Last minute decision to go here for dinner as we hadn't been in a while. Lots of full tables but it was unseasonably hot so no one sitting outside. We were seated quickly and our waitress, Karen, stopped by for drink orders and asked if we had dined there before, that was an affirmative. Karen was no nonsense and efficient, telling us about the special and answering questions about the pot pie. We happened to be seated next to a table from someone I knew, so we didn't have to pretend not to stare at the food they ordered, lol. We just talked about all that we ordered. Their Piccadilly fish looked amazing as did the rib special. I ordered the chicken pot pie, I had been thinking about it, and craving carbs to boot and it didn't disappoint. Karen informed me that it had lima beans and corn, so I wasn't shocked by that. Came in a bowl draped with puff pastry. Pastry was flaky and lightly browned, the base was creamy with lots of chicken chunks, carrots, corn, and lima beans. I haven't had lima beans before and I liked them. I had ordered the soup of the day, Tuscan white bean that sounded great, but I thought it was just ok. Husband ordered the fried chicken with slaw and mashed potatoes. The chicken was HOT! I enjoyed the leg piece I snagged off his plate, the breading is thin and adhered well to the chicken, the slaw was creamy, I didn't try the potatoes. Great home-style food, nice atmosphere, efficient service. Try the pot pie! read more

The Piccadilly at Manhattan - Menú - American Near Me - St. Louis, Missouri

I got the Chicken Pot Pie. It was amazing! First, it came out so quick. I thought that we would be waiting for a lot longer. The pastry was light and flaky, and a perfect golden brown. This filling had lots of chunks of chicken, and the vegetables and gravy were a flavor bomb. This was the best that I've had in a long time. We went on a Saturday evening and we had to wait around 20 minutes for a table, so if you are planning to go on a busy time, definitely try to get a reservation ahead of time. Our waitress was outstanding, helpful, and kept our drinks refilled constantly. The restaurant is small(ish), but has indoor dining, a four seasons type of room, and outdoor seating. We'll be back! read more

See all

We came to Piccadilly with a group of 15 and had an awesome time. It really feels like a true family neighborhood restaurant welcoming, relaxed, and the kind of place you want to come back to. The staff was incredibly friendly and made everything smooth and fun, even with a big group. The food and drinks were outstanding home-style cooking at its best. The fried chicken is absolutely killer, but the short rib pot pie might honestly be the best thing on the menu. Every dish we tried was incredible. Great vibes, great service, and great food highly recommend. *was too distracted by to take pics read more

A beautiful day to sit on their patio. Started with the Smoked Tuna Spread which is always a fantastic choice. Lunch was burgers and Seasonal Salads with a side of Ranch Parmesan Fries to share. Burgers cooked perfectly, juicy and delicious, French fries crispy. For summer, Seasonal Salad is one of the best options on the menu (chicken potpie in the cold weather!)Chicken is always juicy and grilled perfectly, plenty of strawberries and pecans. The Ranch Parmesan Fries are something we have never seen anywhere else and are amazing!!! The trees outdoors have gotten very large so we had great shade the whole time. They are very, very busy every day, but the staff assist each other with the tables to keep everything flowing. Impressive teamwork . Been too long since we have been here, will be back soon! read more

See all

A quaint restaurant with great food. Parking is easy to find, and the restaurant itself is decorated in a rustic manner. I ordered the Short Rib Pot Pie. It was delicious! The puff pastry was flaky, lightly browned, and was thick. Inside of the Pot Pie, there was the short rib, celery, carrots, and a mashed potato base. The first few bites of short rib tasted burnt, but this was not the full experience of the meal. Food came out relatively quickly, I hardly waited 15-20 minutes. An honorable mention to the Seafood Pot Pie. It was a special the last time I came here, and it was incredible. read more

See all

I miss dining at, The Piccadilly at Manhattan on the regular. I use to live fairly close and would easily dine there a couple times a month. I now live in Illinois and it's just not as convenient. When a STL friend and I were going to meet for lunch, I suggested Piccadilly. I was shocked that she'd never been. So I got my fix and got to introduce someone new to this amazing little restaurant. I arrived early, so I went ahead and got us a table. While I was waiting for my friend, I had a Tito's Martini with a twist. I barely had taken a sip and my friend arrived. She joined me at the table and we started to look over the menu. Our server, shared a couple daily specials and we quickly made up our minds on what we were having. My dining partner, chose the Fried Fish Sandwich from the menu and I enjoyed the Prime Rib Sandwich which was a daily special. Both of our sandwiches came with fries. Both of us enjoyed our lunches, I ate all of mine and my friend took a portion of hers home. Their fish sandwiches are huge. I use to get them all the time during Lent. They offer some of their most popular menu items for the freezer. Knowing this, I'll plan a trip to fill up a cooler, then return home and stock up my freezer. Then when I want a Pot Pie (most popular dish), some Lasagna or Meatloaf, I'll feel as if I'm in their dining room. The service was friendly, just what you'd expect from a family owned restaurant. It's been around since, 1901. That means people were eating at, The Piccadilly before the World's Fair. So, Meet Me In St. Louis at The Piccadilly. read more

See all

atmosphere Piccadilly is friendly and our waitress, Tricia, was a delight. short rib, pot pie, and fried chicken and each of us enjoyed it Very tasty and perfectly cooked. read more

The Piccadilly at Manhattan - Short rib pot pie - American Near Me - St. Louis, Missouri

The BF and I came here for dinner date. I heard good things about this place and wanted to try it. The BF was down for a dinner date so off we went. Cute restaurant, very quaint, no frills. We began with cocktails which were the star of the show. The food was highly disappointing, somewhat visually appealing just not meeting the flavor mark. The ribs were overly cooked and completely dry. The prime rib was just OK. The experience was so underwhelming that it did not warrant a return read more

What a fun, interesting little place. Literally a house in a neighborhood in Maplewood. Felt like eating at grandma's when she put a bunch of tables out for sunday meal. We sat out on the back porch. Nice selection of salads, sandwiches and comfort family food. I had the pot roast special. It came in a bowl, with mash potatoes covered in beef and gravy, bread on the side. Interesting presentation, tasty but a little too salty. Service was very good and attentive. Overall solid experience and will come back. read more

The Piccadilly at Manhattan - Pot Roast - American Near Me - St. Louis, Missouri

I can't believe I just discovered The Piccadilly! Great food ! Great service! And adorable atmosphere! I had the short rib pot pie and oh my lord.....soooo good! Friends also raved about the fried chicken. My only regret was not going sooner when we could sit on the patio! read more

The Piccadilly at Manhattan - American Near Me - St. Louis, Missouri

See all

First seen this cute little gem only while driving through this nice neighborhood in the evening and this cute restaurant had its little outdoor lights draped over the eating area outside. It looked so charming so then and there I made a mental note to make a chance to come back and eat there. It took a year but we did! And it did not disappoint! The staff were very welcoming. And we sat covered outside eating area. And even though it was still hot outside for the evening, it was not hot in the area. They seem pretty known for their fried chicken and chicken pot pie. We each had the chicken and a friend of ours had the Mayfair Salad. We also had the onion rings. Everything was delicious. We are not ones to order fried chicken but apparently this is the place to do it and it did not disappoint! Felt like a good homey meal. read more

See all

This place felt like an Ole timey place. The ice tea was good, AC not the best, everything made of wood. We had a little bit of a wait and felt very cramped at the bar and while moving between tables. I think this place attracts more of an older crowd as some of the food is like that overcooked/canned green beans kind which I was in the mood for so no complaints here. I had the smoked tuna steak and crackers as an appetizer which was very good. It was shredded and balled up for you to spread on crackers like a cheese ball. For my main I had the chicken pot pie. The filling was ok. It had a good amount of chicken in it. The best part was the breading. I enjoyed every bite of it. It's not a huge pot pie but it's not small either. Definitely recommend an appetizer to go with it if you're hungry. We had a good time and my wife was excited about her fried chicken and wants to come back, me not so much. read more

The Piccadilly at Manhattan - Chicken pot pie - American Near Me - St. Louis, Missouri

See all

This 125 year old restaurant serves delicious food coupled with amazing and friendly service in a well decorated cozy historic space! read more

The Piccadilly at Manhattan - Smoked prime rib with brown butter potatoes and broccoli! So yummy! - American Near Me - St. Louis, Missouri

Other than our food coming almost all at once (salads, apps and entrees), this was an excellent experience. Our server, Maggie (but not the Maggie who Is one of the owners/founders) was pleasant and knowledgeable. Onion rings appetizer piping hot and sufficient volume but not very flavorful. B. Salad really all lettuce with parmesan and red onion,but the dressings were superb. Sesame ginger and Mayfair dressing quite good. B+. My entree, the seafood pot pie, extraordinarily good. Abundant, buttery crust simply devine. They drop a large square of layered and flaky dough onto a round ceramic pot, leaving four triangular ears that bake wonderfully and can be folded into the pot by the diner. Seafood abundant and broth deliciously reminiscent of lobster bisque. So outstanding and delicious. Wife had fish sandwich. Fried swai which was very good and French fries that were good but not great. Dessert another standout. Blackberry cobbler. Definitely made in house and simply devine. Crust flaky, buttery. Blackberries cooked to perfection in what they said was a simple sugar solution but which we found hauntingly complex and appealing. Amazing. Street parking. Interior comfortably decorated, snug but not too crowded. Furniture comfortable. We declined the chance to sit on the patio so can't comment on that seating area. 84$ with one beer, salads, app, 2 entrees and dessert, before tip, I consider a bargain given the high quality. Appears to be 100% woman owned and staffed, which I found cool. This one is not to be missed. read more

See all

Such a cute little spot for dinner! We sat in the front window of what seems to be a turn of the century home. There is a large patio for warmer weather outdoor dining. The dinner salad is large, dressings are homemade. The blue cheese is mild with quarter sized chunks of real blue cheese! I had the dinner special- seafood pot pie. It was served in a 5" diameter bowl with a flaky layer of philodough baked over the top. Large chunks of fish, shrimp and clam in a lobster bisque. It was delicious! My dining partner had the meatloaf, mashed potatoes and green beans. Also delicious! Lovely atmosphere and hearty, generous servings! read more

The chicken pot pie is like no other. Delicious. The staff here is seasoned and wonderful. I hadn't been here in a very long time and am so happy I thought to try it again. Highly recommend the pot pie! read more

The Piccadilly at Manhattan - Chicken Pot Pie - American Near Me - St. Louis, Missouri

The Fried Chicken is crispy on the outside and juicy and tender on the inside. TDF!! The service was excellent and our waitress was wonderful. We sat in the covered outdoor dining area and it was very quiet and enjoyable. When we arrived at 5:30 it was pretty full of people so we waited for a table to open up and sat at the bar. I had a Manhattan and it was excellent. This restaurant is my favorite "go to"place for a delicious homestyle dinner. read more

I'm so sad I don't have photos of this but it wouldn't do it justice because I ordered the food to go. This will absolutely be on my list to check out in person as I was so surprised by the short rib pot pie that it knocked my socks right off! The crust (even on an uber delivery) held its integrity well. And the filling has all the right elements. It was divine and the perfect stormy weather comfort food. I also ordered the blackberry cobbler after seeing a picture of it! It wasn't your standard cobbler and I was intrigued. Absolutely worth it. Bright, fresh, with some warm spices and a delightful biscuit that had just the right amount of butter and sweetness. From a service perspective, again on an uber eats delivery, all food was accounted for, the order was accurate and the food arrived very hot! Looking forward to seeing if it's a 5 star spot when I visit in person. read more

We will absolutely be back! The food is homestyle cooking! The service was very fast and she knew her stuff! The place is a small restuarant with alot of history to it! I cant wait to go back to try the salads! read more

The Piccadilly at Manhattan - Pork steak so tender we could cut it with a fork! - American Near Me - St. Louis, Missouri

See all

The FOH staff at Piccadilly were so nice even though they were pretty busy. The dining room is small, but the atmosphere is comfortable. Be aware, the streets are small and the restaurant is in the middle of a residential neighborhood. My friend ordered the fish with broccoli cheddar soup on the side, and I ordered meatloaf with brown gravy and mashed potatoes. The food was delicious. I would definitely recommend the Piccadilly. read more

There aren't many places specializing in comfort food anymore. Growing up, we had Sunday Dinner and big family suppers with extended family. Meals were prepared from scratch and took a better part of the day to make. Now days, we're just too busy, or no one knows how to make these meals anymore. Friends have been suggesting Piccadilly on Manhattan for a while. I finally had the opportunity to stop by. One of my favorite parts of St. Louis are the restaurants nestled right in the neighborhood. This place sits on a beautiful tree lined street. The restaurant offers very little parking. I was able to find spots close by in the neighborhood. The space is on the smaller side, but I felt like tables turned over in a reasonable amount of time. We were seated on the out on the deck. It was perfect for an early fall evening. Our server (I apologize, but I didn't catch his name) worked diligently to take care of us. Now on to the main event! We were a party of 6 with a variety of tastes and palates. The classic Mayfair salad was a must-do. The dressing was herbaceous and creamy and perfectly dressed. The onion rings came in a generous heap. Perfectly crisp and delicious. I couldn't decide between the meatloaf or the pot roast pot pie. I asked my server to surprise me and I was treated to a beautiful take on pot roast. A beautiful handmade flaky pastry crust covers a generous bowl of slow cooked falling apart beef. The flavors were absolutely perfect. We also ordered fried chicken with mashed potatoes. The chicken has a black pepper seasoned flour crust. The chicken was as crisp and juicy. The mashed potatoes were a perfect addition. The fish sandwich and Parmesan ranch fries come highly recommended. I enjoyed my experience here. I have fantastic friends who make the best company. We were able to linger over beautiful perfectly cooked homemade meals. And none of us was responsible for washing dishes afterwards! read more

See all

Place was packed on a cold Saturday night. They're known for their fried chicken and pot pies, and I went with the half fried chicken. It came out crispy on the outside but not too heavy. We didn't have a reservation, so we waited on their heated patio with a couple of drinks from the bar. The atmosphere is laid back, with a lot of local St. Louis memorabilia around. I also got a bite of the Meltdown, which is basically a souped-up grilled cheese with two burger patties on white bread; definitely hearty and tasty. For dessert, we shared the bread pudding with ice cream, and it was nice and moist. Overall, it's a solid place for comfort food. I'd definitely recommend it. read more

We showed up a little after six on a Friday evening and the place was packed! We were offered a seat at the bar since there were no tables available when we arrived. I'm never opposed to sitting at the bar so we took our seats and we were greeted immediately by the bartender who took our drink order and let us know of the daily specials. I was a little torn between ordering the pulled pork sandwich and the fried chicken dinner, but after much deliberation, I decided on the fried chicken all white dinner and substituted fries for the mashed potatoes. My husband also ordered the chicken dinner all dark as it comes. Now, I am not one to order fried chicken but this seemed to be the place to do it. I was a bit underwhelmed. The chicken was super crispy and juicy inside but it lacked seasoning and was pretty bland, as were the green beans. The fries were really good. I wouldn't say the dish was a miss, but I did wish it had more flavor...a little salt, pepper and maybe some cayenne or paprika. Despite my thoughts on the chicken, this place was very cute and all of the staff were very nice and friendly. For the way they were packing in customers, they have something going on so I'm open to try it again. Overall it was a good experience. read more

Been meaning to try this place because so many people "rave" about it. I'm sure I'm in the minority here... But I don't know what the big deal is. For a first timer I figured I'd go for the fried chicken. It was average at best. Mashed potatoes. Just lukewarm. Service was great. Waitress was very attentive. Maybe I'm missing something here... Perhaps the summertime sitting out on the patio... I don't know. Again it won't be a play some rushing to get back to. read more

Always a pleasure to dine at Piccadilly. True comfort food served with a smile. Love their Mayfair dressing! Had the meatloaf today, so good with real mashed potatoes and green beans. Next time I'm getting ribs...they looked and smelled amazing. read more

See all

This is a very cute mom and pop restaurant. The restaurant has a lot of antique decorations on the wall, which gives it a diner atmosphere. The tables and floors were cleaned very nicely, as well as their bathrooms. Their staff were very friendly and polite. And were attentive when they showed us where the bathroom is. They were also very quick on ordering and serving us the drinks for us. I ordered a chicken pot pie as my food, and a coke for my drink since I did not feel like alcohol today. The pot pie was delicious when I put my spoon in the pot pie. They have a lot of American options to suit your taste. read more

Always a great experience! Food and service are both terrific. Cute place in the middle of a neighborhood. If you haven't been, you need to try it. read more

First time here and we had a wonderful experience! Kit took excellent care of us and was so helpful offering suggestions while we ordered. We started with the smoked tuna spread and it was fantastic. It was very light mayo and the seasoning was perfect. We all enjoyed our cocktails - the Maggie Manhattan and the Boulevardier. They were very well made. Our table ordered the chicken pot pie, short rib pot pie, smoked Cuban sandwich and the fried chicken. Everything was excellent. My only disappointment was with the green beans. The fried chicken was so exceptional, that I expected the green beans to match and they just didn't work for me, they were kind of bland and soft. For dessert, we ordered the strawberry rhubarb cobbler with ice cream. It was a great decision! Due to the wonderful service from Kit, the welcoming vibe of the restaurant and the fantastic food, this place will quickly become a favorite for the family! read more

Excellent fried chicken and Sangria. Service was great. Go and enjoy!!! The atmosphere is warm and cozy comfortable with very high ceilings, Tables for four are perfectly sized. Enjoy! read more

I tried the chicken pot pie and it was tasty but I wouldn't order it again. It has a great flaky crust, was full of chicken and had good flavor. For me, it lacked in the gravy.. it was a little soupy and I felt it was a little bland. read more

What an adorable restaurant! It reminds me of a cute little neighborhood place that offers good food, great customer service and supported by the locals. I had a good time visiting Piccadilly. I felt welcomed. The food appears to be homemade and the prices are reasonable. It's a small place from what I could tell so check to see if they accept reservations. The pot pie is so good! The crust is soft and delicious. read more

The Piccadilly at Manhattan - American Near Me - St. Louis, Missouri

See all

One of my favorite places to take the special people in my life. It feels like eating in someone's home, and is about the same size. Reservations are highly recommended. The fried chicken is some of the best I've had. My husband ordered the seafood pot pie and that was a bit underwhelming, but I go for the specials and fried chicken. Great bar selection with special martinis and delicious sangria. read more

The Piccadilly at Manhattan - Fried chicken - American Near Me - St. Louis, Missouri

The ambiance is modest but the menu was surprisingly diverse including salad options. The food was well seasoned but not salty. I had a smoked tuna appetizer with crackers that was absolutely delicious, followed by a seared tuna salad with a sesame ginger dressing. The salad dressing was a little too oily, but the tuna was seared perfectly and the sesame oil paired nicely with the ginger. read more

So, I went to dinner here with someone -- not to degrade it, since we've never been -- but as our second choice. It was charming to me, with a causal-but-upscale, East Coast, Magnolia, Provincetown, or Outer Banks vibe to it. I had what I believe was called a "Mayfair Salad", the other guy a short rib pot pie. We sampled each others', nuts for it all, and I'm happy to see they have take-out as well. read more

We had only ordered take out so far. Every time the place is BUSY! The food is delicious and there's lots of variety. The interior is a bit rustic but clean and welcoming. Parking can sometimes be challenging. read more

Okay wow I've been sitting on this way too long. My husband and I finally tried this place yesterday, and it was fantastic! It's a charming little building on a quiet street, with indoor and outdoor seating. We sat at a little table outside and started with a big plate of onion rings. Then we each had a Mayfair salad, and you really can't beat that. I had a cheeseburger and it was mouth watering. I have tried many smash burger types around stl and this is in my top 3, if not tied for number 1. My husband had a corned beef sandwich special and loved that as well. We then shared the bread pudding, and it was also fantastic. Our server was lovely and attentive. We will be back to try the pot pie! read more

We have appreciated Piccadilly as a low-key, comfortable neighborhood spot. We don't expect culinary miracles, but the food has been good and the service very friendly. So why three stars? Our visit this weekend was such a disappointment. Our server appeared to be unhappy we were there. No idea why, as we barely had a chance to speak to her. Throughout the evening, our food arrived well after that of people who arrived after we did. It was the manager or owner who brought it out, and finally took my drink order. A server from another section brought the drink. We had to fill our own water glasses. I'd figure they were just extra busy. However, our server was happy to make multiple trips to the larger party table right next to us--walked to and fro past us multiple times without once stopping. The food and ambiance aren't worth it when the service fails. read more

Piccadilly has been special to my family for a long time. My grandma would rave about the chicken pot pie. Tonight when I went I got the fried chicken. I am a sucker for fried chicken and it satisfied my cravings. Service is personable and it seems like they have a lot of regulars. Cocktails could be a little bit better but overall it was a great experience. Being in a nice neighborhood home gives it a comfort style feel. read more

The Piccadilly at Manhattan - Fried chicken - American Near Me - St. Louis, Missouri

Always delicious. The short rib potpie is so good! So is the chicken potpie. Love it!

Three words: Poppy Seed Dressing. If you have always thought poppy seed dressing tasted like sugar water, you need to try the Piccadilly's home made dressings! All of them are delicious (they even make original Mayfair dressing - an Old St. Louis favorite!), but the poppy seed variety is absolutely addictive, because it brings out the flavor of salad ingredients without overpowering anything with unnecessary sweetness. I hate letting the secret out about this place, but it's the best upscale comfort food in town. Nothing on their menu disappoints, ever. We discovered this little neighborhood treasure on one of our many walks during the pandemic, and we've been diehard fans ever since restaurants opened again. If you've never heard of The Piccadilly at Manhattan, it's because they don't need to advertise. There has been a successful restaurant in this quaint neighborhood location for over 100 years, and I expect there will 100 years from now, because it has a captive audience The location is charmed, and the people who keep this place going are proud of what they do. Reservations recommended, because the word is out about the Piccadilly at Manhattan! read more