The black and blue burger was really good as was the Jet burger with the pan fried cheese. The homemade kettle chips were super crispy. The chili was tasty but the cornbread was awesome. The chicken pot pie needs a bit more gravy but you can tell it is homemade. read more

Nice atmosphere good food and drinks .We are locals and love supporting small local restaurants.

Group of 8 made reservations 12 days in advance for patio. Assured it would be warm with their heaters, temp at our arrival was 56. Arrived and had to eat inside, 4 heaters broken. Panini sandwich was not put in panini grill, it was just a cold cut sandwich. Asparagus half cooked for 3 people, burger with extra pickles had no pickles, meatloaf was very smokey flavored then smothered in brown gravy ( disliked by 3) . Would not recommend or return. read more

Spent the evening there last night. Dylan was our bartender and we had so much Fun. We gave him free reign to make is whatever and he gave us some great drinks and very friendly service. Dude was legit and did a fantastic job keeping up with us!!! Good Show D!! Give that boy a raise read more

My wings and drink were great. Here's the issue, the kitchen is part of the bar/restaurant and what happens in the kitchen, echoes. I mean, really echoes. There's a short, fat, dark bearded man in the back, who I can only assume is the lead chef, just by the way he speaks to the others and demands how things get done, dropping the "f" bomb loud enough that the whole restaurant can hear. I'm not a prude and have used the word plenty in my life, but buddy, there are customers with children listening to every word you say. I'm embarrassed for you. You're very loud spoken and rude. You need to go, son. read more

The fish is better than Coleman's bc of the beer batter. Thick pieces, tender,& mild, sweet potato fries were good. We shared a huge piece of strawberry cake that was absolutely delicious! read more

We stumbled across this spot driving along route 40 taking a ride. It's in middlemof nowhere but a hidden gem. There is a bar area, plenty of seating and outside area. They have everything from brunch to burgers. I had the southwest quesadilla and my husband had smashburger. We had to try a dessert as the case was calling our name all throughout the meal. read more

Very nice place. Food and service were excellent. My wife had the Pike Inn salad, which is her new favorite. Fish and chips were good. Had this light coffee stout (not really dark but tasted great. We will be back. read more

Love The Pike 40!! Always great food and amazing service. Love the seasonal menus and atmosphere. Great local eatery.

The food can be hit and miss. Had the beef tip and noodles. Noodles were just plan old store bought and the beef tips were tough. Could even cut with a knife due to the gristle. Wife had chicken salad wraps and loved them! The desserts are always delicious. read more

Great food, old school diner vibes, some things can be a lil pricey but the burger alone is worth it.

Excellent jalapeños burger and very good fried pickles. Great stop off I 70. Don't miss out. I'm

We made a reservation a day in advance for pike idol and drove 35 minutes to get there for them to not have our reservation. We gave them our name and number. The best they could do was give us a table in the pouring rain a foot from the stage. We left. read more

First, let me say that I will return to this spot, but want to clarify on my 3 star rating. I've been here several times and I suppose I'm somewhere between a 3 and a 4 rating. On the surface, seems like the menu is well thought out and presented well on paper, but I've been less than impressed with the execution at times. Took the kids this past Friday evening on our way to a local park; they ordered mac n cheese (a cavatappi pasta with velveeta?), not bad. One was the adult portion, which is a larger serving with a piece of regular bacon broken up on top, not special. The other was off the kid's menu, just a small bowl, no big deal - kids ate it, I dad-taxed my couple of bites. I had the Pike burger (cooked medium), which, at 9.99, I figured would be your average pub burger, maybe 1/3 pound or so. It came to the table needing some reassembly. The bun was rather dry and parched the tongue. Patty more resembled a sausage patty in size and was too thin to really cook medium and still get a good char. Chose the broccoli as my side and it was really the "star" of the meal, but I wouldn't put too much weight on that. Stole some fries from the kids and they were on point. Servers are generally good, especially given the timing of a friday night around 6-7pm. Haven't had an issue there. Oh, and given the location, its the best eatery around (it's either McD's or gas station). But I'm an IPA guy and they really didn't offer much there, but they do carry a couple local brews, so definitely points there in my opinion. The new patio out back is awesome, so I wouldn't argue against going back, just haven't been so impressed with the food, I suppose. Had the chef salad the time before last and, I know this might sound odd, but I had a hard time getting a balanced bite because seemed like there was hardly any lettuce. There was certainly plenty of protein and fixin's which is a plus, but just didn't seem well executed. read more

Wow! Me and my partner stopped here to grab something to eat, and wow! This place was (there are no words to describe it) bomb. Like the customer service was A1, walked in the door everyone says hi; the restaurant was beautiful and clean and fresh inside and the AC worked great, the tables and chairs were comfortable and clean. Our waiter Megan, was so amazing and funny and outgoing and she knew everything about the food and offered her favorites, we got the steak salad and a side of Chilli the salad was amazing and bomb , it was cooked greatly, and the meat was fresh and wow! The chili was bomb as well and can tell it was freshly made. This place in all words is amazing, can't wait to come back to Ohio and try this place again. Thank you to the restaurant staff and management, and to our amazing waiter Megan she is amazing. Thank you guys read more

The Pike 40 - Comfort Food Near Me - Morristown, Ohio

See all

My girlfriend and I were deciding what we wanted for dinner, when we decided on this place. We called to place an order, and the person who answered the phone sounded frantic almost, and was very loud. She said that they are not doing take-out orders because they were "too busy". I've never heard of a restaurant that refuses business like that. Safe to say we'll never be going here. read more

What a lucky find! We were driving home to NJ after dropping off our daughter at school in Indiana and found this place on Yelp. It wasn't too far off our route and we couldn't stomach fast food or the typical eats you see on those blue signs. What a warm welcoming place amidst a road that at night seems to lead to nowhere. It's seat yourself so we sat in the bar area and were warmly greeted and served by Leslie. The vibe is casual but the food was anything but. Such great touches of care to every item, even the coleslaw! I had the Jet Burger which was made with from beef from a local farm, frizzled onions, real bacon slab and a patty of fried cheese served on a brioche bun. I've never had a burger with fried cheese, it was insanely good! My husband had their pulled pork sandwich which was the best he's ever had. Not the typical pulled pork masked by a ton of overpowering sauce. This one was all tasty meat. The best surprise was the cole slaw! Unlike typical coleslaw swimming in mayo, this one was finely chopped cabbage in a slightly sugary vinaigrette. It was unlike any coleslaw I've had before. I stole my husbands coleslaw and asked if we can order a small container to go. That is how much I loved this coleslaw. It is easily 6+ hours away for me from this place. But needless to say that I will find a way to make it back to this place and make sure becomes a "must" stop on our road trip to/from Indiana. Special thanks to Leslie, our server for her warm hospitality. read more

This place was terrible. I understand that some people don't mind sitting there waiting awhile while you listen to music, but this time this wasn't the case! My family and i were extremely disappointed waiting 20+ minutes for someone to even bring out water or even tell us someone was on the way even though the place wasn't crowded. There was a lady there that made eye contact with us multiple times and continued to walk past us. As a person apart of a black family and a young black lady i wonder if this has anything to do with the way we were treated. I would suggest to stay away from this place, especially if you are a person of color. read more

I love it It's a great restaurant to go for dinner to I love their tea and their burgers especially pan fried cheese read more

The food is delicious and fresh, restaurant is clean and casual. Service is friendly and welcoming. Great for date night or for the whole family. read more

Great food! Great service-! Very simple atmosphere, clean & inviting, indoor & outdoor seating.

Stopped on our way East. What a pleasant surprise! The food was delicious and the atmosphere was casual. Loved the decor. I had the Cobb salad with grilled chicken. It was perfect. The homemade ranch dressing was delicious. The service was friendly and attentive. I absolutely recommend you stop here if you are nearby and looking for a good place to eat. read more

Hard biscuits and gravey from a can. Would give zero stars but it won't let me. Salty fries. Just plain and dull food.

Nice selection of americana foods - I had fish and chips and spouse had the pub burger. Both were delicious. Even the french fries were especially good. And the dessert menu is amazing. Our server was pleasant and helpful. We will definitely come back when we're in the area again! read more

Burger was very good and wife loves the pulled pork sandwich for lunch. We finished it off with a fudge covered cake ice cream concoction. Thanks. read more

Local restaurant wanted to try. Portions were average, prices were large. Husband got the spaghetti special, portion was good size but they use angel hair pasta and sauce was thin and tasteless $12.99, I had the chicken pot pie, the crust wasn't flaky, and was thin and stuck to the container, the sauce was watery and it was full of huge pieces of chicken breast, so big I had to dig them out and cut them up, 2 pieces of potato and one carrot. It was $13.99 Marie Callender sells a better pot pie in the freezer section of Kroger for $2.99 or sometimes 10 for $10. My son had the kids cheeseburger and he said it was good. The fries were good I stole a few. We had soft drinks and a piece of hot fudge cake that was tasteless. Bummed out because everyone talks about this place and the food looks really good in pictures. $52 is a lot for such a small Amount of food. read more

The food is very good at this establishment and if you save enough room for dessert they do have some good options for you to choose from and are great finish to the meal. However, the downfall to this restaurant is the service. All aspects of the service need improvement from pre-order, to drink order, to the food order as well as waiting for the check. If you are looking for good food and you are in no hurry then this place is the one for you. read more

Found this gem on yelp while passing through The food is INCREDIBLE along with the service! We had 5 meals ( rueben, beef tips, pulled pork, chicken tenders, and Mac and cheese) ALL were amazing!!!! We will definitely be coming back as often as we can!!! read more

Stay away the food is overpriced has no taste and the service is awful waited 20 minutes for a waitress then she took her time completely ignored us another waitress had to bring our check because she was at the bar talking on the phone fish was overcooked. REALLY BAD unprofessional hope they close read more

Excellent. Good service, food was great and ambiance is nice and new. I hope they are able to maintain this little spot since it's needed in the area. Thank you for a nice experience. read more

The Pike 40 - Comfort Food Near Me - Morristown, Ohio

See all

Good luck catching them open. Twice now i have went there during regular business hours and they were closed both times. If you do manage to go while they are open, the fish and chips are to die for. read more

This place is very good. Been in many different dishes there. The prices are very good. The buffalo chicken dip is great. I highly recommend the beef tips and noodles and the pike Ruben. But if you are a burger person I love the mushroom burger. The only other place that has one was Hardee's but this one is so much better and you can have it cooked to your temp you want. The staff is friendly and helpful. And they have a Sunday buffet to die for and the price is great read more

Awesome experience! Friendly waitstaff, timely service, clean surroundings. The food is the star attraction-I had the best pulled pork sandwich in years here. With homemade slaw (w/o Mayo) and homemade kettle chips! Nice portions and well presented. Also had their pickle fries as an appetizer. So good! All desserts are homemade as well. Yummy! Worth the drive on historic Rte. 40. read more

Stopped in today...friendly wait staff, great food, classy decor, and great atmosphere. We will definitely be stopping back by. The Fried Cod Sandwich with the hand cut fries are delicious. The Fried Zucchini planks really also good. Everything we got was amazing 10 out of 10 stars from us -WV & Louisiana read more

The Pike 40 - Comfort Food Near Me - Morristown, Ohio

See all

Fabulous food and service. Although I was not a fan of the sangria (very sweet), everything else we had was fantastic. I LOVED the chicken. We loved the service. We were a group of 6 (adults and teens). Trying to please this group is not an easy task. But, Pike 40 did it with ease. Customer service is alive and well and living at the Pike 40 restaurant. We will definitely be back. So glad we found you!! read more

Amazing restaurant. Looks like something you would find in a larger city. Great food and atmosphere. Highly recommend!

Drove out of our way to eat at this restaurant based on the hours they have posted only to find them closed. Disappointed that they do not keep their info updated. read more

Service is rough most days. Food quality has steadily declined. Over priced small portions. Better options close by.

Underwhelming is the best description. Burgers had no flavor but the beer cheese was good. The pike salad was interesting but sloppy as my waitress sat it down cheese fell in my lap. Service was atrocious... waitress greeted us with "hi" and nothing else. We stared at each other till I just went ahead and ordered my drink. We all sat with empty glasses multiple times. Sat with all our appetizer plates empty and stacked for a long while. The restaurant was not busy at all (3 maybe 4 tables when we arrived) and she took forever to do anything. Ordered a red velvet roll slice for dessert and she didn't even put the whipped cream on it. Then we sat for at least 10 minutes with empty glasses and plates waiting on a check while she chatted with other waitresses. We may get carry out but will not be dining in again. read more

Great food and excellent service! Food was fresh and hot, served quickly, wish I had room for the delicious looking pie, definitely would go here again! read more