(kicking off.... NATCHELORETTE with some delicious grub!!! love ya~~~ cheers to finding your final rose heheh) Shout-out to Ivan!! He was so sweet and patient with answering all questions about pizza ingredients and popularity DELICIOUS!! huge slices like Costco and quality you can taste-- my party of 12 all really enjoyed it!! the Hawaiian pizza -- very among our group and so many customers were ordering it in store too! Chicken Parmesan -- my personal favorite, SO good! Margherita -- love the mozz cheese and basil combo! also popular among our group Cheese (might as well mention haha) -- not bad! And there was leftovers of it the next day haha Such a great neighborhood staple, it was so cozy and homey while dining in...hoping to visit again in the future! read more

See all

The pizza here is thick, filling, and really flavorful. It's very much a neighborhood spot and has been a local staple forever. I've never tried the sandwiches or pasta, but the pizza slices never miss. I'm especially into the penne a la vodka slice. They rotate slices daily, but that one is usually there along with buffalo chicken and their signature pepperoni. read more

Tony's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Buffalo Chicken Pizza & Penne Vodka Slice - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

If you're thinking of doing delivery here, do not. After 2.5 hours I still don't know where my food is. The manager was unhelpful, claiming, "it's not my fault." Do your self a favor and order somewhere else. read more

The cheese slice had a thin, yummy crust with tasty dough and good cheese. I just wish it had a bit more sauce, though the oregano flavor came through nicely. The restaurant was clean, and the staff were friendly. I deducted one star for no soap in the bathroom, but the food was excellent. Left a tip for the guys. read more

The pizza here is always great to me. They also have speciality pizzas that they rotate. They speciality pizzas are pretty good. For ex: there are days they serve a cheeseburger pizza. The ambiance and service reflects a regular Italian pizzeria. The employees are lovely as well. Never had a bad experience here and I go a lot. read more

The Spicy Margherita slice might be up there as one of the greatest slices of pie in Brooklyn. Service was super nice, place was poppin at 10PM on a Thursday. I will be back again and again. read more

Amazing pizza! I tried the MVP, buffalo chicken and meat lovers. All were 10/10. I also bought their chocolate truffles and they were good. I'll be back!! read more

Tony's Pizzeria & Restaurant - MVP and buffalo chicken - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

incredible food especially the immaculate buffalo slice and zeppelis sososo goodie nice to dine in too cute atmosphere read more

Tony's Pizzeria & Restaurant - vodka and barbecue chi - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The food is good I enjoy the buffalo chicken slice and I enjoyed the white slice the service is great as always read more

Tony's Pizzeria & Restaurant - BBQ and Buffalo Chicken pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Used to come as a family to Tony's pizzeria as a child when we lived in this area . Came by recently to have pizza, Food tasted great , cooked well . Clean atmosphere indoor and also outdoor dining . Quick service of food . Variety of pizza , ice cream , soda , cakes and cookies and other foods variety read more

See all

So I was on Knickerbocker Avenue this Easter Sunday 4/9/23 around 6:pm and I just wasn't feeling all that Spanish food today I was actually craving Italian and believe it or not there's an Italian cook in this kitchen !!! This is a real deal Still Italian owned & operated Pizzeria and restaurant..... I was craving penny à la vodka and the slice, which both were delicious.... My vodka sauce was perfect with a lil chunky tomato's and with a lil prosciutto chopped up nice & creamy & my pasta is cooked to perfection al dente !! They give you a lil twisted garlic bread with melted cheese in the middle which did its job helping me scoop all that yummy sauce out from my plate !!! Move over garlic knots & Italian bread & hello twisty hot garlic cheesy stick !!! Also they served me a lil Indy garden salad with Italian dressing also very good ... The slice I choose was their margarita with fresh mozzarella and basil, the crust was super thin & crispy & the sauce & fresh mozzarella was delicious !!! Sorry for no picture but the slice had no chance I was starving !!! Lol The restaurant is very clean with plenty of seating and the counter servers we're very polite & fast .. They are extremely busy over here with pizza alone for a holiday they had over 15 different kinds of fresh pies to go by the slice .... Deserts they definitely got ya covered over here; take a look, gelato, numerous cake slices, as well as whole cakes, big selection to please everyone !! Definitely coming back when in the area and definitely telling my co workers about this place ... By the way that pasta dish with the twisty bread & the side salad with a slice and a can soda $ 20 bucks well worth it !! A must try !!! Thanks, Greg D / NYCDOT EMERGENCY JOLT TASK TEAM. read more

See all

Easiest 5 star of my life. Penne alla vodka w parm chicken absolutely hits the spot. Did not know o got a complimentary salad and bread roll. They even offered me a free dessert for going 2 days in a row. They care about their customers, make it easy to order with cool vibe inside. Wish I could come back but from out of town read more

Tony's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Penne Alla Vodka with chicken - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Great pizza and great service . Feels like home . The balance between cheese and sauce and the crust everything is amazing

Good pizza! Ordered a pizza as well as a pasta dish and meatballs All were very good

We honored the right of passage - having pizza after a move. Staff is friendly, place is clean and chill. Pizza selections looked fresh and delish. We recommend to anyone looking for a local pizza spot. read more

Seriously awesome food. The other day we put in an order for rice balls with vodka sauce, pesto sauce, and tomato sauce on top. We got the upside down pie and the Caesar salad as an extra thing. Everything was excellent. i ordered the greek salad today for lunch. it was fantastic. read more

See all

My first NYC pizza was the best NYC pizza. Great vibes in here too. Go get em! The buffalo chicken smacks read more

Tony's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

I have been going to this pizza shop for over 40 years and have become acquainted with the mom/owner of this place we usually sit and speak while I go there. I went to order pizza pies for workers who were working on my home and unfortunately one of the sons or family member who answered the phone was extremely rude I wasn't sure if he was able to hear me but all he was yelling can I help you!!!! over and over again not much etiquette I said sorry I not sure if you heard me I was saying hello and would like to order he said well I did say can I help you but if he is yelling over me speaking while i am trying to order the conversation is definitely not going anywhere. I was not going to continue with the conversation and hung up. He actually called me back to continue to the attitude I said i was not going to argue so he hang up on me. I hope that made his day. Unfortunately, if one is having personal problems they should leave it at home before going to work. It's a shame I would never expect this especially coming from this Pizzeria. Had to feed a total of 10 contract workers it was not going to be a small order. Truly disappointed and shocked with the rudeness. Sad, I did consider this the family pizza place to go no longer for me. The attitude was so uncalled for read more

Easily the best pizza in Bushwick and wouldn't dream of ordering from another place. Luckily, I live within a 5 minute walk from this great pizzeria, and their pickup game is strong. Everyone who works there is helpful, knowledgeable, and gives off an old school Brooklyn vibe. I love that they run movies all the time in shop so on the off chance you have to wait for an order, you're never bored. I've gotten the Brooklyner and a meat lovers pizza, and both just absolutely slapped. Quality meats, good amount of cheese, prefect cook on the crust, no complaints anywhere! An absolute staple in my take out diet and dream of their pizzas! read more

Tony's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Meat lovers - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Not to be confused with the other Tony's by Dekalb. This is our go-to place for parties (by parties I mean the same people in our house, just with more food lol). Their extra large pizzas are indeed extra large I'm not even kidding. Probably as big as a toddler. Their pastas are delicious too, and they offer catering trays. Delivery does take a while, usually an hour minimum. But we always anticipate it and order ahead anyway. read more

See all

Well worth the wait!! Had to come and try the stuffed mushroom slice after my sister ranted and raved about it to me last week... they were making a fresh slice when I came in (Lucky me) so I waited 40 min for it. I didn't realize that they were so big because I never had one before so I ordered 2. Totally NOT necessary. One slice is more than enough. I'm stuffed and satisfied!! And happy that I now know about this place. Sheesh!! Got a bunch of other slices for other people. Great Pizza in Bushwick. Worth the drive and the wait!! Satisfied Customer!! read more

See all

VEGAN REVIEW! Tony's is such a great spot! It's a chill and authentic pizza place that's been serving up the classics since the 70's, complete with vegan offerings. They always have a vegan cheese slice on deck, and you can add other toppings to your slice including vegan meat and a variety of veggies. If you prefer a whole pie, you can grab a vegan cheese or vegan pepperoni, as well as making your own, of course. I've gotten cheese slices and whole pepperoni pies before, and both were fantastic! Tony's also offers vegan desserts in the form of sorbet and even vegan cake slices! Aside from the fact that they have plenty of vegan options, Tony's has great service. The guys behind the counter are super friendly and funny, a true testament to this Bushwick institution. When they heard it was my birthday one night that we came in, they had everyone sing and gave me a free slice of vegan cake. It absolutely made my night and on subsequent visits the staff have been just as friendly and cool! Needless to say, Tony's is my go-to whenever I'm craving a classic New York slice or pie in Bushwick, and it should be yours, too :) read more

Tony's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Vegan cheese slice - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Fabulous pizzeria all around! I went for the first time today and the person working the counter was incredibly patient as I questioned the menu. The pizza was ready in about 25 minutes, and it was DELICIOUS. Everyone loved the pizza. The ingredients were fresh and delicious. Highly recommend the egg and hash brown pizza - we put bacon on it. Helpful tip: There were 6 of us and we got 2 larges (because we eat a lot normally). It was actually wayyyy too much. We ended up with a whole large leftover. Next time we would get 2 mediums. read more

Tony's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Came All The Way from California to eat here and damn it was worth it. Best Lasagna I've had by far .. place was Clean and Staff were Super Sweet .. I'll definitely be back before I head home to Cali.. read more

Tony's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Salvatore made the ambiance welcoming and warm! He didn't discriminate my pineapple love on my cheesy slice.. in-fact he embraced it with an extra side! If you want good pizza with a side of spicy personality this is the place for you. All your wildest dreams will come true read more

Tony's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Salvatore was such a gentleman! Understood my need for pinaeapple on pizza & made my dreams come true. - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

See all

Bostonians hit Bushwick. Fabulous pizza. Best we've had ever. So many flavors. Great sauce. Personable team. Zeppoles were a nice finish. Can't wait to come again. read more

I'd rate Tony's three and a half stars. We shared the three sauce slice which had a spicy red sauce (I believe arrabiata), a vodka sauce, and a pesto drizzle with some fresh mozzarella slices. Toppings were good. Dough reminded me a bit more of the dough used for sausage rolls than for pizza. Crust was pretty thick and dense. Their forte is specialty slices. Lots of varieties including but not limited to Buffalo chicken, bbq chicken, macaroni and cheese, penne, ceasar salad, taco, and many more. Lots of indoor and outdoor seating. read more

Best pizza in the neighborhood! My partner who grew up in Queens has been looking for the best pizza in Brooklyn and he found it. Ask for Salvatore! read more

Fucking amazing! I had the best gluten free pizza I have ever had here. It may well have been the best pizza I've ever had. The crust was thin, crispy and delicious. The toppings were generous and delicious. They were super friendly. The pizza was ready when they said it would. The decor really shouted pizzeria, and even at 10:30 pm on a Tuesday night the place was hopping. I cannot recommend Tony's enough. You will be so thankful you got a pizza here. read more

The pizza options here are overwhelming in a good way! I have tried the pepperoni and sausage Sicilian and the Hawaiian, which were all amazing. The staff is very friendly and a service is quick. they have a small section for outdoor seating which is really nice in the summer when the weather is warm. I had the pleasure of meeting Tony himself and he shared a slice of his favorite pizza with me. This pizza place isn't the nearest one to me, but it definitely is worth the walk! read more

Every pizza spot claims they are the best spot in town however Tony's Pizzeria is truly the Best Pizzeria in Brooklyn!! There's a variety of options here that you can't get anywhere else like Mac and cheese pizza, taco pizza, pasta pizza!! Sheesh My favorite is the Buffalo chicken, cooked to perfection. Tony's is a must go-to if your in the Bushwick area or visiting Brooklyn in general. read more

Tony's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Buffalo Chicken** - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

The pizza and the welcoming vibe are both worth coming back for!! I felt comfortable lingering and staff, as well customers, were happy to suggest items from the menu and often had a memory associated with it. read more

I ordered a large pizza on Sunday night but unfortunately for my taste was extremely salty and over priced I won't order it again

BEST PIZZA IN BROOKLYN! So many different slices and all of them are amazing! Just tried the baked potato and wow! Never had a pizza like it! Icecream is delicious too! Banana pudding is our favorite! Amazing service always, and such a community spot. Tony's is the best!!! read more

Best pizzeria in town BY FAR. Not just a pizzeria but in my opinion a 5 star Italian restaurant. I had the scallops -- AMAZING, the gelato -- tasted like Italia for real. My group of friends each had a different dish & everything, the meat dishes, pasta dishes, side dishes, salad, the breads, all Micheline quality. Don't even get me started with the pizza. All pies all styles from the sicilian to the classic slice I give a 12 out of 10! Vegan options as well this place is THE BEST. Let me not forget the service & atmospher -- on point!! P.S Their homemade desserts are a must try! read more

I love their pizza; it is typical New York pizza. I love their ingredients; I usually order cheese or a pizza roll. Both are really good! The chicken rolls have sesame seeds; I would prefer it if they didn't, but they are still delicious. The staff are super lovely every single time I've ordered for takeout and in person. The ambiance here is very welcoming, and the workers are friendly and speak to customers; I've never had a bad encounter here. read more

Tony's Pizzeria & Restaurant - Cheese pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brooklyn, New York

Pizza was great as expected, there's the new slice going around called the MVP. I don't know where it started but I've started to see them around the pizza circuits. Well Tony's Pizzeria just so happen to have that slice and I had to indulge. It was super delicious, I forgot to take a picture because by the time I remembered to, it was gone. But it has all my favorites it's a pesto and vodka on top of a Margherita slice/Sicilian. My new favorite slice. read more

The best freaking pizza I've ever had!! Ate WAY too much pizza and gelato because I can't get this level of amazing pizza at home! I also had the pleasure of meeting Jack, one of the owners, who was the very essence of an Italian New Yorker- treats you like family, generous in spirit, and a delight to talk to!! Give this place a try, your won't be disappointed! read more

See all

Ordered a Caesar salad with grilled chicken, I should've tasted the dressing before putting it on the salad but I just assumed it was normal Caesar dressing. The salad itself was the expected ingredients: lettuce, cheese, croutons and chicken. But the dressing...good lord. It was sweet and syrupy...it made the salad completely inedible. It tasted so wrong, the complete opposite of a savory salty Caesar dressing. I was so upset. Waste of time and money. read more

Very good pizza. Spicy margarita was on point and crispy and the stuffed mushroom pizza was tasty read more