive thru. I got the iced TCP Mocha which didn't taste very much like coffee which I liked but coffee lovers may want to add an extra shot. Very nice staff and answered all questions very quickly. Very efficient as the line moves fast. read more

The Coffee Potter - Medium iced TCP Mocha with almond milk - Coffee & Tea Near Me - Long Valley, New Jersey