I am a first time customer -- I recently ordered 2 pies and 12 garlic knots to be delivered to a local shelter for the volunteers there. The shelter is literally about a 4 minute drive away, right down the block. We tipped $4.00, which I thought was reasonable for such a short delivery, although maybe I should have tipped more. I'm not sure. Unfortunately, the delivery driver was clearly unhappy with the tip and asked for more money. I was honestly flabbergasted. He told me to go inside and ask them if they're willing to give him more. He kept asking for more, became angry and rude, and the interaction lasted a solid 2-3 minutes before I finally walked away and called the store to report it. Mind you, it takes A LOT for me to want to complain... The first manager I spoke to was a woman who basically just said sorry, and that was it. However, I later spoke with Rich, who I believe is either a manager or the owner, and he completely changed how I felt about the situation. Rich took the time out of his day to go over everything with me in detail, listened to what happened, made sure the situation was made right with us, and handled things with his driver. He could have easily been rude, dismissive, or just brushed me off, but he did the exact opposite. He immediately took action, handled the situation professionally, and resolved it to the best of his ability. I genuinely found that commendable. Because of how kind, respectful, and professional Rich was, I still plan on supporting the business moving forward. For our next event, I actually plan on ordering 3 pies and other items from them. Their food is absolutely amazing! I'll personally be doing pickup moving forward rather than delivery, but I truly do want to support Rich and his business because of how well he handled everything. Thank you again Rich. Wishing you and the business well. read more

Not sure what's going on there but we ordered 2 hero's this evening and the chicken cutlet parm hero had barely any cheese and almost no meat. It was all bread. I don't even think it was one complete cutlet. And the eggplant parm also had no cheese for some reason and seemed like the hero bread had been cut off and lacking any eggplant. We ate them but were not full by any means. Won't order from them ever again. Prices keep going up and food quantity goes down. read more

First I went over the menu for misspelled Italian words and I could only find one. This tells me that the chef is competent. Then I started with a Negroni and it wasn't what I expected, but it tasted good. At the table we ordered a variety of things and I must say that the food is good. The seafood is cooked to perfection and that goes for the meat as well. The service was good and the waiter, that pretended to be Italian, gave us lots of attention. The only thing I didn't like about the ambiance was the noise level, but a good espresso and an excellent brand of grappa made up for it. The portions are generous and reasonably priced. read more

SUCH good pasta, the penne is phenomenal. Tons of veggie options, waiters are so nice. The complimentary bread is also so good. Super clean inside and so much seating and fast service. read more

Umberto's Restaurant & Pizza - Penne ala Vodka - Pizza Near Me - Wantagh, New York

The food is always amazing. And we had a great waiter which always makes going out so much nicer . The place is big and beautiful in the back we love it !! Looking forward to going back again. read more

Let me make something very clear: the pizza is amazing. There is no other pizzeria on Long Island. That has the sauce and overall flavor of this pizza. Here is the problem: when you order multiple slices instead of a pie, you liable to get a small piece any large piece or a medium piece. The slices are never the same. Second, even if you order in the middle of the day, you can get an old piece of pizza. That is un unacceptable at their prices. Do better! read more

Umberto's Restaurant & Pizza - This is the small amount of basil that causes all the problem. - Pizza Near Me - Wantagh, New York

The best pizza in town That's no knock on the entire menu which is just as good Our go to restaurant read more

This place may look like a run of the mill pizzeria but don't be fooled. The food is excellent.

I've been here several times for lunch. I always get their pizza, because it's always good. Today I had the sausage, peppers, and olive slice. It was delicious. There was a bite of sauce and peppers in every bite and the saltiness of the olives just added to it. I also like their white pie, grandma pie and of course, just a plain slice of pizza. It's nice inside. We order from the counter and then seat ourselves, but there is a large dining area in the back. There's a small bar, but it's nice enough. I come here every time I shop at iavarones, which is in the shopping center. read more

I go there with my friends at least once a month. The food is always fresh & tasty. Good place to take out or dine in. read more

Umberto's Restaurant & Pizza - Escarole with grilled shrimp topped with mozzarella. - Pizza Near Me - Wantagh, New York

Told me my pizza would be ready by 6:30. I ordered at 6 o'clock at 6:45. They told me five more minutes. My pizza was ready at seven and then the guy behind the counter gave me shit because I said it's about time read more

I've been a customer for years. I food has always been very good. Recently I visited the restaurant and ordered pizza and two fried cappellini. When I asked the counter man for a side sauce I was rudely and quickly was told that it would be an additional 65 cents. This restaurant is at the top of local pizzerias price range and for them to charge $.65 for 1 ounce of sauce is insulting. I would consider dining at some of the many local pizzerias in the future read more

There are great appetizers from here, and great shrimp meals and a chicken cutlet hero too! The food here normally is great. :)

You get exactly what you hope and pay for They do it very good. As far as we are concerned, this is where you find it read more

So before I write this review, I have to preface this with saying that I am a pizza girlie, and I've certainly tried many different pizzerias on Long Island... but this is NEXT LEVEL! After just discovering this Wantagh gem, better late than never I suppose, LOL, I cannot stop raving about Umberto's take on the New York slice -- their high quality ingredients and their authentic touch is surely worth the hype especially when it comes to their incredible crust, fresh tomato sauce, and olive oil. (My mom literally said their pizza reminded her of a slice she had in Italy, and my boyfriend was very much impressed as well!) I recommend the slightly deeper dish slice called the Pazzo -- fresh sausage and peppers and olives and an unreal crust that will have you shouting from the pizza rooftops. I also love their take on the tri-colored Grandma's with three sauces --- marinara, vodka, and pesto. Finally, I have to preach their Chicken Bacon Ranch slice for being SO comforting and balanced. (Again, I cannot get over how good and crunchy their crust is!) Run, don't walk, to this Wantagh staple --- I TOTALLY understand why it has been voted best on Long Island. read more

Umberto's Restaurant & Pizza - Slices: Pazzo, tri-colored Grandma's, and Chicken Bacon Ranch :) - Pizza Near Me - Wantagh, New York

4 1/2 stars for Umberto's in Wantagh. ( see Pix) Delicious chicken and noodles , leftovers spilled out and oil . This said, food and service was consistently great. Chicken park and Angel hair spaghetti well cooked , presented and plentiful. Note: rewards card give your-# at time of bill. Note: takeout - the young blond girl is a fine worker and is a keeper. Food equity fresh at counter. read more

See all

Ordered from Umberto's Wantagh tonight. Sicilian pie burnt, inedible! Trashed. Not cheap either! read more

Umberto's Restaurant & Pizza - Burnt silician - Pizza Near Me - Wantagh, New York

See all

The service is great and the food is delicious. I have never been disappointed and one of my favorites is their chicken Marsala. Their pizza is great too and a favorite is their sausage and broccoli rabe pizza. read more

staff is rude, overpriced, & foods always burnt yeah it taste good but is it worth the aggravation NO...there's other options for great pizza! read more

Umberto's Restaurant & Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wantagh, New York

See all

Constantly consistent, delicious dinner entrees make this a go to every time your looking for a great Italian meal to eat in or take out. The entrees are fresh and cooked to perfection and one of the few that doesn't up charge for Garlic and Oil pasta side to your entree. Great Grandma and Sicilian squares and great selection of pizza combinations. Staff is always friendly and courteous. They have a great online ordering platform and you get 15% off your first order Highly recommend read more

See all

Always good & consistent . The best Umbertos on LI & I go all the time over the one closer to me in Bellmore

First, they make an amazing pizza of many varieties. If I have a table of six or eight, sometimes we'll order a pie as an appetizer for the table. The staff are extremely friendly and the food is quite good and reasonably priced. I would recommend them go a good hearty Italian dish with a pleasant atmosphere. read more

Food was very good. Loved their salads and baked clams. Penne abruzzo was spiced just right. Service was lovely. Great place to dine with friends. read more

Crumpled sausage slice is heavenly. Usually ask for it well done. Always fresh and delicious.

Garlic Bread w/ Cheese Penne Alla Vodka Pizza's All great food and service. Must try if you haven't given Umberto's a try read more

Thank you Umberto's!!! My wife and I went to dinner with my cousins at Umberto's on Saturday night. My cousins traveled to Long Island and wanted to meet us for dinner and asked us to recommend a restaurant. Ahh, the pressure!!! My cousins know good restaurants and I didn't want to disappoint them. So we thought of Umberto's. We've been there many times. For dinner with friends, for weekend and mid-week dinners, and, our favorite, nice sit down lunches during the week. My family even chose Umberto's for dinner after spending the day watching over me in ICU (yup, I survived!). The food is always great. My wife loves the grilled chicken with broccoli rabe. She still talks about a special she had with gnocchi, sausage and broccoli rabe. They make a great cappuccino and have delicious desserts. Umberto's is a pizzeria and restaurant. They have more casual seating up front and then opens up into a beautiful more formal restaurant in back. I haven't been to Italy, but I kind of feel like I'm there in that room. Big Guy Comfort Factor of 9. Very sturdy chairs. I did feel like it could have been a deeper seat for maximum comfort. Nice and clean bathrooms and ample parking - although it is a very busy strip mall. They had two N.A. beer selections - Heineken Zero and O'Doul's. I had the Heineken in a nice frosted glass. The service is very very good. Very attentive. They must be good to their employees because their waiters and waitresses stay there for years and years. We had a waiter (can't remember his name) who worked at our local pizzeria for many years and then he moved on to Umberto's probably 10 to 15 years ago. He was very very friendly and attentive to my wife and I and especially to our guests. The food was awesome. I had homemade sausage with broccoli rabe over capellini in a garlic olive oil sauce. Amazing. My cousin had the Sunday Sauce and really enjoyed it. My wife loved her grilled chicken but just wished it was a little hotter. We had cannolis and cappuccino for dessert. Yummy. It was a great dining experience and my cousin and his wife enjoyed Umberto's - mentioning both the delicious food and the restaurant's great ambiance. Oh, and superior company of course. My wife did mention that the reservation process was a bit difficult. The restaurant is first come first served after 5 p.m. There were plenty of tables when we got there but the restaurant quickly filled. I'm definitely looking forward to my next visit to Umberto's. read more

Our Sunday evening 2/23, our dinner was very quickly ruined when my family and I went to Umberto's in Wantagh and we had to repeat our order to the Waiter at least 3x before he seemed to understand what we wanted to order. Please keep in mind that we didn't order anything unusual, we ordered direct from their menu. Once our food came, I knew something was wrong after the first bite. My pasta and mozzarella tasted like clumps of raw dough, and had absolutely NO taste! My son ordered chicken cutlet with pasta, garlic & oil, and even though he stressed "light on the oil" his pasta and chicken were drowning in oil, I've never seen anything like it, it looked like soup! Naturally, he was sick to his stomach a couple of bites later. My son's girlfriend ordered spaghetti and it was barely edible. I also never saw spaghetti so thick, looked more like linguini, and not spaghetti. The Waiter came over a few minutes later and I told him my pasta and mozzarella tasted like raw dough and had absolutely NO taste, he basically said there was nothing he could do. I asked for the manager. Next thing I knew, the Manager approached and began to questioned me. He instantly got very defensive when he heard the food had no taste! He told me it tasted the way it's supposed to taste! I then told him I was Italian and asked if he was Italian. He chose not to answer but then asked if I was born in Italy. I told him I could not eat my dinner and I don't expect to pay for it. This so called person they call a manager, continued to discuss my Italian nationality and then walked away. My family and I decided to leave the restaurant. As we waited up front for my son paying the check, (YES, we DID pay the check) another Waiter or younger Manager approached us and very angrily, he started talking nasty to us and started saying various things like: "you're nothing but Trash, get out of here,"Get out Trash cans," "Get out out Trash! Get out Trash, Get out" Needless to say, my family has never been treated like this by any Our Sunday evening 2/23, our dinner was very quickly ruined when my family and I went to Umberto's in Wantagh and we had to repeat our order to the Waiter at least 3x before he seemed to understand what we wanted to order. Please keep in mind that we didn't order anything unusual, we ordered direct from their menu. Once our food came, I knew something was wrong after the first bite. My pasta and mozzarella tasted like clumps of raw dough, and had absolutely NO taste! My son ordered chicken cutlet with pasta, garlic & oil, and even though he stressed "light on the oil" his pasta and chicken were drowning in oil, I've never seen anything like it, it looked like soup! Naturally, he was sick to his stomach a couple of bites later. My son's girlfriend ordered spaghetti and it was barely edible. I also never saw spaghetti so thick, looked more like linguini, and not spaghetti. The Waiter came over a few minutes later and I told him my pasta and mozzarella tasted like raw dough and had absolutely NO taste, he basically said there was nothing he could do. I asked for the managers name and phone # so I could call them tomorrow. Next thing I knew, the Manager approached and began to questioned me. He instantly got very defensive when he heard the food had no taste! He told me it tasted the way it's supposed to taste! I then told him I was Italian and asked if he was Italian. He chose not to answer but then asked if I was born in Italy. I told him I could not eat my dinner and I don't expect to pay for it. This so called person they call a manager, continued to discuss my Italian nationality and then walked away. My family and I decided to leave the restaurant. As we waited up front for my son paying the check, (YES, we DID pay the check) another Waiter or younger Manager approached us to say various things like: "you're nothing but Trash, get out of here,"Get out Trash cans," "Get out out Trash! Get out Trash, Get out" Needless to say, my family has never been treated like this by any business establishment ever! business establishment ever! The Manager instructed us NEVER to return. I wouldn't return if they were the last restaurant on Long Island. This owner/manager is a DISGRACE to treat a paying customer like this! read more

The pizza is delicious (esp the grandma pizza!) but the food is outstanding and reasonably priced. The staff are really friendly and attentive. The quality of ingredients is evident in each bite! I highly recommend the chicken fiorentina. read more

Admitted pizza snob here...first off, I live nowhere near this place but pass by. Had a regular slice, as always when trying a new place, and it was really good! Hot, but not molten magma, and the crust was crispy but still foldable, which is the New York way, thank you. The sauce is key and this is a really nice sauce...not too sweet or salty. The cheeses was melts, if that's a word, and not stringy or salty ( salty is the mark of cheap cheeses, if you ask me). A very solid and tasty slice ...worth a bit of travel out of your way! The star here though is the fried capalini bites with warm marinara for topping. The capalini melts in your mouth and the warm sauce (it's got to be warm) just makes the taste complete! Also, try the Metro pizza for a nice spin on your standard pizza...you won't be disappointed! read more

Little Twilight Zone here. Go to the website and check out the menus. One is for a lunch menu. Go to the restaurant, are seated and menus are brought out. This is a dinner menu. I ask for the lunch one and am told there isn't one. Not in the mood for spending $35/40 for lunch. Copy of lunch menu as taken from their webpage shown in photo. read more

Umberto's Restaurant & Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Wantagh, New York

The man took my order nicely and as I waited for my order, the other guy who takes the pizza from the oven and packs the food was SO disrespectful and chastised the guy that took my order.I felt bad for the person who took my order to be yelled at in front of customers because he didn't put the paper in front of him. He spoke so disrespectfully to his co- worker that I doubt I'll ever eat there again. How dare you speak to your co- worker in front of customers with such anger and disrespect. read more

Food great. Service Great. Drinks excellent Best pizza around!! Wish you could make a Saturday night reservation but they dont take them anymore read more

Got an eggplant parm hero, I asked for it toasted (was not toasted. Very little eggplant and 4 strings of cheese... pathetic hero!!! I will never go back to this OVER-RATED pizza place again ... read more

Umberto's Restaurant & Pizza - Very little eggplant and 4 strings of cheese... pathetic hero!!! - Pizza Near Me - Wantagh, New York

Great service always!!! Love the pizza here. We always come to Umberto's to celebrate any special occasion, and it never fails to be good!

Went for dinner couple years ago food was terrible figured I would give it another shot so I went there for Father's Day it definitely did not get any better cold seafood salad was absolutely terrible for dinner I had the veal and peppers just as bad the wife got spaghetti white clam sauce also terrible the owner should try eating the food he is serving and make some serious changes.... The pizza is always good though read more

Heard so much about this restaurant went there last night big disappointment. Extremely noisy food was very average at best and very pricey went with another couple everybody ordered something different and we all came to the same conclusion read more

Stopped in on Friday night to pick up hero's , wings and calamari i had ordered. Although it was very busy , my order was ready in the estimated time . I find the food consistently good at Umbertos ! Their tomato sauce tastes like it's been sitting in a big pot all day , like my grandmothers ! Cheese is good quality , bread fresh and crispy . Calamari crispy and tender . Now for me the wings are too thickly coated , just not my favorite style . However , it did not stop me from eating them ! The other side of the restaurant has a large well lit area for table service with a casual vibe . Come as you are ! My thoughts , you can always count on Umbertos for a good meal The one down side is the parking lot is my least favorite . Tip: park far away read more

Visited here for lunch with my mom on a Monday afternoon. All umbertos food is great but this experience was absolutely horrible with our service. We wanted a table to sit down at but waited at the hostess stand. EVENTUALLY someone came and sat us. Then our waiter took about 10 minutes to come and greet us. We ordered our drinks. Then we took our appetizer and meal order, together. Which usually I hate doing but the waiter wanted it all together. He brought out our appetizers. Then....our waiter disappeared. We need refills and utensils and wanted a side of dressing. After our appetizers, we sat at our table for about 30 minutes until our mini pizzas were brought out. I had to ask another waiter where it was bc we were waiting a while. Especially for a lunch hour and there was not that many tables. And you know where the mini pizzas were? Sitting at the counter waiting to be brought out! And you know where our waiter was? Sitting at the bar and eating!! The poor bus boys were basically our server. They got us extra utensils, refills, boxes, dressing.. literally anything we asked. Then when we finished we sat there waiting for someone to bring us the check. Our waiter is still sitting at the bar. Eventually I get another waiters attention and he brings us the check. But it's completely wrong! At this point my mom and I had enough. We said loudly hoping our original waiter would hear that if he was taking a break or his shift ended that he should have made us aware and then introduced us to who will be helping us. But nope. So unprofessional. Worst service ever!!!! read more

See all

Decided to move on from my go to pizza places in Seaford, thought I'd give Umberto's a shot. Ordered a regular slice and a grandma pie. The grandma pie was ehhh and the slice was soggy and the size of a slice of cake. Very disappointed. On to the next! read more

Umberto's Restaurant & Pizza - Tiny slice of pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Wantagh, New York

Good food potions are a good size. The specials tend to be expensive. Ask for dressing on the side as they put to much on your salad. The red sauce is a little bland but the brown sauce is terrific. I usually get the veal Marsala which is terrific m. The room in the back can be loud so I like to sit up front. I've taken out grandpa pizza which is always good but very expensive The service is good desserts are the usual I would have given five stars but it can be loud and it is expensive read more