You can not get anymore authentic than this restaurant. They use all the tricks in the book and this is our go to and we come from an hour away. The server was very attentive to our needs, I never had to ask for a refill of our drinks( which is very important to me) I'll be the first to admit not the most Italian looking joint but the service and food is top notch. Flavors were so authentic flavorful and filling. We enjoyed a Super mozzarella Pizza with extra bacon, Baked Ziti, and Breaded Chicken penne in a wine marinera sauce. we walked out of the place overstuffed. 4 adults for $80.00. left a big tip since the server and Manager checked on my party multiple times. Will visit again. Keep it up read more

Walking in to Tomasino's it's small but cozy. We sat ourselves and our waitress was very friendly and super attentive. For appetizers we ordered the Cheesy Garlic Knots and Mozzarella Sticks. Both items were delicious and their marinara sauce compliments the cheese so well. For entrees we had a Pizza half cheese and half pepperoni as well as a Calzone Special. The pizza was good and hot with a nice crisp to it. The calzone was filled with tons of flavorful toppings. Overall food and service were great and we will definitely be back, highly recommend. read more

See all

New favorite pizza unlocked. The Hothead Spicy Calabria Pie really did ignite my taste buds! The spicy Calabrian sauce, the delicious dollops of ricotta, the little popcorn chicken chunks in every bite! Yuuum. read more

See all

As always Tomasino's is the pizza place to live and to never disappoint. With its always fresh food and great service (be prepared to wait a bit as everything is made fresh to order). To it's small Italian seating to make you feel like la familia. This time around we got some new stuff which is what this review is really for. First off we got the Garlicky cheese knots which you get for free for signing up as a rewards member. And they did not disappoint from the garlic flavor to the covering of melted mozzarella on top. Then came the pie which was the new Hothead Spicy Calabria Pie which contained Calabrian chili paste base, mozzarella, spots of ricotta and bites of crispy breaded chicken. And man was my mouth on fire in a good way with flavor and chili. Normally we get the butcher but this gave that a run for it's money. Definitely check it out and Tomasino's. read more

See all

Server was Christiana. She was great. Got 2 Calzones. Amazing. The chef checked table. Can't wait to go back. Yum and yum. . read more

See all

Came here because of good reviews on yelp and was very disappointed with what I got. Knot your average bruschetta was decent, I love bruschetta and the garlic knots were good. The chicken parm sub was so sad, I had to open the bread and search to make sure there was chicken in there my piece was so small and it was so soggy it was difficult to eat, also most of my sandwich was just bread anyway. I ordered and waited a half hour for pickup as stated on the website and it was about dinner time so it wasn't like I was late picking it up for it to get so soggy. The only reason it's getting 3 stars is because of garlic knots being okay and the staff were polite. It was also very clean and quiet in there. read more

While there's literally dozens of places to get pizza within a few miles of Mills50, Tomasino's is my favorite go-to spot. I just Love them. Sure, they can be a little bit more but you also get a little bit more. The quality tastes better. I'm also a big fan of their salads, gotta keep it healthy, and am usually very happy with their knots, especially when paired up with meatballs and extra sauce and, and :) read more

Tomasino's Pizza - Da Mechanic - Italian Near Me - Orlando, Florida

This is the place to go if you have a family to feed. $30 for the fattest pizza ive evere seen. We ordered the mechanic which is basically their version of a supreme pizza. Really packed a punch with their flavor. The service was nice and easy going and they wore themed outfits. Well themed with the old time style, new York pizza experience. Fantastic. read more

Tomasino's Pizza - The mechanic - Italian Near Me - Orlando, Florida

Pizza is Amazing hands down! Their Cheesy Garlic Knots OMG! The Pizza shop has a cozy vibe. read more

One of the best pizzas in Central Florida! Can't wait to go back!! Hopefully, they consider opening a location near Disney World!

I ordered pepperoni pizza. it said New York style but I am from New York State and have not found a pizza that's like NYS. Florida just doesn't know how to make them. Well today I did and it was great. Highly recommended food and service were excellent read more

Good but way too expensive for a pizza $67 for a large pizza and a small pizza, cheese and pepperoni mushrooms

One of the best pizza spot in Orlando!!!! It's always my go to place for pizza whenever I'm in town. They always deliver a quality product 10/10. read more

All I can say is we go once a week? Pizza is very good. Hot fresh and service is phenomenal. Enjoy this spot really a lot.

We are so excited to have a location in our bithlo area! Not only do they have the best pizza, garlic knots, and Greek salad but the customer service is top notch. Staff is always so kind and friendly and the manager Jake is a great guy who is passionate, will go above and beyond, and truely cares about the customer. We will continue to frequent this location! read more

Stopped in to grab a slice of pizza. We were in the mood for the bianca pizza, but they were out of slices. No worries there were 4 of us so we ordered a large pizza figuring we would bring home the extras. That was our first mistake since it was so good we kept eating and had no left overs and just full and happy bellies!! They have a few booths inside and the staff is very attentive for a busy as they get with those inside, pick-ups, and food delivery services. Nothing fancy to see, but clean and comfortable for some great pizza. They have lots of different specialty pizzas to try as well and will try to force myself to try something else on my next visit. read more

Loved the mama moozarell pizza and I'm a New Yorker. It had a sweetness that wasn't expected but amazing. read more

Tomasino's Pizza - Mamas Moo-Za-Rellll Pie - Italian Near Me - Orlando, Florida

See all

They had a great special for new rewards members-- free 14" pizza and Cheese knots. They were great, ordered on phone, ready on time Very nice young man from Columbia took the order. I highly recommend Tomasimo's. Join their club online . read more

We just moved to the area so currently trying to find everything locally that would be our go to restaurant wise. We got a Greek salad and Margherita pizza. The service was great even with them being clearly slammed. The salad was on point, one of the better that I have had mixing the Italian style into the Greek. The pizza lacked a lot of flavor and we even got it with the balsamic glaze which was odd. Visually it looked great, it just didn't have anything to it that stood out. I will say the side of marinara was some of the best I have ever had. So not great, but not so bad I wouldn't give them another try with a different pizza off the menu. read more

We had slices of the cheese pizza, Bianca pizza and the Pepperoni. All were scrumptious but our favorite of the 3 was the Bianca. Then we had an order of Pasty's Fries - pesto with Parmesan & Pecorino cheese that my granddaughters even though they were full could not stop eating. If you try anything besides the Pizza treat yourself & try the fries. WE WILL BE BACK. read more

Five stars for consistent flavor and my favorite pizza joint in orlando! The inside is very small so if they are busy you will wait awhile but I've only had one time where service was horrendous but I always give another shot and hasn't happened again. My go to is the white pizza aka Bianca and add bacon. It's delicious every time. Just the right amount of garlic, cheese, and other spices. read more

Tomasino's Pizza - Bianca Pizza aka white pizza - Italian Near Me - Orlando, Florida

A bit of a whole-in-the-wall, was looking for good pizza in the area and this came up. Ordered takeout online, the menu is fun & attention grabbing.There's a handful of tables inside to dine-in. Delicious pizza and the garlicky cheesy knots were amazing! read more

Tomasino's Pizza - Pizza - Italian Near Me - Orlando, Florida

People frequently ask me for my favorite white pizza spot in Orlando. Tomasinos is ALWAYS towards the top of that list. I ordered the ricotta me crazy.. Yoooo honest, look at those freaking huge balls of ricotta!! If you're a ricotta fan, this is the pizza for you. I did add peperoncino to the lest and pineapple to the right. Yes, pineapple goes on pizza. So, about the pizza... It tastes better than you'd except. Even if you expect a great tasting pizza, this would exceed it. Not too much sauce and done to a perfect temp. If I had one knock on it, it would have to be the balls of ricotta fall off if you don't pick up your slice carefully. This isn't the first time, and it won't be the last I've ordered this pizza. read more

Tomasino's Pizza - Ricotta me crazy - Italian Near Me - Orlando, Florida

Great pizza. Sauce A+, crust A, cheese A++ and I'm a harsh critic from NY lol. Very good for me

Tomasino's received their 5 stars before I even walked into the restaurant. The excellent service began via direct message on Instagram. I wrote inquiring about the existence of a lunch menu. Not only did whoever is in charge of their social media respond in a short amount of time, they went out of their way to photograph a lunch menu to send me since it was not readily available online. I immediately headed their way because of this prompt service. Then I arrived to the quaint pizzeria and was pleasantly impressed with the food too. I ordered the pasta lunch special (penne and Alfredo). I added the side of meatballs. The pasta is accompanied by a generous sized salad and THE BEST GARLIC KNOTS I've had in Orlando. The restaurant has about 8 booths, limiting the number of guests that may dine in. There are a few outdoor tables. But the bulk of the patrons received their orders to go. My server (Gia I believe) was kind and took good care of all the seated tables. I'll definitely be back. read more

Tomasino's Pizza - Italian Near Me - Orlando, Florida

See all

Anytime I see fried mozzarella on the menu, I think it's a must to order! So obviously I ordered the fried mozzarella and they come out looking like empanadas. But don't get confused they taste AMAZING! The cheese is super thick and melted to perfection. Also tried the chicken Parmigiana and that wasn't too bad either. The chicken did seem a little bland but the marinara sauce helped it out. It's a pretty large sub that can be easily shared between two people. P.S If you like playing with your food, then I highly recommend trying to do a cheese pull to see how far it goes. read more

Tomasino's Pizza - Fried Mozzarella - Italian Near Me - Orlando, Florida

See all

As a New York pizza lover born and raised, this place is pretty dang good. Pizza is awesome and definitely knocks a lot of other pizza places out of competition. If you're looking for NY style pizza done well, check this place out. The walls inside tell you such a story, I will definitely be coming back soon! read more

I was craving their pizza so much I forgot to take a pic. Enjoyed 2 slices of pepperoni. Great for delivery or pickup. They also have a few booths inside for some local intimate dining. read more

Tomasino's Pizza - Whoops. Are all my pizza before I took my pic! Yummy! - Italian Near Me - Orlando, Florida

Excellent pizza. Love the crust. Margherita pizza was very good. Friendly front counter personnel. Pizza was ready in 25 minutes. read more

The pizza (1/2 mushroom and 1/2 pepperoni) was delicious and was served hot out of oven... the only way my wife and I like it. The service was wonderful...good follow by our waitress to ask if everything was okay. The draft beer was cold. What more could one ask? read more

This establishment plays on a gangster vibe and has the servers wearing fedoras and cheesy (no pun intended) T-shirts with a tie printed on it. Maybe the fedora topped ensemble wouldn't be so bad if the servers wore dress shirts with suspenders and maybe a tie while sporting the hat. But it definitely is a definitive look, I will give it that. Coming from New Jersey, I like to think I know good pizza. So I swung by to try a slice. My opinion? This pizza is ok. It could use a bit more seasoning and maybe was a tad overcooked (I like a "well done" pizza, but I hadn't ordered it well done and this was beyond "well done," but still ok (I guess it is a nice way of saying mediocre). They did have a few options with various toppings, but I went for a plain slice. The price was ok for a slice ($2.66 out the door), but looking at their "specials," they seemed a bit high. One special was two 18" pizzas with one topping each for $37.99. The price for an 18" cheese pizza is $17.99. The "special" isn't such a special and the 18" pizza is a bit on the high side (again, only my opinion). Finally, service, while not rude, was not engaging. After placing my order, I kind of stood there for quite a bit until finally my slice was brought out. A final plus for here. The red and white checked wax paper between the pizza and paper plate was a nice touch. read more

Tomasino's Pizza - Italian Near Me - Orlando, Florida

I guess it was our mistake to order pasta at a pizza place. I will say that the chicken in my wife's chicken Parmesan was crispy but that is the last good thing I can say. My penne Alfredo was flavorless and from a jar. Also the garlic knots were inedible. It could have been worse. The family that came in after us the woman got stuck in the bathroom because they were out of toilet paper then they tried to order slices and were told that they were out, then they tried to order Pepsi and they were out of that too!! read more

Just tried to order 25 minutes before closing and was told the kitchen was closed. I have ordered 10 minutes before closing before and never have been told this. Sounds like someone must didn't want to work. This is sad bc it is the best pizza around. read more

Ordered a 14" pizza with pepperoni, green peppers, and onion. Pizza toppings were sparse and the pizza was not 100% done. Payed 32.95 for one pizza... definitely not worth the money. I also purchased and Italian sub. Bread was awful, it was no more than a ham and cheese sandwich. The "special sauce" was a vinegar based hot wing sauce. Not good at all. French fries were awful. Total tab for an Italian sub, order of French fries and a pizza was $55. Will not eat there again. read more

Great french fries Wish that the menu reflected the lunch prices

The first time I tried Tomasino's Pizza was back in 2011. The Chicken Tomasino... Man, oh man. That creamy Tomasino's sauce is EVERYTHING. I swear they need to bottle it, it's that good. I have gotten that dish multiple times, and I absolutely love it. The garlic knots are really good also as is the Greek salad. I've tried their pies, and they're decent. The pizza is pretty good, but in my humble opinion... the Chicken Tomasino is where it's at. If you try this place for any reason at all, you have to get at least one order of that pasta dish. You won't regret it. read more

My faith in good old fashion Italian has been restored! I was craving a Calzone, but after several terrible versions in Utah I was wondering if restaurants forgot what a true Italian Calzone was. Coming back to Florida, I saw this restaurant saying they are a New York style pizza place. Once I walked in, I knew I had arrived to the real deal, you could smell they garlic and oregano in the air. The service was excellent, se hablo Español, and the food was amazing! read more

Worked here for 2 days and was not put on the schedule again and then came back as a customer only to be kicked out of my table, with the manager Caleb saying there was a line of people waiting when in reality, I walked out the door and didn't see a line whatsoever! Never coming back read more

Fantastic pizza joint. Maybe it was because i haven't had pizza for few months but man o man, that was an amazing bite of food. Located somewhere in Orlando, it's in a plaza somewhere, adjacent to a Chik-fil-a? We were supposed to go to Chik for chicken sandwich but i wanted local Orlando grub. Thank you Yelpers! The pizza was fantastic, their original Bianca pizza with eggplant was so damn good!! My friends and I were fighting over the last slice and i lost it (sad face). We also got tiramisu to go. It was also really good, the layers were (wait for it) MOIST! Yes yes, we all hate that word but it's perfect for Tiramisu. The layers were soaked with espresso and mascarpone. By far, my favorite cheat meal. I'll surely be back for more read more

Tomasino's Pizza - Half Don Tomasino/half Chicken Mediterranean: Yumm! Don Tomasino was crowd pleaser - Italian Near Me - Orlando, Florida

Great restaurant great pizza! We ordered a 14 inch white and an 18 inch mechanic. They brought out my 18 inch mechanic and said that there was a bubble in the pizza dough that it burst so it left a part of the pizza without dough underneath, they said they had just brought me this, so I'd have something to munch on until they made me a new one without me even asking. both pizzas tasted great outstanding service I recommend this place to anyone. read more