The Eggplant "Tower" was the most pathetic structure I've ever seen. It had zero height and has no place being referred to as a tower, unless it is a joke. For the price, the portion was unacceptably small. That being said, what little we did get was actually quite delicious. Our main course, Chicken Parmesan, made up for the size shortfall on the appetizer - it was enough for a full meal plus a massive leftovers dinner. The pasta that came with the chicken parm was incredibly fresh and tasty and the bread that comes with dinner was also hot and fresh and delicious. Only other complaint was that our server (don't accidentally call her Emily) wasn't very nice to us and was offended by our party mentioning that the eggplant "tower" was not at all what a customer would reasonably expect from a dish called Eggplant Tower. read more

Huge portion sizes, so definitely great for groups after a long day of skiing/snowboarding. The decor was fun, really loved how they leaned into the Garlic vibe - though the food itself wasn't mind blowing. The lamb chop was pretty good, would definitely recommend that. read more

The Garlic has great food and atmosphere. I went on a Saturday night and it is extremely popular and busy. I felt lucky to find parking. Definitely make a reservation when visiting on the weekend. The wait for a walk-in table for two was over an hour. Fortunately, we were able to find a spot at the bar after about ten minutes. The bartender was very competent. She was taking orders, making drinks, and cleaning, but still provided excellent service. The prices at The Garlic are very reasonable, the portions are huge, and the food is delicious. We tried the chicken parmigiano and penne alla vodka. Both were delicious and we had enough for lunch the next day. And the bread they bring with your meal has roasted garlic you can use as a spread. So delicious! Definitely will be returning next time I'm in Vermont! read more

The Garlic - Penne alla vodka - Italian Near Me - Killington, Vermont

See all

Started with a Manhattan at the bar, which was mixed and served perfectly. Dinner was breaded veal served over spinach and tomatoes. Other than needing maybe a bit more garlic (ironic), it was quite good. Service and atmosphere all added to the evening. read more

Overpriced gas inducing quasi Italiano Best if you make other plano Lots of garlic to ward off the witches They'll need it as this brew is past its prime stew read more

This place was amazing. They have a sister restaurant in Florida in New Smyrna Beach which is equally amazing. Staff was awesome and the garlic soup is must to try. Get there early because they fill up quick. Will be back next year and this will be the first dinner stop when we come back. read more

The Garlic - Italian Near Me - Killington, Vermont

See all

The food and the server were great. It was pretty packed when we came but the service and food was still so good! read more

The Garlic - Artichoke dip - Italian Near Me - Killington, Vermont

On our visit to Pico to attend the Killington Music Festival, we looked for some comfort food and we chose Garlic - based on the reviews. It had a warm atmosphere, not too busy at around 5:30pm. The decor was rustic, garlics everywhere (in a tasteful way) and saw a few salt blocks - interesting. We had the mussels for appetizer. The soup base was so flavorful that we used the bread to soak up all the juice. For main course we tried the veal cutlet and house pasta with meatballs. The cutlery was juicy and thin. The pasta was okay. So summary we will be back again. read more

Great ambiance, warm and friendly. Good, quick, and attentive service. The only disappointment? And it's a big dissapointment, the food! Bland, all the pasta dishes were pretty watery. The best thing on the menu is the free roasted garlic with bread. If not for the good service, we would not consider returning ever again. Needs better chefs maybe. My kids mentioned they think our local Cheesecake Factory does better tasting entrees. read more

Ehhhhhh the garlic. I had heard good things but they really missed the mark for me and everyone I was with. To be fair we had a large party with a heaping handful of kids. However that being said, our waiter was typically MIA, the bread was stale with zero flavor , and the food was also severely under seasoned. I had gotten a gnocchi special, my husband got the shrimp scampi , my brother in law in front of me got the shrimp and scallop diavolo. Every single person at the table added a massive amount of salt and pepper to their dish. No one's had flavor at all. My sister in law next to me got the vodka sauce with penne and her pasta was hard and under cooked. My martini was not balanced, way too tart so I had to ask for a cup of ice on the side. Overall I think the kitchen here could be killing it if they tried the food before serving it. They need to kick up the flavor by 100!!! If everyone needs salt and pepper to enjoy their meal and we had 12 people at the table, you're missing something guys. read more

See all

This place was great, from their appetizers to their food. I like that you can mark the appetizers that you want from their list and their prices were pretty reasonable too. Service was very friendly too. read more

Excellent service, food and ambiance - the service was super friendly & helpful! Food was delicious! The staff & building were interesting & well connected to the local vibe. read more

The Food was AMAZING!!! It was creamy and delicious. On the other hand, the service was not creamy nor delicious. The lady kept on breathing about herself and repeating the same things (Annoying!!) and she would not stop twl read more

The Garlic - The Chicken Alfredo - Italian Near Me - Killington, Vermont

It was really good and value for money place. A must go when in Vermont. Tge bread and roasted garlic they give in starting is too good

So charming and amazing food. Great for family fun. Taylor our bartender was absolutely adorable and made killer drinks. The small plates are perfect for sharing. The bread and roasted garlic that is served to the table is the reason you go there. Delish! read more

See all

This place was delicious. Very cute and rustic aesthetic, and you can smell the garlic and butter scent as you walk up. I docked a point because I was looking forward to ordering the house garlic soup as I saw online but our server informed us it wasn't available (seasonal). Our server, Ryan, though was great and attentive! I had the penne alla vodka and added shrimp, and others in my group had linguini with clam sauce and scallop and shrimp pasta dish. The vodka sauce was very delicious! Everybody also had a house garlic salad. But above all else the garlic and bread that comes complimentary to all tables was TO DIE FOR. read more

The Garlic - Complimentary slow roasted garlic that turns to a butter like consistency! - Italian Near Me - Killington, Vermont

We've been coming here for years and were very exited to come back for a meal during this trip, unfortunately it appears that they have changed their menu to be Italian focused. While the food was still good it wasn't quite the meal that we had been looking for. The dish photoed specifically claimed to have goat cheese but it was very scarce. However, I would highly recommend the golden pear martini. The wine glasses were giant which was exciting, but the wine was expired. The chicken parm would be a solid pass in our opinion and the Alfredo was bomb. Giant serving sizes and you don't need to worry about wearing a turtle neck. read more

The Garlic - Italian Near Me - Killington, Vermont

This is such a quirky and delicious Italian restaurant in the Killington area. As soon as you walk in, you smell roasted garlic and marinara sauce, see bunches of garlic cloves everywhere, and tons of people enjoying delicious Italian food. I would recommend on busy nights getting there as close to opening as possible-- our first time here (over MLK jr weekend) we stood outside for 15 minutes before opening in bone chilling temperatures. It was well worth it! The first time we came here we sat at the bar. I had a golden pear martini and their ravioli bolognese which was so warming and comforting on a really cold night. We ordered their garlic mussels and enjoyed those with the roasted garlic and bread that comes out as part of your dinner. The hubby ordered the pork shank which was fall of the bone tender. The second time (which I remembered to take some pics) we got the spinach artichoke dip instead, which was incredibly decadent. The crostini were a perfect match for the rich dip. I unfortunately forgot to take a pic of the roasted garlic and bread, because we dug right in to its deliciousness. The hubby ordered the 16oz filet mignon meatball, which was so large it warranted two pictures. It was quite good, served over spaghetti. I ordered the penne alla vodka with chicken-- I was very disappointed we didn't have a mini fridge at our Airbnb, as I desperately wanted the leftovers a second day. Lots of great flavor and the chicken was cooked perfectly! This is now one of our favorite places near Killington and we look forward to trying their other dishes!! read more

See all

Love this place! The atmosphere is amazing. Classic ski resort coziness. We had the lamb chops mussels and tortellini and it did not disappoint. Our waiter was very attentive. Definitely will be back! read more

Another place that we stumbled upon while in Killington but we were not disappointed! We didn't see it listed on the menu but be sure to ask for the bread with roasted garlic- unbelievable!! Two giant cloves are garlic that spread like butter. I had the chicken picatta as my entree- large portions and really delicious! Would definitely recommend to anyone in the area. read more

The Garlic - Bread with roasted garlic - Italian Near Me - Killington, Vermont

See all

The garlic is our favorite spot to go to when visiting Killington! No reservations walk in & take out only! The tapas menu offered in the bar area is a must try and fun to share! The staff is awesome read more

The Garlic - Best martinis and great staff - Italian Near Me - Killington, Vermont

See all

My favorite restaurant in Killington. I dream about the lamb appetizer with the blueberries and goat cheese, and the roasted garlic bulb and bread. It's expensive, and you may have to wait for a table (they don't take reservations). But the food and atmosphere is worth it! read more

If my dish had been as good as my friends I would have given a fifth star. The place is definitely the place to go while in killington, even during Covid and no snow the place was pretty busy. We started our dinner with a garlic soup, a soup one must absolutely have, and the house salad My friends had the seafood-linguini which were so delicious, and the chicken parmigiana which was so so. I ordered the puttanesca that was very oily and the meatballs were dried and tasteless. Service was friendly and attentive read more

The Garlic - Puttanesca with meatballs - Italian Near Me - Killington, Vermont

See all

Went in for dinner last night and were able to get a table right away in the bar area. We had Taylor as our server who was super attentive and charming. Food was great and, even better, they had Jäeger! My husband complained that the bartender's voice was too sexy and smooth. Would go back. Five stars. read more

Fun place. First come first serve. So very long wait if you don't get the first seating. Appetizers are the best- lamb lollipop and garlic soup. The pasta mains were ok. Delicious pear martini. read more

My personal favorite for Italian food and elevated dining in the Killington area, the candlelit night ambiance meshes perfectly with their velvet vibe. I come here every trip, if not multiple times, for the quality of the food and the lovely mood. Fair warning, their tables are first come first serve, you'll want to get there before 7:00 if you don't want to wait an hour. There is a wait for a reason, they are that good. Service keeps up as well as can be expected given their popularity, that said, no gaps in coverage and a cheerful disposition. Try the muscles diavolo. read more

food was good. nothing dazzling and amazing, but it was a good food. the restaurant had a pretty good vibe and service was nice as well.

Having been to The Garlic in NSB a number of times, we were excited to try The Garlic in Killington, before we found out they were two different owners. Anyhow, we went in with an expectation and it was certainly met. The ambiance was great, rustic with an old Italian feel. The sangria was delicious, the bread and roasted garlic was amazing, as we expected and wanted. We had the harlots cheese as an appetizer, fried mozzerella in a puttanesca sauce, yummy. The cheese had a nice crisp to it and the sauce was very flavorful. We both opted for the chicken parm which was very good. The chicken was tender with a crisp coating, the sauce was flavorful with lots of chunks of tomato, we both had enough for at least one more meal each. Although Killington didn't offer a Bocce Ball we did get a side of meatballs. They weren't equal to the Bocce Ball in NSB but they were yummy. The service was good, waitress Emma was friendly and attentive, would definitely go back. read more

See all

The bread was amazing. We ordered several pasta dishes with a cream sauce, the Chicken Alfredo and Mushroom Penne. All were very watery and not very flavorful, even with salt. I would not recommend them. The shrimp and scallop scampi was pretty good, but still lacked something. We also ordered the lamb, which was delicious. If I were to go back, I would avoid the pasta and eat the meat. read more

Service was a little slow but im giving this 3 stars for the quality of food. While portions were decent, the food was extremely mediocre. Also, for an italian restaurant to only serve penne and linguini for all their pasta dishes is kind of ridiculous. Overall, overpriced for the waukity and level of authenticity you are getting read more

We stopped by here during a trip to Killington and man were we happy! To start, they give everyone bread with roasted garlic which you can spread like butter! So delicious. We started with the lamb appetizer which I didn't get a picture of, but the goat cheese and blueberry jam along with the lamb was absolutely divine. Probably my favorite dish of the meal. We got lamb, steak and the scallop diavolo which were all super tasty. The meats were supposed to be medium rare and by my eye it looked like there were a little more rare, but I didn't hear any complaints from the boys. Pics included. Overall very great experience. Keep in mind the lamb was market price which ended up resulting in a hefty check. Still a great experience and would highly recommend a trip here. read more

See all

Pretty good place. For starters , they bring you fresh bread with an entire roasted head of garlic that you can mix at the table with oil, vinegar and seasoning, YUM! For an appetizer I ordered the Garlic Mussels and did not like them at all. They tasted like they were just plucked out the sea (fishy and nasty). BTW, I love muscles. For dinner I got the Seafood Italiano minus the salmon. Other than tossing aside the mussels, it was awesome. Our waitress Melissa was super friendly and dare I say spritely. read more

The Garlic - Italian Near Me - Killington, Vermont

Our absolute favorite place to eat in Killington. Cozy ambiance, good food and cocktails. A must visit every fall.

No reservation needed and the portions are large. The staff was great and the food is affordable.

Chicken Marsala with garlic mashed potatoes was delicious. Service was great and our server was super friendly and attentive. The ambience was rustic but perfect after a long day of skiing. read more

Watch out! If you go into The Garlic looking for "winter" items in October and non-alcoholic drinks - "mocktails" as I was told, you will instantly be sized up by Dana G of the Garlic as someone asking for too much and treated accordingly. Allright, The Garlic only serves chicken parmesan and other items in the winter - OK, got it. As for non-alcoholic drinks, they have St. Pauli Girl non-alcoholic beer (which actually contains a minimal amount of alcohol - for those who cannot drink alchohol) and a "wide array of Pepsi" products - as said to me by Dana G with a wise-a$$ grin. "We don't have mocktails here," - this being another retort delivered by Dana G. OK, I order a Pepsi and a non-winter item from the menu, the filet mignon ragu over linguine. So I brought the below cocktail menu to the bar and asked the silver-haired, quite pleasant gentleman bartender if he would make me a lemon, honey mix with soda water. No problem. He actually made me two on the house as they took an extra couple of minutes to mix up. No problem - I tipped him $7 for being so accommodating and pleasant. Dana G - she got 10% - given the way my family (father, mother, partner, and son) were spoken to. Good food, poor service. Stars given show which of those weigh more in my overall experience. I wouldn't normally care about any of this, but the way that Dana G delivered information to me was so wise and mocking - and left me feeling so flat that I will not be returning to The Garlic. read more

The Garlic - Ingredients for a "mocktail" - Italian Near Me - Killington, Vermont

Unlike most of the places in the area, they were actually OPEN! Good, attentive staff/service. The food smelled and tasted great!

Delicious tapas, wine and drinks. Good service as well and nice bar and environment..

Have been coming here from five plus years! Same good menu. Pastas are to die for and great main dishes like Salmon and rack of lamb both are amazing (if you are not very hungry then the lamb in the appetizers better tasting and I get full with it it's a good portion size, only if not very hungry cause they have 4 pieces like lollipops sized). For appetizers try the calamari. They serve warm bread with there amazing roasted whole garlic, which you can request one more if want more. Kids entrees are good sized pasta dishes - we ordered a linguini with marinara but the sauce was a little less as compared to bowl full of pasta which made pasta taste dry. We requested extra sauce and they accommodated us. For desert ordered chocolate lava cake with vanilla ice cream. Overall, a delightful dinner after a day of skiing. read more

The Garlic - Kids spaghetti - Italian Near Me - Killington, Vermont

See all

Food was pretty good, cleanliness was not up to par. There were huge bowls of uncovered grated Parmesan sitting all around unattended, next to cleaning supplies ect. I would not go back. read more