Definitely among the best pizza places around town. Classic brick oven is excellent! Really amazing the thin smoky crust and perfect texture always awesome! Great Garlic knots too. Very consistent and super fresh every time. read more

The pizza is good but would be great if they allowed it to heat up. The pizza is always cold. The kids behind the counter need to leave it in the oven longer. read more

I don't know about everyone else, but I find that it's pretty hard to find GOOD pizza on Long Island. I will trek to Little Vincent's when the craving hits, but Two Brothers is a solid spot in a pinch... definitely ranks as the best pizzeria in Levittown with a loyal following! The place is always packed with people buzzing in and out picking up orders. I've only had their regular and pepperoni, so I can only speak to their basic pies, and they're A-OK. read more

Two Bros. boxes say best Sicilian in town, while that may be true there really isn't much competition. Their pizza is good... Where two brothers really shines is their spinach pizza, It is amazing. I think that this would be a four star pizza place if they would start delivering. One of the great things about pizza is that when you really don't want to leave your house it comes to you. With two brothers not so much. read more

Been here twice since the move to the new location. First time was great food fresh and tasty. Second time also great food tasted great. The only thing that wasn't great was my wife and I ordered a fountain soda and then the waiter came out with refills and we got charged for 4 sodas when we were only supposed to be charged for 2. I thought we were receiving great service but when I saw the bill and asked the server about it he said there are no free refills. So I took away a star for each extra soda I was charged for. $9 for soda that's filled with mostly ice is not right. I would have ordered a beer if I would of known I was going to be charged that. Overall the place is good food is great just beware of the refill scheme they got going on. read more

The food here is definitely better than your average pizzaria, but the staff is SO miserable and the whole set up is really intimidating and disorganized. read more

I just moved to Long Island and was told to go to two brothers that it was soo good and the best Italian food around. I was very disappointed I ordered a chicken Parmesan dinner came with salad or pasta not both, the sauce was not cooked, tasted out of the can, and the chicken was cold. Also in my salad was a piece of plastic wrapper, prob from the lettuce packaging. I never write reviews but becuase of all the talk about them and such underwhelming food I just couldn't resist. read more

I've been coming here my entire life for pizza. their pizza is amazing! my job got relocated to hicksville, where i live, so we order from here every saturday. we always call ahead to order slices so we don't have to wait if it's busy. but today, i called ahead and the girl cut me off as i was ordering, saying i'm "not allowed to call ahead" because it was too busy. i continue to tell her i do this every weekend, yet she tells me no and hangs up. i come in 5 minutes later and there's only two other people there. "too busy" huh? well, there was also another time that another girl gave me the wrong food. she continues to blame me for the issue. but after today i was just really upset. the food is great, the workers... not so much. which is why i'm giving 3 stars. customer service is very important and they clearly do not care. read more

Best. Pizzeria / Restaurant ever. I used to be a waiter here and I miss that meal I'd get every night. The chef Willy is their secret for the dinners, as far as their secret goes for the pizza, it's their fresh ingredients. Any plate you order is more food than anyone else will give yo and the quality is superior as well. Wish more pizzerias raised their standards to Two Brothers level. read more

I've been going to Two Brothers pizzeria for over 20 years the pizza is always delicious the place is always clean and the staff is always Pleasant great place read more

We ordered from here regularly until last week when received a hockey puck instead of chicken scarperello. I think the Levittown/hicksville area suffers from a severe dearth of good Italian food. Two Brothers is no different. read more

Ordered their bolognese sauce and my son tried it immediately said "this tastes like hamburger helper", he was exactly right. And I hate hamburger helper. I also got a side of meatballs that had no flavor and were basically all breadcrumbs and $5.50 for two meatballs?!!! Wow!!! Never again! Next time I'll drive the extra mile and go to Gino's. read more

Been going here my entire life. Really good food. Beautiful atmosphere. It's a part of the fabric of the neighborhood.

I've come to this place a handful of times as I'm new to the neighborhood and their food has been pretty good. However, the service here is beyond terrible and the store seems to be run by teenage girls that not only have attitudes but are also racist. I am not one to write a review but after giving this place multiple chances to improve their service, I find that it's only gotten worse. I left the store today feeling completely disrespected. I was waiting in line after placing an order for a pizza pie when 20 minutes later I noticed everyone (white folks) that ordered after me already received their food. A few mins later, the the same girl that took my order brought out a large pizza pie and when no one came forward to claim it at the register, I approached her to take a look at the receipt to see if it was my order. RUDELY she snatched the receipt out of my hand saying "Excuse me! Don't touch anything". To which I awkwardly responded "I am only checking if this is mine"...I am a veteran of this country and being treated poorly because of their ignorance and intolerance of diversity is something they should be ashamed of. Needless to say, I will not be returning here. read more

Great Pizza, I enjoy both the plain and the chicken parm slice. Tortellini in brodo with spinach and egg is extremely satisfying as well.

Great pizza!!! Another wonderful family owned business in the area!!! Never had a bad slice!!! The variety is a great one along with their salads!!! There are places around with comparable slices but nothing like Thor salads.... You can do take out or dine in.. Quick dime or full service I have experienced all here and was always happy. Their pick up system is great they use last four digits of phone.... Can imagine if they used names they get very busy and must be many Tonys that go in for an order!! This is a great system so order does not go home with the wrong Tony! read more

Their buffalo chicken slice is one of the greatest things I've ever put in my mouth.

They just can't be consistent. Ordered a pizza and a baked ziti a few nights ago. The bottom of the pizza was black and the ziti had no ricotta and no sauce - dry and overcooked. John should be on top of this. This used to be one of the better pizza joints in the area. Fuhgetaboutit. read more

BEST SICILIAN PIZZA EVER. All their food, in fact, is made with high quality ingredients and attention to detail. I grew up 2 blocks away from Two Brothers, and despite it being only one of many pizza spots around, we always ordered from them. Mind you, this must be 20 years ago. Now, though I've moved out of the area, I always make sure to stop there when I pass through while visiting. We bring a whole sicilian pie back home with us, even on long trips. read more

I really like all the many types of pizza and outside the box options available at this pizzeria. I love the tomato and mozzarella salad that the usually have on hand in the front of the store but the last couple of months was unavailable because they are moving to a bigger location in the same shipping center. I will update in a few weeks once I try them in the new store but I am sure they will carry over the great quality and selection that they have always had. read more

This place lost it's touch. Says they're open till midnight and every time I try to grab a slice between 11-12 at night they are closed. I called at 11:15 and after 25 rings someone finally picked up and told me they close at 11. Well if you started closing at 11 fix your yelp hours and let people know you changed the only good thing about you guys. I work late nights and would love to enjoy a nice pie when I get home instead of crappy dominoes. read more

Two bro has one of the best pasta dishes I've eating in awhile they make some of the best tasting baked ziti that i have ever had and cheesy to the fullest. They also make some amazing pizza that would make you take a slice or two home just to reheat for the next day. It has just the right amount of sauce and the perfect amount of cheese and the crust has just the right crunch for the excellent pizza it is. read more

I went to Two Brothers to celebrate my sister and brother's birthday (they're twins). There were 5 of us and we were seated very quickly. The waiter comes over to take our drink and appetizer orders and leaves. He comes back with our drinks and ask for our dinner orders which we gave him (mistake). Our appetizers arrive about 5 minutes later we started sharing the appetizers when 2 minutes later our entrees show up. There wasn't room on the table to fit everything the waiter brought. The food may have been good but the whole experience was ruined by thoughtless service. I'll never go back. read more

I probably come here once a week. Very solid pizza place. Excellent ricotta. Wish they changed their pizza selections a bit more but their normal selection is very good. A little expensive for entrees for a pizza place, but all pizza places are like that in my opinion. The guys and girls behind the counter are great. I think it's the best pizza place in the area. read more

This is an excellent place to just grab a slice or to sit down and have a meal. The service is second to none, the food is great and the prices are very reasonable. read more

A little pricy but one of the best eggplant parm slices ive had, just gets crowded around 5 or 6... Chicken Marsala used to be great few months back its very watery now their greek salad portion is great! read more

Very disappointed in the new restaurant, we walked in to have a sit down lunch. No Hostess to be found or waiter. Had to ask at the counter. We sat down and the back round music was NOT back round. It was so LOUD and the music was BAR Music. Very disappointed the food was ok. I will not go back. read more

Right down the road from where I live. I have been going here for years they have very good pizza at a very good price. Also the convince of having a good pizza joint right down the block also is a plus. read more

All my friends rave about this joint. i happen to be in the neighborhood and hungry so i stopped by. The selection was large and the place was somewhat clean. I got 2 slices and a diet coke.. Is it mandatory for pizzeria employees to be miserable and never smile? guess so. The pizza was decent i liked it and it was hot and tasty. The people around me were nasty and loud and slobs though. typical long island trashbags. Would i go back? probably not,,, read more

This place has been around forever. I have no idea why. The pizza has been crap for at least the last 15 years, ever since their first move. I go here at least once a year because it is close by. Today is hopefully my last time eating this swill. Not only was the pizza soft, chewy, slightly burned, and tasteless as usual, but the prices have gone up considerably. $19 and change for a pizza with half pepperoni is ridiculous. Absolute shit for nearly $20. I'll never understand how this place is still around or why people go here. There are so many other pizza places that are so much better and cost less. Don't go here. read more

Drove 20 mins to try the pizza here. We weren't disappointed. Hubby and I shared a Sicilian slice (their box said they were the best in town) and each a plain slice. The plain during our visit was a bit over cooked bottom of the crust but the sauce, flavors were EXCELLENT! Sicilian was very good and also bursting w flavor. We'll be back to try when the plain slices aren't overdone :) read more

To expensive for ok pizza. And there is never pizza ready when I go. I always have to wait. Monaco's is much better

Very friendly staff. Good NY style pizza in long island.

Best pizza in town. The pizza here is delicious and I would highly recommend it to anyone that loves pizza. The buffalo chicken and BBQ chicken are amazing. Place has been around for a while and with great food like this it will continue to be. read more

Pizza and food is always good. New fav is the upside down slice with the sauce on top. Been comin here since I moved to long island.

Pizza is good but new location is absolutely horrible. Parking is crazy in the corner. People parking illegally. I've almost been in a few accidents. A couple times we could barely get in to park. Have lost a lot of our business since moving to their new location. I'll goto the other local spots. They would have been better to close down for a few months and take over the Chinese restaurant next door if possible. Then remodel and reopen. Corner spot was prime real estate and so much more convenient. read more

Found two brothers on Yelp says it's open to midnight Walked in at 1025 pm. Asked for 5 Reg slices and 2 Sicilian The nasty counter guy starting lifting trays that had all different slices on it and slamming them down saying I don't have any slices. I said I'll wait if you make a pie he said he's not we are closing. Your closing in 35 minutes. You have time. Why even advertise your open late. read more

The absolute best stuffed rigatoni in the world hands down! You must try it! Feeling like a sandwich instead? Get the chicken parm hero. There's nothing better than feeling the crunch of the bread. No soggy heros here! It's all my boyfriend will order. Wanna sit down and eat? Anthony is the best waiter ever! read more

If you like paper thin grease dripping slices this is the place for you then.I will pass.

I love the pizza and heros from here! Two Brothers is a great place to go for Italian food! I usually get the white pizza, chicken parm hero and eggplant parm hero and they are always delicious! read more