Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Windsor Mill Tavern

    4.3 (162 reviews)
    Closed 11:30 am - 10:00 pm

    Order Windsor Mill Tavern Takeout or Delivery

    Windsor Mill Tavern Photos

    WINDSOR MILL TAVERN ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Casual
    Good for groups
    Outdoor seating
    Happy hour specials

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Windsor Mill Tavern

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos - Windsor Mill Tavern

    Taylor M.

    Wow! Loved the vibe here. The prices are great. The full bar is filled with anything anyone could ever want. The staff were nice and attentive. Our food was delicious! The burger and meatloaf were delicious. The crab cake was SO good!!

    Entrance area from inside restaurant.
    Kristine T.

    We went to Windsor Mill Tavern Saturday Evening, 6th of December and we absolutely LOVE it! The staff seems to love their jobs, the service is amazing and the food is delicious and comforting. I had the delicious crab cake appetizer and Salmon in Beurre Blanc Sauce and my husband had the Fried Cheese Curds and Stuffed Pork chop. Both absolutely delicious. Best Mashed potatoes I have ever had. This was our second time at Windsor Mill Tavern and we love the warm Irish Pub Style atmosphere. Only thing missing is a fireplace! This is our new favorite hangout after having moved here to Severance, Co this past March. We love it. Oh! And the seats are comfortable as well. We will be back. Love having a place that is only a couple miles away from where we reside! Well done staff and management! This place is a gem!!!! And the prices? Quite reasonable!

    Cream of chicken soup -- excellent!!!
    Mark B.

    When in the Greeley area, I was hungry for lunch and found Windsor Mill Tavern via Yelp. Fun little place! It's in the basement of a building -- so it took me a few minutes to fugue out how to enter the place. I sat at the bar, and my bartender was great. I started with a cream of chicken soup -- it was excellent, and I wish I had ordered a bowl instead of a cup. : ) For my main course, I ordered the steak bites with mashed potatoes. The steak was ok -- some pieces were pretty chewy -- but I ate most of it and enjoyed the mashed potatoes a lot. Total bill -- with tip -- was $40. Not bad considering how high inflation is!

    Menu
    Maddy B.

    We've been to Windsor Mill Tavern a handful of times now and it's quickly become one of our go-to spots. I love the weekday deals, it gives us an excuse to pop in without feeling like we're splurging. The menu is huge (in a good way) and honestly has something for whatever you're in the mood for. We've tried a few different things and have never been disappointed. They also have a solid tap list, including our favorite: 805. The ambiance is perfect for a casual date night with a good vibe all around.

    Chicken Cordon Blue w/Asparagus
    Dave E.

    Having been here many times in the past this visit was a bit of a disappointment. The good news is they still have Juicy Bits (NEHIPA) on tap. Curious news is they only have 1 white wine, in this case Pinot Grigio, on happy hour. . The bad news concerned dinner. I've always ordered the curried mussels appetizer with the soup of the day. Before it was prepped with yellow Urey and was delicious. This time it was either red curry but more likely sriracha and it was hot ... TOO DAMN HOT in my opinion. Wasn't an enjoyable meal at all yet it was still described on the menu as yellow curry. It even looked different than times past. Perhaps a one off as we'll try it again. Oh, I also had a cup of the soup of the day which was a steak and potato chowder. It was excellent!!!

    Street view

    Amazing drinks, food and service. The fish and chips (walleye) was delicious. I'm sorry I didn't take any photos

    Chicken friend wagyu
    Kelsie T.

    This is our second time coming to Windsor Mill Tavern. We were hoping for the prime rib but they stopped making it. We still had a great experience. The margarita I had was perfection, I got the chicken fried waygu and my husband got the chicken risotto. We also enjoyed the cheese curds and Brussels for a starter. We ended with the espresso torte and bread pudding. Everything was wonderful!

    Foyer and entrance of the restaurant. The bar is in the middle.
    Todd G.

    What a great place! Tucked into the property with several other restaurants in downtown Windsor. Built in the style of an Irish pub the ambiance is so cool. Plenty of space for guests and diners. I had the Bangers and Mash, a perfect Irish fare. My wife had the Cowboy burger and had to bring half home. Our friend had the Bison Philly and it filled the plate. Try the bourbon bread pudding too. Our server, Sophia was awesome and was very responsive, friendly, and timely. The entire staff was busy and the bar was packed as well.

    Pineapple teriyaki burger with bison patty and side of soup, chef's special was a steak chowder.

    See all

    7 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Tim D.

    Tim D.

    Thank you Stacy!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Tim D.

    Tim D.

    Thank you Stephanie!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 5 of 5

    Ask the Community - Windsor Mill Tavern

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Bars 2,043 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    The Gravy Train

    The Gravy Train

    3.3
    (3 reviews)
    0.1 mi

    The Gravy Train makes regular stops at some of our favorite local breweries, including Mighty River…read moreBrewing, MashLab and High Hops - but they're also big community supporters, so look for them at fundraisers in Northern Colorado too. Tracking down your favorite food truck can be challenging, but TGT keeps their Facebook page current! Check it out! The Conductor of The Gravy Train is owner/operator Dee Dee G., and she launched her 5-year dream in January 2019. Business has been deservedly good ever since. Serving breakfast, lunch and dinner from their red and black rig - The Gravy Train regularly features comfort food faves like sliders, mashers, mac and cheese, chicken and dumplings, and crinkle cut fries that go with any beer you can imagine. As the name suggests, plan on a gravy-smothered option or two somewhere on the menu! Like most food trucks, variety and good prices are huge. The Gravy Train offers both! They also cater large and small events, and they also have the "special bank" available for you to donate to those that need help with a home cooked meal. Dee Dee learned about cooking from her Grandma Beulah, and her passion is making people happy through food. Now her dream business is doing just that. Spend an extra few minutes tracking down The Gravy Train in and around Northern Colorado before you head of for your next casual trip out for comfortable meal.

    Absolutely delicious food!!! Dee Dee is a wonderful cook and is so sweet! She does an amazing job…read moreon some old time favorites and puts a little twist to them! Delicious!!!

    Photos
    Happiness on Wheels!
    Happiness on Wheels!
    The Gravy Train
    The Gravy Train

    See all

    River and Woods

    River and Woods

    4.0
    (578 reviews)
    37.1 mi
    $$

    Went here with a group of friends and immediately understood why people love this place. River and…read moreWoods has that very specific cozy Boulder atmosphere that somehow feels both rustic and intimate without trying too hard. The whole space feels warm and relaxed in a way that makes you want to stay longer than planned. Food was genuinely very good across the board and the service struck that perfect balance of being attentive without constantly interrupting the table or hovering over conversations. I'd especially recommend it for small groups or date nights because it manages to feel social without getting overwhelmingly loud. Parking is mostly street parking, but we didn't have too much trouble finding a spot nearby.

    A group and I visited River and Woods for dinner on a weekday. We easily found parking on the…read morestreet right in front of the restaurant where there is a sign to easily identify it. I think the best thing about River and Woods is the interior and exterior decoration. It is very clear that a lot of thought and time was put into the atmosphere here. From the cute door knocker to the bathroom wallpaper, the theme is well-executed. The food was a bit disappointing. The blue oyster mushroom appetizer was extremely salty. I thought it was just me but the rest of the table agreed as well. My trout was well-cooked and I enjoyed it quite a bit. The chicken was also salty although cooked well. I did not try the burger but I was told it was salty as well. The prices of all the items were quite high for what I thought was presented. Service was good and thankfully our waters were filled frequently for how much water we were drinking due to the high salt content.

    Photos
    Outdoor seating
    Outdoor seating
    Braised Shortrib; gnocchi verde with grilled chicken.
    Braised Shortrib; gnocchi verde with grilled chicken.
    S'mores for desert

    See all

    S'mores for desert
    The Still Whiskey Steaks

    The Still Whiskey Steaks

    4.4
    (530 reviews)
    11.9 mi
    $$$

    Amazing dinner at The Still Whiskey Steaks!…read more I had the NY strip with mashed potatoes and a side of Brussels sprouts, and everything was freaking perfect. The Brussels sprouts were a WOW, so good. We ended with a shared bananas foster crème brûlée cheesecake, which was the perfect finish to the meal. Aaron was amazing, and Sean/Shawn -- I hope I'm spelling that right, was also incredibly friendly. Both had great customer service skills and made the experience even better. The ambiance was perfect: not too loud, no harsh bright lighting, and such a rustic, curated feel. Overall, an amazing dinner and definitely a place I'd recommend. A Great Steak!

    We were there to celebrate my husband's birthday that our children reserve in advance. The…read moreatmosphere of the restaurant was lively and exciting so I initially thought this was going to be a great time. The food was amazing I had the Prime Rib and loaded baked potato, my family ordered four appetizers they chose shrimp, oysters and chicken wings we wanted the 3 rolls but we were told we could only order 2 because they were sold out. We had no issues with food every item ordered was amazingly delicious. Compliments to the cooks! The service provided was not as impressive, I had asked for sweetener for our tea twice, he acknowledged and said he would bring it to our table but it never came. I had to ask the individual who brought out our appetizers thankfully he brought it as soon as he left the table. It took a while for our server to ask if we needed any drink refills. Lastly, since I sat at the edge of the table of the corner booth, I felt my personal space was invaded each time he brought out or food. He could have asked me to stand up or move for a little bit (which I wouldn't have mind), with this request he would avoided stepping on my foot, bumping me with his elbow and not reaching over me. Not sure if our server was in the best mood but when we were leaving he knocked over my tea spilling some on me and the take out container. Leaving me disappointed because my husband and I drove 672 miles. Even my children stated usually there is impeccable service.

    Photos
    The Still Whiskey Steaks
    Chocolate cake
    Chocolate cake
    Brussels sprouts, steak tips, Pinot Noir

    See all

    Brussels sprouts, steak tips, Pinot Noir

    Windsor Mill Tavern - bars - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...