Theeeee best pizza and Italian food around by far! Been catering from there for 15 plus years

Calabria pizza has a really good pasta deal on Mondays. That is unless you order the same dish. Today, we ordered 1 cavatelli in meat sauce and 2 orders of penna à la vodka. Upon opening the cavatelli in meat sauce, it was a full to the top serving. When we opened the penne à la vodka tins...they were one single layer of pasta equaling a half tin. When we combined both tins, they made one full tin. This is crazy. I know it's a good deal but splitting one dish into two portions is really disappointing from a place, I've ordered from for decades. Then the pasta was so overcooked, we could have used it as paste. I don't know what's wrong here but the last two times we ordered pasta night were just disappointing and greedy. My recommendation is if you want your full meal order different dishes. read more

I ordered a large pizza here and unfortunately, the experience was very disappointing. They only have 2 sizes (personal and large). Large pie was $25, took almost 30 minutes to prepare, and honestly wasn't worth it. Veggies tasted very bland. Base was too soft . Hopefully the quality improves in the future, as I'd love to have a better experience next time. read more

See all

Great pizza! Soft crust with sweet sauce!!! $38 fir two regular pies and free delivery. Seriously can not beat it. Highly recommend!!! Service is excellent and quick! read more

Tried this place while visiting union dale, needless to say it was delicious. Services was great, family owned

Placed a pickup order for half buffalo half pepperoni pie. 20 minutes pickup the man said. I get there after 20 minutes and it's not ready 10more minutes. Okay I'm going to get a nice hot pizza I thought. After getting that pizza walking to the car wondering why my box was cold. I get home to open the box only to see half buffalo half cheese. So I call them up to tell them they got the order wrong. They let me know they didn't make a mistake. But oh it's okay I didn't charge you for pepperoni. Guess the customer is not right at Calabria! Gotcha! Thanks! So much for giving another local spot a chance. This is going straight to the trash. School pizza tastes better than this. read more

Calabria Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - North Bellmore, New York

We have ordered catered food here more than once. Always delicious!!! Never been disappointed. We can't convince ourselves to try anywhere else, cuz this food is on point. Also we love that you can swap in garlic knots instead of standard bread. Who doesn't LOVE Garlic knots??! read more

Pizza is always top notch especially grandma vodka slices. I highly recommend this slice.

Really nice staff and good pizza. Stopped in late and picked up a white slice, Grandma and chicken bacon. All were very good and tasty, my wife really enjoyed the pizza as well. Everything was hot and ready to go, great for takeout! read more

Did the catering menu for a backyard party at my house, the food came hot and on time, utensils and serving spoons included. The gentlemen who delivered the food also set up everything very nicely. Cannot recommend enough getting the ribs, they are delicious and fall off the bone, everyone kept talking about how great they were. The garlic knots were also a 10/10. The prices were also very reasonable for the high quality of food. read more

always consistently good, nice variety of pizza , friendly people, Joe the boss is usually there making pies, just an all around great local pizza place ... read more

Good and consistant. Pricing is competative. I'll be going back. I would recommend that you should at least try it.

Amazing amazing amazing Pizza! And you won't break the bank! Little hole in the wall but don't let thag fool you!

Love the pizza, meatballs, chicken cutlet slice! Have enjoyed everything I have tried. Excellent service

Well there you have it. As NY transplants we miss GOOD pizza and chicken parm and now we have a place to call the go-to. HUGE orders, friendly people (offered to bring huge order to car), GREAT pricing and GREAT food. We got the chicken parm, changed pasta sauce - to butter with mushrooms, pasta bolognese, pasta with meat sauce, chicken Marsala, zucchini sticks, garlic knots.came with LOTS of extra bread and parm cheese. Forget dinner for 4, this could have been for 12! Means we can bring some of NY to home with us out of state! And when we're back in NY - we'll be back!!! read more

See all

Why not just serve chef Boyardee. Not only can you not listen to the order and serve the right food. You combined two dishes that have no business being combined. Makes sense why you guys are on your last legs. What a waste of money. And time. Do better tomorrow. read more

I love their Meatball Parmigiana which comes with a large side salad. They give you bread, but I usually order garlic twists too.

Living in NYC my whole life I would say I'm pretty spoiled whenit comes to pizza. Outside of the 5 Boroughs it's kinda hard to find really good pizza. Most of the times it's okay but can be downright horrible at some places. In my opinion Calabria has some really good pizza. It's sauce tastes great and it's not too oily. They seem to use fresh ingredients and the crust has the perfect crunch. They offer a variety of different specialty pies as well. The prices are very good as well. At $14/pie you can't go wrong. They have a "2 slice and a soda" special and if you check their website you will find some coupons as well. Enjoy read more

A sort of hybrid of Long Island / Ny pizza. Thick tasty crunch perfectly sweet sauce and the right amount of cheese. Not a better fresh pie in the area. Great people prices and service. read more

We had the linguini with red clam sauce on the Monday pasta special. It was only $8.95 plus tax! What a bargain. Especially for clam sauce with lotsa clams and it was delicious!! Highly recommend. read more

NOW THATS WHAT I CALL PIZZA!! finally found a place that makes pizza the original correct way, from back in the day. obviously does not use that canned pizza sauce mix, plus no added garlic or onion salt that most places now tend to use. bargain of the year, 2 generous slices and a pepsi for $5.50, can't beat that. cheerful and very efficient service a plus.... typical pizza joint , for mostly quick dine in or takeout. i left happy and full!!! read more

My favorite, old school with a crust. The sauce is so balanced. Not salty, oily, or garlicky.

Hands down the best pizza on Long Island. You've tried the rest, now try the best! The pinwheels are amazing too! Very nice staff as well. read more

Calabria Pizzeria - Delicious garlic knots with marinara on the side & the perfect cheese pizza. - Pizza Near Me - North Bellmore, New York

See all

My sister and brother in law love this place mostly I think because it's conveniently located. They swear their cheese pizza is the best around. I think I might be a little bit of a pizza snob because I got used to Frantoni's large assortment of cut, sliced pizzas and my wife and children swear that Frantoni's has the best cheese pizza. The location is a small Eat in/takeout spot like a small Chinese take out spot you can eat in but would rather just be at home eating your food . Frantonis is a larger more decorated Eat in /takeout location which I I have done both many times and they have yet to disappoint my family ! read more

I've been living in Long Island for about seven years now and having such an amazing pizzeria next door is such a blessing. Like every New Yorker we have that ride or die pizzeria and this is my Long Island ride or die pizzeria. Slices are always enormous and fairly priced. The staff is always nice and helpful. I would completely recommend Calabria's if you happen to be in the area because if you don't, you'll miss out. read more

Calabria Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - North Bellmore, New York

Great pizza and people are really nice. Been going here for over 12 yrs. So yum and fresh

I've been coming to this Pizzeria since it's opened and took Annie's spot. Probably 15+ years. It's always been the best spot. Pizza is amazing. Any slice I've had was big and fresh, I can count on one hand how many times it was not fresh. Chicken Parm and Penne ala vodka are great. House Italian dressing is also great!!! Thanks! read more

I have been here a few times for Pizza and excellent. Decent prices, tastes great and easily accessible. I usually prefer Sicilian or grandma so review is based on those 2. read more

Been here twice their pizza is really good and so are their spinach pin wheels. Staff is nice and there's a big lot with plenty of parking .

I gave this restaurant two stars because the food is good. I hired them to cater my husband's surprise 50th birthday party. Not only did they bring the food late, they brought it as he was walking in and ruined the surprise. Then the kid left and did not leave me enough serving spoons so I had to go get them at the store. And to top it off, he didn't bother to light the sterno's and the food got cold because I had no idea he didn't light them. The owner was very apologetic and offered to give me a pizza but I think he should've at least offered me some of my money back. I worked on this party for the better part of the year and this delivery dude just ruined it. His apologies mean nothing. I wish I could take back the tip I gave him. read more

Calabria was one of my favorite places, one reason is because the prices are phenomenal and they're regular slices are huge!! The people that work here are very nice!! The reason for my low rating is due to the last few times that I have gotten pizza,it wasn't fresh on a Friday early afternoon!! I had a disgusting greasy slice,it came off of a full pie,it must have been sitting there from god knows when,I will not be going back anytime soon!! read more

Very exquisite taste. Love the toasted bread with sauce topped with cheese. I love the triangle shape. Definitely going to eat there again. Best pizza . read more

We gave him try after being disappointed with another pizza place. Great pizza hot fresh and not burnt. read more

Wish I could give 3 1/2 stars because that's what I believe about this pizza restaurant. I always enjoy a great Sicilian slice, but that was where they fell short for me. The dough needs to be thinner, as it got a little chewy for me. Now, that said, the traditional Napolitano pizza is excellent. I tried both a regular and specialty slice with chicken bacon and ranch; both great. I will definitely be back for more from this restaurant, but I have to admit I'm sticking with the triangles from now on. read more

One of the best slices you can get. Love this place and the service. I highly highly recommend this environment, product, and overall experience. You're welcome. read more

Consistently amazing pizza. By far the best I've had in the area. Sliced are not only large but hefty. Always fresh and delivery is super quick. read more

One of my favorite Pizza/Italian food places in Nassau County. Friendly and efficient service & fantastic food. Penne Ala Vodka and Baked Ziti are 2 highlights... Pizza is top- shelf ! read more

The staff is so friendly and nice. I've been getting pizza from here for years. The chicken wings are also really good

the staff is always very nice and the place is pretty clean (as clean as a pizzeria can get.) the pizza is always super good but my only complaint is sometimes the pizza feels less fresh than it could be. but I don't really mind, this is my go-to pizzeria and I get pizza here at least like twice a month and on special occasions, never been massively disappointed. all the food is also really well priced, I get two large slices of pizza and a drink for $5 which is crazy like in most places you can't even get a drink for $5! cheap prices, good food, can't go wrong with Calabria pizza :) read more

I Like their Pizza & Hero's. Good food. They seem to care about their reputation. Most Important. Their Food is Fresh. Not Last weeks unmarked leftover. read more