When you've been driving by a spot and have been wanting to try it, but there's no parking in site... you decide to make a special trip on a Sunday evening only to discover its just basic bland pizza... I could've went to the supermarket and bought a frozen pizza with less hassle and better taste.... read more

The bf and I were definitely excited to try WTP out, so it's unfortunate I wasn't as wow-ed by the food itself. We dropped by on an early Sunday afternoon and were able to order right away. Here, all the "pies" are available by the slice at $4ea (or you can order a medium or large whole pizza). I ordered slices of the Buffalo Chicken and the Notorious BBQ Pizza, while the bf ordered Buffalo Mozzarella/Tomato and the Regal Pepper Farm (currently a specialty). I thoroughly enjoyed the BBQ and the bf enjoyed his Pepper Farm. However, the Buffalo Chicken was extremely lackluster and so dry, I couldn't even finish the slice. Essentially, the slice had 1-2 pieces of breaded chicken (not seasoned with buffalo sauce) on top of the pizza, which was only slightly drizzled with buffalo sauce and blue cheese. Where's the spiciness and hot sauce as described on the menu...? The Mozzarella Buffalo pizza was nothing special and I'm happy it was the bf's slice and not my own ($4 for something that tastes like it's from Manny & Olga's late-night...eh, not good!). Otherwise, while this isn't something necessarily impacting my rating, the layout was confusing for ordering (seemed backward), so I can understand other Yelp reviewers' sentiments. I also think others had the same problem since every group/person who came in to order had no idea where to order/who to order from and the woman slicing pizzas kept telling every person what to do. Maybe invest in "order here" and "pick up here" signs? haha. read more

The pizza was fantastic. The place was clean and their were lots of people. The drinks are ok but the pizza is a lot better

I have to agree with Leah K. - I was not satisfied with the tough/rubbery, overcooked (or maybe just sitting for a long time) $20 pizzas I was served. I called in an order for myself and some work friends - a couple pies, wings, salad. I was not given an estimate of how long it would take, so I walked right over (10 minute walk) and ended up standing around for about 45 minutes. That's right, about an hour for two pizzas,1 order of wings and 1 salad. I'll try to describe the scene for you.. total chaos, probably three times over maximum occupancy, I mean packed! - someone is blasting music, but only the first 10 seconds of several songs, like build me up buttercup (god, how appropriate) for the first 15 seconds, then quick switch to the next track, like someone skipping past the songs they don't like. I have no idea where to go or who to talk to about picking up my food, I see some people with those pager thingies, do I wait in this line? I was able to get a staff members attention to ask about my order. A few minutes later, a different person walks past me, dressed like a manager (no uniform or branding on him) called me by my name and said he was taking care of my order. Great! On my way, I thought! Nope.. I'm only 5 minutes in, at this point. Fast forward 20 minutes, the place is starting to clear out from the lunch rush, I'm still standing around, my co-worker is complaining about getting back to work, a random woman walks up and says "Do you guys have a huge order or something, you've been here a long time!" Yes, that's right, we were standing around so long, people became curious about us.. lol. Anyway, 10 more minutes pass, before we meet General Manager Jeff! Yay! He's comes over to "personally take care of me," He asks my name how long I had been waiting. "I've been waiting a pretty long time," I answer, after providing my name. Jeff apologizes and takes off, to return with my food, around 5 minutes later. After recapping the order, he offers this: "ask for me, next time, I'm the general manager, and I want do something special for you." Oh.. okay.. next time? How presumptuous.. you must think you're the only place to get lunch in Crystal City! Jeff, the other thing, when you know about a mistake and acknowledge that mistake with your customer, the general rule in the hospitality business is to do something about it, not dare me to come back and deal with your place again, hoping I may receive "something special, next time," instead of frustration and regret. I understand the situation.. The place just opened, they're SLAMMED busy, new staff, etc (reason for my merciful two star rating) but management needs to figure out how to handle the volume without it impacting the quality and experience. You're charging people a pretty good amount of money for pizza. I expect more than something I pull out of a box from my freezer and make at home! Thanks, but no thanks. read more

WtP is one of the best pizza joints in the area. The ingredients are fresh, the dough is perfect, and the sauce is delicious. They also have a terrific beer selection if you're into fine pairings. Specialty pizzas like butternut squash make it a destination. They are a little on the pricier side but you're paying for a top notch food experience. The service can be slow and parking is tough but patient pizza lovers will be rewarded. read more

Perfect crust! Tried the pepperoni and ham/pineapple pizzas - delicious! Great beer too.

I came in for lunch today. It was kinda busy but I still received good customer service which I was impressed with. They have the Pizza Pizza Fizz deal- two slices of pizza and a handcrafted soda. I ordered the mushroom slice and the white pie slice. I love the face they have the handcrafted sodas made to order..I got the cream soda-my only compliant about that was that I wish they put more soda water. Moving along, the pizzas. The mushroom slice was good, the white pie was so so. It had almost a semi sweet taste and I guess it was because of the ricotta cheese. It's a good lunch deal, they're pretty quick too. I'll return next time and try another kind of pizza. read more

I was craving pizza on a Sunday night which is what led us to We, the Pizza. We were interested in delivery but they don't deliver to Alexandria (right beyond the airport) so we opted for carryout. Overall the pizza was good. Pros: - Quick service at least for carryout. - Open later (until 11pm) on Sundays which is a rare find. - Pizza by the slice option which I would definitely recommend because the pizza is filling! Two slices lasted me two meals. - Pizza was alright a slice or two should be filling enough per person. - Reasonably priced side salad for $4. Cons: - Given the size and doughiness of their pizza the "pizza on tour" options sound disgusting (pico de gallo pizza, cajun chicken pizza, China poblano spicy Mexican pie). I'm a firm believer in stick to what you're good at. Keep things simple! Add more appetizers instead of these pizzas! - Again keep it simple. The homemade sodas usually = gross. - Expensive lunch specials compared to other pizza specials in DC, MD, and VA (trust me I know!) $10 for 2 slices and a homemade soda (yuck) or $10 for a slice, side salad, and homemade soda (again yuck). Most places I prefer are in the $6-$8 range for the same thing. - Not enough appetizer options. The menu is salad, wings, and pizza. Given the heaviness of their pizza it'd be nice if there were some lighter fare options. Unless you're like my fiancé and famished on a rare occasion, wings and pizza are too much together. At least have a caprese salad or some sort of veggies as a side option! read more

As usual, the pizza here is great. I get the peppers and sausage, and the BBQ pulled Pork. Always a good lunch for $11.

Great great pizza but the delivery service cannot be trusted. I've had for totally separate and isolated incidents with massive lateness and wrong orders/pizzas. So just pick it up or do slice at a time, but great pizza!! read more

Great place to stop for a quick lunch or dinner. I had a slice of the White Pie (10/10 recommend if you're like me and love ricotta) and a 2-knot order of the garlic knots (note: they take the word "knot" literally) and it was a bargain at $9. Definitely will be back! read more

Went on their first cc monday lunch slam. Performance? I thought they did a great job dealing with new staff and the massive amounts of people excited to try out the spot. I went to the opening party for their first location about 4 years ago and since then the key to this pizza has always been CONSISTENCY. It is just really good, unique pizza and I'm happy to add the place to my lunch rotation. Judging from the crowds, I'd bet Spike is pleased. read more

This is my third time visiting this location. It's always been late at night just before they close and have had a positive experience every time. This time my friend and I met Jeff, who is the store manager. He was super accommodating and friendly! Saved our souls. Thanks Jeff! read more

I think We, The Pizza generally does a good job. The staff are always friendly, and four bucks for a good-sized slice ($3 for cheese) isn't bad for this area. Some of the pies, however, look like they have been sitting there for a LONG time. I know they pop the slices in the oven to heat them up, but I try to opt for the slices that look the freshest. Suggestion for Management: For dine-in customers, please offer metal utensils, not the cheap plastic ones. Cutting the pizza with a plastic knife and fork is mission impossible. read more

Try buffalo chicken pizza I love it . Also their cream soda are good. Lunch special 2 slices and soda for 10$

Pleasantly surprised as we were starving and stopped at the first spot we found! I would advise ordering a whole pizza, so it is fresh. It is obvious they use fresh ingredients! We ate the entire pizza in less than 15 minutes! You will not be disappointed. read more

The cheese pizza is AMAZING! Great atmosphere - really clean, comfortable and a very polite staff. I go here nearly every time I'm in the area and constantly take friends and family with me - they all love it! Highly recommend! read more

One of the BEST pizza spots I've been to in the DC/VA area!! The Pineapple and Ham Pie is Delish!!

The customer service at this place is what really impressed me! We ordered a pizza (sort of a complicated order) and got the wrong toppings. We let the staff know and they apologized and quickly made us another one. And, they even allowed us to keep the pizza with the incorrect toppings; not all places do this but I always appreciate a restaurant that does, otherwise the food goes to waste! Pizza was pretty good, fun to try all the different combinations! read more

We have been anxiously waiting for the Crystal City location to open and were not let down! Such a great vibe from the second we stepped in. Greeted with a smile by people who look like they genuinely enjoy their work. And the pies are fantastic. I personally recommend the buffalo chicken and the regal pepper farm. Will definitely be coming here on a regular basis. read more

I waited for a long time for this place to open. My coworkers and I are huge fans of Good Stuff Eatery so we expected great things...and EXPECTATIONS FULFILLED!!! The pizza slices are HUGE! I am a big guy...6'3" about 250 pounds...so I can eat! I couldn't even finish 2 slices. The specialty sodas aren't my thing...but they do have fountain drinks. The manager, Jeff, is fantastic! The staff is learning but still got my order right and pretty quick. Every week my office has GSE (Good Stuff Eatery) Wednesday. Now we have may have to change it to GSE Tuesday to make room for We The Pizza Wednesday! read more

Can only review delivery service and pizza. While it does take a while for delivery (30-45 min) it is to be expected, they email you a tracking link so you can know when they are en route!!! The pizza is AMAZING. Forest mushroom is my favorite but all of them are so good. The dough is perfect. Love we the pizza. Can't recommend it enough. So happy I live in delivery range and don't have to deal with crystal city parking! read more

Convenient to a lot of the Crystal City hotels (including the Marriott where I was staying). Service was quick and I liked the pepperoni, but not the Greek pizza. Also got a side Greek salad which, strangely, had what I think was dressing on the bottom (even though I asked for it on the side). read more

This is a fantastic pizza place! I was here for a business trip and ate here twice. The honey ham and pineapple was great-flavorful and the crust was just crispy enough. The service was fast and friendly. read more

I would not recommend this place to my friends or family. Pizza was expensive and the taste below average. The service was very slow and the whole joint looked somehow unpleasant ( somebody may say gross). Average pizza high price and not clean environment. read more

I'm here staying in Crystal City for a week. I was craving pizza and this place smelled so good! So I first tried to get delivery to my hotel online. I guess I was out of the area...or possibly there is no delivery at this store (I don't know). So I walked there. I ordered a whole pepperoni and it was delicious. I wish they had a place like this at home. I don't know what to say about specialty pizzas, I'm an old fashioned girl, but I would definitely come back for more from this place. Looks like friends, couples, and families like this place. I went about 8pm on a Tuesday. There was a steady stream of customers. I'm only here for 3 more days and I have 1/2 pizza to eat later so I won't be back this week...but I will definitely be back when I come back to town. read more

My partner and I are vegan, and we called to order a pizza for pickup. The person who answered the phone was incredibly patient, knowledgeable and accommodating. The customer service alone would make me recommend this place to a friend, vegan or not! read more

Highly over-rated, in my opinion. A decent place for a quick slice of pizza. We'd not return. It's OK, just nothing special. Very limited seating. read more

Great Pizza! Love this place. Our go-to pizza. We get the slices delivered and they are always a hit. The service and staff are also excellent and extremely friendly. read more

Stopped in on my way to the Metro system while I was in town for the conference. I had the 4-cheese pizza (I think that was the name of it). It was really good. The cheese was delicious, the crust cooked just right, and the flavors all blended together well. It was even more awesome that the pizza slice was worth only $4. Most of the time pizza is more expensive. I wish we had one in the St. Louis area is my only complaint. This is a great place for someone looking for a meal on a budget. read more

This place is quick and easy but seating is limited for groups larger than 4. The pizza is thick and doughy and their topping selection is pretty good. I got a lunch combo which was more than enough food. I got a slice, a side salad and a soda creation. I must say their strawberry lemonade soda is delish! I was on a business trip to DC so I probably won't go back there again. There are so many other places to choose from. read more

The pizza at We the Pizza is one of the best in the Arlington area, there aren't many places that can make a good pie around here if you grew up eating pizza in NYC, Long Island, or NJ. The price isn't too bad is you get a specialty pie because they are all the same price so it's a better deal to get one loaded with all the toppings you like. read more

Great pizza, especially for this area. I live in the neighborhood and frequently order. They always get my specialty order right and they have extremely personable costumer service. If you are unhappy with their product they fix it! Rare these days... read more

When my boyfriend and I got there we originally ordered two salads however the cashier said they were out we asked for wings the cashier responded by saying they were out so the only choice we had were pizzas. However our pizzas came out so oily and greasy. I understand pizza is supposed to have those two contents however not to the point where I'm dabbing it with my napkin to remove the excess oil. read more

Update on 7/29/2015. Went back today after receiving an email from the owner that staff was re-trained & new pizza making procedures had been put in place after my original review. Wow what a difference. The pizza was a night & day difference compared to my original visit. The slices tasted amazing. Lots of flavor. Not too much oil. Not chewy at all. Crunchy. Perfect amount of sauce & cheese on the pizza. I event had another Sicilian slice & that tasted amazing. I would now recommend this pizza place given the improvements in quality. On the side note, very impressed by the owners action to recognize bad review, deduce quality issues and then put a plan in place to improve quality. Wish more restaurants acted like this or learn from We The Pizza's management style. Keep up the great work. Can't wait to eat here again. read more

Fabulous veggie pizza and great staff! We enjoyed dining here! They even handled a big group well!!

Took 15 minutes to heat up my pizza, it was just barely warm, and dripping with grease! The staff managing the ovens looked overwhelmed and seemed not to know what they were doing. I won't be back there. read more

It's pretty ho hum pizza. Your pizza craving will be filled because it's edible, but it's nothing to write home about. I ordered two pieces and a beer and gave VA their 11% sales tax and was $14 poorer...kinda expensive for what it is. read more

Good pizza. Lousy service. NEVER call in an order. They never take down and make the order beforehand. And they are very rude. This has happened at 3 times to us. read more

The atmosphere was typical Arlington style. The wings were GREAT but the crust on the pizza was pretty tough.