Pizza was so good! Definitely returning to try more flavors! Ambiance was nice and the pizza place art on the wall were fun to look at

On my way home from visiting my sisters I was crazing a pizza! My usual location was closed, however this one was open and it was on the way...I tried to place my order online, but because it was near closing...so I wasn't able to... Walked in and they were kind of busy for a Saturday night & close to closing...i was just thankful they still had quit a selection of yummy pizza available. Just 2 cheese slices for me please. After making it home and enjoying my pizza, i realized I should have ordered the large size! Hahahaaa!!! Hahahaaa!! The pizza is thin, good flavor and I don't need to pick the pepperonis off for flavor lol the Margherita pizza is yummy too! Plenty of veg options! Appreciate the combo option that comes with a drink... I think Andy's Pizza maybe my favorite pizza! ;)))) Happy Yelping! read more

Pretty decent location for an Andy's pizza not a lot of parking but really close by the neighborhood so you can easily grab some slices. They have a decent amount of seating. It's not a very big space but they have seating if you choose to eat there. They also have oregano and chili flakes, but no additional Parmesan at the tables. They have some pretty good combo deals. I ordered the two slices plus wine for roughly a total of $14. I had said a specialty pepperoni slice and they gave me just a normal pepperoni and when I asked what wine are included the person at the register said it was any of the wines and told me to pick it up at a different counter behind me. I waited for someone to man the other counter and someone didn't appear for at least five minutes. When I said that I wanted the Chianti red they said that it could only be the cheapest reds that they have. I think that they should have better disclosure. It still wasn't a bad deal but more transparency would be nice. Overall, the pizza slices were so pretty good. I just think that they could have more transparency when it comes to what is included in a combos. read more

Andy's Pizza - Old Town - Pizza Near Me - Alexandria, Virginia

See all

I have to be honest, I have NO IDEA how this pizza is so highly rated. First of all... the location isn't very nice inside. It's dirty there are hardly any places to sit. There are pizza boxes everywhere in dining room and one gross trash. The employee we interacted with was rude and standoffish. He said they were out of Margherita pizza... at 7pm on a Saturday. But, they actually had it. Ok... I got my Margherita and burrata slice and it was pretty tasty. I like the giant dollop of burrata on top... but burrata could make anything taste good!! It's creamy and melty. We ordered a half cheese half pepperoni and it came out BURNT on the bottom. And it's incredibly greasy. My entire paper plate was COVERED in grease. When I alerted the same employee that the pizza was burnt, he tried to tell me that's how they cook them. Lol. They made us a second pie and it was OK. Again, super greasy, and not much flavor. I expect more from NY style pizza. We won't be back!!! read more

Had the Buffalo crispy chicken slice. Very large slice, mozzarella, provolone, ricotta, crispy chicken, buffalo sauce. Very fresh and tasty. Had a kale salad with goat cheese and lemon dressing. It was very good, a lot of cranberries. Service was outstanding with a smile. Atmosphere laid back with music in the background. read more

Andy's Pizza - Old Town - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Alexandria, Virginia

If you're in the DC area and don't stop at Andy's Pizza, you're doing it wrong. This place nails it every single time--crispy crust, zero flop, and just straight-up perfect slices. You can actually pick it up and eat it without everything sliding off, which already puts it ahead of most spots. And let's talk about that deal: 2 slices and a Coke for $10? That's hands-down one of the best values around, especially for the quality you're getting. It's the kind of combo that keeps you coming back. I make it a point to stop here every time I'm coming through DC, and it never disappoints. Simple, consistent, and ridiculously good pizza. read more

Andy's Pizza - Old Town - Pizza Near Me - Alexandria, Virginia

See all

Stopped by Andy's Pizza in Alexandria on a cold night while in town for work. I'm from CA and it was my first time in the area. I noticed a steady flow of people going in and out, which is always a good sign. The staff was friendly right away and suggested the 2 slices and a Coke deal, solid recommendation. I also ordered wings. I went with traditional buffalo, which were good, but I should've tried the Old Bay wings since that seems like the local move. Tyler, who I think is the manager or owner, was very nice and welcoming. That kind of hospitality stands out, especially when you're new in town. Overall, great quick stop for pizza by the slice. Good vibe, friendly service, and a spot I'd come back to next time I'm in Alexandria. read more

Andy's Pizza - Old Town - Outside - Pizza Near Me - Alexandria, Virginia

See all

Definitely worth stopping by for a slice at a reasonable price! Not much seating but the pizza is great and has become my Old Town go-to if I don't want something fancy. read more

Andy's Pizza - Old Town - Pizza and lemonade! - Pizza Near Me - Alexandria, Virginia

While visiting National Harbor, we were craving some authentic New York-style pizza, so I did a quick Google search and found Andy's Pizza--about 10 miles away in Alexandria. The drive was easy--just off the interstate and only a couple miles once you exit. Parking wasn't the best (street parking only), but I was able to run in and grab the pizzas pretty quickly, so it wasn't a big deal. We ordered three pizzas (since they only come in one size): cheese, pepperoni, and their "carnivore." Now, I will say...that carnivore pizza was missing a few things to truly be a carnivore in my opinion--it only had sausage and pepperoni. But hey, it still got the job done. The pizzas came out hot, fresh, and delicious! The crust had that perfect crisp, and the flavor was definitely on point. Service was great too--the gentleman at pickup was kind, made a little joke, and told me to enjoy, which I always appreciate. All in all, it was a smooth, satisfying experience. A solid 4/5! I'd definitely be back and would recommend if you're in the area! read more

Andy's Pizza in Old Town is a fantastic pizza spot in Old Town, Alexandria. We ordered the pepperoni and sausage pizza as well as the white pizza, and both were absolutely delicious; fresh, flavorful, and perfectly cooked. The inside is cozy, warm, and nicely decorated, making it a great place to sit and enjoy a meal. They also offer wine, which is a nice touch and pairs well with the food. Overall, everything was excellent, and we truly enjoyed our experience. We will definitely be back! Service was quick and polite and they offered Veterans' discount to my husband which is an added bonus. read more

See all

Thin, crispy, and amazing. Also, pregnant wife strongly recommends the strawberry lemonade. read more

Andy's Pizza - Old Town - This was an amazing slice of pizza but it disappeared before I could capture it - Pizza Near Me - Alexandria, Virginia

Andy's pizza is absolutely delicious. The crust is thin and crunchy but not hard. The Mushroom and onion pizza has a white sauce that is not overpowering; all the ingredients are balanced. I also had a slice of the Burrata Margherita. The additional burrata cheese is worth the additional $1.50. Next time, I plan to purchase an entire pie. read more

Andy's Pizza - Old Town - Mushroom and caramelized onion pie - Pizza Near Me - Alexandria, Virginia

Stopped here after an event nearby to get a slice of pizza for dinner. Love that they sell pizza by the slice. I got the 2 slice +coke special for $10. First slice not pictured because I was eating halfway and realize I forgot a picture I forgot to ask for ranch but when I told one of the employees he bought it to me no problem. The service was quick and fast and everyone was very polite. While I was eating I was amazed at how many people came in and out and the staff handled it with ease. There is plenty of seating whether you are solo or with a group, and everything is very clean. read more

Andy's Pizza - Old Town - Pizza Near Me - Alexandria, Virginia

Unfortunately this place was so unorganized during our order, they weren't communicating with each other and got all confused causing a big backup with orders. We didn't get one of the slices of pizza we bought and they weren't paying attention, so my husband had to get back in line and ordered another slice. So we ended up double paying due to their mistake. Pizza was ok but not great. Wouldn't recommend trying this place out too many frustrations. It's a great location in Old Town just needs some changes! read more

Andy's Pizza - Old Town - Mushroom and Onion Pie - Pizza Near Me - Alexandria, Virginia

See all

Solid by the slice joint! Their crust is crispy and has the slightest bit of chew on the edge. Yum! My only disappointment was that the slices weren't bigger. My eyes wanted the slice to be bigger but really a single slide was really all that I should eat. We dropped in for a late lunch and had 3 slices between 2 of us. Their cheese was excellent for a cheese pizza. The right amount of cheese and sauce. Simple and delicious. The margarita had big leaves of basil and the buffalo chicken was covered in chicken. Props to Andy's for a perfect lunch. There's a large community table some smaller tables and two bars along the window and side of the dining room for seating. read more

Andy's Pizza - Old Town - Margarita, cheese and buffalo - Pizza Near Me - Alexandria, Virginia

Really good NY style pizza in the DMV. Several locations in the area. I really like this location, the place is super clean and the people are super nice. My daughter loves the crispy wings and I love that I can buy pizza by the slide. Other sides are delicious too. Definitely fresh ingredients and the crust is perfect. The place is small, but nice for a quick bite if you're in the area. I really like the variety of local beers, in draft and cans. read more

Andy's Pizza - Old Town - Wings - Pizza Near Me - Alexandria, Virginia

See all

Great pizza! Buy it by the slice or get the two slices and a beer for $12! BEST DEAL IN OLD TOWN!!!

WWOOWWWWW!!!! Sooooooooooooo F'ing gooooooood. Perfect crunch, perfect sauce, perfect cheesiness and perfect workers. The two men who attended us treated us like close friends and were sooo warm to interact with. That pizza though!!! Run, sprint, speed or scooter your way to Andy's. Your only regret will be leaving after you've devoured 3 slices. Walk those calories off baby, it's in a very nice area. read more

I'm not a pizza person but the crust on their pizza is crazy good. Also for a price of $4 dollars per slice, it's a perfect stop for some quick lunch. Nice place to sit next to a window alone or hang with some friends on the booths. read more

Andy's Pizza - Old Town - Pizza Near Me - Alexandria, Virginia

See all

Already was a fan of Andy's pizza and now I've fallen in even more in love with the Old Town location. The seating area is really spacious. They offer fresh lemonade with your slice. The team was friendly. I had the cheese slice and a buffalo chicken slice. The buffalo chicken was by far my favorite with so much flavor. As a girl from Jersey who loves a good pizza slice, Andy's is a great option until I can make it back up north. Thank you! read more

Andy's Pizza - Old Town - Buffalo Crispy Chicken Pie - Pizza Near Me - Alexandria, Virginia

See all

Andy's pizza was a great lunch spot to hit after exploring the area. I got the pepperoni special and the Caesar salad which can generously serve two people. There was plenty of seating available on a Tuesday during lunch hour and service was quick. read more

Andy's Pizza - Old Town - Pizza Near Me - Alexandria, Virginia

After hearing so much about Andy's Pizza, I finally checked it out a few months ago and I have not been able to get pizza anywhere else since because Andy's Pepperoni Special is that good! This location was the first time I went to Andy's. Order the pepperoni special. You will love it! There is street parking only. Seating is VERY limited and we had to take our food to a bench outside, which was fine as the weather was good that day. Ordering was chaotic and difficult from how crowded it was that evening. Lighting inside is pretty dark too. Overall, food was 5/5 and Andy's Pizza is the best pizza I've ever had! read more

YES!...YES!...And more YES! Andy's is my favorite pizza spot in the DMV area, and the best thing is they have multiple locations throughout. The touch of sourdough in the crust is just simply amazing. The have great walk-in/walk-up specials at the Old Towne Alexandria location where you can get two slices and a drink for like $10, which you can't beat. This location has seating but is rather on the small side. Parties of 4 or more might have a tough time finding seating, so take that in mind. The staff is quick on point and nice, I've never had a problem in the many times I've been there. Pro Tips: 1. I personally like the taste of their pizza when you get the whole pie rather than the slice which essentially is quickly reheated. 2. Their pizza on the reheat is top tier, which is another reason to get the whole pie. They have oven instructions on the box but, just listen to me...Pre heat an air fryer at 400 pop the slice in for about 1-2 minutes and it's perfect just like as if they reheated it at the brick & mortar. 3. Follow steps 1 & 2 It's understandable that a whole pie may be too much or out of the price range but trust me it will be worth it in the end for 2nd dinner later or lunch/dinner the next day. You can't go wrong here. read more

Andy's Pizza - Old Town - Pepperoni Pie - Pizza Near Me - Alexandria, Virginia

Quick and friendly service from the young man running the store front. They have a clean eating bar, fantastic pizza! read more

Andy's Pizza - Old Town - Carnivore Pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Alexandria, Virginia

delicious pizza!! i'm picky with mine and they have a great carriage and flavor. my favorites are the mushroom one and the buffalo chicken one. really want to try the diavolo this location is better than other ones i've been to and the slices are better sized! the only issue is that sometimes they overcook / burn my slices when reheating read more

Andy's Pizza - Old Town - Pizza Near Me - Alexandria, Virginia

I was really excited to try Andy's pizza. I heard good things about it, and have been wanting to try it for a while now. I ordered the pepperoni special, which was very good. I ordered it to go and ate it around an hour later, so the crust was a little bit tough and hard to bite through, but it still tasted really good. I liked the hot honey quite a bit, but it was pretty spicy. I would definitely come back again, and would highly recommend trying it! read more

See all

Hands down the best New York style pizza you can find in the DMV area. The crust is absolutely spot on, sturdy with no flop, crisp on the outside, and soft and chewy on the inside. Each bite gives you that perfect balance of crunch and flavor. The cheese is rich and evenly melted, offering a satisfying pull with every slice. The ambiance adds to the experience, cozy, casual, and full of that classic pizzeria charm. You can smell the fresh dough and hear the buzz of happy diners, which makes waiting a little easier. Service was a bit on the slower side, but given it was a rainy weekend rush, it's hard to fault them. Totally worth the wait for the best pizza in town. I'll definitely be back for more! read more

Andy's Pizza - Old Town - Pepperoni pie - Pizza Near Me - Alexandria, Virginia

See all

I flew in town to visit some family and they ordered the pepperoni pizza with honey for delivery. I must say this is one of the best pizzas I had in my life and it's definitely a top 10 Pizza Pl. I've had pizza everywhere from New York to Chicago and Italy. This was fantastic. I would love to have it delivered to my home in Texas if I could. read more

Great ambience and delicious pizza! I appreciated the quick service as well, definitely coming back soon. read more

Andy's Pizza - Old Town - margarita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Alexandria, Virginia

I can't believe it's taken me so long to not only learn about but try Andy's Pizza out! It's a quality pizza by the slice joint that you can also get full size pies, chicken wings, chicken tenders, and salads from. Nobody told me about the lemonade situation. I ordered the strawberry lemonade thinking nothing much of it and was shocked with pure childlike delight at the sight of the lemonade in a 24oz plastic kitchen storage container! It was a feast for the eyes and for the tastebuds as well since it tasted perfectly balanced in terms of sweetness and tartness. Don't sleep on their Old Bay Fries. They are crisp, seasoned well, and massively portioned for the price - great for sharing. I'll stop in to get a slize of pepperoni, but I much prefer to be able to get a whole pie of the Diavolo. Their generosity in the calabrian ricotta make this a unique tasting pizza that's good fresh, reheated, or cold. The ceasar salad isn't anything over the top, but it is a large, reliable salad if nothing else to help balance out the heaviness of everything else on the menu. read more

Andy's Pizza - Old Town - Diavolo - Pizza Near Me - Alexandria, Virginia

See all

5 stars all across the board. Just moved to the DMV & my husband was craving a good slice of pizza. This exceeded our expectations. Easy to find street parking, super cute pizza shop, cozy chill vibes with great music. Margarita pizza was our favorite, but the pepperoni special & the mushroom onion were just as good! Service was also great, nice guys. We will definitely be coming back :) read more

See all

Great pizza and I go for the crust the take out is efficient and fast and I was amazed by how friendly the staff was. I ordered a large pizza with the works and it was delicious. read more

Fantastic pizza, absolutely packed and my pie was still out in 15 minutes from the time of ordering. I had three slices after getting back to my hotel (3 blocks walk), still warm and super crisp. No flop! It's still crisp now that it's cooled off, 40 minutes later! Delicious sauce, not spicy, burrata and basil leaves truly finished this pie. So damn good! read more

Andy's Pizza - Old Town - Burrata Margarita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Alexandria, Virginia

Amazing spot! I stopped by real quick and grabbed a slice of burrata margherita pizza. It was delicious--I was in NYC the day before, and it was comparable to the slices I had up there. Inside had a simple setup but still a cohesive pizza-shop-style vibe. Their assembly line system was efficient. I recommend! read more

Andy's Pizza - Old Town - Burrata Margherita Pie - Pizza Near Me - Alexandria, Virginia

Staff were all working hard and were super friendly and patient while I was taking forever to decide what I wanted. This is the second location I've been to and it was my first time trying the burrata margarita pizza and let me tell you it's the best pizza slice I've ever had!!! They had high tops and booths you could sit in and it's the perfect quick little casual lunch/dinner spot while walking through Old Town. Will be back soon! read more

Andy's Pizza - Old Town - Burrata Margherita Pie - Pizza Near Me - Alexandria, Virginia

Visiting the child and needed a quick dinner idea. Child suggested this and being a pizza snob I said yes. Functions like a Chicago deep dish in that you tell them when you want to pick up. Walked in and it reminded me of a NYC pizzeria. Slices and calzones in a case for your choice. We ordered the carnivore and pepperoni special with burrata and hot honey. Both were delicious and as close to NYC I've had since moving to the South. Would definitely go back and eat in to see what it tastes like hot out of the oven. Very impressed with dough, sauce, and cheese ratio. Slices are huge! Well done, people! read more

Andy's Pizza - Old Town - Or - Pizza Near Me - Alexandria, Virginia

See all

Quick review - super good, crispy slice. Best I've had in the area. Indoors is a little cramped but beer and wine served directly from a standup cooler. Different lines for slices and whole pies is great around dinner time, let's service go quickly! read more

I love this piece of place always come on my lunch break best pizza in Virginia you guys have to check it out read more

Andy's Pizza - Old Town - Pizza Near Me - Alexandria, Virginia

The pizza here was supreme. The staff is also super helpful. My only negative is the cleanliness but the place was packed and I'm not taking off a star because we loved the pizza!! read more

Probably my favorite pizza place in the DMV area. Amazing pizza every time. Love the sausage and pepperoni, and the white pizza. Andy's just has the best tomato sauce, and a great, thin, crispy crust. Especially appreciate the Monday slice + draft deal. Always good vibes at this location, and super chill, friendly staff. Thank you for bringing great pizza to my neighborhood! read more