Pretty average. Soup and 1/2 sandwich lunch deal is nice (about $8). But I was not excited about either the soup or the sandwich! The split pea w/ham soup was very thick and brown. Wasn't expecting either! Didn't have a lot of "pea" flavor but wasn't terrible. The ham and cheese sandwich was pretty average also, but I did like the pretzel roll. Not a huge dine in area, seems most customers take food to go. Soup is served in paper cups, even for sit down customers. read more

The Soup Market - Split Pea w/ Ham (Only OK) - Sandwiches Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

3.5 stars- there are a few soups at the Soup Market which are big stars- the sirloin steak red chili, or the pork chili verde, the chicken dumpling is a good standby and African peanut stew a fave as well. This Soup Market has some indoor seating or is an easy carryout destination in Bay View. read more

I love the choices of fresh hot soup everyday. They have great sandwiches and treats too. My favorite is the grilled Reuben. They have a variety of Rice Krispie treats and in-house cookies for deserts. Looks like they do catering as well. read more

3 stars means "A-OK!" on Yelp and I'd say that's spot on for this soup spot. I popped in for a quick lunch in between meetings and chose half of a ham and cheese sandwich on a pretzel bun (these were made earlier the same day, not made fresh to order) and a cup of Italian chili. Both the sandwich and the chili were good. I was satisfied. It's a no-frills kind of place but you'll leave full and ready for the rest of your day. I'd have no problem coming back here but I wouldn't necessarily seek it out. read more

The Soup Market - The lunch special: half ham and cheese sandwich on a pretzel bun and a cup of Italian chili. - Sandwiches Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Top notch Looking at other reviews, they are definitely suspect. I've been going to this location for years now. They always have an amazing selection of offerings, and if you don't like what they have here (check online before you stop in) then look at their other locations as they might just have something that piques your interest. Soups are great. The sandwiches are nicely sized. Everything tastes fresh. Don't forget to grab a cookie too - the peanut butter ones are the best! I've always gotten super friendly and quick service too. read more

The soup is delicious! The sandwiches are top notch! And the cookies oh my! I highly recommend the gazpacho in the summer, the tomato soup with grilled cheese in the fall and the meatloaf and mashed potato in the winter! read more

Really horrible soup, I had been looking forward to some special soups but they were cloying and tasted horrible, I tried 5 different soups and in the end just wasted a great deal of money unfortunately. Even bread was stale and lousy that they give with it. read more

Not Good, Not worth you're money or time! Went and selected a bowl of Chicken Dumpling Soup. The soup, is not "assembled"! They scoop a few dumplings, from One stainless steel warming pan, then a scoop of diced chicken breast, then a scoop of vegetables, and finally pour a ladle of broth over the rest. Totally lacked flavor, obviously, because the ingredients couldn't blend together through simmering process. The bowl portion was served in a tall paper cup, so it was difficult to eat with the cheapest, flimsy, plastic spoon. Their sandwiches are pre-made, with the ingredients already on the house's choice of bread, stacked in rows of sheet pans. Not freshly made to order. Not worth it! Won't return! $27 for a small bowl of lackluster soup, one full sandwich, and one half-sandwich and two canned beverages. read more

Two stars for the nice welcoming woman behind the counter. I ordered the Caribbean Crab and Corn Chowder. There's nothing Caribbean about this soup. Such a lack of flavor. I also ordered the Chicken and Dumpling and Tomato Bisque to go. When I got home I had two bowls of Tomato Bisque... I will not be returning. Head over to Soup Otzie instead! read more

This spot is a great place located right on Kinnickinnic St in Bayview. I love soup so having found this place is a blessing!! Super good for breakfast lunch and dinner! Also great service, Zina was amazing. I came right during "happy hour" and she helped me navigate their menu and prices. Thank you so much Zina :) read more

The Soup Market - cars parked on the side of the road - Sandwiches Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

is it Soup? is it food? They do not use Noodles and I thought all soup has Noodles???? not even in there chilly do they put Moodles. i dont know why this place is so popular, I think the sandwich read more

I will admit, I am a soup lover. Love it all seasons, love all kinds, I just love soup. I stop in the soup market often. I have liked many soups I have tried here and I love their chicken salad sandwich. Popped in today and had a special soup of the day. It's a chicken curry and it is beyond wonderful and surpassed my expectations. I took the picture a little late (ate the bread and half the soup) but it was 4 star worthy!! read more

The Soup Market - Delicious!! Chicken curry soup! - Sandwiches Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

They always have at least one vegan soup so I'm guaranteed to find a good soup here for sure! Very filling, especially with the bread. Nice ambience, super friendly service, so glad they are here in my neighborhood! I'll keep on coming back, as I have since they opened. Oh, just a note, I gave it 4 stars for food only because I would like there to be even more vegan soups. If they had at least 3 on their menu daily, I would definitely give this a 5 star rating. read more

The Soup Market - Vegan Tomato Basil and Rice - Sandwiches Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

The three soups I ordered were bland, even though they were ladened with salt, and too heavy. They sure didn't taste healthy. Too bad because I love soup. Contrary to their response, I did not ask for a refund. I just considered it my loss. read more

Location / Atmosphere - Very nice and clean restaurant. Small but nice seating area, perfect for a quick lunch break. I did see a lot of 'to go' business which is also great. Food / Beverage - Very good selection of 'home made' soups. I also over heard the managers planning orders for future soup items all which sounded very good. Two recommendations - 1. Had a soup / sandwich combo. It would be nice to have 'made to order' sandwiches. I'm guessing that the sandwich I had was made earlier in the day and with this the bread tested a bit stale. I would think that you would want your sandwiches as good as your soups. 2. I had the cheese and andouille sausage soup which was fabulous by the way. The temperature of the soup was a bit hot for my 'in-dinning' experience but did cool and was able to eat it. I'm sure it would have been fine if I had ordered 'to go'. Service - Very quick service which is perfect when trying to get a quick lunch in. All prices were very reasonable. Very clean. Overall a very awesome place. In summary - Very impressed all around good service. Hope to stop back in the next time I'm in the area. read more

The Soup Market - cars parked on the side of the street - Sandwiches Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

I shopped the public market today. I always get the soup market when there. The soup is great! and the girl Masie who works there is very helpful with soup choices and very friendly. Easy to take soups home and eat during the week. Love this place! read more

Awful soup! My boyfriend tried to bring me some and it actually made me sick. The staff was also super rude to him when he was in there ordering. I'm usually not hard to please as I have been working the service industry my entire working life and understand most things but this place is no Bueno for me. read more

The beer cheese soup made me shit blood. I called and the owner said to choose better next time

I went for the pretzels, and they were out. I went for my favorite African peanut soup.. they were out. The owner didn't apologize that they were out of most of their food. The menu is non existent. If the soup wasn't so loud and full of fat, I'd try other things. My friend ordered the grilled cheese.... for $1.50 I could have made one just as good if not better. Last but not least when I went.. I noticed a few flies hanging around while we were eating. I just wasn't impressed. read more

Yikes! So salty! Love Milwaukee and all the local businesses but this place is a terrible. Sorry to say the soup is sub-par, the owner is a bit saucy behind the counter. No menu and I'm not sure why they serve ice cream with soup! What is this?!?? read more

Update your menus, old data is useless. It is not good business practice to advertise something that you do not carry. This is the second occurrence at this location. read more

It's been a couple months since I went but it wasn't the most pleasant experience. I thought I'd get a sandwich and soup. Tried to order a ham sandwich but everything is pre made. Luckily I asked before he charged me for a sandwich with every ingredient you could think of. It even already had mustard on it. I can only imagine how soggy it would've been. I received an attitude for changing my mind on the day old sandwich (they were about to close). The soup I ordered was okay. It was some sort of pot roast soup with beer broth. Pretty good. I prefer my soups with lots of meat and lots of potatoes, dontcha know. This one lacked in that aspect. However the effort in making that (hopefully) homemade soup earns the two stars. It was also considerably expensive. Spent almost five bucks on the tiny bit of soup. read more

I want to love this place but I can't, I've tried it a few times. Soup and sandwich is hands down my favorite lunch but I find it incredibly over priced for what you get. The grilled cheese I just received was flatter than a pancake. See pictures. I wish I could give them a good review but it's just not deserved. read more

The Soup Market - Sadly, this is half of my $3.00 grilled cheese. - Sandwiches Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

The soup is good, and their Tuna melt is fantastic. However, the last 7 (I kid you not, 7) times I've stopped in for a tuna melt, they've been out. I give up. read more

The Soup Market. Have the pizza. I kid. I kid. Unless of course they have pizza soup, then it's probably a pretty good choice. I've been dining here for lunch for years. It's one of my favorite Gosh-I-gotta-get-out-of-the-office-for-an-hour-before-I-strangle-somebody places to dine. Their soups are fresh, tasty and a good value. In fact, it seems to me the odder sounding the soup, the better it tastes. I recall a few years back a Polish dill soup that was a brothy, but heartwarming delicious entree on a blustery January day. It may even be souper easy to make (see what I did there?), but I haven't seen it on the menu since. Another favorite is African Peanut Chicken -- which is almost as much fun to say as it is to eat. Try it: African. Peanut. Chicken. Fun, right? And a few days ago I enjoyed fresh pea with spätzle. Hey, I'm 50% German. If you put spätzle in it, I'll eat it. Furthermore, saying "Spätzle" is also a fun thing to say. Again, try it: Spätzle. (If your German pronounciation is rusty, maybe this will help: shpéts'l.) Unfortunately not everything is fun to say at The Soup Market. For instance "Chicken Noodle Soup" is not much fun. It's followed closely by "Chicken Dumpling Soup." Why? My chicken soup bar has been set awfully high by my mom's, grandmother's, wife's and sister-in-law's versions. When I say "Chicken Noodle Soup" or "Chicken Dumpling Soup" around them, what follows shortly thereafter is a very happy tummy. I think what makes my relatives' soup so good is liberal use of chicken ... the WHOLE chicken. That means dark meat included. That gives the broth a full, slightly oily body with a whole lot of flavor. The chicken, too, falls apart and off the bone. I've seen mom pull it out and tear it apart with her fingers before throwing it back in the stock. Now there's the key to a hearty chicken noodle soup! The Soup Market uses cubed white meat chicken. Cubes of white meat chicken floating in yellow broth obtain the texture of driving range golf ball. I'm sure it's a healthier version that may appeal to some and probably is more expensive to make, but for me, I'd prefer it prepared old school style. Gimme the fat! All in all, The Soup Market is a solid choice. I know what I like there and what I don't, so it makes for a very satisfying lunch option. Oh, and one more thing: if you can make it past the toffee-covered chocolate chip cookies placed tantalizingly close to the check-out register, you've got a lot more willpower than I do. Dang those things are good. Like I said: Gimme the fat!! read more

Let me start this by saying, I like soup, I really do. BUT I'm not a SOUP GUY. That being said I was working outside on what seems to be our 167th day of snow and thought, "I want some soup"... there it was right in front of me... "The Soup Market". I ordered the the "five alarm chili"... now, given I have lived in Wisconsin for years, I wasn't expecting the "five alarm" to be much more than "point five alarm" ... I was wrong! It was so spicy, in a good way. The soup was homemade, thick, hot, and had big chunks of beef (not taco meat). Honestly, I can say it was the best chili I have ever had. A complex concoction of spices, but with the familiarity of chili and heat. Served with a big hunk of bread and butter and a couple packs of oyster crackers, a good deal for around 6 bucks. read more

Disclaimer: soup is my favorite food and I want to eat it every day of my life. And man, this place knows how to do soup. I'm reviewing the Bay View location even though I've been to all three (and loved them all, naturally). I really like that this location gives you the food in actual dishes instead of Styrofoam if you're staying there, a choice that I didn't get at the other two locations. Who still uses Styrofoam? The Soup Market, that's who. Only bad thing about this place. So, on to the good things: DELICIOUS SOUPS. Dear lord. I want to shove it all in my mouth. One of the best things about this place is that they let you sample soups to see if you would like them before you make your decision -- I highly recommend doing this. There've only been a couple I've tried that I didn't think were absolutely delightful, but I'm sure they've got their perfect audience out there, as well. Here are some of the soups I've had at The Soup Market: - meatloaf and mashed potato: are you kidding me, this tasted EXACTLY like a meatloaf and mashed potato dinner, I die - BBQ pulled pork chili: WHUT - African peanut & chicken soup: you guys. YOU GUYS. This is DELICIOUS. Seriously, y'all. I don't live in Milwaukee anymore but I can GUARANTEE that I will be going back to The Soup Market at least once or twice when I'm back in town to visit. I already miss it. read more

I really enjoyed my soup. So 5 stars! Ok so it's not quite like the Soup Nazi from Seinfeld...they're actually very friendly over here. I had a bowl of the Chicken Asiago and the Polish Pickle soups so far, and they were fantastic! The only problem I have is deciding which soup to get. They have SO many available to choose from. Each soup comes with a good chunk of bread, which was great because the Polish Pickle was perfect for dipping. I would say the Chicken Asiago was more hearty...very much like a Chicken Noodle soup, but better because of the added cheese. There's more than just soup to choose from here. They also have other items like sandwiches and salads...but I've only come here for the soup. There is a nice area inside for dining in if you can't wait to eat your soup! read more

Just OK. I wanted to dig it more but alas...just OK. Although the soups are fresh and hand crafted, the treatment of chicken soups (insert separated, pre-cooked, rather spongy chicken chunks and dumplings into cup then cover with ladle of chicken broth) was really weak. I love that the ingredients are fresh and real and some of the other recipes are great but chicken soup (and its variations) are standards and need to be done right. Sandwiches (I had the half and half lunch meal) are just fair. Front counter service procedure for ordering and serving could use a rethink too. I love good soups and the idea here is good but I'm only 50% on stopping in again. On the other hand, good fresh soup restaurant alternative deserves support so maybe I'll hope and gently cajole so that they up their game just a touch. Also worth noting that the prices are quite reasonable. Maybe I'll wait for the right menu day and do the three-cup meal deal. read more

Finally dined in at lunch the other day, and glad I did. I love that they have a number of combo options (soup + bread, soup + sandwich, 3 soup sampler). Husband had the grilled cheese + tomato soup combo, which was good. Grilled cheese was a nice classic 3-cheese deal - bread wasn't too soggy or mouth rippingly crusty...tomato bisque was amazing (thick, tomato-y, creamy but not gloppy). I had the 3 soup combo with lobster bisque (very lobstery, creamy but not overly thickened), italian chili (garbanzo beans + italian sausage = yum), and chicken dumpling. One thing that I definitely noticed with the chicken dumpling was that the broth was very nice - not horribly salty, and not oily. The chunks of meat, carrot, and celery were still firm - it was just like grandma's (if grandma could make it without oversalting and actually skimmed the stock a bit more). They have some soups to go in the fridge (stuff that isn't necessarily on the menu that day) - I love love love their african peanut, and was happy to see it available in there. This place is on my way home from work, and I honestly don't know why I haven't stopped here more often! read more

Pretty good, pretty good. I had the chicken dumpling and some ridiculously good oatmeal cranberry coconut cookie. My husband was a bit pissed I ate the soup quick and didn't let him taste it... Oh wouldn't he be mad to find out I had the cookie, he would have loved it and I just didn't want to share!!!! Reason for us to go back for certain. I must say, I don't like this soup (bread is always dry) at the public market but really enjoyed the bayview location. My bread was so soft and chewy. Heck I would go there just for the bread to be honest. Service was great, gal behind the counter was really nice and helpful. Wrapped my soup really good and was worried about me biking it home. I'll have to let her know it all worked out when I go back for that cookie... And some more soup;) read more

The Soup Market - Chicken dumpling with amazingly soft and chewy bread!!!! Yum:) - Sandwiches Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

Pretty basic spot to grab a bowl of soup and sandwich. Comparable in quality to Panera, so nothing mind-blowing. Some of the soups are fatty and salty, but taste decent. If you're looking for some average hot liquid to warm your throat, you can do worse. read more

This place is a good spot to get lunch. I usually go in here and enjoy a bowl of soup. There is a menu which means different soup options. It's nice and clean in the inside who doesn't like a clean place to eat at. read more

I stopped in today randomly for a quick lunch with my daughter and enjoyed the Soup Market. Service at the counter was quick and friendly. The menu was varied with 3 vegan options and a couple of chilled soups, ideal for a day in the 90's! I had the chilled cucumber, yogurt and dill and it was delicious. My daughter had the chicken and dumpling and it was good. A little more seasoning in the stock would make this 5 stars. Definitely a good value for the money! read more

So glad I took a friend's recommendation. Not too often am I in the mood for soup on a 90 degree day, but I was. My soup was Italian sausage, egglplant(?)/vegetable, and Parmesan. Yummy!! I decided to get half a Caesar chicken wrap and was satisfied and full. It could have had a little more dressing and a little less cheese, but I think that a personal preference. I would want to give 4.5 stars. My soup was $4. Although delicious, I would concede with it being more expensive than I ever want to pay for a cup of soup. Service was excellent. read more

Roughly two years later, I have a sore throat and I want soup. My SO suggests we make a stop for lunch and see if our experience is more enjoyable. The food was fine and tasted fresh, but was nothing special. The staff is something else... the lady that helped us was so unwelcoming like we were a bother to come in. How does this establishment stay open and keep people coming?! After paying, I tried to ask the lady prepping our soup/sandwiches to break my bill so I could leave a tip, but she abruptly walked away from me to help the next person. Ok then. Two stars because the food was fine and seemed fresh. Would have been 1 star if the food wasn't up to par. read more

the soup is great, but service is lackluster. Counter service is tortise-slow with one person working the register. Mistakles happen but how the staff reacts is always telling. I picked up a $45 carryout order that was phoned in ahead of time. Unfortunately, i realized a sandwich was missing when I returned to my office. I called and the person who answered acknowledged the missed sandwich, saying it was "left on the counter right next to the grill." After asking for a refund the person unapologetically replied "I dont know how to do that." Customer service at its finest. I have yet to see a credit or get a call back from a manager. If I didnt love the African peanut chicken soup so much I'd probably never go back. Maybe my Reuben will still be waiting for me after I simmer down... read more

My favorite place to get fresh (not from a bag!) soup! I go to this location more than the Milwaukee Public Market one because it's much quieter. They usually have at least one vegetarian/vegan soup - I would check before you go to see what they have (they post it on their website, so it's super simple to check). Make sure you check what kind of broth they use if you are getting a soup marked "vegetable ______" and not "vegetarian/vegan _______" - a lot of times it's chicken or beef broth. I've only ever had one soup there that I didn't care for which was a tomato florentine something or other. Otherwise the soups are tasty and, depending on what size you get, come with crackers or a hunk of fresh bread. read more

The Soup Market specializes in fantastic freshly-made soups. I became a soup convert after discovering a coffee shop near my home that sells the Soup Market's soup. My only prior soup experience was crappy canned soup and other restaurants' poor excuses for soup in a dinner starter course. Today I had Manhattan clam chowder and it was fabulous. Earlier this week I had a vegetarian barley mushroom soup...which is one of my favorites. The African Peanut Chicken soup is wonderful - somewhat spicy with a subtle peanut flavor. The list of soups for the day is listed on their web site along with ingredients for each soup - very handy. Make sure you shell out 50 cents more for a chunk of fresh warm bread - so worth it!! The vanilla root beer is great, too. They also make hot and cold sandwiches and quiche. To top it off, the restaurant's atmosphere is really friendly and in my experience street parking hasn't been a problem. The Soup Market also has a location in Hales Corners, but this one beats it by a mile with the great atmosphere. read more

They serve Sarma, is this place Croat or Serb? The owner runs the Bella Cafe in Brookfield and in the 3rd ward. The Sarma soup was created by his chef, it is very good: rice, beef or pork, peppers, paprika, mmmm read more