DO NOT PATRONIZE! A slice joint with poor logistics and too much bad attitude. After delivering the wrong pizza, the delivery guy kept our money and said he'd be back in 10 mins with correct order. We got a friendly call to apologize and say we'd get 50% off. ....It took 2 hours total for us to get our order, and 2nd delivery guy refused to give us our money back. Called back to complain and "manager" acted like we were problem customers. And pizza sucked when it arrived. read more

Ok. I'm writing this review because I want to lower their average. The pizzas are good. Some of the best around. Problem is, they say it will be 45 mins, and it ends up being over TWO HOURS, and then likely wrong. This happens EVERY FUCKING TIME. read more

Our food said it would deliver in an hour. We live 10 minutes away and we only ordered a pizza. They did not have the ingredients for the pizza we wanted so we substituted stuff to make a whole new pie. After an hour and half we called and they said it was on the way. After two hours, same thing. After two and a half hours, the delivery guy didnt even get out of the car, I had to get our wrong soggy pizza from his car. NOT WORTH THE PIZZA - tons of better pizza in brooklyn. read more

Over priced and not good at all. The girl behind the counter is extremely nice and I hate to give this place a bad review but I've tried it multiple times and it's not good at all. read more

By far the worst customer service I've had. Waited in store for an hour before I asked how much longer and it wasn't even in the oven yet. The pizza is good but the shop is run horribly. Won't be going back. read more

AGAIN, the promised delivery time was 35 minutes and the pizza has not arrived two hours later. Completely rude staff member on the phone blames it on only having one driver. Please hire another driver if you know you are a super popular pizza place and it's a holiday where people are craving pizza (Halloween). Hard to understand how such an unprofessional, poorly run business is so popular, even if the pizza tastes good. A new low in delivery. Don't bother. If I could give them zero stars for service, I would. read more

Years ago when this place first opened I gave them a 5 star review and gushed about how awesome their pizza is. I particularly talked up the calabrese. Seriously, go back and check it out... I was one of the first ever reviews. Fast forward to now, and someone needs to f*cking explain to me why when i order a calabrese on a round crust i'm told you won't make it anymore. I've had this exact pie like 100 times. I have even Instagrammed it on several occasions with the hashtag from the box. Now when I order they act like I just ordered a pizza with angels wings and f*cking puppies on it or something, like they just don't have the fortitude or technology to make it happen. Most of the time they make it anyway after i put up a fuss, but i just got off the phone now and they wouldn't. They would not take my money for a pizza. What difference to you does it make what shape my f*cking crust is? Motherf*ckers I know what you're capable of with pizza ingredients, and this qualifies. I shouldn't have to attempt to negotiate over the phone with a manager every time and hear why you refuse to make a pizza that is literally on your goddamned menu. Seriously guys, go f*ck yourselves. read more

They do not offer gluten free pizza. They will say they offer gluten free pizza, but then sell you a Conte's frozen pizza out of a box that comes on a aluminum pie tin and with the little cellophane wrapped branded Conte's pizza cutter that came with it. 24 dollars for a reboxed frozen pizza from a grocery store. So mad about it. Just don't say you offer gluten free pizza. I would have ordered something different. Now I will AVOID. read more

Used to be the best pie, knots and Caesar salad. Now they consistently send every order wrong (4 in a row) and this last time did not refund me for missing toppings on my salad to boot. Which is shitty. The garlic knots were undercooked. If I wanted to put my own toppings on a salad and turn on my oven to cook, I wouldn't spend 55 dollars on delivery. It must be that the owner is becoming less involved due to other locations they opened recently. The staff is rude when you call about the mistake too. Not the way to run a business. It's unfortunate because this used to be my favorite. Don't waste your time or money getting delivery from here, order elsewhere, or go in person for a slice. read more

WORST pizza delivery experience ! after 50minutes wait they assured us it'll be here in 15mintutes and after antother 30minutes of wait we cancelled our order! They lied three times and told us that the delivery guy is on the way to our place but nobody ever showed up! read more

The pizza is not bad and a decent deal, but the customer service is absolutely awful. Just one week after spending $170 on delivery pizza from this place for a party, I ordered a single pie. After waiting for 20 min. (out of an hour), someone called back to tell me that I was out of their delivery area and cancelled my order. If in fact this is the case, it didn't stop them from delivering to me on previous occasions! The person who called me was AS RUDE AS CAN BE! Others on their phone line have been mildly rude and stupid too, but this one was the worst. Viva Motorino -- you've got my business! read more

Best mix of fancy pizza done well with a casual, homey, sit down and stay a while feel. We had the Blanco and the Tartufo and both were amazing. You know it's good when the ricotta cheese is arranged ever so carefully on your slice in a decorative flouret shape. These guys definitely care for their pies. Garlic knots were big and buttery, and plenty garlicy. Everyone behind the counter was friendly and the owner greeted us with a huge smile and explained how the chef takes his craft so seriously that the place isn't even equipped with a freezer. Totally fresh ingredients. Check this place out. read more

The pizza is good....if you get it. I have now ordered from them twice (the second time out of desperation as they were the only place delivering) AND I NEVER RECEIVED MY FOOD! Not worth the gamble. Order from somewhere that actually follows through. read more

After sampling a few different pizzas here at lunch today this place will definitely be my go-to. The grandma pizza and tartufo pizza were excellent, and the garlic knots seriously addictive. I'm looking forward to trying the other creative options, including the pear pizza (the pear salad was excellent) and the portabella. So glad these guys are in the neighborhood, and just sorry I didn't discover them sooner! read more

the most magical pizza you will ever have, i swear. i usually order the grandma pie (it's like a square sized margerita pizza but with kind of a deep dish crust). the crust is covered in what seems to be olive oil and it makes it chewy but not doughy, the sauce is perfect - a little sweet and salty, and the cheese/basil is the freshest i've ever had. it's also all priced accordingly. the kale gorgonzola and the apple walnut one with meat (sausauge? i've forgotten what kind) are two of my favorite pies. some might consider them expensive, but given the quality of ingredients, i do believe it's relatively fair. one big pro - if you follow their instagram (williamsburgpizza i think?), they'll often do shoutouts and offer free slices so people can try it out. i've also seen offers for whole pies on the house as a thank you to their loyal customers/fanbase. read more

Hands down, the greatest pizza in Brooklyn. You would be doing yourself a huge disservice by eating pizza anywhere else.

Be prepared to wait an hour and a half for your pizza, after they tell you 40-50 minutes. It's the same story every time, and I've fallen for it three times now. When you call to complain, they tell you, "Oh we're understaffed today." The pizza then arrives cold, because it's been on someone's bike for an hour. The pizza is okay, not great, and definitely not worth this BS. Never again. read more

The pizza may be somewhat decent but the service is consistently atrocious. Final straw this evening when the woman who took my order was extremely rude - when I checked in again on the status of my delivery as it had been over an hour and she originally quoted 45 mins, I was appalled by her behavior and tone. I will never order from this place again. read more

Hands down, the BEST pizza in NYC (and I've had A LOT of pizza!)

Pizza showed up (no joke) 16 minutes after ordering online from seamless - I checked the confirmation email for confirm timing. Absolutely crazy!!! Best thing ever after a few late night drinks. Bravo, Williamsburg Pizza, bravo... read more

The Calbrese is consistently one of the best pizzas I've ever had. Delivery time was a half an hour and I live a mile and a half away. Zero complaints. read more

Stopped by for the first time for a couple of plain slices while in the area. Heard good things about this place and figured I should give it a try since I always take the opportunity to experience the Brooklyn pizza scene whenever possible. The place is small, but the interior and service were both pleasant. The slices were solid, but unspectacular. In terms of size, they were large, true cuts from a 18" pie. The crust was a little thick for my liking, and although crispy, it was somewhat dense and overly chewy. The cheese to sauce ratio was on point, with a nice amount of cheese complimented with a flavorful sauce that had a nice hint of sweetness. Some reviews mention "greasy", which it was, but I think that is a vital part of the NYC pizza experience. One other issue I found was the pizza was pretty salty. My friend, who likes her food really salty, even commented that it was a little too much. Anyway, overall a solid slice, and if this place was in Jersey, it would probably be one of my go to places, but in the heavily competitive region of Brooklyn, they would have to up the game a few notches for me to pick them over the many other great places in the area. read more

This place is habitually late delivering pizza, and completely unorganized. It's a pizza business not a tech company. Not to mention they're pricks. Never ordering pizza from here again read more

Stopped in for a slice. The tartufo square slice was awesome and fresh. The exterior makes it look like a standard nyc slice joint, but it's little more fancy and super Delish. read more

Really nice place for some nice variety of pizza. I usually go there at least twice a week. It's 4$ a slice but i feel like it worth it I feel full after one slice. Your really getting your money worth. read more

took over 1.5 hours to get a basic pie and a salad. Pizza was cold when it came and they gave me a cheap iceberg lettuce salad with chunk of cucumbers to pass off as the $11 Kale salad I ordered! Not one marinated Artichokes, Sundried Cherry Tomatoes, Cucumber, & Pine Nuts -just iceberg lettuce. The staff answer the phone sunday night had no sense of customer service. Not only did he not apologize for the error but he gave me a hard time processing a refund. Good pizza - but save yourself the headache and order from somewhere else. read more

I've never reviewed anything on yelp, but I just feel so strongly about this place that i had to. It drove me to make a review, which I think sums it up. I don't want others to experience what I did. read more

As mentioned below, the cashier does not acknowledge the customer(one of the men from the back always take the order}. Now the pizza itself; VERY salty, no taste and stiff. I picked up my order, saw it coming out of the oven and by the time I was home (I live 2 mins away walking) it was cold. Very disappointed. Never again. read more

Nino makes the best pizza this side of the Atlantic! His speciality, which isn't always available is my favorite. The alla pera, it's like dinner and dessert at the same time. read more

Horrible service.. I went in there to grab a slice and the guy behind the counter pretended like I wasn't there... After waiting a few minutes i asked for a slice, he said I have to wait. So I walked right out and will never return. My recommendation is not to give these guys your business. read more

DO NOT ORDER DELIVERY - you will regret it. They couldn't manage their way out of a pizza box. Idiots.

I'm backin it. The service is great and slices are fresh; one quickly turns into three. Also, don't sleep on the brownies.

Maybe this pizza is better fresh out of the oven, but when it was delivered the crust was awful. It was tough and it had too way much corn meal on the bottom. The sauce and cheese was great, but the heavy, thick crust made it pretty unpleasant. read more

Tried this pizza for the first time this weekend and it is hands down the best pizza in the neighborhood. The kale slice and grandma slice were both fantastic and their house salad is delicious. Additionally, the staff were all super friendly which is a nice bonus. This will definitely be my new go to place for a slice or for delivery. Highly recommend to anyone who loves good pizza! read more

Best Pizza in Brooklyn! I've already walked in three times for slices and each time I try something different. All excellent! Crust is perfect, sauce/cheese ratio as well, and quality toppings. I wouldnt listen to all these negative reviews, go taste some and see what you think for yourself. Very good service too, small place but has great character. read more

Horrible horrible horrible customer service and completely disorganized operation, they mess up and/or completely forget to even start making your order almost every time I've gone there. read more

Grandma pizza is the bomb (get the whole thing, I think it makes a difference). It's our go-to. Do it.

Pizza is ok. I feel they have a lack of variety of pizza. Lastly, I noticed the cash handler also gives you the pizza with no gloves. Very unsanitary. read more

DON'T bother, customer service and delivery is awful. Ordered a pizza at 7:05pm arrived at 9:45pm. COLD, cheese barely melted. Several calls to a very surely lady. Once I got angry she comped the pizza but who cares.....GO/CALL SOMEWHERE ELSE. ThEY SUCK!!! read more

They deliver past midnight, so that's great, but the quality has gone down this last year. It used to be my go to, and now it's what I get when nothing else will deliver. read more