We found ourselves way out east over the weekend, and realized we were an hour from home and should…read morefind someplace to have lunch. We asked Google Maps what is good and nearby. We were told that Watermark was five minutes away, and people liked it. We verified that in Yelp, and sure enough, let's go. This is not the sort of place you'd find by accident - on a minor coastal road and pretty much off by itself. The parking lot was so packed that we had to give up on it and park on the road. We were told that there would be a slight delay for a table, but seeing the enthusiastic crowd, we figured it might be worth it. It was. We got a really great roomy table, and our server was a gem. Looking back over the reviews here, we got their star quarterback in Connor, who sat down at a spare chair and talked to us about what to eat. Within two minutes, we were old friends. I'm a big fan of originality in menus, and they had it to spare. I ended up with the fried chicken sandwich and Donna had the Left Coast sandwich. Ham turkey and swiss on crainberry bread. They were both delicious and too much for one sitting. Connor even offered to wrap my mayo. The vibe was enthusiastic but not horribly loud, the food was unifromly great and the service was superior. We now have a go-to place in the Riverhead area.

I recently stayed in the area for a wedding and was looking for somewhere fun to get breakfast the…read morenext morning. This place had really good reviews, so decided to check it out. They had a lot of fun options, but I got the "ultimate pancakes", which had bananas and blueberries, and also ordered a side of bacon. The service was great and food came out quickly! The onlyyy thing I wish they had was flavored iced coffee, but I was happy with the orange juice instead, so it's not a huge deal. Would definitely come back!

A Little hidden gem in The Mattituck shopping center…read more Really good food. Comfy setting. The the staff are friendly And the food is great. What more do you want? They will not disappoint you. Lots of wine to choose from.

What a great place. Food was excellent and came out fast. We had 5 kids with us and the server was…read moreso kind to them, gave them crayons to use and ring pops (at the end of the meal). Wonderful service and yummy food. We had the French dip, lobster roll, kids had pasta and chicken fingers/fries. All delicious. Will definitely be back!

I don't usually eat at the on course grill/restaurant but the Yelp reviews for this place were good…read moreenough that I gave them a shot, and I was glad I did. It is a very nice space and the staff were extremely friendly. The food was better many standalone restaurants and price were pretty reasonable. It was so good that when I was playing Rock Hill, which is 10 minutes from this course (Pine Hills), we drove here afterwards for drinks and lunch. I forgot to take pictures but the burgers looked really good! Will be back!

We get takeout from here bc it's close by. Service is quick and friendly, food is absolutely…read moredelicious and the desserts are absolutely incredible!

Cheap and cheerful. This local spot is a gem. The menu…read moreoffers plenty of variety, no matter what you're in the mood for, and the drink selections are just as impressive. Everything was fresh, flavorful, and reasonably priced. I'll definitely be back to try more of the menu.

I had just gotten off the orient point ferry and was starving. I had a burrata and tomato sandwich…read morewith shallot dusted fries. It was delicious. The fries were wonderful. Will say I got a container of cole slaw and was not a fan. Would highly recommend

We go to this place every time before a show at the Suffolk Theater. It's such a casual, friendly…read moreawesome place that has great food and drinks. The bartender Jeff is amazing and remembers us every time we go here. He's a lot of fun, and so is the rest of the staff. You can tell they really enjoy working there and are so friendly and accommodating, even with large parties like ours was that night. The steaks are delicious, and since it is a steak place, you have to try them, you won't be disappointed! Drinks are also great and service is awesome! When we tell them we have a show to catch, they are quick to serve us, but we never feel rushed. This is a great place to hang out with friends and just enjoy a casual night out with the locals.

Meatloaf dinner with mashed potatoes was ok. Salad with…read moreolive oil and salt added. Charred Steak tid bits were dissapointing. Not tender nor had any flavor. The best part was the Swiss and Artichoke Dip with the fresh fried chips .

Been here a bunch of times and we always order the same thing . I love the ambience and the history…read morewith the large bison, heads hanging in the wall/the cozy hotel vibe! Cabbage soup with bison is incredible and I don't even like cabbage. The beef burger and bison burger both taste really good and I do enjoy their steak fries when they are cooked properly. My biggest grape with this place is the service. I've never had a great waitress there. It's a small place and the service is never adequate. The last time we went there, they brought out my husband's food and forgot to put in my order. My food arrives 15 minutes later, overcooked. I sent my parents here for their anniversary year or so ago and their service was terrible as well.

Highly recommend!…read more Reservations could be made online and were easy to make. Parking was a little difficult, but that is not their fault, so I would just give yourself some extra time. The live piano, which I believe is on Fridays, was such a great touch and made the experience different than many of the other establishments in Riverhead. The food all around was very yummy. It was my first time trying bison and I really enjoyed it. It was leaner than beef yet still had so much flavor. The corn could have had a little more on it but I think it was just a bad piece. Definitely a great experience overall!!!

JULY 2026 We came on A sunny Thursday morning to eat…read morebreakfast at Lollys Hut. We had 2 coffees Pineapple juice 2 whole wheat French toast with butter and syrup Eggs. Homefries abs corned beef hash. Everything was DELICIOUS!!!

I've been coming here for almost a decade for breakfast and hope to come for decades more!…read more The proprietor Lolly is a no BS not PC owner and I love every minute of it! It's a true greasy spoon and the ambience has a nostalgic feel of the favorite moments in the past and fun new memories from the present. Food is always made to order, hot and fresh and you are not encouraged to just sit there and occupy a table if you are not eating and I appreciate that as that makes the wait time for a table not too long! But get here before 9am on a summer weekend if you really want to grab a quick bite and go before the crowd gets there!

Been wanting to dine here for a long time & it did not disappoint. I *do* wish that the fall menu…read morewas available, being that it was October 1st - just because I had seen photos of what was going to be on it, but honestly, everything we got was sublime. Our waitress was wonderful. To start, we got there lobster fritters & jamesport baked Brie which were both so flavorful and the flavors were perfectly balanced. We shared the duck confit & stuffed summer squash & I am now determined to make that squash at home! Also had butternut beer for the first time and woah. It rivaled my favorite seasonal pumpkin beer! The patio was beautiful and decorated perfectly! I also loved the skeletons that greeted us as we entered!

I used to go to this restaurant when it was the Jamesport Manor Inn and loved it. It's been a…read morewhile since we've been back and decided to try it since it is now Dimon's. We went out for a nice dinner with another couple and our friend has to be sure there are gluten free items on the menu. When I called to check, the woman on the phone, who was so nice and I wish I remembered her name, said that they had gluten free options, and they can also change some of the entrees to be gluten free. When we arrived we were greeted by a very friendly hostess, and seated in their very beautiful dining area near the outside patio. It was too hot to eat outside, but at least we got to see the beautiful outside area, which we will definitely check out when the weather is nicer. When we got to our table we met our awesome server Kim, who helped our friend with the menu and gluten free options. She was so friendly, knowledgeable and patient with all of us and our questions. When the drinks and apps came out, they were absolutely delicious. Kim is also an awesome bartender and her drinks were perfect! The apps I would recommend are the scallops, shrimp, fried mozzarella, and the mussels. Yes, we had them all and they were awesome! When our entrees arrived they were not only delicious, but also beautifully presented. Everything we ate here from the apps to our desserts were outstanding! When we were done with dinner, we asked about exploring the upstairs since it looked very interesting and we were curious about it when we first walked in. Kim encouraged us to go explore, even though they were closing, and we were so happy we did. You have to try this place, and also see what is upstairs, you will not be disappointed; it's beautiful, very unique and I also think it may be haunted :-) Thank you to Kim and all the staff for making our night really special, we will be back soon!