Wow. I thought this place was incredible in the old location. They moved into a much larger and nicer space in the same shopping center. I had two Sicilian and some garlic knots that were superior to anything I've Had in the Area. The food was surprisingly better than it was in the old spot. I know, hard to believe but true. read more

Two Bros Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Levittown, New York

The quality of food & service has gone downhill a lot in the last few years. My family used to love this place. Stopped in tonight on my way home for dinner for my parents & I. I got 2 slices of Greek salad pizza & 2 slices of regular pizza. I get home & find out there's no dressing at all on the salad slices! Yuck! Who wants dry salad! They used to serve it with dressing on it & it was so good. Tonight it was awful! Had to use olive oil just to be able to eat the salad. The 2 slices of regular pizza were hours old. Horrible. Burnt crust. Honestly looked like leftover pizza from the day before re-heated. Needless to say the whole meal sucked. Had a terrible experience last year when friends & I went for dinner. This never used to happen. Won't be going back. It's sad. They were the best. read more

Done with them ever since the move they have gone down hill. Went in today10/21/18 to order chicken Parm with very little sauce it comes out swimming in it! Tell the guy behind the counter I asked for very little sauce he takes it back and they dump off some of the sauce.and try to bring it back I'll never be back read more

I'll give this place 2 stars because the food wasn't terrible, but the service was so bad that I couldn't rate it anything more than that. We were seated right away but the waiter that we had could not care less about our table. It took him 20 minutes to get our tables drink orders, so obviously by the time he finally came over to our table, we were ready to order. Then the waiting game continued. We watched him cater to every single other table but ours. He refilled their drinks, brought out all of their food, and did multiple check ups on their table. He was not at all concerned of us. I personally believe it is because of my friends age (20-21) that he did not feel the need to give us paying customers the proper service. 35 minutes after ordering our food, we received our spegetti and meatballs, pasta carbonara, and hero. Truly terrible service. read more

Probably one of the best pizza around in a 10 mile radius. I was treating my mechanic working on my car and they suggested this place. I ordered 2 different pies and they loved it. My car also loved them. I went another time to this pizza place and I knew why they liked it hear so much. You walked in and they had so many options of pizzas, calzone, stuffed pizzas, and more. The place was still busy for a 3pm time. This is great place for a great slice. read more

Just moved to area and got to share can't find a local Pizzeria / Resteraunt that represents! I tried my luck on Shrimp Scampi and couple of slices to bring home. I'm so over being overcharged for subpar fare. I have no problem paying $20+ for a shrimp dinner - if it's good will pay every time! Will not try anything else here! certainly weren't jumbo shrimp as on menu and were overcooked! Can only imagine it's this area as tried another local and same sitch -- and have learned lesson to stick to Pizzetta near my office. They represent! Even Chicken Marsala slice no mushrooms... just so wrong. read more

I have been going to this Pizza place With my friends and family for years. Always had a good experience till yesterday. This girl was so rude and disrespectful ,when I told her the Zeppole is burned she threw the pan and and she was so mad. She reheated new one but she is acting like childish that she is throwing everything she touch. When I asked her if she is mad, she has the nerve to say yes. She shouldn't be working around customer because she is so disrespectful and no idea about customer service. I asked her I can pay the burned ones but she says No. I never had a experience like this in any pizza store. I will never bother to bring my friends and family here again. read more

Two brothers is a pizzeria restaurant that absoultely shines in its sit-in and dine. Their baked clams are the best I've had in any restaurant hands down. Me and my girlfriend have visted this location numerous times and just love the place. Their specials are always great and their service is always excellent. This is one restaurant I've reccommended and will continue to do so. read more

Love how their pizza isn't heavy or greasy at all. You think of pizza in general and have this idea of greasy stuff dripping through the slice and how you feel so heavy after a slice or two. Well, the pizza here definitely isn't loaded with cheese but still tastes great. It is dripping with olive oil though, which I guess is better with all the mon & poly unsaturated fats. The mozzarella cheese blocks on the slice taste really fresh. And the place is pretty affordable. read more

Two Bros Pizzeria - Grandma's pizza & Chicken Parm - Pizza Near Me - Levittown, New York

They just redid the entire restaurant, they moved a few doors down for a bigger spot , everything is amazing too "knot " Italian , my wife is pregnant and was demanding a taco slice , thank god they have them , I fed her a taco slice and all was saved! Everything else is amazing just as good as any top pizza restaurants around read more

Nice family restaurant. Decent italian food, rolls and pizza. Update:4/12-Two Brothers has slipped in food quality and service. read more

I love this pizza place TWO BROTHER's ....everything is good here the BEST pizza slice is the Chicken Parm slice. I love the little Sprite and Coke bottle's too. read more

Best eggplant, sausage and chicken rolls- better with a side of their sauce. Pizza has never disappointed. Salads (on take out) are what you would usually make--nothing special. (Salad pizza is your better bet.) Penne ala vodka is better than most takeout/pizza places. Baked ziti is OK. They will make whatever you ask them to make especially if you can't have an item that is already out (my husband can't have green peppers on the sausage rolls- they will make fresh for him). Front counter staff are great! read more

Above average, the spinach slice is a must try. Conveniently open later than many other pizzerias in town and have a great dine in area

The food here is always good until I ordered a margherita pie today. A small margherita at that. I got a 10 inch pie with no fresh mozzarella or anything that would even resemble a margherita pie. When I asked why I didn't get a margherita they told me this was a margherita bc of the sauce. They charge $15 for a small pie because they change the sauce. The kid behind the counter was extremely rude when we asked a question as well. Not to mention how destroyed the box was when we got the pizza. Still giving them 3 stars to be fair because there food is usually good and the pizza normally is also. Just had a very bad experience this time and they've lost my business over it. Good food good pizza normally, just don't ever have a dispute and you'll be fine. read more

Two Bros Pizzeria - Terrible box along with a sub par small margherita for 15 dollars. No fresh mozzarella nothing that resembles a margherita. - Pizza Near Me - Levittown, New York

See all

Our favorite Long Island pizzeria. The staff is always friendly and helpful even though the place is usually crowded. Welcoming and relaxing atmosphere. read more

If this review was solely based on their Grandma Pizza then it would easily be given 5 stars. I would say their pizza across the board pretty solid along with the other items in the pizza display case. The heroes are also solid and a good size. Unfortunately the rest of the Italian food is nothing to sing about. I'm very curious if it's even something basic as not salting the pasta water because it's pretty bland when not drowned in sauce. I recently ordered rigatoni with broccoli rabe and sausage in garlic and oil. Saying the dish was bland is an understatement. It also seemed like the sausage was fried and placed on top. Same with the broccoli rabe, it was just placed on top of the bland pasta. This is the type of dish where you want the flavors for the garlic and sausage to infuse the pasta and veg. Not to mention, the dish was screaming for salt and my personal favorite, crushed red pepper. I would continue going back here but most likely only for the pizza itself. read more

It's usually hard to make bad pizza. But Two Brothers goes above and beyond and makes great pizza AND food. My family moved to Levittown a couple years ago and we found this place and we go here all the time. We've used two brothers to cater our house warming party and my 21st birthday party and the food has always been delicious. We've gone out for dinner at their restaurant portion. The service is great. There's a waitress (I don't know her name) who always recognizes us when we come in and she's always super friendly and accommodating. I usually get the fettuccine Alfredo or manicotti. It's hard to find good creamy fettuccine Alfredo most of the time. Most places make it really oily but not two brothers! I'm glad to say I've found a spot for my favorite fettuccine Alfredo!!! My mom always gets the fish and my dad usually gets chicken or veil and they both have always loved their food. Only thing: I wish they delivered!!! read more

Their pizza is always fresh and delicious they have a wide selection of different path types of pizzas sold by the slice. Rice balls rolls etc..Their heroes are very good I highly recommend them. read more

I really cannot think of a single bad thing to say about this pizza spot. Oh wait, I just thought of one...THEY DON"T DELIVER! But in all seriousness, I have to say that I have tried everything at 2 Bros. I have had pizza, pasta, heroes, salad, etc. I have to say that the ultimate indulgence here is the baked ziti slice of pizza. Now, there is no need to have baked ziti on a piece of pizza, but DAMN is it worth every calorie. Make sure if you get this that you ask for a side of sauce. SOOOO GOOD. I could drink the red sauce with a spoon or straw. Thank you Two Bros for being everything a pizzeria should be. DELISH! read more

I'm sorry but they have some nerve to charge $15 for this and it's nothing spectacular either. I had to add more grated cheese to it too. read more

Two Bros Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Levittown, New York

I had a party with 40 people here , the food was great and service was amazing , I will be having my next party here .

Great pizza great selection good value and good service highly recommend on a recent night stoped off for a few slices and was amazed at the selection and taste of the food for the price read more

Been going to Two Brothers since I was a kid. Amazingggg pizza always served super hot! Best white slice and spinach slice!! Always busy at night, but it still never takes too long to get in and out with a few slices. Keep it up guys!!! read more

had a delivery on friday 12.23 23 of lasagna from 2 brothers it was always good this time it was the worst lasagna that you delivered to us, we had company and I was so embarassed read more

What can I say about two brothers .. it is the best food you are gonna find for great prices. I use to eat there almost every day when I was in college. They have the best chicken parm hero you are going to find!! get a sauce cup. even to go !! Veal parm dinner excellent! Best baked ziti in I have ever had! Oh did a mention great service great staff someone needs to get some pics of the food up so i can drool .. Open till midnight.. cannot beat that .. use to show up at 1130 get pizza slices that were real fresh!! or a dinner .. read more

The pizza was just as I remember. Growing up one of my favorite pizza places! The grandma pie and Sicilian pies are amazing Garlic knots have a lot of garlic flavor so not for everyone but I love it! Thanks two brothers pizza for excellent courteous staff members! We come back here very year during our vacations to NewYork! read more

We love Two Brothers. Everything is always great, they are friendly and accommodating. Simply wonderful

Average pizza. I've dinned in for dinner dishes as well. Burrata is good but serving it with 6 cherry tomato halves and balsamic vinegar is weak. Linguine Alfredo was good but lacked in flavor, add pepper and parm. Chicken cutlet too thick over breaded, but tasty. House wine cheap, as expected but 1 notch above gas station wine. Sauce is again average. Slice is available and fast, service is pretty good. Doesn't deliver. Convenient location, nice new digs, but now prices to pay for their new restaurant. And they microwave your Rice Balls, seriously? Forgettable. read more

Easily one of my favorite pizza spots in my area. Probably the best pizza in town or is it around? Regardless they have great specialty slices I've had almost all of them. From they Caesar salad slice to buffalo chicken and they are all excellent. Love the pin wheels and garlic knots as well they go great with their homemade sauce. They also make great rice balls. #twobrospizza read more

Hands down the best eye-talian food to be had in Hicksville area. My staple is grilled chicken over penne marinara or a chicken roll and Sicilian-- mood dependant. Cannoli and espresso very good add on if you want to linger. The place moved into the center of the shopping center and is now pretty large plenty of tables with plenty of flat screens. Wait staff is friendly and polite. Give it a try there is nothing that can compare nearby. read more

I know my pizza ... and after trying so many different places, I rate Two Bros Pizzeria #1. They make the most delicious sesame seed crust pizza that I must get at least once a week!! Their pizza sauce is just right (not too salty like some others) and the pizza is never dripping with oil!!! I have to travel 15 minutes to get food from Two Bros, but it's definitely worth the trip!! read more

I am confused as to why this pizza place got rave reviews. I went this Friday the staff behind the counter were unorganized and slow . Ordered two slices , the counter help touched my slice before packing it up. Pizza was overcooked and did not taste fresh. Will not be going back read more

While I can't say it's the BEST pizza I've ever had it's def really good. in particular their chicken caesar salad slice. that's my go to. their meat stuffed and chicken parm are pretty dope as well. never ordered a full pie or entree's though. read more

Good atmosphere in the new store. Prices are a little high. Doesn't really have that mom& pop feel too it anymore.

Oh yeah, my bros and I used to hit this place up on the regular because the food was top notch and the service was 2 legit. Stopped in to see the new place and it was a real bummer. New place is big and clean (like me) but it goes downhill from there. Waited in line forever and finally got a sampler platter of different personal pizzas. When I sat down to eat in the dining area the pizzas were colder than my ex's heart. Had to send them back to get reheated. Wish I could sent my ex girlfriend back because she really stomped on my heart. I'm sad. When the food was heated up enough, it was terrible. Definitely several days old. Safe to say I won't be back. Bye bye 2 brothers. Peace out read more

This is one of my favorite pizzerias which I can rely on being served very good Italian food, it has three important factors on how I rate a restaurant, quality, taste, and atmosphere. Two Brothers consistently hits those marks and has been for many years now. Keep up the good work Two Brothers! read more

Love the specialty pizza...the chicken masala and the taco pizza and bbq chicken pizza. Went to check it out after they expanded to the bigger spot and had their fettuccine pasta...it was kind of heavy and greasy and it just doesn't seem the same for some reason. But I'm not giving up on this place yet..they've got the best pizza around these parts. read more

Gosh the service was amazing. the young man behind the counter did an outstanding job handling my pizza. it was cooked to perfection and filled my yum yum tummy. for desert i had some wildbery mascrapatone gelato which was extraordinarily scooped by none other than the young man who cooked my pizza. amazing restaurant, even better staff. 45/10 will recommend to everyone i know. dr bob. read more

Definitely among the best pizza places around town. Classic brick oven is excellent! Really amazing the thin smoky crust and perfect texture always awesome! Great Garlic knots too. Very consistent and super fresh every time. read more