Cancel

Open app

Search

What's Cookin'

4.3 (63 reviews)
ModerateNew American, Delis
Closed • Closed

What's Cookin' Photos

WHAT'S COOKIN' ATMOSPHERE

What's the vibe?
Quiet
Outdoor seating
Good for kids
Dogs allowed

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - What's Cookin'

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
Yelp app icon
Browse more easily on the app
Review Feed Illustration

Reviews With Photos

Egg and cheese on rye bread
Meg A.

Great breakfast sandwiches! Staff is super friendly, everything was made fresh but was still done very quick. Great place to grab breakfast and pickup a prepared meal for lunch/dinner.

Outside roadside sign
Dave J.

Amazing place to grab a bite to eat! The food here was good, and they serve breakfast and lunch options all day! The food is really good, and the salad is made to order. The price is also very reasonable for what you're buying, so it's a great place to stop if you're out for the day and want a quick bite to eat. The service was very nice as well, with the staff friendly and helpful to patrons as well as enjoyed being around one another and working together. Communicated order well and got us our food in a timely manner. Additionally, when I entered, staff was sanitizing countertops and tables, which let me know that the establishment is clean The ambience was nice. Small indoor seating area. They had multiple freezers and refrigerators running, which had a slightly annoying hum when trying to eat or talk, but not deafening; worst case scenario I could eat outside or in my vehicle and doesn't effect the overall atmosphere for the business. Very pleasant venue overall and decorated to fit a beachside aspect! Will come again!

 a grocery store
Jared M.

Wow. Delicious. Cute little diner off the side of the road, with the nicest people around. The breakfast sandwiches were fantastic. And the iced coffee has frozen coffee cubes! No watered down coffee for the drive. Definitely worth a visit!

Iced coffee with coffee ice cubes
Lindsey S.

So yummy so glad we found this spot. The cleanest, cutest spot. Staff was super friendly and the food was AMAZING!!! We will be back for sure!!!

Boss Man
Matthew C.

We made a pit stop at What's Cookin' this weekend while traveling through Madison, CT and could not have been more delighted! Nestled away in its private little corner, this small deli is kickin with major flavors on its diverse and full menu including sandwiches, chili's, soups, sweets and more! Not only can you eat at the deli (either inside OR outside) but they also have freshly cooked frozen/refrigerated options for you to pick up and bring home to enjoy with family and friends. Definitely recommend this hidden treasure! Enjoy!

 a display of food

Exploring Connecticut and came across What's Cookin'. Decided to pop in for a bite. I was impressed with all of the gluten free options they had in their ready-made cases. Several paleo and gluten free dessert options too. Several people came in for to go orders as we ate our breakfast panini and split pea soup. Both items stayed hot throughout, which is unfortunately rare in many dining establishments. All employees were nice and helpful. Would definitely recommend stopping by if you are in the area.

Chicken cutlet sandwich

See all

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

14 years ago

Helpful 2
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

14 years ago

"It's great if you like over priced cafeteria food. Food is lousy and service slow. Save your money and go somewhere else"

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of Bobbi G.
3
126
254

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Really good ham & cheese omelette with home fries! But today they forgot my whole wheat toast.

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

7 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

8 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

13 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

13 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

12 years ago

Helpful 1
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0
Photo of S T.
0
1
0

9 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 1
Oh no 0

10 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

11 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

13 years ago

Helpful 0
Thanks 0
Love this 0
Oh no 0

Page 2 of 2

Ask the Community - What's Cookin'

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for New American 7,180 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Guilford Bistro & Grille Cafe

Guilford Bistro & Grille Cafe

4.0
(183 reviews)
2.2 mi
•$$

Started with the Beet Salad which we started. It contained goat cheese, baby arugula, candied…read morewalnuts and apples. With a thick balsamic dressing. It was very good. The main entree was Chicken Cristin. I ordered it over pappardelle. It had two pieces of white chicken meat in a sherry wine sauce. It was covered with spinach, mozzarella, artichoke hearts and roasted peppers. It was delicious. For dessert I ordered the Gelato. The said 3 scoops of gelato, however it was 3 small spoonfuls. Order 3 different flavors. Except for the espresso, they all tasted the same. Not worth the money. The meal was very good, disappointed in the dessert I ordered. Service was good and they had off street parking. Would have given it 5 stars except for my dessert .

Whoever said this place never disappoints should have been at my table today. I've come here many…read moretimes but the last 2-3 times it has been lacking....and I always get the same thing..Bistro Salmon. Today, small, thin piece and the sauce was missing the usual honey sweetness and overly mustardy. Squash barely cooked and a few pieces of asparagus that looked more like string beans. Basically not much on the plate for $33. The service was also bad. The waitress was absent from visiting our table in the beginning , middle and end of our meal, had to ask her for water, she never asked us how our meal was and was, didn't clear our plates etc. it was poor all the way around this trip. Maybe chef was on vacation with the usual servers!!

Photos
Gelato
Gelato
Papardelle Rustica
Papardelle Rustica
Guilford Bistro & Grille Cafe

See all

Lobster Landing

Lobster Landing

4.3
(678 reviews)
5.9 mi
•$$$

We ended up coming to Lobster Landing twice during our trip -- once on the way to Mystic and again…read moreon the way back -- which probably says everything you need to know. It's definitely a little more expensive than some of the other lobster spots we tried, but I honestly liked the food here the most. The lobster meat is lightly seasoned with what tasted like butter and lemon, and it all worked perfectly together without overpowering the lobster. The bun was incredibly soft and loaded with so much meat that it was practically falling apart in the middle. We got the half-pound lobster roll both times and would absolutely order it again, but it is $60. The clam chowder was also excellent. It's creamy without being too thick, and you can really taste all the ingredients. The hot dogs seem to be really popular -- almost everyone was ordering a lobster roll and a hot dog combo. My son loved them so much he had two the first visit! The outdoor seating and water views make it such a relaxing place to sit and eat, and there's also a market on-site where you can buy lobster and shellfish. Definitely one of our favorite stops and somewhere we'd happily return to.

Great lobster roll, the meat was perfection, the bun unique and hearty, nice views of the harbor,…read moresturdy seating. Wish there was the option of fries but I get it more money on ventilation etc. they offer bagged chips, lobster bisque (which I wish we got to dip in) the tables are also a bit gross on some (due to weather and birds) but since it's outside this is inevitable. You're here for the lobster and water and you get it. Pure summer vibes.

Photos
Lobster Landing
Lobster Landing
Overcast in Connecticut - 4/19/2026

See all

Overcast in Connecticut - 4/19/2026
The Shipwright's Daughter

The Shipwright's Daughter

4.4
(421 reviews)
35.2 mi
•$$

We'd heard from friends that Shipwright's Daughter in Mystic was a must-try. Wow, were they right…read more From the warm greeting at the door to the beautiful decor, the experience started strong. We were seated at a lovely table for two overlooking Main Street - watching people stroll by from that elevated perch behind glass felt almost cinematic. The real star of the show was the food, which is ultimately what you're there for, and it delivered. The menu offers plenty of options without being overwhelming. I started with the Crispy Pig's Head as an appetizer - a bold choice that turned out to be outstanding. For my entrée, the bucatini with seacoast mushrooms, sherry, parmesan, mushroom cream, and fine herbs was perfectly cooked, and carried a subtle but deeply flavorful sauce. And the housemade sourdough with poblano honey butter? Absolutely outstanding. To be fair, our server took a little time to warm up but found their footing and gave us everything we needed. Parking in Mystic on a busy weekend night can also be a challenge and expensive. Neither is reason enough to skip this one. Ship Wright's Daughter is exactly the kind of restaurant Mystic deserves. Don't wait for a special occasion -- just go.

I really didn't want to write this review, but potential patrons should know what they can expect…read morewhen working with the event staff at Shipwright's Daughter - if they plan to have a private dining experience and event there. My husband and I got married last December. We decided we would hold off on celebrating with our family and invite everyone out from California to join us for a weekend full of activities in Connecticut and a special dinner at Shipwright's Daughter during Memorial Day weekend. We contacted the restaurant's events team to work out high level details starting in late January - to book a private room and hold a date and time. From the get go, the communication we received from the event staff was dismal to say the least. Not only did the events manager misquote the estimate for the room reservation, she came back and asked for a much higher price (up charging by an additional 30% of the original minimum fee) two months after we confirmed and discussed the date. She then explained it was due to the holiday weekend. Our date had never changed from the moment we inquired, so we would have appreciated knowing this upfront. Over the course of several months (and an absurd number of emails and a few calls), we tried to solidify the menu and wine selection and made multiple attempts before hearing back from the team. It was about two weeks before the big event when we were able to confirm a menu. It was about four days before the event that we heard back from the beverage director, but by then, my husband and I had already decided we would bring our own wine bottles, not wanting to leave it to chance with this team. I won't go into further details about the frustration we felt regarding their system for communications (they use an internal system that doesn't make it easy for guests to know who is copied on emails and who sees what). That is something I hope they will work out. When the big day came, I walked into the room and noticed there were a number of chairs missing, so I counted the chairs. They had an incorrect number of chairs for adults and not enough high chairs for the toddlers. We had requested a specific number of these chairs (weeks prior and mentioned it multiple times in writing), and I thought it was safe to assume that this was a basic checklist item for events set up. I was dumbfounded in the moment. I couldn't help but wonder what else they were going to miss or mess up that evening. It was disappointing to have our family members wait while the staff scrambled to pull other chairs into the room. From the time it took to take everyone's order from the set menu, the time between courses being served, and the attentiveness for pouring water and wine - all of it was a miss. The level of hospitality that we expected from a restaurant so recognized for its incredible food and approach to sustainable sourcing was completely overshadowed by the lack of attention and care by its staff - since day one of planning this event. Even a few of our family members commented on this during the dinner. At the end of the day, we felt like an obligation rather than welcomed guests, and that is mainly why I'm leaving this review. We had been patrons of Shipwright's a couple of times prior to this event, which is why we chose this establishment - to represent the best that Connecticut has to offer, when it comes to a dining experience we could vouch for. We no longer feel that we can recommend this restaurant. If you care about hospitality, I would recommend looking elsewhere.

Photos
Interior
Interior
Smoked clam dip
Smoked clam dip
Steak Tartare

See all

Steak Tartare
Brushmill by the Waterfall

Brushmill by the Waterfall

3.4
(210 reviews)
11.8 mi
•$$
Locally owned & operated
Locally sourced ingredients

Had a wonderful dining experience at Brushmill by the Waterfall! They offered an amazing selection…read moreof gluten-free options, making it easy to enjoy an incredible meal without compromise. The staff was absolutely amazing--friendly, attentive, and genuinely welcoming from start to finish. Great food, outstanding service, and a beautiful atmosphere. We can't wait to come back!

Great ambiance as you walk in by the waterfall. Three rooms depending upon the vibe you're looking…read morefor; dressy dining area, casual bar, or cozy informal den. We chose the latter in a corner window right by the falls. The service was outstanding. From the moment we arrived, to helping us find our seat, to our server helping us with the menu, to the manager coming over and talking with us to make sure everything was ok. I liked how the server first checked to see if we had any time restraints along with food allergies, etc. Speaking of the food. We started with the clam chowder and scallops. The chowder was the best I've ever had. Plenty of meat and seasoned perfectly. The scallops were amazing. The manager later told us that the scallops were the only thing that had been on the menu since day one. They tried to rotate them off once and the people went nuts. We moved on to the duck and salmon. Both were delicious. Sides were perfect as well. I'd love to write about dessert, but unfortunately, we were stuffed. They looked good, but that will have to wait until next time.

Photos
Upstairs in the restaurant
Upstairs in the restaurant
Brushmill by the Waterfall
Delicious coffee martini

See all

Delicious coffee martini

What's Cookin' - newamerican - Updated July 2026

Loading...
Loading...
Loading...