This place is always packed when we are in Door County, so I was surprised when the lot looked pretty empty. Little did I know the seating at the Fish Creek location is very limited inside and the bathrooms are located outside which I thought was a bit odd. The pizza was right up there with some of the best I have had, we also had the bread basket appetizer that came with 3 separate dips which was very tasty. I would definitely be back and next time maybe call in and get it to go. read more

Really solid-quality pizza, service, and beer menu. Very friendly staff at all levels of interaction. My one fault would be the apocalyptic level of flies in the outdoor seating area. It's as if a Mothra-scale fly -- let's call it Flytor -- laid its eggs throughout the area, watching remotely in amusement as its spawn endlessly harasses the patrons. You're never not without at least 2 flies in your hair, on your arms, or circling your food. In any event...save for the insect apocalypse, this is a great addition to Door County family cuisine. Just bring 37 fly swatters should you choose the outdoor seating. read more

The pizza here is hands down the best pizza you are going to find in door county. Wide variety of topping, and quality ingredients. The appetizers are great too. read more

amazing pizza, and the mac and cheese is delicious. I recommend getting the appetizer of the assortment of breads too, they were SO good. read more

Very cool vibe here. We got a veggie pizza. Was excellent. Veggies are very fresh. Cherry walnut salad was excellent also. Got the petit version, still plenty of food, great portion! Only complaint is that it's a bummer that a wood oven pizza place doesn't have a margarita pizza. read more

Very very good pizza and pasta dishes! Excellent customer service - bar none. Great music and outdoor seating. One of the best dinning experiences in Door County! read more

Wow. Fantastic. Busy little place, wish it was summer and sitting on patio. Great little bar and great stone fire pizza. Cool to watch the chef spin the dough. Will be back. Great beer on tap. read more

Wild Tomato - Pizza flipper - Pizza Near Me - Fish Creek, Wisconsin

See all

I wouldn't have ever thought I would have givens five for a pizza place, but it's a solid 4.5 and my son says I need to round up. That said, our meal started with an excellent caprese salad. Though the tomatoes weren't perfect, the warm, fresh made olive bread that accompanied it, pushed it to the top of my list. It was excellent! Others around us were enjoying fried cheese curds or a popular bread basket that came with three dips: marinara, a white cheese looking spread, and an oil dip. Though we wanted to try one of their creative original pizzas, we had our sons so we went with a traditional deluxe, and it was outstanding. Crust was thin, sauce was tasty, and the toppings were fresh and flavorful! Well worth the one hour wait. read more

Wild Tomato - Pic of their wood fire oven with a few pies. - Pizza Near Me - Fish Creek, Wisconsin

Why write yet another 5 star review for this place? Because they deserve it! This was our first time here, and it was great. It was a very cold, windy night, and we heeded the advice to get here early. Walking in, we were welcomed by the warmth and glow of the wood oven and the greeting of a waiter who actually seemed to enjoy his job. We ordered the small D-Lux, and took home half a pizza. Okay, we had a giant artichoke dip as a starter... Pizza had delicious crispy dough, blistered just enough, covered by a sunshine ripe tomato sauce, mozzarella that actually had taste, sausage, pepperoni and vegetables that still had crunch. Can't wait to go back! read more

Wild Tomato - Heaven. - Pizza Near Me - Fish Creek, Wisconsin

The best pizza I've ever had in Wisconsin, possibly the best I've ever had. Very friendly staff, cute location, nice patio. We got the cheese curds to start, which were delicious. They had a very nice, light batter which was so good. For pizza we got the BBQ, pulled pork, green pepper and pineapple and it was amazing. Wood fire grilled which lent it a nice smoky flavor and the crust was awesome. They hand-toss their pizza which is fun to watch. They also have a hand-made cherry soda on tap that is to die for. Oh man. I can't even explain how awesome that soda was. Definitely worth a try. read more

Wild Tomato - Pizza Near Me - Fish Creek, Wisconsin

See all

The pizza here was good, but not great or life changing and a little too much sauce for my personal taste. The atmosphere is just too small. The few people with a table were tripping over each other just to sit down. One great positive was the service. Our waiter was attentive, knowledgeable, and funny. read more

Great pizza!! We had the Donation Creation...loved it...see my photo to see what was on it. A really good stop for yummy food while driving through Door County. Also had the Cherry Mixed Green Salad...had dried Cherries, Glazed Walnuts and Goat Cheese with a Cherry Vineagarette...yum!! read more

Wild Tomato - Pizza we had...Donation Creation - Pizza Near Me - Fish Creek, Wisconsin

See all

The cooks were killing it in the carry out building! They were cranking out 40+ pizzas an hour plus the main restaurant was doing the same. Pizza was really good, perfectly cooked with the seasoned browned crust and fresh toppings! read more

Wild Tomato - The cooks are killin' it!! - Pizza Near Me - Fish Creek, Wisconsin

Wild Tomato Wood-Fired Pizza and Grille is a restaurant helping pizza live up to and beyond its potential for excellence. With two locations along Wisconsin's Door County Peninsula (Fish Creek and Sister Bay), "[t]he Wild Tomato is focused on and dedicated to making a positive impact on the world through a sustainable business concept of linked prosperity: Product Mission: To purchase, prepare, and sell food of the highest quality with a continued commitment to incorporating wholesome, natural ingredients and promoting business practices that respect our natural environment. Social Mission: We strive to show a deep respect for human beings inside and outside our company and for the community in which we live." Whenever we visit Door County, we make it a point to eat at Wild Tomato, tucking into one of their many innovative creations on their packed patio during pre-COVID times or more recently grabbing a short stack of pizzas and traveling into the deeps of Peninsula State Park to enjoy our slices from paper plates while perched on a bench overlooking Green Bay. And with each bite, generally accompanied by a Midwest-brewed beer, cider, or pop/soda, I can't help but believe Wild Tomato is meeting both their product and social missions handily. The menu boasts your stalwart build-your-own favorites, but with plenty of bonus ingredient options to make for some unique combinations. Tri-colored jalapenos? Carmelized onions? Cheese curds? Sure, why the hell the not. Where Wild Tomato truly shines, however, is in their specialty pizzas. We haven't tried every pizza on the menu, but I can recommend: The Green and Gold ("Go, Pack, Go") which has grilled chicken, bacon, grilled broccoli, and spinach. Topped with REAL Wisconsin cheese curds; the Margherita, which has Buffalo mozzarella, fresh basil, and olive oil over a crushed tomato base; and, finally, the Fun Guy, featuring five types of sautéed mushrooms, spinach, and caramelized onions over a garlic cream base. One other menu item, the Donation Creation, changes up every month. This is a specialty, specialty pizza with $1 of every pizza sold going to that month's charity, group, or cause. Last night we picked up July's Donation Creation, the Ninth Annual Thai Pie! "It features grilled chicken, yellow & red bell peppers, red onions, over a green curry cream base finished with fresh basil, cilantro, pea shoots, carrots and a chili lime drizzle." This is one of the best pizzas I've ever tried! I would recommend a lighter hand with the chili lime sauce as too much tends to overpower the green curry base. If you ever find yourself in Door County, make it a point to swing through the Wild Tomato. And if you don't find the place in your neck of the woods which elevates pizza beyond the everyday. (Longer post at https://rlpurdy.com/2021/07/10/wild-tomato-pizza-a-colossus-in-door-county/) read more

Too much cheese on both our pizzas. Also not enough sauce. Ratio was off with crust, cheese, and sauce. Even the kids pulled a lot of the cheese off. Cheese just overwhelmed the flavor so even with veggies added including onions, the pizza was kinda bland. read more

Hands down the best pizza in Door County, great pizzas, great crust and sauce, fantastic toppings and really creative specialty pizzas. They source as many ingredients as possible locally. They have locations in Fish Creek, Sister Bay, and now Egg Harbor attached to the One Barrel Brewery there which is a match made in heaven, great beer and pizza (does it get better than that?). All the locations though have an incredible beer selection too. read more

Service was terrible. Server who served us a "Pinot Grigio" served us a pink wine the server described as a pink "Pinot Grigio" after we had asked to taste two of the 4 white wines on their menu- the wine served being neither of these. The server was very rude and did not want to explain the wines that they had on shelf, and was very short/dismissive seeming annoyed that we asked about the wines on the menu that we received. After ordering food, and after over 45 minutes without our meal after ordering and no update on the order, the waiter did not alert our table that our initial pizza order had been burnt which caused another pizza to be cooked (which would not be a huge deal if we were notified of the situation )-- causing quite a delay in service with no update. Sad to say we came back here initially because we loved the pizza/drinks but will not come back and definitely would not recommend to others. Left with the pizza to go and will not return. read more

Good service and pizza. Been here two times now. Have had the D-Lux and Pork BBQ and cheese curds. All were excellent. Service was prompt and efficient. The place is always crowded and a wait, but the outdoor bar helps pass the time. Unique pizza recipes. If the wait is really long- we've done take out and it is good. read more

Delicious food, great staff! I have a dietary restriction and this restaurant was able to accommodate all of them. All around excellent place to eat! read more

The pizza is great and the service is great. Just be prepared to wait a bit for a seat due to lack of seating. The pizza is definitely worth the wait. But the real showstopper is the cherry salad, which never ceases to disappoint. read more

Used to love this place but won't be back! Waited almost 2 hours for food when we were told 20-30 minutes. Not worth the hype when you can get a delicious pizza over at Bayside down the road in 1/5 of the time! read more

My husband and I went here after taking the 10 mile bike at peninsula state park. Everything about this place was great the food and our table service. It was fast and delicious. We got a great tasting pizza and our waitress Nikki was busy but never made us feel that way. She was so helpful and actually picked out a great replacement for a cider for me. We had beer and a pepperoni and mushroom pizza. We were starving, but the service was fast and the dough was so fresh and delicious. The one issue we had is the hostess was incredibly rude. We were there on 8/24/19 in the afternoon she was not manning her station and she was rude because we went to ask the bar if we seat ourselves or wait. We apologized and thanked her for seating us but she was abrupt and dismissive. I'm glad our waitress was so nice because it really turned the experience around. Hopefully when we visit again in the future we are treated throughout the experience the way our waitress treated us. read more

Wonderful food, honestly some of the best pizza and service we have ever had at Fish Creek, WI! Crust is so soft and the toppings are very tasty. Definitely different than what we are used to (never had wood fired pizza before), but definitely worth a try. read more

On our list of places we have to go to every time we are in the area. A salad and pizza out on the patio is the perfect lunch. Fresh ingredients, excellent food and great service. read more

Nice food. Too crowded for the obvious reasons. Plan ahead if it's a weekend in order to get a table. We had to wait 1 hr and the food was worth it read more

We went here years ago and loved it. We remembered unique & fun pizzas with high quality ingredients. We just revisited and it was just another pizza place to us. Simple, plain in taste, and like I stated, like any run of the mill pizza place. read more

This place is amazing. The pizza is excellent, outstanding local ingredients. choices of beer are great. Service great. You may have to wait a while and don't expect A/C or super comfy seating. read more

Good pizza and great location right across from the state park. Sit outside though because it is very crowded inside. We felt like we were dinig with the people at the table next to us. The pizza is pretty good for Wisconsin, but the people who said it rivals Chicago pizza??? Come on now. It's not that good. read more

Visited the Wild Tomato for lunch and now wish there was one on my town. We began with one of their many beers and wines followed by the bread bowl as an appetizer. The Friday specialty pizza was fresh Mozzerella, cheddard, pepperoni, and smoked ham! Amazing! Thankfully we went for lunch on a weekday because there is only seating for a few dozen people inside. They do have a big patio for summer dining. Would definitely go back! read more

Wild Tomato - Pizza Near Me - Fish Creek, Wisconsin

WOW!!!! Our favorite restaurant of all time! When we come to door county we go here waaaay too much. Get the veggie pizza, you won't be disappointed. Seating is a little limited and waitstaff is hit or miss, but good lord that veggie pizza! read more

So I was recommended by a friend to come here. While they only take walk ins and I reservations it took over an hour to wait to be seated... Let me tell you it was worth the wait! The drinks we had at the outdoor bar were phenomenal! The seasonal sangria and hard cider was amazing. The outdoor atmosphere was incredible as well. Great service, ambiance and music. When we were finally seated we were comped some free drinks for the wait. The bread basket and spinach artichoke dip were amazing. The green and gold and fun guy pizza were awesome. All the food and drinks were great. If you find yourself waiting for your meal I promise it's worth it. The service and food were the best I experienced in door county. read more

Highly recommend it. Pizza is outstanding with a friendly environment. Unique place in Fish Ceek. read more

Wild Tomato - Wood fire grill for pizza! - Pizza Near Me - Fish Creek, Wisconsin

The simple things are sometimes the hardest to perfect. And, let me tell ya, they've PERFECTED the cheese pizza!!! Whole milk mozzarella is the star of their pie but credit must be given to their sauce and crust. Even their gluten free crust is their recipe! Props to you Wild Tomato: ROCK ON!!! read more

Best pizza ever! We lucked out and we're seated immediately outside. Our server was great. We had the D-Lux pizza. A small is 12 inches, so more than enough for 2 people. We only ate half and can finish it off tomorrow morning at the hotel. read more

Wild Tomato - Pizza Near Me - Fish Creek, Wisconsin

See all

Restaurant is conveniently located right at the entrance of Peninsula State Park. Got there at 5:45pm on a Friday and waited about 30 minutes for a table for two. There is a bar located outside which makes the waiting more bearable and plenty of waiting seats in the form of boulders. Breadbasket to start was a lot for two people but it was very good. We ordered the sausage and pesto pizza which was also good. Staff was very friendly. Sodas are allows one refill. Most of the seating is outside and some tables are not under an umbrella. Would visit again! read more

See all

We have now eaten here 4 times, each for lunch on a Saturday in the summer (anniversary trip to Door County). It is a must stop for us: great pizza, always impressive list of craft beers, lovely outdoor patio, and excellent service. The Tomato is the kind of place that would get too much of my money if it were located near my home. Be sure to try the grilled veggies and hummus. At any other restaurant that would sound boring. This is...perfect. Also, fried cheese curds are nailed by the chef here. This is the perfect way to continue day drinking on a holiday weekend. read more

This place is amazing! Absolutely everything we got was unique and delicious! No matter how long the wait YOU MUST GO HERE. Friendly service, perfect pizza, great drinks, appetizers, burgers, and sweets! Can't wait to go back. read more

Awful service. Waited 15 minutes for a drink order. Another 10 to get the drinks. Wife ordered a pasta dish. They brought that out and she ate while the pizza I ordered was made. Brought that out 20 minutes later. And it was wrong. Couldn't even communicate how awful the experience was to a host or hostess because no one was around. Pathetic. Won't be back. read more

We came here for dinner after arriving to Fish Creek. There was a wait, but there's an outside bar where you can order drinks and appetizers while you wait--which we did since we were with our two small kids. The cheese curds were great. Once we got to our table, the server gave our kids little pieces of pizza dough to play with while we waited for our food. We ordered a pizza and thought it was pretty good (and we are from Chicago, so we know pizza). read more

Good food, good service. Expect long wait times during peak dinner hour in summer. We orders burger, pizza and salad and all were great