The artichoke turkey sandwich CHANGED my life. It sucks their hours are so weird because I always want to come back here. I need their recipe seriously. I won't get anything else. Try it! read more

I am OBSESSED with this place. I saw them on Facebook yesterday and ordered through Uber eats. These were some of the best sandwiches I've had in my life! I liked them so much that I had to order it again today! I really enjoyed the Turkey artichoke sandwich and the French Dip is to die for! If anyone has any recommendations for other things to try here please let me know!! read more

See all

I took my son to lunch here yesterday. We both had the Italian sandwich. It was perfect! Honestly! Just the right amount of everything. The price was right too! read more

I recently got a job in the building above this amazing café, oh man when I walked by the savory amazing sweet smell was like an aphrodisiac. As soon as I got out of my interview & went in there & placed my first order, the Ham, salami, provolone cheese, mayo, tomato & lettuce Deli sandwich. I'm hooked.. I'm on a mission to try as many of their foods & drinks that I can! The staff is so friendly & helpful with those who haven't been there before, there is a rhythm to the hum there & once you get it down, it's fun & delicious! It's a small place that is packed with an amazing vibe that just attracts you. This place is one of the best parts of my day when I am on the side of town! Thank you... Oh & their specials are great opportunities to try things that aren't on the menu. Love this place. read more

I wish I tried this place sooner! I was craving a good sandwich and got a recommendation to go here. The sandwich I had was so good that I am already planning my next visit. They were also very friendly! read more

Friendly staff, amazingly fresh ingredients. Whether it's sandwiches,soups,salads, and even pizzas you will not be disappointed. This is another hidden gem. read more

The Pickled Pepper - Italian toasted sandwich, with side salad. - Sandwiches Near Me - Puyallup, Washington

Tasty sandwiches! Ordered for lunch and dinner due to us going out of town, so tried three sandiches: Roast Beef and Wasabi, Turkey and Artichoke Focaccia, Grilled Chicken Panini. They were all rich, but also light... Got a garden salad also... salad was so-so. But the mark of success is that the leftover sandwiches ate cold great, too. I'll definitely mark this place down as a good sandwich joint around! read more

Fresh and delicious! We had the toasted Focaccia BLTC, added the fresh cucumber salad. Added strawberry smoothie and snickerdoodle cookie. Filling and fabulous. read more

Waaaayyyy Overpriced. I don't mind paying $15 for a sandwich if it's loaded with protein, flavor and fresh but this was very mediocre Lack of meat on sandwiches. Salads not fresh and lacking ingredients. Won't be coming back. read more

Delicious sandwiches, the bread has a good texture and they are generous with the meat. Their French dip is amazing!! It's like toasted cheese bread with roast beef. I've tried several soups and they were all good. I want to try their wraps and paninis next but the French dip is so good it's hard to want to get something different. read more

A perfect little lunch stop during our visit to Puyallup. This place was busy even for an early lunch on a Thursday. We enjoyed their chipotle turkey special, a chicken panini, tortilla soup, and a cowboy salad. The salad was a surprisingly tasty little pasta and veggie salad with a smokey flavor. Sandwiches were quite large and I was stuffed after a half sandwich and the pasta salad side. read more

I had the veggie panini right after I gave birth to my daughter and it was the best thing I could've eaten after delivery. I'm obsessed with this place. The restaurant in so cute and all the ladies that greeted me after I visited a couple times after have been so sweet and kind. Definitely my favorite sandwich place read more

10/10 experience. The focaccia bread was fluffy and flavorful, the chicken was tender, as well as the homemade honey mustard and homemade cheesy garlic spread really brought out the flavors of the other components on the dish. Definitely need to stop by if your in the area. read more

The Pickled Pepper - Aussie Chicken - Sandwiches Near Me - Puyallup, Washington

Normally the food is pretty good, but don't order the chicken asian salad. Horrible and absolutely no flavor. read more

The Pickled Pepper - a salad in a plastic container - Sandwiches Near Me - Puyallup, Washington

This was my very first encounter with the Pickled Pepper, and I wanted to love this quaint little shop. However, after an employee making certain I was corrected each and every single time I said only "Ham and Cheese" I finally tried the "Not Just Ham and Cheese"....with HAIR! The words "Not Just" in the title seem rather ironic and appropriate, now, don't they? No thanks Pepper, your Pickle is not for me. read more

The Pickled Pepper - Sandwiches Near Me - Puyallup, Washington

See all

This place is delicious! We went here for the first time today. The staff was kind and quick. We got the club sub and grilled chicken panini. They were so fresh and meaty! We were thrilled. Make sure you add the cherry peppers to your sandwich-they are awesome! We will be back! read more

I ordered Pickled Peppers via door dash for lunch and I was glad to see they had a veggie wrap and sandwich option. I got the wrap and the broccoli cheddar soup. The soup was a little too gelatinous for my liking but it wrap was interesting. I enjoyed the artichoke and peppers. It was a bit on the soggy side but I think it was because of the delivery. Overall, I would try it out again but maybe in person. read more

I highly recommend this spot. I had the TUSCAN TURKEY PANINI. It had cream cheese and delish AF. The staff was super friendly. I also got a Chi tea which was the best one I've ever had. I'll definitely be back. I only wish it was open on weekends. read more

This is my dream restaurant. it would be nice if they had seating indoors but that's OK we go on a nice day. everything on the menu sounded fantastic and the wrap that I had was delicious. read more

Omg so so so so much better than i would have ever expected. Not my first time at a cute little shop in an office building and expectations were slightly on the lower side. Staff was super friendly and helpful (since it was my first time) and food was absolutely delicious. So fresh and flavorful and just enough to get you full without being in a coma. We absolutely loved it and will definitely be back! read more

Every time I've gone here (about 4 times now) I've really enjoyed the paninis and pastas. The mixture of flavors is absolutely delicious. I've never eaten anywhere where this happens. Today I had the Tuscan Turkey Panini and it was amazing. I would give them 5 stars every time I've eaten here. read more

Two sandwiches for less than $21. Unheard of from most places nowadays. The service was quick and food came out anazing. Definitely recommend this to anyone with a 20 and appetite read more

Hands down the best sandwich I've had in Washington! Also, the staff there is absolutely amazing! Highly recommend it read more

The Pickled Pepper - Sandwiches Near Me - Puyallup, Washington

I have been in there several times in the past few months out of convenience. However, the staff completely shirks all COVID protocols. I wear my mask and go up to the register to order and both the cashier and anyone working behind her (in a very small space I might add) have their masks around their chins. They have clearly given false info to yelp about their COVID protocols (they aren't even in compliance with the state laws). Also, I saw the woman who makes the food cough onto the food with her mask around her chin. Yuck, read more

Okay. Good pasta salad (cranberry chicken). Sandwich is a sandwich. Very noisy in a very small space.

Oh yes!! This place hits the spot. I called in my order and was able to pick it up during my lunch break. Friendly service when I walked in the door. I wish I would have taken a picture of this sandwich but I ate it too fast! The meat was plentiful, veggies fresh, but that bread.... That was magical and made the sandwich! I recommend the club sub!! read more

We needed to stop for a quick sandwich and this place is great. We both got the Italian sub and the bread was superb. Toasted perfectly. Great toppings, just the right mix of meats, cheese and veggies with a nice addition of dressing and Mayo. Really happy we stopped to check them out. They will be added to our list of great options. read more

OMG the aussie sandwich. I had an internship around here and this was my lunch spot. One day we ordered in lunch for a meeting and this was my order. Afterwards I raced to the orderer to figure out where to get this sandwich again. Once I found it I was in love. Ok so the sandwich: delicious bread (don't quote me but it might be foccacia), sweet onions, chicken, honey mustard (?). I don't know, but it's amazing. Just go order it. read more

I was going to post a picture of my sandwich but I couldn't resist! I have to say - this is the top cafe in the area. I got the grilled chicken panini and wow.. so good! I'll definitely be back! Highly recommend! read more

We had headed for this place a while ago but it was Saturday and they are only open during the week. It looked interesting so we tried it again. It is a small location in the business building. I figured that the quality of the food is not that special since they have a captive audience. The staff was friendly but that isn't enough to make a special trip. We ordered the Tomato Basel Pizza which was on the cold side and nothing special. I had the Roast beef sandwich which had lots of meat taste OK and actually was medium rare. However - You get nothing with it. No chips or pickle - just the sandwich which is the price of other places that offer a little extra. Also the bread is supposed to be Sour Dough bu taste like cheap white bread. I did find out later - if you ask for a pickle you might get one - really - so if they have to they will make the plate a little special but they are hoping you don't - a pickle slice is not that much. read more

I had three tortellini soup and grilled cheese. It was the special of the day. I also had thier campfire mocha. All of it was quite good. read more

Unfortunately had a very poor experience. Ordered a hot sandwich and potato salad. I ate a few bites of each before I realized both tasted... off. Like Aunt Carols potato salad that's been in the sun for 2 hrs. I let them know and they said they would check into it. Fast forward 6 hours later and I was violently ill. Called and informed them and they were very kind and apologetic and offered to refund my meal. Unfortunate but doubtful I'll be back. read more

SUPPORT LOCAL!! Amazing food! I ordered the French dip to try today and was definitely not let down! Side salad was the perfect compliment. The staff was really friendly! 10/10 would recommend to anyone that enjoys a good meal. read more

Best lunch spot in town by far! I eat there 3 times a week and order door dash even more from there.

Best grilled sandwiches in Puyallup! Fast service, friendly staff and fresh breads and salads. Quick in-and-out)!

Love the Pickled Pepper! Paninis are huge and fresh and delicious! There's enough to feed two people for sure! I haven't had their soup yet but I'm sure it's fresh and homemade. We also go there for our redbull drinks. They have many flavors to choose from and the service is super friendly! read more

Yes the food is delicious but hands down the best service! It makes a difference when you are served by the ladies who are happy to be there. Panini sandwiches are creative and fresh! read more

This is one of my favorite spots in Puyallup! Everything is made with love and you can tell. Friendly, attentive staff, the quality of the food is great, the coffee is amazing. The french Dip is a must but i encourage to try any of the items on the menu, you won't be disappointed! I start my day with The pickled Pepper just about every day. read more

This place was so good! It is located in an office building and is a bit small inside with only two tables however the food is delicious. They have additional seating outside as well. We had the grilled chicken panini and sausage gumbo soup. Omg so good. I wanted another, lol. You've got to try their homemade italian dressing! Good on everything!! read more

The only negative I have for this place is that it was a little difficult to find. They are located on the ground floor of those big blue office buildings. One bite of my sandwich and I was hooked. Not sure what else there is to say, but there's no need for anything else; they're a sandwich shop. And a VERY good one at that. read more