Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    The Pizzeria of Smithtown

    4.4 (52 reviews)
    Closed 11:00 am - 10:00 pm
    Updated 1 month ago

    Order The Pizzeria of Smithtown Takeout or Delivery

    The Pizzeria of Smithtown Photos

    THE PIZZERIA OF SMITHTOWN ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    You might also consider

    More like The Pizzeria of Smithtown

    Recommended Reviews - The Pizzeria of Smithtown

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Victoria D.

    I loved my first visit to The Pizzeria in Smithtown! I brought my nephew for our lunch date on a Saturday afternoon. The ambiance inside is bright, clean, and welcoming. From start to finish, the service was excellent. Our waitress was super friendly and sweet, especially when my nephew decided he didn't want to share a pizza with me (how rude). She laughed with me and quickly brought him his own cheese slice, which made him happy! We started with drinks. My nephew had apple juice, and I got the Montauk Wave Chaser on tap. For starters, we went with the mozzarella sticks. They were perfectly crispy on the outside, with gooey cheese inside, and a side of marinara. A classic done right. I tried their bruschetta slice, which I think I could eat a slice of this everyday. The crust had a hint of balsamic baked in, topped with fresh bruschetta, creamy burrata, basil, and a balsamic glaze drizzle. So good. We decided to go with the Aunt Danielle. The personal pizza was 16", perfect for sharing. Topped with vodka sauce, pepperoni, stracciatella cheese, fresh basil, and a perfect swirl of hot honey over the top. The hot honey was the star of the show here. The spicy pepperoni mixed with the hot honey, mmmm mm. I will definitely be back. This place is a Smithtown gem! Highly recommended for families or anyone who loves great pizza with a twist. I can't wait to try their wraps that you could see through the window counter.

    Barbara S.

    Stopped by for a quick slice for lunch. The ambiance is light and roomy inside and the service is friendly. The plain cheese slice was just ok, I've had much better tasting slices. We tried the regular garlic knots and buffalo knots. Not much flavor to them and they were small at 70 cents each but they were soft and fresh. The tri-fecta with was decent with a nice thin olive oil crust.

    John D.

    I recently gave The Pizzeria a 4 star review. I would like to upgrade my review to a 5. Went for lunch and as promised tried the slices of Pizza. Tried a chicken with bacon and white sauce. Also had a hot honey with pepperoni and sausage. Both of these were outstanding. Had more than enough to eat

    Broccoli Rabe & Sausage Pasta
    Lou A.

    I just bought a pasta with broccoli rabe and sausage . They need to put some sausage on it. Just a few crumbles. Like a dusting of sausage. No chunks at all. Not impressed at all. very small portion.

    Amazing Espresso Martini!
    Adam A.

    This is a upscale pizza restaurant. The menu has just the right amount of Italian classics. The pizza is on point along with there wings ! Don't skip on the calzone made baked or fried (old school) the only way IMHO the chicken parm is also a hit with vodka sauce and ricotta . We always try and sit at the bar where Luke the bartender provides 5 star service and 5 star drinks (makes a killer espresso martini)! Seating in the dinning area is first come first serve with plenty of seating and great service! Only good things to say go enjoy! I think they have a Sunday special (take out I believe) check them out you won't be disappointed.

    Margherita and white slice
    S R.

    This branch of The Pizzeria just opened in Smithtown. The restaurant looks beautiful and there is a bar that opens to be al fresco. I didn't dine in but simply ordered two slices to go. I didn't have them heated up because I was bringing them home to share. The white slice was delicious but the margherita wasn't that great. I didn't care for the crust. Lastly I thought the slices were pricey. $11.96 for them both. I'll probably go back to try their pasta and skip the pizza.

    See all

    7 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    9 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 months ago

    We love to eat here! Always friendly staff and great food. Their cocktails are unique, fun and very good.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of L M.
    0
    56
    1

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Gary F.
    32
    207
    85

    11 months ago

    went here for lunch and the food is really really good. the service is equally as good and the ambiance is great.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 months ago

    We had amazing service and were treated incredible! We will definitely be back....plus the food was spectacular!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    My husband and I tried 4 different slices of pizza and they were all excellent. Place is real pretty too.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 months ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - The Pizzeria of Smithtown

    You might also consider

    iWrap NY

    iWrap NY

    4.3
    (6 reviews)
    3.7 mi

    Efe really is a master at wrapping…read more He started the job when he said he would. He finished earlier than he had promised. For the price he quoted. And the car (a 1967 Pontiac GTO convertible) looks AMAZING. I brought it to the body-shop that suggested I get the car wrapped (rather than a complete paint-job) and he said: "This guy is going to put me out of business!" I brought it to the mechanic who works on the car and all of his workers asked me for Efe's number. I brought it to a car show, parked it next to an older guy who owns 3 GTO's. He had no idea the car had been wrapped and couldn't believe it until I showed him a piece of the material I had in the glove-box. Efe's attention to detail is superb. So incredibly happy with his work.

    Got my C8 Corvette PPF for the front of the car and the side skirts. There was numerous…read moreimperfections which I noticed a few weeks after having the car done. I figured when I bring it in for a ceramic coating in a few months, they can fix the PPF. Well where do I begin. I dropped the car off 3 days ago to have the ceramic coating done. I arrive today and not one single area that I pointed out that needed the PPF to be fixed was corrected. Not one. When Efe's dad called him up because he wasn't there and I was pointing out over 10 spots min that needed to be fixed, his response was" you only pointed 4 spots out to me" my response was " and all 4 are still there". I told him to go through the car with a microscope and make sure the PPF was good. I arrived today to the same bubbling all over the front bumper, side bumpers, head lights and rear view mirrors all while being given excuses like " this is expected, the C8 front bumper is very hard, Its typical when you put film over the car that this happens". Absolutely every excuse in the book possible. Then after the father confirms there are a lot of area that are bubbling in the PPF, he tells me to bring it back to him on Saturday. So 3 times to get the PPF correct. The price changed 3 times in 5 months. Quoted me one price for the ceramic after I got the PPF done. Then another price when I dropped it off 3 days ago, and another price when I went to go pick it up today. I brought my car to a performance shop in Huntington and the first thing they asked me was if I PPF'd the car myself. That's how bad it was. They thought a complete amateur did it or I did it myself. It's cloudy out now but next sunny day I will post all the areas that have bubbles. On front of car, sides of car and even the rear view mirrors. Absolutely the worse experience I have ever had with a detailer and I have owned and taken care of cars meticulously for the last 30 years. You are completely out of your mind if you get your car PPF by this pace. Or just make sure you confirm your car is easy enough to do unlike my C8. As you see in these 2 pics, how bad the front was peeling. When I arrived today it was just as bad. Their excuse was that it was an oversight. Maybe for a blind person but if they consider this an oversight just imagine what else they will miss. Go to this place if you need to advertise for your company. Go to a PPF specialist if you don't drive a Honda Accord. I now have to bring this to another place to have this fixed correctly. My friend has his M4 done 2 year ago and not 1 bubble on his car. I now have to bring it to his place in Farmingdale and can only imagine what this will cost me. Also Imagine having a business charge you money to tell you the bubbles in your PPF is normal... All over your car. I will never bring my car back to this place again. Lastly they offered to fix it but I had to come back at 5pm. It was 1:30, I live 30 min away. Told me to take an Uber home and back again so no worries just another 100$ in taxis. That was also apart of their solution today as well. Look at the pictures!!! I came up there today and it looked Identical! How is that an oversight. Are you Blind!!!!! I think Ray Charles would have caught that but what do I know about PPF. People put it on their cars according to these guys to look at bubbles all over their car to protect the paint. I have done 100's of reviews. If I Could give them 0 stars I would. Rude, Argumentative, and outlandish to be honest!

    Photos
    iWrap NY
    iWrap NY
    How my car was after the ceramic coating after I specifically pointed this out to them when I dropped off the car.

    See all

    How my car was after the ceramic coating after I specifically pointed this out to them when I dropped off the car.
    Grafton Street Irish Pub

    Grafton Street Irish Pub

    4.2
    (102 reviews)
    2.7 mi
    $$

    Grafton Street Irish Pub in Hauppauge really leans into what it is at its core--a local pub that…read morehappens to serve food lol. This place isn't trying for polished restaurant experience, and honestly, that's kinda part of its charm. It feels like the kind of spot where the bar comes first and the kitchen supports it if this makes sense. The atmosphere is a neighborhood hangout feel. You can tell it's a local spot--people walking in were greeted by name, and there's a familiar, lived-in vibe that makes it feel welcoming if you're a regular, and easy enough to settle into if you're not. Food-wise, the corned beef on both the Gaiety and the Finnegan's Wake sandwiches stood out--tender, flavorful, and generous. Both sandwiches came with fries, and while I appreciate skin-on fries, these leaned a bit soggy rather than crispy. Overall, this is a solid spot if you go in with the right expectations. It's less of a destination restaurant and more of a go-to pub where you can grab a drink, and enjoy pub food. If you're looking for a lively, casual bar with good portions and a strong local following, it delivers--even if not everything on the plate is perfect. I think I'd like to make an update review after trying a few more dishes. At a glance, 3.5 with overall good experience.

    Wow Hidden gem…read moreBartenders are traditional Irish and it's a great location to stop and enjoy a piping hot burger cooked to your liking and a chilled beer on tap. Parking Ample Bathrooms Clean Accessible Music Friendly and ill be back Service was excellent Ad my drinks were served immediately and food thereafter

    Photos
    Grafton Street Irish Pub
    Grafton Street Irish Pub
    The Gaiety

    See all

    The Gaiety

    The Pizzeria of Smithtown - pizza - Updated June 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...