Pizza wasn't great but it wasn't terrible either. Half a slice of cake for $7 didn't help their cause. My son wasn't too happy with it. read more

Old Chicago Pizzeria - Half a slice - Pizza Near Me - Alexandria, Virginia

NO JOKE!!! This is not the same place. Same name, but 100% better. The doubleburgers are perfect. Fries perfect. The calzone ... perfect. Friendly greeting by Amin. Seats inside. Easy to pick up. Folks at Ourismann Jeep told me this place has changed. Glad I stopped in. Prices are reasonable. You will be glad that you gave this place a try. read more

See all

I ordered here a couple times in early 2025, and the burger was very good. The bun and the beef in particular, on their "chicagos charburger" were better than most burger places. Their fries had a soggy texture to them, but despite that were still good, too. The pizza was decent, too. And the steak topping was also good. Unfortunately it seems since this past summer they have changed ownership or just changed the sourcing for their ingredients. The burger is completely different- it is almost unbearable. The bun and beef patties have drastically changed taste and quality wise. I can no longer recommend dining here. read more

I visited Old Chicago Pizza and brought a friend from out of state to try it. We had a great experience! The pizza was amazing, fresh, flavorful, and definitely the best part. We also tried the steak and cheese, and it was really good too. My friend loved everything, especially the pizza, and said they'd come back again. Nice atmosphere and a great spot to enjoy a meal. Highly recommend! read more

After 34 minutes of waiting I asked for a refund since they were still unfreezing my burger sauce whatever that means. Insane

I recently ordered and noticed there are new owners. The toppings on the meat lovers pizza isn't what it used to be. This was my go to place for thin crusted pizza but not anymore. Other items have a seasoning that I don't like either. Another place bites the dust. No thank you. ‍ read more

Tonight I forgot my previous bad experiences with the food from here, and ordered by mistake from them. I ordered a bowl with gyro meat and rice, and I was expecting a normal Mediterranean bowl like you can get from so many restaurants. That's what the menu led me to expect. Instead I received a serving of dried out rice, dried meat, with iceberg lettuce and chopped mushy tomatoes. Save yourself the annoyance i experienced tonight. I forgot that the food from this building is never fresh. read more

Old Chicago Pizzeria - Dried rice, dried gyro meat, soggy tomatoes, and iceberg lettuce - Pizza Near Me - Alexandria, Virginia

I had the steak and cheese sandwich. 8.5/10 Had flavor and a lot of steak. I will be going back for another one.

We wanted to try a new pizza place and old Chicago did not disappoint. Pizza was really goo, crust just the right amount crunch.

FOOD IS AMAZING!! Service is nice and welcoming. The atmosphere and ambiance is homey and cozy.

I fought to find meat in this absolutely awful meal The portions are very small and they don't even take into account the reaction. I can't even call it a disgraceful restaurant. read more

This place has amazing pizza. My food is always made quickly and correct and tastes wonderful. I live close by and i'm glad to have them as my neighborhood pizza place. The customer service is always great. Highly recommend! read more

Service is quick, food is above average and I'm pleasantly surprised with the taste.. definitely my "Go To" places before heading home late a night read more

Old Chicago Pizzeria - Steak and Cheese Sub with Fries - Pizza Near Me - Alexandria, Virginia

Regrettably, cannot recommend with so many better options out there. For the cost, the Pizza was skimpy on ingredients and generally pretty disappointing, and seemed much like a typical frozen pizza. read more

Awful service. I ordered my food over a hour and a half ago. No one delivered it. Old Chicago pizza does nothing to treat the customer good after screwing up their order. Im warning you, please do not waste your money at this restaurant. The manger called only to say I'm canceling your order after a long unnecessary wait. This place is the worst service in Alexandria. read more

Phenomenal! Have been a customer for a few years and they continually improve. Great food, very fast delivery. Bravo!

Not great pizza, but better than Dominoes.... Prices are reasonable and the service is pretty quick.

Entertainment (the longstanding coupon book and app, dating back to the 1960s!) offers a buy-one-get-one-free coupon for this place. Location claims to know nothing about Entertainment and hence won't honor it. I do not believe that Entertainment made up this location's participation; rather, some prior manager authorized it, and that's now been forgotten. Too bad for them, they should sort it out between themselves -- and give the customers the benefit promised. I'd give 0 stars if I could -- drove over, waited, ultimately left with nothing. read more

Pretty good pies. They have a nice crust and a good sauce. I have dined in and carry out from this restaurant. Friendly service. They do delivery. Please support this place during these crazy times. read more

Old Chicago Pizzeria - the front of the restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Alexandria, Virginia

Definitely not Chicago style thin crust pizza. Very disappointing. The crust is much thicker than thin crust Chicago and if you order anything other than a plain cheese pizza be prepared to be underwhelmed as the toppings are very scarce if that. The strawberry cheesecake is basically a strawberry syrup drizzled over a frozen piece of store bought cheesecake. read more

Delicious! I love calzones and pizza from this spot. The only complaint I can think of is that toppings for the calzones don't go close enough to the edges? read more

Terrible , pizza was dry as shit no toppings overcharged me bathroom didn't work. Terrible customer service told me to "get fucked" read more

Omggg!!! The customer service I received here was the best customer service I've received in months!!! Got the chicken Philly sub & it was delicious!!! My brother got the steak Philly pizza & loved it! We tried the Buffalo chicken pizza and it was the best pizza I've had in forever!!! My Daughter got a small pepperoni and she ate the whole thing which she doesn't normally do! Everything was so good!!! OMGGG HIGHLY IMPRESSED! 10/10!!! Loved it !! I wish we had one where I live!!!! read more

Extremely well run, friendly & hard working staff. Fantastic Chicken Kabob & subs. Still haven't tried their pizza, because everything else is too darn good. Usually order from here, but decided to stop by & check it out. They're always super busy and hustling around the restaurant banging out orders, but the manager (owner too?) was still social, and apologized for the wait, despite me arriving early expecting it. You guys deserve all the success! read more

I love their pizza! I always order the BBQ Chicken pizza and Buffalo Chicken pizza. It never disappoints, and they open late so whenever you have late cravings for pizza, this is the spot to order. read more

We are big fans of this chain! We order here pretty often when we have guests because they have a great variety of food. Excellent comfort food. We have had everything from pizza, to subs and all the fried food (gimme all the grease! Haha) The delivery and prices are competitive and the one time it took them a little longer they comped is with some garlic bread. Will continue to order from them; I suggest you do the same!!! read more

Ordered for pickup while visiting. Didn't take long to be ready, maybe 10-15mins. The pizza was good! Somewhere between NY style and typical dominos like pizza. And was pretty cheap, $10 for L. However I did think the pizza would be bigger than it was. But it satisfied 4 people! read more

Old Chicago Pizzeria - Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Alexandria, Virginia

I went back to the restaurant Old Chicago for the 3rd time on Huntington Avenue to get a tuna sandwich I like and check and see if they were wearing face masks. Sure enough the cashier or owner was not wearing a mask again. This time I asked him where is your face mask?, Oh he said I can't breathe with those masks, I said you're lying to me you can breathe just fine. Then I said no face mask means no business and on my way out somebody else was driving in, I told her that the owner was not wearing a face mask in the building and the woman got back into her car and left, two customers are gone. I am proceeding to fill out another online form to complain to the Virginia Authorities. https://redcap.vdh.virginia.gov/redcap/surveys/?s=Y4P9H7DTWA I like Old Chicago, I do not know why the employees do not wear face mask, they have social distancing arrows all over the place. They could be asymptomatic spreading COVID to their customers and they can be on the receiving end of this virus. It is bad enough that customers may refuse to wear face masks, but the owners? COVID ALERT @ Old Chicago. read more

I have no idea why I haven't reviewed this place before but I'm doing it now! They have the best Gyro this side of Greece! And don't let me stop there, their fries are out of this world! Their side salad is so fresh and crispy, i'm surprised there's not a couple of bunnies attached to it when it's delivered to me! I have nothing bad or negative to say about this place. The food is always delivered well packed, on time and piping hot. I highly recommend it. A plus for a delicious, economical meal! read more

This could be the worst pizza I've ever eaten. And I've eaten a lot of pizza. I heard the Lasagna is good, but I can't be sure. read more

Started working in Old town recently so have slowly Started finding lunch spots. This place was on DoorDash and had a lunch special for a small 1-topping pizza and soda for 6.99$ so I gave it a try. For the price it was not bad !! People need to stop expecting this place to be gourmet. The pizza was hot and soft. I didn't like the jalapeño poppers but I liked the mozzarella sticks. Try it out ! read more

Old Chicago Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Alexandria, Virginia

See all

Ordered some late evening appetizers after a recommendation from the front desk at Club Wyndham. Very pleased with each of them. The mozzarella sticks were some of the best we've ever had. I was also surprised with the onion rings, very good, real onions. Grape leaves were good, rice needed a little more seasoning. Can't give any opinions on other foods but I'd expect them to be good. read more

This is my new fave pizza/wing place. Their wings are awesome, just the way I like them and their calzone is one of the best I've had, try the veggie calzone soon, you won't regret it!!! read more

Amazinggggg and hot! Delivery took exactly 45 min and it was delicious!! We got a large supreme and XL pepperoni. I recommend asking what specials they have. Delicious fresh pizza! read more

I had two bites of the pizza before putting it down. The marinara sauce on the pizza tasted funny, not to mention the toppings didn't seem to be cooked completely. All together it was worse than Pizza Hut and Dominos pizza, and that's saying a lot because both those "pizza" establishments make dough-marinara concoctions that they dare to call pizza. But to shift gears and explain why this place still got 3 stars out of me, I will point to the wings. Like other reviews mentioned, the sauce and wings are separated so that they don't get soggy when they arrive (I ordered delivery though Yelp). Upon my first bite, I was in heaven. My hot wings hit every taste bud with perfection. I didn't even notice that the failed pizza didn't register until I looked down at my messily two bits. I ended up throwing the rest of the pizza away and deliciously eating my wings. I would recommend going to this place only for their wings and the fact that they deliver to my house. read more

It was cold last night when the late night pizza craving hit. Around 30 degrees, in fact. So I was surprised when I met the delivery person at the front door of the building carrying the pizza in its box with no sign of an insulated bag or anything else used to keep it warm. It was not surprised that the pizza and wings were cold. The pizza itself was okay, but nothing special. The sauce was watery, which wasn't great. Topping amounts and cheese were pretty good. But the wings themselves were a disappointment. I ordered spicy wings. These had absolutely no hint of spiciness about them whatsoever. Did they send me the wrong wings or are their spicy, hot wings just really mislabeled? I have no idea. read more

I've been a customer for years. The place has been great until the past few months. The girl taking orders over the phone cannot get an order straight. It takes nearly 10 minutes to place an online order because she doesn't listen. Recently, she completely messed up my take-out order and when I called her out on it, she gave the worst "I don't care" attitude that I've seen. I'm done with old Chicago pizza until management makes some changes. read more

A friend who grew up in Brooklyn recommended this place during a recent conversation about great local pizza. I spent some years earlier in life working at a small family owned pizza place so I'm always trying to find the great mom & pop pies. I think I've found my new go-to. Their white pizza was excellent. The right amount of garlic and gobs of melted ricotta. The surface was perfectly browned in the oven and the dough had that flavor like they were using the right water for the job. Also tried the eggplant Parmesan. Still under COVID seating restrictions I had mine to go and when I got home it had held up - spaghetti in the bottom of the tin pan was warm with a great sauce. The eggplant which was layered above the pasta was still crispy on the outside and the inside wasn't that slimy texture some places serve. The cheese on top was just as perfectly brown as the pie. If the food remains consistent during future visits, I think I've found my new favorite pizza place! read more

Warning: Despite the restaurant's name being Chicago Pizzeria, the pizza is NOT Chicago style deep dish. Why wouldnt you just name the place "Huntington Pizzeria" or just plain "pizzeria"? At least then it's not false advertising. Hmm. The cheese is not that rich, flavorful mozzarella like Papa Johns or Dominoes. The crust is rather flat and bland (again not like Chicago style at all). BUT the bacon was way better than the bacon they serve at dominoes....so that's a plus. Anyway, our server never checked on us after dropping off our food. Soooo all in all....very sub-par and will probably try somewhere else next time. read more

Old Chicago Pizzeria - Xlarge three topping pizza for $12.99 - Pizza Near Me - Alexandria, Virginia

See all

I've been looking for a pizza with a doughy crust and I found it at old Chicago pizza