We've been ordering from Vital Choice for years and it used to be so good! The last 3 orders of canned Mackerel have tasted so 'off' we couldn't eat them. While they were replaced, one of the replacements was also 'off' tasting to the point of not being able to/wanting to eat them. One order of Salmon was bad as well in a previous order. We never had problems like this prior to VC being sold to a large corporation. What a shame! Searching for a new high quality, ethically sourced business to buy from. read more

The canned sockeye salmon once opened smelled and was partially raw, uncooked - can't figure that one out! It was so disgusting that I no choice but threw it in the garbage. I purchased 24 cans and threw it all in the garbage. I would never consider donating that horrible canned salmon to any food bank. Chock it up to the worst food purchase ever! read more

2 months for deliver. When arrived, ikura was extremely salty almost inedible. Cannot recommend. read more

After trying to communicate my issues directly to the company (no email available, Feedback link inoperable, no info on contact us other than Live chat with a bot) I will place my review here. I have been a customer of Vital Choice for over 15 years. Ordering online has never been an issue. Recently I have been trying to place an online order & get caught in loop of Review Order, Place Order but it doesn't go thru. The items I usually order were not available. I called customer service. They attempted to verify my personal info- address old, phone number wrong (was correct on website). Then wanted to charge me $20 on a $100 order of 12 small cans of tuna. I am disappointed that a once reliable company appears to have been eaten by the Big Fish & quality on every level has suffered. read more

The fish was hard and horrible. I'll definitely won't be ordering from them again. It doesn't taste fresh at all.

My experience with orders in Aug and Oct 2024 has been consistently unacceptable customer service. Promises made = promises not kept. Orders made were not delivered and problems not resolved. Multiple calls to customer service (reps and supervisors) resulted in new promises of a new delivery date, approx 5-7 days in the future, that would in turn, not be fulfilled. The Vital Choice brand and buying experience used to be exceptional. Since the sale of the company, their customer experience has dropped to a level of unacceptable. I hope someone at Vital Choice reads these reviews. You've lost a long-time customer. read more

If only they would use organic ingredients in their soups and chowders, i would buy them. I don't see why they don't. But they use regular milk and cream, pesticide-laden tomatoes, and factory farm gelatin. WHY?? apparently they don't realize that people who are willing to pay for their high grade seafood will also be happy to pay more for organic! read more

Used to be great but they sold out to a large corporation. Think customer service is outsourced to another country and it is so awful if not comical. I used to receive product that had 2 year dating on it. Last order had 3 months!! Took me about 6 emails to get customer service to understand what my issue was with that. The exchange was clearly was comical in language and maybe culture. I was told that I could use the product 3 years after the expiration date. The date was 'just a best by date'. I think grocery stores can not sell products past the due date, so not sure how they get away with this. Maybe non US companies sell product and use product 3 years after it expires?? I know we tend to be more wasteful, but at the prices you would think we would not have to use past expiration dates!! Will not be ordering again. read more

I have purchased many items from Vital Choice. I just received a large order yesterday, and I can confirm the negative reviews. I won't be fooled again. Their items are pathetically small, and the quality has diminished drastically. The Ikura is frozen and almost inedible. The seabass portions and the salmon burgers were tiny, as was the seafood bisque, which tasted marginal at best. read more

I'm a Vital Choice Customer for over 20 years. Ever since the sale to Flowers, Customer service is beyond bad. Incomplete records, undelivered product and no ability to resolve problems. AVOID THIS COMPANY Before VC sold out, they were the best at Customer service. Those days are gone. read more

Since 1800Flowers bought Vital Choice, it has turned into a scam organization. I ordered $900 worth of salmon that never arrived, and when I repeatedly called about my order over three months, the call was answered by boiler room employees who gave me lies for three months. I finally had to dispute it with my credit card. So unfortunate be sure Vital Choice used to be great. The new owners are scam artists, so avoid at all costs! read more

My family has enjoyed both seafood and meats from Vital Choice in the past. We are extremely disappointed with the quality of tri tip steaks we recently purchased. Meant to be a special treat, the steaks are anything but. They are chewy and tasteless. read more

Loved this company and their product. Over the last few years, I influenced friends to get their fish from Vital Choice. My last frustrating experience dealing with their new customer service AI computer representative because they didn't ship my order correctly (first time this happened) and no "repair" done led me to research and find that 1-800-flowers purchased Vital Choice. Forget good customer service. Use another company. There are good alternatives that make sure you get what you've ordered and paid for. read more

I have ordered from Vital Choice for years. Ran into my first serious problem and desperately needed to speak with customer service about sending products to a different address since it did not look like they were going to make the original date. I spent almost two hours on hold before I was disconnected. During the entire hold period I had to listen to endless advertisements for other companies. In the meanwhile I was trying to use the chat function asking for help as well. The customer service person did not seem to speak or understand English very well and after quite some time she told me she had to transfer me to a specialist. I waited for a very long time for someone to come on before giving up on the chat option. Given the high price of these products, it's inexcusable that there is a complete lack of customer service when something goes wrong. read more

I have been a long time customer...over a decade plus and since they were sold to 1 800 Flowers it has been slowly going downhill. I am beyond disappointed. The quality of the canned salmon has gone downhill to the point I can't stand it anymore. You've lost another long time customer. read more

Terrible customer service Never delivered my order, never sent replacement as promised and still dealing with it after 2 weeks. They have been a disaster since being purchased by Harry and David read more

My experience matched all the latest reviews, avoid this company. The customer service has been offshored and the product is awful. Once they sold out everything has gone downhill. read more

This used to be great but the customer service is abysmal!! My delivery was missing most of the order, even though the order was closed as delivered on the website. After 30 min on the phone trying to explain the situation to someone whose english is clearly a second language, i was assured my replacement was on the way. NADA. after another week, I called again, same drill, it took 30 minutes to explain what was going on. Same promise. Now I am waiting again and hopefully won't have to call back. So frustrating. they just lost a long time customer! read more

It is disappointing to give this low rating. I've ordered several times in years past and the service and quality of product has been excellent. Until now. My product of choice is the box of 4 --1 lb packs of salmon pieces. Order arrived. every one on the 4 packs had a nick in the plastic, exposing the fish to air and dry ice--rendering them useless. Vital Choice sent out a replacement right away--I ate two of the packs, now 3 weeks later I see the last 2 packs have air in the packaging and ice crystals on the fish because they too have cuts in the packaging exposing the fish to air. I'm getting a different fish as a replacement this time but come on . What a horrible waste of salmon. Do better. 2 stars is for customer service and the fish (that I could eat) actually tasted really really good. read more

They struggled to accept my 5 year old gift cards. Chat and live chat were not helpful. Received a timely response to an email request on a Saturday and was able to place the order via the toll free number. Good followup by the Joy L after chat told me my gift card had expired. Call them directly at 800-608-4825 for any help you might need in placing an order. read more

Before they sold to 1800 flowers they were great. Since selling the quality of the salmon is trash. The last order I received was not even edible. I called and they said it depends on where it is sourced and they will replace the order with salmon from a different source. Seriously? That was the entire reason I purchased from vital choice because they assure customers of high quality excellent sourced salmon. Well customer service replaced my 24 pieces of salmon and the next batch was the same. I will never purchase any more salmon from this company. If I could give 0 stars I would. read more

This company is terrible since being acquired by 1 800 Flowers. The customer service is sub standard, they deliver late so you food is thawed and they tell you they cannot refund your order and you have to call another department despite the support number printed on your packing slip. This is by the far the worst experience I have endured and I'm a customer that spent over $400 a month. Never again! read more

I am walking away after being a customer for years. After waiting 6 WEEKS for my order to be delivered, having to make 5 calls somewhere out of the states and speaking to people that appeared to be new to the job AND having extra charges randomly tacked onto my bill.....I am totally done. It was sooooo good while it lasted! Makes me sad in a way..... read more

I never had any issues before Harry & David purchased Vital Choice. Now, it's Horrible Customer Service! I placed an order on July 15, 2024 and paid $402.97 with the understanding that my Cases of 7.5 oz cans would arrive approximately 10/17/2024. It's now 11/17/2024 and Vital Choice has not communicated with me at all, even though they have my Phone Number and Email. If I owed them money, I guarantee they would be communicating but I guess it is not important when they already have the money. So, I called them today and the representative says " it's still on Back Order and they do not expect it until October of 2025! Yes, October 2025! When was I going to find out? Had I not called, they would have drug it on forever. How many other people are waiting like me? I got my Refund and kindly asked to be "Removed from any and everything to do with Harry & David". If this is how they do business, I want nothing to do with anything they have. There are other brands that do not take 1 year and 3 months (may be more - they were not sure as to when they would have it, that was a guesstimate. We live with all the talk of AI and Cars that drive themselves but not one can pick up a phone or email a customer to inform them of further delay? I am taking my business elsewhere. read more

In spite of the super high prices, I have used Vital Choice several times because I swallowed the hype about "wild caught / best quality". They work the snob appeal like experts. I care about my family's health so I don't mind paying more for really quality food but whenever I've used Vital Choice, I end up feeling ripped off. After several orders, I have been disappointed more times than I can count because the quality is not all it is cracked up to be and the prices are way too high. The shipping is a nightmare, the customer service it terrible and the food it not better than you can buy at Costco for a fraction of the cost. The final straw came when I ordered some fish eggs to give as Christmas gifts. The products came late and when they arrived, the fish eggs were still frozen but they were rancid. We had given our gifts before we opened ours and so we didn't actually know until we tried to eat the fish eggs. When we realized that we had given our friends and family EXPENSIVE spoiled fish eggs, we were mortified! It was so downright nasty, that gift recipients told us straight out that they couldn't eat it. I am not a roe novice and I do know what fish eggs are supposed to taste like. I usually love them but these were just plain awful. Since the fish were frozen when they arrived, I have to assume that they were rancid before they were shipped out. When we tried to resolve the situation, we got a great big yawn from Vital Choice. They never made it right but they lost me as a customer. Terrible, terrible, terrible, overpriced, snobby, and fake high-end fish. Ewe. read more

I am so disappointed in Vital Choice--a company I used to trust. They sent me the wrong product and I called customer service to let them know. I was assured I would be sent the correct product. It never showed, so I called again. I was again assured I would be sent the correct product. That was three weeks ago and I still have not received what I ordered. Now when I call customer service I cannot reach anyone at all. I've tried the "request a call back" option 4 times and have not received a callback. I may need to take this up with my credit card company. read more

The only reason I am writing this review is because my mother just asked about this company after close to a year back, and I had already forgotten about them, so I had to look up and see the damage and of course I am not surprised by the reviews.  Last year when Vital Choice mentioned that 1 800 Flowers was taking over, I sent them a message and asked WHYYYY? Why ruin your business like that? I already had so many issues with 1 800 Flowers and across their other brands in general, I knew this would be a bad decision and ruin my fish supplier. Why not sell to another fish supplier or give to a COOP? Oh right, because of the money offered and selling themselves out to 1800Flowers. I quickly placed my orders and stocked up on fish from VC before the takeover date, then told them to delete my account and data and that I would never order from them again because of them giving up to 1800 Flowers. I guess my message was received well but nothing came of my warning, regardless it was too late.  They should have done their research on this company which would have taken one 4 second google search or BBB search on how horrible it is. I feel sorry for those who did not know that VC would lose its integrity in this takeover and have experienced poor service since. Hope that others can learn from these reviews before purchasing. Since last year I have used another supplier to order sustainably caught fish for my mother and myself. read more

My wife has been a fan for years, but I think even she is done with this company now. We got a shipment of sea bass the other day and I took two pieces out of the freezer today for dinner. Both were about the size of a deck of cards--while frozen. When defrosted one was fine, but the other turned out to be 1/4" thick, but folded in thirds to make it look thick. Nonetheless I cooked it up, but it turned out to be so tough and rubbery neither of us would eat it. This stuff is expensive, so being gamed by this company doesn't go down well. From here on we'll be buying fish from local markets where we can see what we're getting. Caveat emptor.... read more

I have bought salmon from Vital Choice for well over 10 years and always loved the product. I am sorry to say that is not the case any longer. I ordered Cooper River Salmon which is expensive but delicious. I don't know where the company is getting there salmon now but I venture to say it is not Cooper River. Made it for dinner last night and no one could eat it. Ended up throwing it away. I now the company is no longer privately owned and will no longer order from Vital Choice! read more

I have been a customer of Vital Choice for several years. I ordered $250.00 worth of Salmon and Chilean Sea bass as you all know is very expensive any where you buy it from. I received this order today it was supposed to arrive 2 days ago and when I opened the box it wasn't even cold. The 15lbs of dry ice was gone. I called them because according to their web site they will make it right, they offered to refund the shipping cost which I told them I had already paid for the passport option which gives you free shipping. Then they came up with 20% back. So, I get back $48.50 back from an order of $250.00 which is laughable. I won't be making anymore purchases from this company unless I receive a comparable refund. How they think 1 person can eat 12 pieces of fish in 2 days is unbelievable. Mary H. read more

I have been a customer of Vital Choice in Washington State for many years. I stopped buying online over the pandemic for myriad reasons. I placed an order over the weekend, today I received a notification from FedEx indicating my package is in transit, origin point is HEBRON, OH. I trusted Vital Choice and didn't mind paying more because I knew I was receiving quality FRESH salmon. Shirley over the phone just told me that they have frozen salmon at her facility and they ship it from there, I mentioned it could be sitting there for six months and who would know, her response was "not that long", so five months, one imagines is acceptable to the new Vital Choice. - The new automated chat is awful, robotic responses are never helpful - The new outside sourcing of reps is not helpful, people are unable to understand or respond adequately as they are probably elsewhere without the foggiest idea of what is being discussed. Too bad, all good things come to an end, this is one of them. read more

In the summer 2024 I ordered fish and salmon oil. It took a long time to arrive and the fish came eventually but without warning and no updated tracking. The salmon oil came a month late. Aug 2024 I reordered the salmon oil thinking it would take a month to arrive. January 2025 it still hasn't arrived and they changed my estimated arrival at the date for the fourth time. The most recent ETA was February 1, 2025. I just found out that they canceled my order January 1st but did not refund me. They claimed they already did refund me via PayPal. They are trying to keep $125 and that just stinks. I'm getting the runaround from the company. They can't prove have they refunded me. PayPal has no record of any refund from vital choice (or their parent company Harry and David or 1800Flowers) but only the initial charge from 5 months ago. PayPal is now getting the runaround from them. I would not do business with them again. Very shady business dealings. As an I'm sorry for jerking you around they offered to sell me a fruit basket for 40% off, the nerve of them! read more

Have been ordering salmon and other seafood from Vital Choice Seafoods for years. Their quality has gone down the drain. It is not worth the price anymore. Mediocre at best. Will not order from them ever again. read more

We used to love Vital Choice! We got supplements, fish broths and the frozen foods from them. Since we had done it before, recently tried to order the omega 3 test online (which was a great service that they provided) and realized it didn't exist anymore just like many other products. So we called the customer service to figure out what is going on. They wouldn't tell us that the company was bought out. Instead, they kept saying "I don't know which product you're talking about". When I insisted for them to look up my orders on my customer account, they finally told me that those no longer exist because the company was bought over. Our entire family was using the supplements and food products of the original Vital Choice company for over 20 years and that is why it is very sad to say that we no longer will be buying anything from them as the quality and the vision is completely diminished. Very disappointing!!! read more

We have tried numerous types of fish at Vital Choice: Salmon, Salmon Burgers, Sole, Haddock, Scallops and Rockfish. And, after enough orders finally realized that none of the fish is fresh, as its caught and then stored in a warehouse - either on the west coast or east coast until it is sold. This could be 6 months, which is why the fish is rarely consistent in taste and quality and on many occasions has that "fishy" smell or arrives with freezer burn because the packaging is not shrink wrapped. Good, fresh fish should NOT smell fishy. Although their refund and replacement policy is stellar, Vital Choice just does not live up to the price point they are charging. The plus I will give them is that at least the fish is not farm raised and their salmon burgers have minimal, organic ingredients and make it a more economical choice for getting some healthy salmon in your diet. read more

HORRIBLE EXPERIENCE!!! I have purchased from Vital Choice for years. Loved their products and they had great customer service. And then they joined up with 1-800-Flowers. And it all went to hell! And it did so quickly. I always bought enough to qualify for free shipping. Now if I don't join the Passport program I have to pay for shipping. While scrolling through salmon options I don't need to see the cheap junk from the other vendors. I am looking for salmon, not a cheap wooden box with my name on it. The new site is c**p. I had reward points with Vital Choice. Those are gone. I assume 1-800-Flowers did away with them. Vital Choice had a good thing going. And then they blew it. I am done. No longer will I purchase from Vital Choice. I hate giving the one star. They did not earn it. read more

I gave vital Choice 1 star because there wasn't a zero star option. I did not get what I ordered and after several phone calls, I received part of what I ordered-but it came thawed out with no dry ice or any kind of ice. That order will have to be disposed of as I have no clue how long it has been unfrozen read more

Im all done after so many years of being a loyal customer. I was hoping that the last 2 shipments were just a fluke but I now see for sure the deterioration in the company since they were taken over by a corporation. This is my last order. I placed a large shipment for the 20% off sale which arrived completely defrosted. Fedex partly to blame as it took them 5 days to deliver. Customer service is outsourced to a foreign country where the agents dont understand the English language which causes them to put me on hold while they find someone who can understand what I am saying. The replacement order invoice was wrong and the delivery date was wrong. Tried to get that fixed - useless efforts. The replacement order arrived with no dry ice left. Fortunately the fish seemed to still be frozen but 6 salmon pieces were missing. So had to call AGAIN and be put on hold AGAIN. The fish used to be nice uniform pieces; now they are the oddest and weird shapes which I cant serve to guests. read more

Since they were bought, by 1-800-Flowers, the shipping costs became laughable. Used to get great deals, on coupons and free shipping. They were never the cheapest, but since the ridiculous extra costs, I have found an alternative. read more

I have been trying to get off of the catalog mailing list for more than a year. I have called 6 times and been reassured that I would be off the list, just got another catalog. So frustrating. Horrible customer service. read more