Who knew that going to a pizza place would be your best option in Sisters Bay for GREAT cheese curds? I have enjoyed many a cheese curd in my day, and the curds here are at the top! they melt in your mouth! Oh, yea the pizza is pretty good too! they have great outdoor seating and a nice staff! read more

What some nice people and excellent pizza! It was later on a Sunday and close to closing time. When we called in our order for pickup they were out of some toppings so we said that was ok. When we picked up the pizza they said someone did not pick their order and they would like to give that pizza because of not having all the toppings on our order. How nice! The one they gave us was our origin ordered toppings. Thanks again. read more

Good pizza, quick service and a fun environment. If you find yourself in this area, check them out!

Food was spectacular. Very fast service. Great ambiance. Definitely coming again. All staff was nice and overall expierience was amazing.

The small pizza with every thing was excellent and the salad with feta cheese,cherries,and pecans was one of the best I have ever experienced. The young ladies serving were very good and worked hard. We sat outside since the temperature was 73 degrees. The outside patio was clean with nice tables. read more

We ate dinner here last week with a friend. Our pizzas were fabulous. Hubby ordered a meat pizza and I ordered a vegan pizza. We loved them and look forward to another visit before we head home next week. read more

Wild Tomato - Vegan pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fish Creek, Wisconsin

Had 2 pizzas. Both great. Also had Mediterranean salads which were huge. Good service too. Only issue was we had to eat outside with all the flies read more

After walking several trails in Penninsula Park, my husband and I decided to have pizza in the town of Fish Creek. He'd looked up restaurants in the area of the park, and discovered wood-fired pizza at a place called Wild Tomato. There is a small parking lot next to the restaurant. Most of the tables are outside, picnic-style wooden variety. A hostess greeted us, and suggested we choose an outside table because the inside seating was filled. She estimated it would be about fifteen minutes before a table became available. We settled at a picnic table, but decided the day was too cool and breezy to enjoy lunch outside. We did get an inside table about ten minutes later. The music was oldies hits from the 70s, some from the 60s. The pizza oven was in sight from any table in the room. Unfortunately, there were more flies inside than outside. We waved them away during our entire stay. A waiter came within a few minutes to take our drink and pizza order: we decided on a Paisano pie, with an on tap Blue Moon beer and a glass of sangiovesi wine. The lady making the pizzas never stopped creating them the entire time we were there: she grabbed a ball of crust dough, stretched it, filled it, and tucked it into the oven, then checked the new orders and started the next one. The manager came over to welcome us. Our pizza arrived sooner than we expected, and it was very good: the crust was toasty outside, tender inside, and the sauce was excellent, not too sweet or too acidic. We ate all but two pieces, and took the rest back to stash in the refrigerator at our hotel. Fish Creek Wild Tomato gets our vote for pizza in Door County, especially after a long walk in the park. read more

Wild Tomato - Paisano pizza, Wild Tomato at Fish Creek, WI. - Pizza Near Me - Fish Creek, Wisconsin

See all

After the wait on my last review go check that out we had good service throughout the rest of the visit. Food was great too keep doing you!

I was absolutely starving when I got here and although the wait was not ideal I can't complain. Our server was very nice; I went with my family and we're a large group but he was still able to be a great server. The vibe is on point, so fun and cozy. The cool breeze while we sat outside made the warm pizza all the better. We got the cheese curd appetizer and it was very good; pizza was nice and yummy. 8/10, top tear restaurant, highly recommended by me. read more

Wild Tomato - Cheese curds - Pizza Near Me - Fish Creek, Wisconsin

We had reservations at the local theater and ordered to have later after returned from the theater. Delicious D-Lux Pizza, Garlic knots and Large Greek Salad. So nice to have to warm up after the play. Every restaurant was closed after the play! We were so happy with our choice! Thank you! read more

While the parmesan knots were good, and the Mediterranean pizza was decent, the tables were dirty. The young lady who seated us had a permanent scowl on her face and acted as though it was a major inconvenience to seat us. Our middle-aged waiter was AWOL most of the time, and we waited quite a while for a second drink. The $75 bill was overpriced for the unsanitary surroundings and lethargic service. read more

Poor inattentive service. Very dirty restrooms. Had to flag down server. Food was very good.

Delicious, creative wood fired pizzas. The menu selection was extensive, and the flavor combinations on the pizzas were a good blend of traditional and non-traditional options. The portions were very generous, and our server was friendly and efficient. He showed up when we needed him, but left us alone to talk so we could enjoy our time together. All together a pleasant experience! read more

Pizza with no taste and the sauce is super watery and bland. Service is fine and eating outside was nice but a little chilly. All these positive reviews saying it's the best pizza they've ever had are truly like a twilight zone episode. It's serviceable passable pizza for the area while on vacation but ranks no where near even the best pizza in the state or in neighboring Illinois let alone the whole country. It's mediocre but not terrible. Don't get the margarita though, try something else. Also the parmesan knots taste like a sock. S.T.A.B.B. read more

Awesome experience and great food. Our "must stop" when we visit Door County. Highly recommend!

Excellent pizza. One of the best I've ever had. We went to the one in SisterBay in Door County Wisconsin. There was a bit of a wait to be seated but it was worth it. read more

Exceptional pizza and salad and a delicious hibiscus lemonade. Server was awesome. Only complaint was there was a couple black hairs in the pizza, but that did not bother me. read more

Wild Tomato - Greek salad - Pizza Near Me - Fish Creek, Wisconsin

See all

Visited sister bay and went to wild tomato twice because it was so good, the service was fast, bathrooms were clean, and GOSH did it live up to all the good reviews!! Must go if you are a pizza lover! read more

This has always one of my favorite spots in door county. I look forward to the pizza each time we go. We passed up several other newer pizza places because of how great the pizza is. What we received on our last visit was terrible. We brought the pizza back to our room and ended up throwing most of it away. The Margherita pizza did not have any basil on it. That is one of the two toppings so we were quite disappointed. The restaurant itself appeared under staffed and overwhelmed. All in all it was not a pleasant experience. We paid too much for bad pizza. I hope this was just a bad night. read more

The pizzas are phenomenal. The bread plate was hit and miss. Most of it was very good, but the bread with tapenade on it was so so. Maybe my family and I are not so much into tapenade. Anyway, we tried to get a table and the hostess could see me waiting, but my text didn't go through as fast as they cleared a table and went ahead and seated some folks that just walked in, so I was a little irritated by that, but otherwise we didn't have to wait too long to get seated. the salads were good. The waiter was pretty good too. read more

Ordered the margarita pizza on this rainy day as the waiting was over an hour and we were in no mood to wait that long so decided for a pick up of a large margarita pizza but not sure what happened but the crust was too dry hardly any mozzarella herbs on one side and the but service was warm and reviving read more

See all

I've heard the hype for Wild Tomato and had to try it for myself! The place was pretty busy for a Monday afternoon, which is always a good sign. Thankfully, we were able to order beer while we waited for an outdoor table. They've got a great tap list! They also have a good-sized parking lot, so we didn't have to deal with street parking. We ordered two pizzas. The Fun Guy was at the top of our list. Five types of mushrooms! It was excellent. My group agreed this one is a must-have if you're a fan of mushrooms. The cream sauce was the perfect pairing. We also tried The Paloma. Shrimp on pizza? Very intriguing. Unfortunately, this one fell flat. My group felt like it was missing something. We doctored it up with some red pepper flakes and salt. It wasn't bad, but I wouldn't get it again. All in all, this place has solid pizza. Check it out! read more

Wild Tomato - The Paloma (top) and The Fun Guy (bottom) - Pizza Near Me - Fish Creek, Wisconsin

Veggie pizza was OK. The pizza base was not to our taste or texture and there was no real flavor to the pizza until we added the beloved ranch (first and last time for doing that methinks). The crowd seemed to be loving the food so each to his own. A small pizza was more than enough for two. Nice outside setting and we were seated quickly, service was great both from hostess and server. read more

The plates were filthy - there was dried food on 4 of the plates we were given. The pizza was okay. The cheese curds were very greasy like they weren't drained. The salad was decent but they forgot to serve the salad until 10 minutes after they brought the pizza. Also, there was a loud hot rod type of car that went back and forth several times in the parking lot and was speeding way too fast (kid got out and went into the back so was an employee). I would skip the Wild Tomato in Fish Creek. We have been to the one in Sister Bay and it was much better and cleaner. read more

Wild Tomato - 4 plates had dried food like this on them. - Pizza Near Me - Fish Creek, Wisconsin

This place shows up on several lists of places to eat when you're in Door County. We were there as a family of 5. We ate at the Wild Tomato at around 5:15 on a Tuesday night. Three teenagers, a wife with a gluten allergy, and me. We ordered cheese curds, Parmesan bites, a large pizza with half bacon half ham, and a gluten free pizza with sopresetta and goat cheese. We were seated right away, but the restaurant was pretty full already. Mostly outdoor seating which was nice enough last night. The curds came out first. Different from any we'd had. A far more delicate batter than usual. Reviews were mixed at our table but I thought they were good. The Parmesan bites were panned by everyone at the table except the 12yo who wanted them. They really ought to be called "Parmesan puffs." They were puffy pieces of bread with Parmesan cheese sprinkled on them. There was a lot of them but they weren't much to brag about. The regular crust pizza was fine. It didn't wow us but ham/bacon pizza isn't a "wow" order so that could be it. We ate the whole thing. But it was pretty meh. The gluten free pizza was the winner which is nice for a change - the gluten free wife never wins any menu comparisons. The crust tasted homemade - not Udis - and the ingredients were fresh. We really enjoyed it. Service was fine. Not super attentive with refills or second rounds but no real complaints. They were busy. All said, we'd probably skip this place next time but weren't sad that we ate here. read more

Wild Tomato - Cheese curds - Pizza Near Me - Fish Creek, Wisconsin

We were vacationing in Fish Creek. Due to Covid, we were looking for takeout dinner and decided to give Wild Tomato a try. Glad we did. Their Margherita Pizza was delicious. Hubbie thought the crust could be crisper but I liked it just fine. Perfect amounts of ingredients. We also added sausage. Yum! Other: The small sized pizza was perfect for two. I liked that carry out was in a separate building in the back. read more

Wild Tomato - Margherita pizza with sausage - Pizza Near Me - Fish Creek, Wisconsin

I have been here twice now and have had great food both times. I got the veggie pizza and subbed traditional mozzarella instead of the goat cheese and it was delicious. The waitress was very friendly but food was a touch slow in coming. I think our order may not have been put in right away as other tables weren't having the same issue. That being said, it was a nice summer day with the big door open so it wasn't a big deal. Place is cute and clean and I love the outdoor seating options. read more

Wild Tomato - Pizza Near Me - Fish Creek, Wisconsin

A great pizza joint , the bread basket is something you wouldn't necessarily brag about but this one is worth it , their marinara sauce is some of the best I've ever tasted . Opens at 5:00 and by 5:30 it was a 30 minute wait , not a large place, you can watch the pizzas being put in the wood fired oven ,and occasionally the chef puts on a little show. Nice size patio for seating , can't imagine this place on a raining day what kind of wait that would be read more

Atmosphere: Great outdoor seating area for the summer. The inside maybe had 5 to 8 tables, so I can imagine this place gets slammed pretty quick. The bathrooms are outside, so if you need to use the bathroom in winter, you are going to be taking a nice long walk. Service: Very friendly server who was passionate about what he does. We always had water in our glasses and our food came out really quickly. Food: Um wow. The food was just fantastic. I had an amazing salad and I CAN NOT RECOMMEND THE BREAD BASKET ENOUGH. No matter what you do, get that bread basket, it is worth every penny. All of the ingredients were fresh and the group thoroughly enjoyed their meal. I hope to make another stop here soon, in the meantime I'll be dreaming about that bread basket. read more

Wild Tomato - Really great salad and I loved the bread basket - Pizza Near Me - Fish Creek, Wisconsin

On our first night in Fish Creek, we looked for a restaurant and came across Wild Tomato. Since there aren't many restaurants to choose from in the first place, it wasn't hard to decide on this place. First off, we completely appreciate the honest sign posted outside that due to the pandemic, the restaurant is short-staffed so the wait may be longer than usual. While it's often implicated this is the case, the sign does give customers more awareness of the situation instead of complaining about the prolonged wait time. We ordered the fried cheese curds and the D Lux pizza and we were not disappointed. The cheese curds were SO good--in fact, I found them to be more enjoyable than the pizza itself. The pizza was also fairly delicious but it wasn't mind-blowing (hence the minus 1 star). I think the specialty pizzas would have tasted more special, such as the Al Pastor pizza they had going on. I also want to comment that this is a family restaurant, so it was cute to see the different family members working together to make their customers happy. There were so many takeout orders, in addition to the dine-in customers, so the restaurant is very popular! I'm glad to have tried this place out while in Door county, but I'm not sure if I'll go again unless we were starving with no where else to go at night! read more

Wild Tomato - Pizza Near Me - Fish Creek, Wisconsin

See all

I created my own pizza. Small Sausage, onion & mushroom. The crust was slightly burnt, but that was ok by me.

Always a good bet. Big crowd and the outdoor seating was just too cold to stay. We took the pizza to go and the server kindly brought it to us boxed. read more

Wild Tomato - Green & Gold Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fish Creek, Wisconsin

See all

This is one of the few places we have been in door county that was completely not kid friendly. The kids would not eat the kids mac and cheese. The service was awful, took about 20 minutes to get the attention of the server to get the check and boxes. The pizza we had was so spicy it was uneditable and there was an ingredient not listed that give me an allergic reaction. Complete waste of a dinner. read more

Nice outdoor setting in Fish Creek. I had the gluten free crust Fun Guy and the crust was burnt. My husband had one of the regular crust pizzas and it was ok, but lacking toppings. I expected more for the price. The fried cheese curds were delicious. Good beer and wine selection. read more

Had my family here in Fish Creek for dinner. There was a wait but it was a beautiful winter evening and wasn't to cold outside while we waited. The inside seating is small thus the wait. The pizzas were excellent! We had four different kinds. The staff were friendly and attentive and we had a good time. read more

This was one of our favorite spots during our time in Door County. The service was excellent and the food was delicious. Outdoor seating was so nice as well. read more

Wild Tomato - Margherita pizza - Pizza Near Me - Fish Creek, Wisconsin

The worst service in door county. Our server was the worst waiter we have had in a long time. He forgot to bring us forks, water, our appetizer, and the dough balls we requested for our kids. My wife had to get up from our table to get silverware for our kids and he stared right through her, not even acknowledging that a customer was standing in front of him. The level of apathy oozing from our server and the host were incredible. The permanent scowl on the hosts face made it painfully apparent he didn't want to be there. What an unfortunate experience. We look forward to having dinner at Wild Tomato when we vacation in Door County and this was so disappointing. The staff needs some retraining on customer service and basic human kindness. read more

Veggies weren't cooked. Cheese barely melted. So called "woodfire crust" was barely browned, not crisp at all. Sausage needs an upgrade. Pepperoni flavor was OK. Wild Tomato" was more "Mild Tomato". Total lack of flavor. UGH! read more

Great place for the wood fire pizza. The sauce was the biggest winner here. We went for lunch and the service as kind and fast. A great place to check out. read more