The dough is thin and crispy. The toppings are generous. The red sauce is meh. It was just so bland that it marred my pizza experience. If you go the pizza route, try one of the specialty pizzas that don't have sauce. They are delightful. They tend to get busy, so order ahead or give yourself some extra time. If it's a pretty day take advantage of the picnic tables outside. read more

Upper crust is our favorite family movie night go to. The kids love it and so do we! The ranch here is the best.

Great pizza, the crust is thin and chewy, and the staff is amazing. It is worth the drive

This place doesn't have as much indoor seating and is more of a pick-up place. As vegetarians, we ordered the Veggie Pesto and the Mediterranean, both of which were delicious and flavorful. As a call-out, even a simple order for picking up can take up to ~1 hour and so I'd recommend calling in early :-) read more

Really great pizza! They were crankin on a Friday night so be sure to call ahead. You will not be disappointed in this pizza.

Good pizza. Outside sitting was nice. Crust wasn't great. Took awhile. But Good place.

Excellent pizza, thin crust and tasty. Service was great despite the fact it was packed. People were friendly and courteous.

Best pizza in Gualala bar non. My favorite pizza is the house combo. It's Sliced perfect. Sauce and condiments cover Dow near to edge. Will not go wrong with your choice, and great customer service. read more

Best pizza ever! PERIOD. Ingredients were spot on! Custumer service was spot on. Atmosphere was perfect for a small town.

I did not expect to find phenomenal pizza driving up the 1. (Don't get lost and go to the other pizzeria on the far side of the lot. Fresh hand made pizza, a few beers on tap, and a gorgeous view while you wait. A few seats inside, I picked up a to go. Dinner and breakfast and road snacks. Noms!! Possibly the best food I had on the trip north up the PCH and 101 along the coast from L.A. all the way to Astoria. read more

If I could give 0 stars I would. BUYER BEWARE! I recommend you stay far away from this place. Owner is very rude from the moment our group walked into the restaurant because we were a group of 10. We were more than happy to wait till a seat opened up or order to go. Ended up at Miramar Mexican restaurant they were amazing and accommodating our large party! read more

Incredibly rude service, we came in 50 minutes before closing and they did not want the business. They refused to sit us and made a few rude remarks. I am not sure of the response to this review from the owner, but we never attempted to bring alcohol and I have no idea what he is referencing. read more

Me and my group of five sat down and placed our order at this joint around 6:30. the workers told us that they were kind of backed up in the kitchen which would make sense on a Saturday night. we sat there awkwardly and waited for what should have been 30 minutes at the most, but for what instead was closer to an hour and twenty minutes. never in all my 13 years have i seen such a slow pizza place. Eventually after seeing people who arrived way after us get their pizza, we got curious and asked about our pizza. the waitress walked into the kitchen and found our pizza under a pile of random things. She came out guiltily and gave us our pizza, which once was a piping hot pie, but now was closer to a cold, rock hard brick. we choked down the food like we were vultures to a carcus. The food wasn't terrible and the beer was great read more

Best pizza ever! And in my little town of Gualala. Who would have thought it possible? ( And I've had lots of experience eating pizza) Folks who work there are always friendly and welcoming. Good beer too! read more

Great pizza place with a diverse menu of fresh, hot, delicious pizzas! Order early to avoid the wait. Friendly service.

The most flavorful pizza I ever ate! I don't know but it has the most delicious and delicate taste pizza. Dough was kneaded good and not dry. Has its own flavor and texture.. the ingredients of the pizza is not cut in half. Every bite there is meat, vegetable, sauce and a very generous amount of cheese. A hidden gem we have unlocked throughout our Highway 1 Road trip. Be sure to get a pie when you are in this quaint town of gualala. By the way, they have very strict implementation of Covid19 rules. Definitely a plus! read more

Upper Crust Pizzeria - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Gualala, California

Surprisingly good. Well balanced flavor. Good crust. I asked for crispy crust and it was done exceptionally well. We got the vegetarian pizza. Good service. Ambiance typical of a pizza place. read more

while the paper plate tore apart as I cut up portions of my slice to eat, the pizza itself was stunningly excellent, one of the best pizzas I've ever had, and I'm pretty fussy about my pizzas. Bravo! I had the vegetable pizza substituting mushrooms for onions and could taste every single ingredient. wow! read more

Surprisingly good for a pizza place along the coast. I always expect it to be some super touristy, low grade meal but the pizza was top notch and we got outstanding service. Also the beach is right across the street if you want to dip your toes in the Pacific. read more

After visiting Gualala for two decades we finally ordered pizza. Three mediums fed our family of 7 perfectly. The toppings were generous, the quality was excellent, the staff was friendly! Why didn't we do this sooner? We opted for the Bonita, a pepperoni and the margarita pizzas. Great job, future trips will always include pizza night! read more

Upper Crust Pizzeria is a must for visitors who frequently vacation in Mendonoma like my family and I. Most of the dining options in the area could use some work, but Upper Crust is a winner I eat at every year. They use high quality ingredients, and their process consistently produces tasty results. A small is perfect size for two adults and runs a reasonable $20-ish after tax etc. The quality is several notches above your big pizza joint chains. Bottom line, if your family is visiting and not sure what to grab for take-out, Upper Crust is awesome. read more

We got a "take and bake" to bake and eat at our vacation rental house. The pizza was delicious. Great thin crust!

My boyfriend and I stopped in on New Years Day to grab a warm satisfying lunch. We were welcomed warmly into the shop and after some time looking over the menu ordered a small Gio pizza and Caesar salad to share. The salads are stored in a side fridge where you can grab the croutons and dressing and add it all together so it remains fresh. The pizza came out in about 10 minutes and was topped with an even spread of the ingredients and nice heat. The crust was lovely and had a nice texture. read more

Upper Crust Pizzeria - Gio - Pizza Near Me - Gualala, California

Everything was great, as usual very solid pizza only real option up there for good pizza anytime you go to very nice only place up here to eat really read more

We had the pesto chicken pizza. It had just the right amount of pesto. The pizza was delicious as always.

Super good ZA!! Nice little spot to get some food along the beach.

I get it's a small town and choices are limited but unless this is the ONLY pizza you have ever eaten in your life, then you should know this is not good quality pizza. We ordered 1 medium veggie pesto pizza, 2 large pepperoni pizzas and 20 wings.....$100!! And I thought Round Table was expensive. The pesto pizza was ok, only thing saving this place from one star. The pepperoni pizzas however were saturated in grease and minimal flavor because their sauce was nonexistent. It's like they did one tiny dollop of sauce for the entire pizza. And the wings...again dry as a bone and zero flavor because again, minimal sauce. We visit the coast and this area quite often, but this place is for sure a hard pass in our book for future pizza cravings. read more

Very very tasty. Fresh and excellent. We always buy from them . One of the best restaurant in Sea Ranch .

Best pizza in Northern California. I always look forward to getting a pizza when from upper crust when I'm In town. read more

Sea Ranch is a truly epic coastal town with unparalleled scenery that everyone should experience at least once in a lifetime. My only gripe with the town is that the dining options are somewhat sparse. Fortunately there are a few really good gems nearby in the Gualala area. One such place is Upper Crust. For really tasty pizza, it is a must try. Adults and kids alike in our family like it a lot. With the pandemic, the place does get busy and takeout times can be over 30 min. So just make sure to remember this when you are ordering in advance. read more

I love this place, I usually phone in my order for pick up and always order the Spicy Hawaiian for me and the meat lovers for my significant, the pizzas are delicious and always ready when promised. The staff is very friendly, they also have salads, calzones, wings, if someone in your group is not into pizza. read more

Had to leave an immediate review. Didnt have cash to tip and I didn't get to sign a tip for them when I ordered. So this needed to be done! Driving through the 1 and only having camp food for two days makes anything delicious. However, these guys got it down! Food was delicious! Service was awesome! The view to the beach was great! read more

I ordered a large pepperoni over the phone. Pizza was ready by the stated time. The restaurant is just off Highway 1. There is a limited amount of indoor seating but I got my pizza to go. Service was friendly and efficient but still made time to chat with some of the regulars. Pizza was good and I'm sure I'll be back the next time I'm in The Sea Ranch. read more

Great pizza and service! The crust is perfection and the toppings were super high quality. A must if you are in Gualala!

Angry little man, the owner really rude.. horrible example to his staff on how to treat customers. I felt he thought that because it was his business and he thought he was in the right he didn't need to be polite. I walk up holding a beer had no idea anything was wrong and he rudely yelled at me and said I couldn't bring it in. Mind you I didn't even realize it was an issue, gladly poured it out and apologized. Somehow that wasn't enough for him he continued to be a D!cK. I hate people like this... As a retired business owner myself it made me sad he didn't take the olive branch opportunity to step back reflect and start over with his poor attitude. read more

We ordered the blue cheese chicken pizza here to give it a try. Wouldn't recommend...it had barely any chicken and very little blue cheese. In fact I couldn't taste it, though my husband says he got a bite of blue cheese. The pizza was mostly just crust! Hopefully their other selections are tastier and heartier! read more

We ate here while a weekend stay in Gualala, CA. We had excellent service. They gave my little guy pizza dough to play with while we waited for our food, which was not long at all. I was pleasantly surprised at how fast our pizza was made. They also let my son help spread sauce on the pizza. We ordered pizza, salad and wings. Everything was yummy! read more

See all

I haven't been here in 25 years. I'm happy to say the Upper Crust has maintained their pizza quality over the past quarter century! The crust, as you'd expect, is tremendous. The sourdough base they use makes for a perfect balance of an almost crispy outer crust and soft inner crust. They've maintained their old pizzeria ambiance, you can see the staff kneading and rolling out the dough when you walk in. Things to know: -there is seating but definitely plan on taking your pizza to-go if you're party is bigger than 4 people -they do have beers and a small front porch while you wait; the tap selection was small but good. Went with a local ale, wasn't disappointed -if salad is your thing, there was only personal sized salads available -Saturday night was a 35-40 min wait for pie, not too bad! read more

We nice, friendly folks working. Pizza smelled amazing and everyone liked it. They normally have gluten free crusts which is great!

Cruised into town, first time in the area. Upper Crust was absolutely perfect, awesome staff