Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    The Mayfly

    4.3 (98 reviews)
    Closed 5:00 pm - 4:00 am (Next day)

    Order The Mayfly Takeout or Delivery

    The Mayfly Photos

    Business Info

    THE MAYFLY ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Hipster
    Happy hour specials
    Dogs allowed

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - The Mayfly

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Our server Bella was incredible. Everyone in the entire restaurant was happy and she was the only server. It's very noticeable how great she is at her job. Knowing the menu and being really attentive and super nice to everyone! Props to the kitchen for getting the food out hot. It was all great! We got the flatbread, burger, kale salad, truffle fries, nachos, and Benedict. Restaurant was also very clean, smelled nice, and was warm on this super snowy day.

    Burnt chicken tenders not crispy!!!
    Tywana J.

    I asked for crispy not burnt music was ehh late menu was trash just wings fries and tenders. Drinks average just a local bar depends on your crowd.

    Lakwan H.

    I was trying to get a late reservation into another restaurant nearby and they told me it was an hour wait. So I decided to see what was in the area. Around the corner was The Mayfly and it was relatively empty only with one party in there. My partner and I were seated immediately and was able to order as soon as we knew what we wanted. We tried their drinks as well as their food and it was very delicious. Although this wasn't our intended spot we were really able to enjoy our food and each other. Our waitress was attentive to us and very kind. I would definitely go back and would love to try their happy out and other dishes on the menu.

    Mayfly Wings
    Amanda D.

    This review is solely for their Happy Hour. Finding a good happy hour deal in the city doesn't seem like a daunting task but sometimes it can be! Came here for an after work happy hour with some friends and their menu had me once I saw espresso martini. The inside is cozy and a little small and there are bar tables alll along the middle of the restaurant. Their drink specials included a few speciality cocktails for $10 and then well drinks and beers (the basics). Outside of that they also offered happy hour food specials that came with a HH cocktail for $16. (Such a steal bc it's not just the bar snacks, it's like a full meal). The food was nothing spectacular, in fact I wasn't a fan of the dry rubbed wings I got but because I was hungry I ate It anyway. We got wings, flatbread and tacos. Our waitress was super nice and attentive -- loved her! Overall, i'd def return and have already added this spot to my running list of HH spots to visit.

    Rose water
    Jordan C.

    There are tons of great spots downtown, but I have never had such a fun brunch! The food is amazing, the drinks are crafty and delicious, and strong, I must go! I ordered the grilled cheese and the French toast, the grilled cheese was melted perfectly with bacon and tomato and a side of truffle fries, Yum! The French toast was seriously out of this world, light soft fluffy and delicious came with a side of preserves, whip cream and syrup so I tried all three! Then there was a drag bingo that was so much fun, I love the whole vibe.

    Cheese Fries
    Lauren L.

    The Mayfly is a great restaurant. The relaxed vibe of the restaurant is very comforting. The food is very good. I typically get the Kale salad, and it is incredible. Another great dish is the Cheese Fries. I ordered this as an appetizer, but it was so large it ended p being my meal! This is a great place. They even have trivia nights!

    Eggs Benedict
    Keyla P.

    Cozy and cute. Peach Bellini was the favorite drink. Truffle fries were very tasty. Eggs benny was also very good. Friend loved his grilled cheese.

    a bowl of french fries with a side of dips
    Navya J.

    Brunch here was so much fun! I went with 3 other friends, and it was a great place for a group brunch. They have bottomless mimosas but we also tried out some of their cocktails, which were really well made! The spicy tequila drink was my favorite. The food was delicious as well- don't forget to get truffle fries for the table! I really enjoyed the French toast since it was perfectly crispy on the edges and soft in the middle. The truffle mac and cheese could have the cheese be slightly more melty but was still really good! - Navya J @nyconthetable

    Kale Caesar Salad with chicken
    Donna U.

    The food was great. I tried their kale Caesar salad and asked for chicken to be added. The bowl was small so I thought I'd be hungry but it was the perfect size for lunch. They have these amazing crouton pieces that is almost like a dust so every bite has this nice croutony texture and flavor. My wife got the grilled cheese. She saved half for later because it was a little too greasy to finish in one serving. Flavor was great though.

    See all

    4 years ago

    Had the best time at brunch- it's great for groups! We loved the lazy susan on our table. Such a fun addition!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Jody C.
    169
    7
    0

    5 years ago

    I love this place. Decor is awesome. Get the burger. The rest of the menu is also amazing. I would have ordered the lamb but they were out.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Best happy hour deal in all of Manhattan. $16 for a burger/ tacos plus a drink! Will definitely be back. Probably every week.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    The mayfly had great drinks and the bartenders Connor and Isaac were very easy to talk to. I'll definitely be back again

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Staff is incredible and 10/10. The chef has a slay menu. Drinks are too yummy for words.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Fai R.
    156
    2
    1

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Amazing drinks ! Amazing service! Amazing food ! The crispy chicken sandwich and the beat salad is to die for will be coming here again

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    amazing service, love the space and the fried chicken sandwich (YUM!)

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 3 of 3

    The Mayfly Reviews in Other Languages

    Ask the Community - The Mayfly

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for American 23,207 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Monkey Bar - Smoked Whitefish Caesar (~$28)

    Monkey Bar

    4.3(528 reviews)
    2.7 miMidtown East

    As reservations go, this was hard but not as hard as Polo Bar or Carbone! One of my friends opened…read moreher TikTok and was trying to try their Monkey Bread so as a good friend, I booked it! Reservations open 2 weeks in advance around 10am and they go super fest so I recommend you try for the day you need as for me I could only have gotten brunch on a Sunday. Those people spam the crap out of their buttons for the dinner spots and when I went I can see why. The place is brimming with old school New York charm and it's completely overwhelmingly beautiful and has an old jazzy vibe to it. It's large and spacious and they sat us in the middle of the entire restaurant. (I had a group of 6) The vibe was so good you don't really want to leave and they also don't really kick you out. I think we were the last ones to exit for brunch but they were so nice they didn't kick us out. Their espresso martinis are ok. It wasn't as amazing as a regular cocktail bar but it is just ok. We started off with a shrimp cocktail, smoked whitefish Caesar salad and the two plates of truffle monkey bread which was soooo good. I really enjoyed this as it's the main reason we came here. It's almost like a honey dinner roll with truffle. We got everything next which some people got their own and some shared. Some people got their own American breakfast platter which was some overdone eggs and a meat with gigantic toast and if you only order scrambled eggs it comes in a bowl but I would much rather order their classics like steak sandwich and the spicy shrimp was pretty good! Fries are top tier! I can see why people just come here for dinner. I would give it mostly 5 stars for the overall ambiance and environment and a few classics. I think their old fashioned is better than their espresso martinis though even though it looks so good in this type of setting! It's hard to get a reservation though so next time I'll need to try some new things if I score another!

    Go for lunch, easier to get a res! Wowed by the truffle…read morebread and mushrooms Ambiance is super moody, the restaurant is darkly lit, it's automatically night when you walk in. Menu - we got steak, truffle bread, chicken parm, fries, and a pasta - solid portions, always tasty, they're reliably delicious

    Photos
    Monkey Bar - Spicy Shrimp scampi

    Spicy Shrimp scampi

    Monkey Bar - Truffle Monkey Bread (~$35)

    Truffle Monkey Bread (~$35)

    Monkey Bar - Chocolate Cream Pie

    See all

    Chocolate Cream Pie

    Friedman's - Shakshuka

    Friedman's

    4.0(3.4k reviews)
    1.9 miMidtown West
    $$

    Friedman is an absolute must-visit if you are looking for an incredible burger in NYC. I honestly…read moredid not expect to be this impressed, but this ended up being one of the best burgers I have ever had -- and quite possibly the best burger of my life. I ordered the burger with cheese, and everything about it was perfect. The burger itself was THICK, incredibly juicy, and cooked beautifully. You could immediately tell that the meat was high quality, and knowing that they use Creekstone beef made it even better. The flavor was rich and beefy without being overwhelming, and every bite was incredibly satisfying. The patty had that perfect combination of a beautifully cooked exterior while still being extremely juicy and tender inside. And the bread deserves its own paragraph! The brioche-style bun was excellent. It was soft, slightly buttery, and substantial enough to hold the thick patty without falling apart or becoming soggy. It complemented the burger perfectly rather than taking away from the meat. The combination of the juicy Creekstone beef, melted cheese, and that excellent brioche-style bread was honestly phenomenal. What really stood out to me was how substantial the burger was. This wasn't one of those thin burgers where you finish it and immediately feel like you could eat another one. It was thick, hearty, juicy, and incredibly flavorful. Every bite felt like you were getting exactly what you want from a great burger. The fries were also excellent. I really appreciated that they weren't overly fried or greasy. They had a great texture and were crispy without feeling heavy or excessively oily. Sometimes fries can completely overwhelm a meal because they're so fried, but these were much more balanced and paired perfectly with the burger. Overall, Friedman absolutely exceeded my expectations. The burger, especially with the cheese, was outstanding, the Creekstone beef was incredibly flavorful, the brioche-style bun was excellent, and the fries were the perfect accompaniment. If you're in NYC and love burgers, this is a must-go-to. I would absolutely order this burger again and would highly recommend Friedman to anyone looking for a thick, juicy, high-quality burger. Easily one of the best burgers I've ever

    Don't always believe Yelp reviews--especially coming from a Yelp Elite--so let's set the record…read morestraight! First off, just a quick note for anyone looking: this restaurant is not halal. Aside from that, we had a fantastic experience here at Friedmans Herald Square near Penn Station. They were playing Hilary Duff music, which was such a fun touch since they often match the vibe of whatever is happening at MSG! They even had special Hilary Duff mocktails. The atmosphere is super sweet and cozy. The restaurant was empty when we first walked in, but the second we sat down, it completely packed up! The waiter was very friendly, and even though they weren't able to split the check at the table, they did provide an itemized receipt to make figuring it out easy. The food was great overall--the Mac & Cheese bites and the corn were especially good! We also tried the cheesecake and molten cake. Plus, the neighbors sitting next to us were so sweet. A wonderful spot with a fun vibe!

    Photos
    Friedman's - Interior

    Interior

    Friedman's - Lemon Ricotta Pancakes

    Lemon Ricotta Pancakes

    Friedman's - Vanilla Cafe Latte

    See all

    Vanilla Cafe Latte

    Zou Zou’s

    Zou Zou’s

    4.2(601 reviews)
    2.3 miChelsea, Midtown West, Hell's Kitchen
    $$$
    Full bar
    Gluten-free friendly

    We all know that New York is home to so many great restaurants, yet I can confidently say that Zou…read moreZou's is one of the best. They have a lovely rooftop bar while you wait for a table. Then, when it was finally time to be seated in the dining room, I was so pleased with the upscale, romantic interior. Our server for that night was Ferdian, who was so attentive and had real class service. We made the reservation with OpenTable for 12 and ended up with 13 people. I love that the staff was so accommodating with the last-minute request We did the pre-fixed menu to make things easier. Everything was delicious from the beginning to the end. They were also able to accommodate gluten-free and dairy-free restrictions among those wonderful meals. My favorites were the dips, branzino, and hamachi. duck borek, and the desserts! The grilled pineapple was out of this world. Simple dish with complex flavors. The crunchy cheese cake was delicious too. I had the Road to Jericho cocktail, and it was yummy.

    I came here with a large group so got to sample a lot of new things…read more - the kasseri cheese comes with a focaccia that has a pleasant sweetness to it - fattoush is probably going to be my go-to salad here with a moderate vinaigrette and candied pecans to balance the cabbage - the rice was good but didn't think it was so memorable; same with the roasted chicken which was tender and juicy and suited for a healthy meal - the Yemeni steak was my favorite thing here so far; the green sauce has a sweetness that complements the meat well and it's actually cooked medium rare - Moroccan fried chicken was just fine; came with a sour cream like sauce (perhaps for latkes?) and a sweet fruit compote that was good but besides a kick to the breading, this was some regular chicken - the charred broccoli is savory with a kick from the cashew harissa - Latkes were good and hot, but nothing too memorable Desserts: chocolate tart was good enough, the lemon froyo was actually even better, and the toffee pudding was too much cinnamon cake rather than decadent sticky pudding for my preference. Overall, I like the vegetables dishes a lot more here and I know what I like now, but not very interested in trying more things.

    Photos
    Zou Zou’s
    Zou Zou’s
    Zou Zou’s

    See all

    Lillie's Victorian Establishment

    Lillie's Victorian Establishment

    3.9(2.1k reviews)
    2.8 miTheater District, Midtown West
    $$
    Locally owned & operated
    Free WiFi

    Lillie's is always a good place to stop in for a drink. The flower decor changes…read more We sat at the bar and had a hummus plate which was a decent portion and tasty. Bartenders are attentive even when it's busts

    Absolutely awful experience. Never again. Do NOT recommend…read more One of the staff, in charge of refilling water, spilled water on our table multiple times. I watched him spill on other tables as well. He never apologized. He never wiped it up. Then 4th time he filled our glasses, he spilled the water on my wife. He did not apologize. He did not even acknowledge it and it was very clear that he noticed he did it. My wife, quite restrained, let our waitress know what happened. Her response: "What do you want me to do about it?" My wife said that he should not serving water if he doesn't know how to pour it properly. The waitress, moments later, told him what we had said, merely inches from our tables. Beyond awkward. And, instead of coming over and apologizing, he simply never returned to our table. No more water. The waitress had an attitude with us since we sat down - no idea what we could have done - unsure what was going on - but it was beyond unpleasant. Most of our "table conversation" was about how lousy the staff were acting and how uncomfortable we felt along with how much we couldn't wait to leave. We had shared an appetizer and had no interest in ordering anything else after that. We paid. We left. I feel stupid for tipping them.

    Photos
    Lillie's Victorian Establishment
    Lillie's Victorian Establishment
    Lillie's Victorian Establishment

    See all

    The Mayfly - tradamerican - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...