Funny enough, my sister & I were watching Nonnas & the first ten minutes made us want the pastries. So, we stopped to think where could we get a pastry? I remembered this place. It happened to be a little under twenty minutes away from us so we decided let's do it & they were open late. Hell yeah. There's not a crazy amount of pastries but the selection was great. We got two tiramisus, one vanilla custard lobster tail, some mini cannolis, & the wedding cookies. Everything came out to about $50 so beware, prices aren't exactly cheap. But for one, if you're going to do "bad" then do it right & we also shared with our family of 5 so plenty to go around. & Holy cow, everything was incredible. So indulgent, decadent & rich in flavor. My nephews liked the cannolis, personally they're not my favorite, but if you're into it the mini's are a great option to quench the craving. The lobster tail with the vanilla custard took me by surprise. I didn't think I was going to care for it, but the cold custard was refreshing & the flakiness of the bread was crazy, my taster buds were confused by the textures, but in the best way. They complemented each other well. My ultimate favorite was the tiramisu & the wedding cookies. I honestly wish I had gotten more of the wedding cookies, those things took me back. I grew up eating the Mexican ones & the Italians did it right *applause* But damn, the tiramisu was to die for. I would order that again & again. Perfectly chilled, the dusting of the cocoa powder didn't taste like nesquik--incredible. At first the price had me thinking if we were doing too much, like damn, should we have just gone to Sprouts bakery? But after being able to indulge in a great quality dessert, it was worth every dollar. My only feedback, careful when you're paying at the register. If you're not paying attention, the tip automatically defaults to 18% on the tablet. Only thing I didn't care for. I could see if I was eating at the restaurant, but I just popped in to take pastries to go. So, that was kind of annoying. The service was fine, the girl that helped me was nice, but again I just pointed at desserts I wanted & went home. The location is part of the main restaurant, but it has its own entrance & little room making it feel separate to the Sicilian Butcher. They also carry gelato which I haven't tried yet. I believe they have little tables to sit at also. Highly recommend checking this out so save room for dessert! read more

I've never tried this place or the butcher, but I saw it on too good to go and have been eyeing the bag for a very long time! I finally got the one that is daily up for grans, and I was so excited! My sister and I can't figure out why there's only one bag per day, but it's very coveted so we were excited to see what was actually inside! We walked in to the bakery with the intention of ordering more treats, in addition to what was in the too good to go surprise. When we walked in, it was 10:05, and they closed at 10:30. They had already put away half of their gelato and baked goods in the cabinet. I understand closing time is at 10:30, but if you still have almost half an hour left, I'm sure there are customers that are gonna come in and buy things. There were three parties of people that walked in while we were in there and then sitting out on the really nice patio. There is a little bit of seating inside, but the patio was very nice and there was plenty of seating out there too. The vibe is super cute, and I love the decor. Hopefully next time we go back, we can actually try things because they won't be put away! read more

See all

This was a lobster roll with vanilla cream from the Sicilian Butcher/ Baker was AMAZING. The outside was shaped like a lobster tail but it was like a croissant . Hard and flakey on the outside was soft on the inside and then it had vanilla cream or you had a choice of Nutella. I'm really glad I do not live anywhere near this restaurant. Otherwise I'd be there every other day, getting one of these, they were so good. They had gelato and an original cannoli among with so many other desserts! You got to pick your shell and filling for the cannoli. My MIL said their gelato tastes like it did when she traveled to Italy. All of the desserts looked AMAZING. We went there with my MIL for Christmas Eve dinner. My dish for dinner was ok but I should have got the lasagna as it was a smaller portion than what everyone else got. read more

See all

The Sicilian Baker is an Italian dessert and coffee counter attached to the Sicilian Butcher. They have gelato (ice cream) and homemade cannolis with a multitude of fillings. In addition, there is tiramisu, traditional Italian cookies, Sfogliatelle (lobster tails), cheesecake, and more. They have a great happy hour Monday-Thursday from 1-5 PM where you can get $1 mini cannolis and $2 scoops of gelato. We had the torta lemon pie gelato which was vanilla with real chunks of the dessert mixed it - absolutely delicious! I also ordered a mango sorbet which was blended with real mango. They were both 10/10! I also ordered an iced latte with almond milk and pistachio syrup. The espresso beans were a dark Italian roast - high quality and yummy! Cute and delicious dessert and coffee counter. I would absolutely recommend this spot for a sweet treat! read more

See all

This place is amazing they have some seats that you can sit down in we got the lemon meringue tart and Italian wedding cookie and the chocolate hazelnut mousse cake Everything was so amazing so rich and flavorful you have to try that this Bakery read more

See all

Best cookies and pastries in town. Fast and friendly service every time I've come to pick up, no matter how busy they are. Love the small bakery feel when you walk in. Coffee is on point too. read more

A canoli bar where you can pick a flavor (about 8 choices) for the filling?'. YES please. Friendly service. Fresh canoli shells. I picked banana pudding and peanut butter canoli filling w dark chocolate dipped shell. I ate the whole thing. No sharing. Get your own!! read more

The Sicilian Baker - Peoria - Canoli and Italian flag cookie - Desserts Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

See all

Celebrated my graduation here. Party of 12. Loved the bread and calamari. Food was great! Service was good! We changed our reservations last minute to make our lunch earlier and they accommodated. Would highly recommend. read more

Omg! The best cannolis around. I love the ambience, it's a whole wonderful experience. I love me a authentic dessert and well let's just say this place fulfilled every single taste bud. I took some treats to go but the fact that they have a whole section bar dedicated to cannoli fillings is awesome. They do offer other options, I will attach the pictures below. My husband and I sat in our car and ate almost everything we bought that was supposed to make it home. Great place will visit again soon, maybe today. I appreciate a great place! read more

The Sicilian Baker - Peoria - Pistachio Cannoli and a Cookie butter filling cannoli. - Desserts Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

Maya was so sweet and patient. There are so many desserts to choose from. I ended up with the tiramisu and cannoli. They were both very good. I would highly recommend this place. read more

See all

Not sure why my original review didn't post completely so here it is. What a cute little spot connected to The Sicilian Butcher. We came in to try some coffee, but after eyeballing so desserts I opted for a mini cannoli too. Both our hot and iced coffees were phenomenal, the cannoli to die for and service amazing. I love how happy everyone seemed to be. We are already talking about our next visit! give me all the treats! read more

See all

This place is a little gem. The desserts are very good and fresh. We tried the lobster roll, Napolean, lemon meringue, chocolate hazel nut mousse and the Italian wedding cookie. Every dessert we tried was delightful and so yummy. The cookie was just ok. I thought it was on the plane side; I thought it would be better. Anyhow, this dessert place is really good. I will definitely come back. read more

See all

If you know, you know, Sicilian Bakery doesn't just make desserts, they create masterpieces. Their chocolate mousse is a dream, and absolutely unforgettable. And don't even get me started on the Napoleon, layers of perfection so delicate and decadent, it should be a love language. Truly the best you'll ever taste. read more

The Sicilian Baker - Peoria - Desserts Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

The mini cannoli was what I was craving for ever since I heard about this place... and they are sooo tasty! But holy moly, the traditional ones are almost 3 times the size (not pictured). My friends and I sat inside, but they had outdoor seating as well. I love their hanging rolling pins and mixing bowl heads (is that what you called them? lol) as decorations, and I could not stop staring at them! Service was a bit lacking. When we arrived, there were no greetings, both staff members were seem to be in the zone on their non-guests-serving tasks. There was no direction on who to ask for help or where to pay. This was about 2:15pm, so there wasn't a rush. It felt more like a transaction than an experience. read more

See all

This was our first time trying The Sicilian Baker. The gelato really stood out super smooth and flavorful! The pastries were okay, not bad but nothing that wowed us. It is a smaller spot, and while they do have indoor and outdoor seating, the experience felt a bit rushed when we were ordering. Maybe it was a busy time, but it definitely took away from the relaxed bakery vibe we were hoping for. Still, the gelato alone is worth coming back for. We'll probably give it another try at a less busy time. read more

The Sicilian Baker - Peoria - Tiramisu and a Cannoli - Desserts Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

The tiramisu is to die for the service has been great thanks to Emma and Maya. Also try their lobster tails. read more

The Sicilian Baker - Peoria - Tiramisu's are the best - Desserts Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

After eating at the restaurant, it was only natural to peruse their Sicilian Bakery attached to the restaurant. One of the cashiers was helping the bar with drying some wine & beer glasses when they weren't busy at the bakery. Cannolis, pastries, cookies, gelato, etc. There is so much to look at. We couldn't get a cannoli because we were too full. They did look delicious and was very tempting. We settled on... LOBSTER TAIL: buttery flaky dough, nutella, or vanilla custard (5/5). Wow, this was so crispy, buttery, and flakey throughout! Each bite was crunchy. The custard cream was delightfully decadent. FLAG COOKIE: soft, fluffy almond cake layers all covered in a smooth layer of rich chocolate (3.5/5). It was good, but maybe a bit firm from the refrigeration. The best I had was in NYC. read more

See all

Great pizza. We just moved and were craving. I wish there was one in Surprise. Delivery was fast too. Cannoli were great.

So the food was on point. The pine nuts with the olives and the sauce with the peppers, amazing! And, don't get me started about the cheese and the main dish...I swear there was a sweet but tangy spice that made for a fun complexity. Definitely will be back! Espresso on point with a yummy surprise cookie to boot. Mike our server was the best. It's so nice having an amazing server who knows the menu. Just eat anything he recommends! Love this place. read more

The Sicilian Baker - Peoria - Espresso - Desserts Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

Excellent place to fill your spiritual dessert stomach with a treat- they have a variety of gelato flavors, cookies, cakes, and cannoli. I appreciate the staff for being so friendly and allowing our group to sample as many gelato flavors as we wanted. I sampled the Italian Espresso and immediately decided to get that one (call me a woman of caffeinated habits). Children tend to love the Italian specialty stracciatella, which they may describe as cookies and cream lol. Other options include the palate-cleansing lemon, bourbon apple crisp, and seasonal flavors depending on the moment of your visit. Prices vary by number of scoops, and for a whimsical flashback into your summer childhood you may choose a waffle cone for $1 more. The other baked goods that stood out to me were the tiramisu and cheesecake sold by the slice. A member of our party was celebrating her birthday and they gifted her a complimentary tiramisu surrounded by a rainbow road of sprinkles. Thank you for a sweet time! read more

The Sicilian Baker - Peoria - Italian Espresso Gelato in a waffle cone - Desserts Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

Stopped by for my fave Gelato. Guess what if you leave a review of the dessert experience, you qualify for a free mini Cannoli. Ask your friendly staff for details. Can't wait to dive in my Gelato. The ambiance transports me t simpler tinea. Manggia....happy Friday....yippee read more

See all

The pastries are to die for!!! Lemon bars are Devine, and the service is wonderful and friendly

That was fun! After enjoying a nice lunch at The Sicilian Butcher, we couldn't help but check out all of the great Italian goodies at The Sicilian Baker. It all looks so good! Many Gelato flavors and baked goodies galore! Hmmm, but what to get? I decided to try some cookies, so that we could take a few home to try. The fig cookies look good, the almond cookies look good and the lemon cookies look good. Which to get? And there it was on the countertop. A gift box with everything that I wanted to try and more. That's it! They are all delicious! My grandmother immigrated from Sicily and I can tell you that these are the real deal! The fig and almond cookies are very similar to what I grew up with. What a treat and a fun conclusion to a great meal at the Sicilian Butcher! Or, you could just have dessert as your main course! The Sicilian Butcher ant the Sicilian Baker is a win-win! read more

See all

Food was very good Service Ken was the best serving us Like this place come here when craving Italian read more

1st timers and so glad we came. Very busy venue with nice decor, delicious food, and amazing customer service. They also have their own bakery next door that is also connected to the restaurant! Win, win all the way around. We ordered: Ceasar salad - delish and enough to feed two people Calamari - cooked perfectly Bread w/oil & balsamic vinegar - (not on the menu) bread was ABSOLUTELY AMAZING! Not hard like most places! Italian Saganaki - Cheese Lovers...MUST ORDER! Delish and presentation is a show in itself!! Truffle mushroom spaghetti pasta - Amazing! Not too overpowering with truffle flavor. Cheesecake - Delish Tiramisu- Delish Cannoli- good If in the area definitely give this spot a try! Stop by the bakery if you don't have room for dessert after eating dinner. They have tasty treats you can take home for later as well as gelato!! read more

See all

I hadn't really noticed this place during my other visits. I needed to check out what they had. They carried specialty Italian desserts. Gelatos, cookies and pastries all looked wonderful. They were quite crowded having just opened. A good sign for sure. Free outdoor parking lot. read more

See all

Great sweets here! Didn't realize though the place is connected inside of the Sicilian butcher restaurant which makes for a very crowded space. Service was alright, you get you g workers who are very stressed out and too busy to greet you when asking for your order. I went on a Saturday night though so maybe it was a rough shift for the girls. Who knows. read more

The Gelato is amazing, several flavors to choose from, but I highly recommend the espresso mixed with the Belgian chocolate! The service is stellar and the AGM Jason is very generous. Thank you! read more

First, Mike mixed up a delicious Marg Al Melone for me! We then ordered the Truffle Mushroom Gnocci and Spaghetti Carbonara with Chicken Parm meatballs. Both were very tasty as well. In addition to Mike, Cheyenne and Jason also gave us great, attentive service at the bar! We enjoyed the chill vibe also! Definitely will be coming back here! read more

The Sicilian Baker - Peoria - Marg Al Melone cocktail - Desserts Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

The pastries are fantastic. I love the cannolis, and assorted cookies. They also have gelato. I love that you can customize a cannoli and pick one of several different flavors for your entire cannoli or you can have two different flavors in one cannoli, they put a different flavor on each end. Emma and Maya are very friendly and let you take your time while you try to decide what high flavor to get and which pastries to buy and they let you taste the different flavor fillings to help you decide. I really like the ambience and the vibe of the bakery too. read more

See all

Bakery was reasonably priced, and even better because we went during happy hour, the help was delightful. She was kind helpful and patient with us. And the pastries were like we were walking around Tuscany and just stopped for a treat at one of the local bakeries. read more

I wish I had visited the Sicilian Baker sooner. The bakery has a cute cafe look. Small cafe tables inside and out. Ambiance makes for a nice place to sit, enjoy something sweet, and catch-up with friends. Enjoy pastries, cakes, gelato and coffee. The Sicilian Baker is best know for their cannoli and lobster tails. Cannoli are available in mini and traditional sizes. They are also available in a variety of flavor combinations. Lobster tails are a crisp and flaky pastry that resembles a lobster's tail. Tails are filled with a dense cream that is similar to a thick pudding. The lobster tails weren't really my thing. My youngest loves them. Their other desserts are more to my liking. We came for the pastries. I can't wait to go back and try the gelato. Bakery goods may be ordered ahead of time. Holiday cakes may be ordered as early as late October. Unlike most bakeries, the Sicilian Baker does not open until late morning. read more

See all

Customer service was great!! Also? What we bought was delicious! A pumpkin cheesecake read more

The Sicilian Baker - Peoria - Pumpkin seasonal pastry and cannoli. - Desserts Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

See all

My first experience here was excellent. The girl helping us was awesome. She was super friendly and helpful (and patient) with us as we struggled to choose our cannoli fillings. They have a good selection of Italian influenced pastries. We got the napoleon. It was delicious - highly recommend. We also got a trio of the build-your-own cannolis. They have so many options it was hard to choose; but you can sample as many as you'd like to help make your decision. I recommend the Lemon, Cookie Butter, and Pecan Pie. The ambiance inside is really cute as well. The pastries can get a little pricey depending on what you choose, but the high quality justifies the value. I would return without hesitation. read more

The Sicilian Baker - Peoria - Cannoli Filling options! - Desserts Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

After lunch we came over here for dessert. We got a Lobster Tail with vanilla creme, 1 Italian wedding cake, a latte and Vanilla Bean and Espresso Gelato. The Lobster Tail easily breaks away in pieces, which makes it easy to share. Gelato was really good. They have Cannoli's too. But today we did not one. Next time! read more

See all

This rating is based solely on the Berry Mascarpone Tartlet. What pure joy was experienced while devouring this subtle delicacy! From the light and flaky phyllo pastry shell, to the light and creamy, but not too sweet, mascarpone, to the fresh and bursting trio of berries that rested atop this masterful pastry. Each layer wove a tapestry of texture that would make even Anton Ego pause mid-chew as synapses started firing, revealing a dessert experience finally attained! They're only like six bucks... get a couple. read more

The Sicilian Baker - Peoria - Berry marscapone tart - Desserts Near Me - Peoria, Arizona

This place was so delicious. The service was amazing, and every single baked item was pristine and delicious.

Our server was Ken. As busy as it was he was very attentive, kept up with our needs, and it was an all around enjoyable experience.

Ken did a great job taking care of us. Explained all the dishes and we had a lovely birthday celebration with our friends. We enjoyed having Jason stop by our table and share some stories. read more

The Sicilian Baker is perfect solution for sweet tooth. Their desserts are decadent and little bit goes long way. Very rich and sweet so pair it with coffee or tea. Very easily shareable too. Highly recommend! read more

The Sicilian Baker - Peoria - Tiramisu, cannoli, Nutella - Desserts Near Me - Peoria, Arizona