Old style diner with the usual fare of burgers and grilled cheeses. No pretense. Food was okay. Service was okay. I had the meat loaf sandwich which came with a pickle and a minuscule amount of cole slaw. Had a spice in it that I had never experienced before with meat loaf, but edible. The coconut custard pie was delicious. Would I come here again? Probably not. read more

See all

Delicious eggs bacon and homefries stop when you're heading east on the North Fork. Good pit stop for breakfast or lunch. Nice service in an old-style luncheonette. No fuss, but good service. Its my kind of place. Low key and tasty. The price os competitive. Everything is expensive these days, so...Im sucking it up on my travels. read more

See all

I stopped in for breakfast randomly because I had to wait for a customer down the block. The staff were very friendly , mostly locals in the old school diner . The food was good , just got some eggs, bacon and home fries. I tried the chocolate chip pancakes and they were very good. Would recommend and definitely go back if In the area. read more

The Cutchogue Diner - Chocolate chip pancakes - Diners Near Me - Cutchogue, New York

See all

I was sick for a week after eating there. I had food poisoning that caused me to have diarrhea for better than 5 days. My system is still not settled yet and it has been 2 weeks tomorrow. Clean up your surfaces and check the age of your products. Clean the fuse box surface there is some black substance on it. Check the cleanliness of your ice machine. Give the place a washing from stem to stern. And my burger was dry for a rare cooked burger. Other than that you are quaint read more

This is an update. Cutchouge Diner is the bomb. I have been coming here for decades and nothing has changed including the quality of the food and the friendly service. It is a must-stop when I get back into town and they have the best link sausages I have ever eaten. Stop here enough mornings and there will be somebody who knows your name. Avail yourself of a bit of nostalgia of eating in an old-fashioned American diner while they still exist. read more

A great diner spot, very classic and vintage reminding you of the way that old school 50's boxcar style was like. Place was super busy when I walked in, so I got a seat at the counter, which had plenty of stools available. Had a standard breakfast, good spinach/veggie omelette, fresh coffee, water refills, jams and jellies for your toast. A great breakfast really. 5 stars. Enjoyed this place. The classic diner experience. read more

A throwback. A typical diner, nothing fancy but good food. I had a meatloaf sandwich and my wife had a tuna fish sandwich. Good service with a smile. read more

A true landmark! Old fashion diner with good food, good service, takes you back in time!! Recommend for sure

This has, for decades, been the stopping off point when we are headed to take the Ferry to Connecticut at Orient Point. It is one of only a few train car diners on the island, and the only one I know of in Suffolk County. Moer to the point, the food never disappoints - good wholesome stick to the ribs comfort food. On our latest visit, I had a turkey dinner with all the trimmings/ It was all great, but the potatoes and stuffing were absolutely to die for. Service is always pleasant and efficient. May they keep going for decades more like this. read more

See all

Nice quaint diner. Delicious food, friendly mom and pop service, and great ambience! The coffee was extra delicious! Homemade pie for dessert also delicious! Bought a T-shirt for my son who treated his mom. Highly recommended. read more

The Cutchogue Diner - Best coffee... East end deliciousness - Diners Near Me - Cutchogue, New York

See all

My husband and I pass here all the time back and forth to the ferry. He has said for years he wanted to stop here. So we did. The place is very small in the front but there is a back with tables. The tables are pretty much on top of one another. The man behind me kept moving his chair and banged into me each time. The table we sat at rocked every time we used a knife. The decor needs a much needed facelift. It's a very old diner, but come on! Clean it up a bit. The food was ok, nothing special but not bad. The eggs were cooked over easy, as ordered. The home fries were delicious. The kielbasa was just ok. Their French toast is made with thin bread or it's flatten down while cooking it. It was thin but good. The sausage was a big link and ok. We would not return here. read more

Closes by 3pm! This diner is classic. Friendly and kind waitresses. Portions are not overwhelming large. Just right. read more

See all

I did not have a chance to eat here. I stopped in to see if they were open and was told they were closing at 3 and we would have to be quick. It was 2:33. I said we were just having sandwiches and there would be three of us. When the server glanced around I said my handicapped mother would be in soon. She looked out and saw my mother coming with her walker and said by the time she gets in here there just won't be any time, with an "ugh" to boot. I was ushered out the door. There will never be a review from me as I will never eat here. I have run restaurants my whole adult life and I would never treat a handicapped person in that manner. My mother almost burst into tears. read more

Food is made fresh . Very homey lovely staff. Old school decor worth a try. Good service

food is always delicious!!!! service is excellent!!!! love visiting this landmark!!! don't pass this gem up!!!!! read more

I haven't been here in years, man what have I been missing? I picked a nice, sunny & most importantly of all quiet late Wednesday morning to enjoy this landmark diner in the center of the north fork. Needless to say I enjoyed the whole experience as much as my breakfast it self. If you haven't seen this establishment it is an old school silver stream style diner. Check it out, you won't be disappointed. read more

The Cutchogue Diner - Western omelette, with crispy home fries & dark toast! - Diners Near Me - Cutchogue, New York

First and last. We ordered meatloaf and it was tasteless and served with an overcook broccoli. How are they not ashamed to serve a plate with a yellow broccoli to their clients? Shame of them. read more

A top, local favorite! Always fresh, always timely, and always a pleasant experience. It is also nice that the owner is on hand and present during business hours. read more

I give it a five because it has good home made food. It is Not one of those 200 items on the menu diner. Built in 1941, you will step back in time. Great coffee. I had pancakes that were light and perfect. Place hasn't changed in the decades I have been coming. Formica tables. Waitress very friendly and attentive. I love coming here during the week Roads too crowded on weekends now until November. read more

The Cutchogue Diner - Counter service - Diners Near Me - Cutchogue, New York

Great old home cooking diner . Retro burgers breakfast all good bring back nice memories

Wow! Just wow! An unforgettable diner experience, the Cutchogue Diner has a peaceful atmosphere, excellent service, and superb food. I was promised "the best bacon", and they delivered! My new favorite spot on the North Fork. If you're thinking of anywhere else for breakfast, you're making a mistake; come here instead! Highly recommend the Chili Cheddar Omelet! read more

Very friendly and good food !! Waffles are awesome!! Seating is far apart in order to social distance. We felt safe eating here. read more

I love this place. Great breakfast with great prices. Such a relic but it's awesome. Get the poached eggs or banana pancakes!

Absolutely amazing!!! Delicious pancakes, home fries, toast, eggs and bacon! I want to go back right now and have it again and I just left! We loved our waitress! read more

This is a great first date spot. Spinach and feta omelet is amazing. Friendly and quick service. Absolutely love this place

This place is awesome. Old fashioned diner experience (I'm waiting for the blob to come get me) . The chili was awesome....I wish I took a picture of it! The fried flounder is delicious as well! Our waitress Debbie gave us terrific recommendations! A must stop in Cutchogue! read more

The Cutchogue Diner - Good ole fashioned dinner# - Diners Near Me - Cutchogue, New York

See all

Amazing breakfast. Fast and pleasant service. Very local spot that we love bringing family to when they are in town visiting us. Highly recommended. read more

Best chef in town. Fernando knows about good service, attention and how to prepare an excellent lunch - we love this place! Try the tuna melt sandwich! read more

Very cute little place. It is an official historic site and definitely has that authentic diner feel! We arrived during a busy Sunday lunch rush and were lucky to get a table. They also have seating at the counter with very cool old stools. We seated ourselves and had to wait about 5 minutes before having our drink order taken. They were very busy though, so we didn't mind. Both waitresses were pleasant in an old diner way. We had the turkey dinner and grilled cheese. Grilled cheese was tasty. The turkey dinner was good as well, although it would have been nice to have fresh vegetables (they were either canned or frozen, mixed veggies). I believe the stuffing and mashed potatoes were homemade, but the cranberry sauce was canned. There was a good portion of turkey and gravy. Overall a very filling meal! read more

Solid diner food. Friendly service. Eggs any way you like 'em. These are the basic elements of any good diner (in my book) and The Cutchogue certainly fulfills these requirements. We stopped in here on our way back to the airport in Islip, looking for delicious fuel for our travels ahead. Thankfully, the diner provided us with just what we were looking for. I chowed down on a breakfast sandwich that was totally satisfying and tasty; egg and cheese on a fluffy roll. Delicious and completely filling. Home fries accompanied my sammie and they were seasoned well and added a great flavorful aspect to my order. The bf is an oatmeal fan, so he ordered the instant oatmeal (the waitress made a point of telling us it was instant when we ordered- props to her for that!) with a side of home fries. Thankfully he loved the home fries, because the oatmeal just wasn't too appetizing. Honestly, with instant oatmeal the expectations can't really be too high, so I wouldn't really recommend it unless you cant eat eggs or pancakes, As others have mentioned, the diner is truly an old mobile home made into a restaurant, with additions created to accommodate additional patrons and the kitchen. It's super casual and welcoming. Parking's available in the back lot, so it's not difficult to abandon the vehicle for an hour or so. If you're in the area and looking for standard American breakfast, then give this place a shot. The bfast Sammie just may surprise you. read more

Welcome back to the 1950s! No, this isn't a themed diner, but rather it's still a chrome-plated teensy tiny diner in an airstream! Very cool greasy spoon, but the quarters are a little tight. And parking is a nightmare on the main drag in Cutchogue. It's fun for a one-time visit. read more

We're taking it back a few decades... welcome to north fork long island, circa 1950s. Farms, hicks and wide open land Huzzah! Cut-cha-geew diner reminds you of this and stays true to its roots. The decor is traditional and most likely original, minus a few upgrades like the seats and such. You can see they tried to match it all up. Me and two very good friends stopped in here for a bite before wine tasting for the day. It was sweet, the service was personal, fast and smiling. The food was A-OK (thanks yelp for the expression), your typical diner fare. The place is tiny and there isn't much parking but it's worth the nostalgia trip. I'll be stopping in again, im sure :) read more

I've eaten at quite a few diners in my time, having been a teenager in New York City suburbs, and I had a good diner time at the Cutchogue Diner. The waitress was friendly. The menu was simple but had all of the requisite diner dishes. The food came quickly and tasted just fine (I had a very filled ham and cheddar omelet accompanied by curly French fries). The sodas came with free refills, of which we got three, without having to ask! I also liked that as I ate my food, "The Cutchogue Diner" slowly revealed itself on their personalized plates. It was a nice touch. When I visit my friends in the spring and summer for wine tastings and beach fun, I will definitely make a point of coming back here. read more

I stumbled on the Cutchogue Diner on my way into the North Fork touring wineries. What a great, truly local experience. I enjoyed a meatloaf sandwich (as listed on the Specials board, and on the advice of the server who said it was "good today"), and would have loved some dessert had the sandwich not been so filling! The pie list was simply classic. It's the kind of "local flavor" place I crave when traveling, and I'd easily go back were I in the area again. read more

Great old style ny diner! Don't expect classy meals, but do expect nice friendly service, and the usual diner food. Top quality, and you have to get a shake while your there!! It is a great stop if your heading to the Orient pt ferry to New England, or through wine country. The diner is sure to please. I would reccomend traveling to this diner, either in the fall while the trees are changing, rt 25 is beautiful that time of year, or the spring/summer as the sights are nice, but beware of traffic in the nice weather. read more

Perhaps my favorite diner for breakfast or lunch. Everything is delicious. The servers are very friendly. Prices very reasonable. My wife and I often make a trip here for breakfast and local stops. Well worth the 45 minute drive. The potatoes are delicious, egg dishes, fresh kielbasa, homemade muffins... Getting hungry writing this. Anyway, stop there, it's great. read more

This is the best diner I have ever been to. My girlfriend and I try to come out here as often as possible. Whether we get breakfast, an omelette(kielbasa omelette is amazing), pancakes, or hash... Or if we get a gyro, meatloaf sandwich, or burger, there food is always amazingly perfect every time. Even there coffee is great. It's worth the 30 minute drive every time. Some of the best service I have ever had, great small town diner feel... You won't feel like a stranger when you eat there. read more

This is not good, My business partner and I were out east and saw this old style box car diner and thought it would be cool to stop in for lunch. It was around 12;30 and we were the only people there. We ordered 2 burgers deluxe and within minutes the place had a very strong smell of bacon. I think they turned on the grill and the remnants of breakfast was still on the grill. Needless to say we ate the food, and it was ok nothing great and the small burger is placed upon a very large kaiser roll (the burger was lost). Glasses for drinks were plastic and looked kind of dirty or just old. A few hours later we were running to the bathroom. The grill needs to be cleaned before the two services(breakfast and lunch) too much grease left over from previous service. Will not be returning any time soon. read more

this place receives 4 stars because as Yelp would say, "Yay! I'm a fan." And that I definiately am...this is my usual spot with my north fork wine tasting buddies as we're heading out east to be on "all day liquid diets" enjoying lovely livations from Strong Island's north fork. This diner was built in 1940... Since calories and carbs aren't my friend, I typically will spring for an egg sandwhich on whole wheat or omelettes and this place will never disappoint in either category. I'm definitely the typical french froo froo foodie but don't mind kicking it back to ca.1947 in this really old style themed diner....it's got quite the charm! Red is my fav color as most of my friends know, the entire interior decor is classic red/white diner decor...love it! great pancake specials and waffle specials, but as I mentioned earlier, my metabolism sucks and calories/carbs aren't my friend so i typically have to order more healthier items :) the ladies with me however, can afford ordering these really yummy treats and they love them everytime! just a warning though...this place is quite popular and is small on the inside so finding a seat may be difficult :) go in with expectations of it being a diner and you won't be disappointed... FYI - THE GOOGLE MAP ARROW IS INCORRECT, THIS IS ON MAIN ROAD (THE MAIN STRIP IN DOWNTOWN CUTCHOGUE VILLAGE) :) read more

I live in Cutchogue and I've been coming here my whole life. As someone else mentioned "the diner" (as we call it) is an authentic mobile car with an addition extending it in the back. Theoretically, it could be attached to a truck and rolled away, in which case I, and many others, would be forced to form a caravan behind it. I have a lot of memories here but I won't go into all that. Let's focus on the rating criteria. It's a very casual, cozy place on the old country, "downtown" Cutchogue strip on the Main Road. It is elevated with windows running along the front which makes for great people and car watching and sunshine. The staff are warm, welcoming, accommodating and very local. The food is good and the old school milkshakes are to die for. As demonstrated by their restaurant in Dumbo, the owners are completely capable of serving a more gourmet menu. That is simply not their vision of a landmark (seriously) diner down the street from the Amish furniture shop, the Cutchogue Library and Wickham's Fruit Farm. They are keeping it real, authentic and delicious but focused on the overall experience, not just the food quality. Woop! read more