We ate here celebrating a birthday. The food (shrimp, lake perch and porterhouse steak) was good but I wouldn't say it was exceptional. I likewise don't believe that the quality of the food was up to the cost of it. Plus my wife was somewhat disappointed with the menu options. And I didn't see a kids meal menu, but I assume that they have one if children are part of your group. Anyway, the service was very good. The ambiance was equally good. We were seated in an area that despite being a little crowded, we were still able to carry on a conversation ( I usually have to adjust my hearing aids to silence background noise but not here). read more

This was my second visit to the restaurant, and unfortunately, both experiences were disappointing. The first time, I ordered an old-fashioned that fell flat and lacked any real depth of flavor. On my second visit a year later, I decided to give it another shot--this time opting for the traditional version instead of the smoked one. It was better, but still only average at best. It was also served warm, and the ice melted quickly, suggesting the glass or drink wasn't properly chilled. The martini was also underwhelming--it tasted mostly like juice, with little to no noticeable alcohol. As for the food, the starters were definitely the highlight. The French onion soup was actually very good. However, the main courses didn't live up to expectations. I ordered the steak medium rare, but it came out closer to medium well--overcooked and under-seasoned. The chicken Vesuvio was also disappointing; the sauce tasted like it came from a jar, and neither it nor the rice stood out in any meaningful way. On a positive note, the ambiance was very nice. The lighting created a pleasant atmosphere, and the staff was friendly and attentive throughout the meal. Overall, while the setting and service were enjoyable, the food and drinks didn't justify a return visit. read more

Theo's Steak & Seafood C/O District /Executive Director 9144 Indianápolis Blvd. Highland, IN 46322 Good afternoon, (A Really Bad Experience) I am writing to you concerning my visit to your establishment on February 7, 2026. I had the worst experience that I have ever had in a restaurant. First, I did not have a problem with the price because it was $60.00 per person and I paid for my daughter, son, and daughter-in-law, as well as myself. They were very unprofessional. One waitress came out and stated that we could order onions and mushrooms on our steak, but that would be an extra charge, if the bride state it was okay. I went to the bride, and they told her that it would be an extra $10.00, I gave her $15.00. So, at that point, they came out and took our orders and among the 4 of us we ordered a steak medium well with just a little charred on it. Well, I had to wait because the waitress came out and stated that they had charred it too much and they had to put me another one in. Now it is half an hour later and everybody in the place is complaining because now they are coming back stating that you can't order the onions or mushrooms that they have already given to the bride. Don't nobody want to go back and say give it back 1 /2 hour later, so we let her keep it. My steak came out burnt. Also, the waiter came around with water and one of the people at my table had gone out to the bar and purchased her a drink and he poured water in her glass that already had her drink that she paid for, and he told her that he would replace it. Then the manager whom I sent a picture of to the store came back and said she would get another drink, well she went back to the bar and purchased another and was waiting for the one that they were supposed to bring to her. So, I asked the manager if they could replace my steak and she threw her hands up in the air and stated that it is what you ordered and walked away. My daughter-in-law was so upset her husband had to make her be quiet because she was so mad at the lady who talked to me like that, and she travel all over the world and I have never seen her get upset like that. Everybody in the room complained about the services, we asked whether we could go out and order it from outside and still pay her and they kept telling us that we couldn't. I was so angry and I did not eat at all, and I only eat once a day and I had the worst service that I have ever had anywhere and we traveled all over the world. First, that Manager owes me an apology and I would like to meet with you concerning this, because it was so unprofessional, and maybe it was because of our race, I do not know, but at this point we all are saying I will never go back to Theo's. I feel that even if it costs extra, because not everybody eats steaks with onions or mushrooms on it, we still paid her $60.00 for their meal, that should have been able to order anything else. One lady just wanted a salad with any meat, just some lettuce, tomatoes, and croutons and they told her that they could not accommodate her with that. My god daughter that got married her son does not eat meat and she was able to just get him some noodles. I feel that even if we paid the $60.00 for the meal that we should still had been able to order something else, and not only that one waitress should not be able to tell you that you can order onions or mushroom on your steak and then the other one come back and say no. We did not care about the extra charge, and I feel we should have been able to order appetizers if we wanted them. A lot of us had not eaten all day, getting off the plane and going to the wedding and straight to your place and this is the service we received. I am not just complaining just about myself, but for my family, your staff need training on what they can or cannot do before entering that room and one person says one thing and the other one is saying something else. I have never been to any place where the manager did not try to rectify the situation or just remove that price off the bill. I sent a you the picture of the manager that was in charge I guess, but she was the one that threw her hands up in the air and said that is what you ordered. I order my steak chard everywhere and it has never been burnt, and they want me to except it, and I did not eat one thing on the plate. I just paid for something that I could not eat. Your place was very beautiful and that was my first time there, but that was a horrible experience, but when you went out of the room the bartenders and all the other people were so nice. I do not feel that the people that were working back there in the room can handle 50 people and one time ordering, but they should have been a little more accommodating. I know she had to pay $3,000.00 for just the people and a tip, but I don't feel that she got what she paid for. I tried to send this letter to the store,so that someone would contact me and they never did till this day. read more

EXCELLENT!!! Wow!!! The food was so fantastic! Amy, our incredible server was the best! She knows how to take care of customers! Give her a raise! We had the yummy table bread which was so soft, definitely fresh baked. We had lemon soup and French onion soup. We also had Caesar salad. Great starters. I had the special, stuffed chicken breast with spinach and feta. Yummy! My mother in law had blackened shrimp and broccoli I got to sample and it was yummy! Theo's is a top notch, local steak house and I really enjoyed it! Beautiful holiday decor too! Loved it! Looking forward to returning soon! read more

See all

I found the food mediocre at best. I literally regretted not going to a different restaurant after I started to eat. The prices seem high for the quality. I had salmon dinner with wine. The calamari appetizer seemed slightly undercooked with a little slime(slipperier than normal texture) to it. I like to consider myself a self-certified foodie. I will pay a lot for good food. This missed the mark. The dress code seemed extremely relaxed. The server did his best to keep up with the rush. I will not be back. read more

Theo's Steaks & Seafood - Salmon - Seafood Near Me - Highland, Indiana

See all

This place completely hit the mark for us this past weekend. We celebrated our anniversary (no free desert like every other place but that's ok). The foot was outstanding. We started off with the lemon rice and the chicken vegetable soups and side salads. I got Greek dressing she got ranch. These were complimentary with our meal and very tasty. We got the special which was 6 oz filet and three coconut shrimp with a side. Cooked to perfection and the shrimp were huge! We also order the rack of lamb with Vesuvius potatoes and it was stellar - a must order! We will definitely come back - it's worth every penny. read more

See all

Visited for Father's Day after a friend recommended it as she has raved about Theo for at least a year. The food was definitely mediocre at best and very very expensive for what the meal was itself. I was so disappointed after hearing my friend rave about it but wouldn't go back again. The calamari was rubbery, my house salad was good, lemon rice soup was tasty but the lobster bisque for an extra $17 per bowl was salty and gritty. I asked for my strip steak medium rare. It definitely came in medium to medium well. my brother's prime rib was gigantic, but the fattiest piece of prime rib I've ever seen. He could barely find any meat to eat and my dad prime rib was the butt end of meat because he does like it a little bit more well cooked and in that case you get what you get when you order prime rib well done-- that's on my dad. Our two desserts were of epic size but tasty. Service was ok. Wine by the glass was reasonable. Room was very dark and odd. Needed an overhaul. Not welcoming and seemed to be attached to a banquet hall-- so glad we didn't get seated there. So very very disappointed for a meal with tax and automatic tip for 3 people at $373. Never again. read more

We walked in 5:45pm on a Saturday evening w/no reservations. Restaurant was very full, but they seated us immediately (we will make reservations next time!) Our server, Amy, took care of us tonight and everything was wonderful, steaks perfect again of course! ... such a busy evening there yet the service was still impeccable. We both had filet mignon (he had it Theo's special filet topped with crabmeat, and our chefs bearnaise sauce). I had the chicken noodle soup, he had lemon rice. I had the garlic dressing on my salad and Theo's garlic salad dressing is by far my fav!!! Baked potatoes cooked perfectly too! The lighting was dim and perfect with a small lamp on ea table, great music in the background. We love Theo's! read more

Theo's Steaks & Seafood - Celebrating Jeff Minard's birthday a lil early! - Seafood Near Me - Highland, Indiana

All of the above were excellent, good, excellent. I can't wait tobgi back I live by O'Hare in Chicago but I'm worth the ride. read more

Our waitress was fantastic. And it's a lovely ambience. But $125 for 2 crab legs?!? I would also NOT recommend the perch. Overcooked and a mouth full of bones. Sadly sent it back. They did an auto gratuity which I found interesting for a party of 2. Overall this restaurant missed the mark. What a shame. read more

Theo's Steaks & Seafood - Receipt - Seafood Near Me - Highland, Indiana

April 16, 2026 I had a bad experience with Theo's steak and seafood. I ordered salmon and requested that it would be medium well done. The salmon came out and it was the tail of the salmon looking very dry, I spoke with Jack the manager he stated that I would have to pay for it anyway with his hands on his hip bad customer service . I will never recommend to anyone to go to Theo's steakhouse in Highland Indiana read more

Thank you so much for the Amazing Turkey Dinners, my husband, son and I had. Our server, Alberto couldn't have showed more professionalism if he tried. He was so kind, and he brought a smile to all of us. Happy Thanksgiving to everyone. We will be back Christmas Eve. Thank you again ~ Larry, Sandra, Dean Mysliwiec read more

I frequent Highland, Indiana often as a Chicagoan to get gas, shop and eat. I've passed by this place many times wondering how the place was. My friend and I wanted to get together and looked into a place to dine and I thought "why not finally try this place" and so on 7/21/23, we went. We walk in and the ambiance was so perfect - dimly lit, nice music softly playing in the background. Staff immediately greeted us and brought us to our table. We had a very friendly yet professional waitress who made our experience even nicer. She was well versed in their menu and gave good recommendations. I am a picky eater and I must say, everything I had from here was DELICIOUS!!! I was so impressed with this place. I noticed that there was a private room beautifully decorated. My friend saw that it was for a wedding event so this is a great offering if you are looking to have an event at a nice place with good food. I can't wait to visit this place again. There is nothing like a good fine dining place where you are treated WELL. Excellent experience Theo's, A+++! read more

See all

Beware of their gift card scam everyone's talking about on f/b. The free bonus gift cards are treated as coupons and cannot be used on holiday dinners. They misrepresented the bonus card. read more

These 4 stars are specifically for the staff. They were amazing!! From being greeted by the host all the way to the ones that came to get our plates and box up our leftovers for us. We were there celebrating a birthday. So it was about 10-12 of us, 5 being kids. Our waitress was friendly and patient with them as she took their drink and food options. The host joked with them at the door. He came to the table and had playful bets with them and gave them suckers on the way out. Food was BLAND!!! Nothing was nasty.. just could've been better. I thought it was just me being a "gotta have seasoning on my food type person" but when I looked up everyone is waiting for others to finish with the salt and pepper so they can have a turn. Kids didn't seem to have a problem with their chicken tenders and fries though. Oh, my lobster bisque was pretty good! Overall, it's a nice and comfortable dining experience. Cool just to check it off your list for a date night maybe. I feel safe saying check them out. Just don't expect to be wowed. I almost forgot... the guy walking around to refill water was on point!! My glass never got halfway empty until they started cleaning the table off. He was like a ninja popping up out of nowhere then boom he gone lol. Good job staff!!! read more

See all

Had my mother-in-law's funeral luncheon on Friday. Food and service was excellent. The place is always especially clean. Been going here forever. It's always been great. read more

Theo's is one of our favorite places to go. Have been there numerous times and have never had a bad meal. From steak, shrimp, perch always tasty. The saganaki is awesome! The portions are generous and with soup, salad and meal, never leave hungry. We have taken many of our business associates here and they also rave about the food and service. From the owner, managers and staff everyone is always pleasant and courteous. Theo's is definitely the best restaurant in the area. read more

I had lunch with a client at Theo's this past week and it was great! The inside has been renovated and looks nice and it was all decorated for Christmas. Our service was very attentive and the food was good as well! I had the lobster roll, which was good! As usual around this area it comes with soup or salad. The Caesar was good! A great place to take a client or have a nice meal with friends! read more

If you don't know now you know!!! We come here for the 30oz bone-in Ribeye steak. A cut above the rest! There's a theory that steak, when cooked on the bone, tastes better than its boneless counterpart. Theo's bone in ribeye has such lavish flavors because the rich flavours of the marrow seep their way into the meat during the cooking process, thus enhancing the flavour and juiciness of the steak. If you want a true full service culinary experience then Theo's is the place for you. read more

Theo's Steaks & Seafood - Bone-In Ribeye - Seafood Near Me - Highland, Indiana

See all

Nice place on old 41, good martinis, lobster and soups. Nice staff severing good food. Driving on 41 there are many old school restaurants to visit. I think this is a must. read more

I've been supporting Theo's Dining Group locations for several years now and have always been pleased with the quality of food and service. On Saturday, 5/10, I made reservations for Theo's to take my girlfriend out for dinner. We were both pleased with the quality of service and food, however, our overall experience started to decline when brought the bill... Back in November, Theo's promoted a Gift Card special on Facebook where I would get two $25 Bonus GIFT CARDS if I purchased a $100 Gift Card. I was finishing up my holiday shopping, so I thought this was a great idea. I didn't only see this as a great gift, but also a way to continue supporting local business. I provided the server one of our bonus GIFT CARDS as well as my credit card to cover the difference. She returned with a sad look on her face letting us know that the gift card cannot be used. I asked why and she informed me that management told her that this was not a GIFT CARD and that they would not accept this special "Discount" over Mother's Day weekend. She showed me the back of the GIFT CARD where it stated that this could not be redeemed on Holidays. I then explained that Saturday was not a Holiday and that Mother's Day was on Sunday. She then explained that she was only telling us what the manager told her. I then asked if I could speak with the manager and she said she would try to bring her over. The manager (Chris) arrived to our table and had an irritated look on her face from start to finish. I asked her for a better explanation as to why this could not be used and she jumped right into "THIS IS NOT A GIFT CARD AND WE WILL NOT BE PROVIDING DISCOUNTS ON A HOLIDAY" I showed her the November Facebook advertisement calling this a "Gift Card", showed her that the card I was given in November says "Gift Card" on it , and that Saturday was not a Holiday. She continued to argue that this is not a gift card and she will not be accepting it. At this point, it wasn't worth my time. The manager found this as a benefit to get her way and that a $25 Gift Card was not worth retaining a customer. That's really sad, especially with how many dining options there are in NW today. And most importantly, dining options that don't make you feel like you've been scammed. read more

OMG this place is amazing. The food and service are just spectacular. We celebrated my 50th birthday here and there were a lot of us the table. Our bill was over $1000. We had lots of drinks all the appetizers and huge portions of food mostly steaks. We even had a dessert at the end, which we really didn't need, but we wanted to try them all. The service was fantastic. It was so good. We made friends with our server and even shared cookies from our birthday celebration. We definitely had a reservation at a place in the back of the restaurant. It was kind of loud but it was to be expected because there's so much space in open areas, but honestly, you can still have a conversation with people nearby and you can still hear fine. I also think they had some private party rooms but we didn't get one of those. The menu is pretty extravagant and you can get just a bunch of appetizers or I can get some main courses as well but all of the food was just excellent. No one was disappointed. read more

Theo's Steaks & Seafood - Filet - it had the signature sauce on it. Amazing!!! - Seafood Near Me - Highland, Indiana

See all

We came here last week with a couple of other couples and had such a great night. We ordered the tomahawk steak, crab legs, lamb, and lobster. Everything was delicious and beautifully presented. The tomahawk was carved tableside, which was such a cool touch, and all of the seafood and meat tasted incredibly fresh. The service was next level. Our waitress Ashley was outstanding. She was professional, attentive, and somehow knew what we needed before we even had to ask. Drinks stayed full, plates were cleared right on time, and she made the whole evening flow perfectly. We will definitely be back. Huge thanks to Ashley and the rest of the staff for an amazing experience. read more

EXCELLENT FOOD! EXCELLENTLY STAFFED with EXCELLENT PEOPLE. Theo's truly has the BEST SERVICE of any restaurant.. Friendly, attentive and polite! Our steaks were cooked to our liking (perfection): my parm crusted ribeye was divine! My family enjoyed their porterhouse and Gorgonzola crusted ribeye. Lemon rice soup not too lemony and the Caesar salad had those large shavings of parm cheese (love!) Bartender does drinks well !! Shrimp Dejongh appetizer was very tasty! But we saw quite a few of the seafood towers -- gotta try next time for sure. The holiday decorations were beautiful (looked professionally done) and the soft music playing in background was soft rock from 80-90s which was right up my alley. It was a Friday night so apparently it was "date night" / birthday for several of the other diners there -- truly good choice. We went as a family with grown daughter. Everything from calling in to make our reservation to walking out with our leftovers (great portions!) was OUTSTANDING and a pleasant experience. I was so impressed and genuinely enjoyed Theo's. Also, pricing was better than my husband expected. Go! See for yourself. read more

Theo's Steaks & Seafood - Seafood Near Me - Highland, Indiana

We just celebrated my brother's 56th birthday here at Theo's Steaks and Seafood on Indianapolis Blvd. It was an amazing experience on all levels!! Service was impeccable, Ashley was fantastic asked her to be your server! The GM Jack was awesome..he stopped by to say hello and was just lovely. Ambiance is warm friendly and welcoming. You feel right at home. I wish I can give this place more than 10 stars!!! Honestly THE BEST STEAKHOUSE and SEAFOOD place in the south suburbs!!!! We will be back! read more

See all

This was my first time here and I will go again. For it to be a Fri night it was not as crowded as I would have thought. This place is a hidden steak house. Because compared to some places downtown this food tasted better. I would consider this place to be intimate due to the lighting. Our server was attentive. Her name was Andrea, if I'm not mistaken. The ribeye was cooked to perfection and cooked with good flavor. Thankfully, at this restaurant you actually get sides with your meal and do not have to purchase a la carte, pleasant surprise. I had lemon rice soup and my friend had the lobster bisque. No complaints. The only complaint I have from the night were the drinks. You could barely taste any alcohol, a bit sweet and watered down. I ordered a side car and my friend had a long island. read more

See all

I came here 1x before years ago before the rebrand and I had a way better experience this time. I started off with the lemon drop martini and it kinda tasted like sweet lemon medicine but I drank the whole thing so it wasn't too bad. The lemon rice soup was good! The best thing was the steak, that was actually cooked very nicely and was juicy and tender. The double baked potato was honestly bad, it had no seasoning and a weird taste. Our waitress was really nice and accommodating! The interior does look a lot better, they did a good job on the remodel. read more

See all

Awesome place to enjoy for date night and the service was great. I will definitely be back for the tasty desserts.

I was celebrating my husband's birthday today at Theo's, a popular steakhouse restaurant known for its cozy ambiance. Our bill totaled $84.00 and some change, which I paid using a $100.00 gift card I had purchased earlier. I handed the gift card to our waitress, expecting the balance to be $16.00. However, she returned with a receipt indicating a remaining balance of $34.00, which I knew was incorrect. I told her so, and she responded, "Let me go check," then disappeared for a few minutes. When she returned, she reiterated the same incorrect amount. To clarify, I showed her the receipt for my gift card confirming it had a remaining balance of $100.00 initially, but it should have been reduced appropriately. She then said, "Let me check again," but she did not return my gift card--because it still had $50.00 left on it. A few moments later, she came back with an elaborate story claiming that the restaurant's gift card machine erroneously deducted $50.00 at once, which I found extremely suspicious. I was left staring at her in disbelief, thinking she might be confused or misleading us. My husband and I were both hurt by what seemed to be a lack of integrity and honesty from the staff, which really dampened our special day. Yours, Gloriatte Evans-Dumas read more

We are fine diners and our first visit to Theo's was fantastic. Moved to Munster six months ago from Chicago and believe this fine dining establishment competes well to some of best steak houses in Chicago area. Great service, menu and cocktails. Highly recommend. We'll be back soon. Cheers to the kitchen and staff! read more

I would have given this restaurant a five star had it not been for the rip off. My friends and I split the bill three ways, because it was 3 of us. The total bill was approximately $358 (which included gratuity and tax), I gave the waitress Jennifer $240 in cash. So why was $133 charged on my card? She and the older lady with the short blond hair want to convince me that that was the correct amount charged to my card. The math is NOT mathing. It appears that Jennifer not only received $51 in gratuity, but approximately an additional $13. The service was good, but not that good! I don't mind tipping, but I don't like to be ripped off. Jennifer kept fast talking about how she took her gratuity out and then charged my card. Either way, no more than $120 should have been charged to my card and of course I couldn't see the original bill. read more

I came here with my family after church. It was their suggestion. I really wish they would have listened to mine. I ordered a saganaki, a porterhouse steak, a salad and a loaded baked potato. The saganaki was the star of the show. Very tasty and everybody loves it lit up and yelling OPA! The porterhouse steak, of which was cooked med well, was tougher than the '85 Bears defense! I'm glad I lift weights! The salad and the potato looked and tasted like it was borrowed from Texas Roadhouse. And for the life of me, I can't understand why all of this bad food came to over $100 for one person! On the other hand, nice parking lot, accommodating for large groups, families and banquets. They get quite the business. Nice bar. Decent service. Great dinner rolls. I won't be back. I'm sure my family will be. read more

See all

I heard some good reviews about Theos and decided to try them myself. Over the last year or so we did stop by three times, each time saying the same thing. Maybe next time it will be better. Unfortunately after each visit I was less and less impressed. The last time we only stopped in for drinks. The bar prices are steep and drinks are nothing to brag about. What I didn't like is that the bar tender came across super standoffish and at one point rude. Overall the food is just ok. I tried everything from appetizers to steaks and fish. At the end of the day I came to a conclusion that Theos is just a FANCY DINER. I can't think of one dish that would bring me back. read more

Our favorite place for special occasions and 'fancy' date nights! Love the lemon chicken soup

I had not been here in over 20 years. I decided to place an order for pickup and I'm so glad I did. Everything was delicious. The chicken was moist and full of flavor. The calamari and tomato sauce was delicious. The bread was warm and soft. The salad was crisp and garlic dressing was great! The lemon rice soup did not disappoint. I'll be coming back real soon to try more food. read more

See all

Food is a bit pricey! My wife and I had porterhouse steak $56 and 2 lb Alaskan king crab legs $185, 2 rounds of drinks (each), oysters, crab cakes and gratuity ($65). Mainly my bill was $454. The food was remarkably good, the service was outstanding and the ambience was very welcoming and intimate. If you have the money to spend, I recommend if not SAVE SAVE SAVE because it's worth the night out. I still have 90% of the steak in the fridge for later... lol! The waitress Kelly was excellent and I'm sure the other waitresses and waiters are great, but I'm coming back strictly for her... Thanks again for our date night first time experience and I will be back for the reoccurring excellent experience again. Now it's time to tell everyone about!!!! read more

We had a great experience the other day at Theo's. The service was impeccable by Becky aka Mariam. She not gave us the time needed to enjoy our meal, she was also very entertaining. It was like having dinner and a show for one price. The food has always been spot on regardless of what you order. I highly recommend this place when you have the opportunity. Ted & Chris are always a pleasure to see when they're there. read more

Went for the first time and maybe I shouldn't have chosen a holiday. Due to the holiday they opened up their party room which was nice but it was so brightly lit it took away from the ambience you get in the front of the restaurant. The service we had was spot on. Melissa was there every time we needed anything and the other staff were quick to whisk away all unwanted items. The raw oyster s were good but small and not shucked well. The Rockefeller were very tasty but again small in size. The soup and salad were good and the filet was cooked perfectly. Overall the food was fine. We didn't try the desserts. The smoky old fashioned was good except the smoke machine didn't work at the table so the show was cancelled. With other steak places in the area I am not sure we will be back. read more

Fathers Day weekend is special for us and Theo's is usually the place to go. But I was disappointed; The bread was not good, no mushrooms or onions for the steak and what Father doesn't want mushrooms or onions on a 65$ steak. Going down read more

Wonderful service, food and drinks. Modern remodeling job enhanced the experience. Daily specials only added to the confusion about what to order in a good way. read more