Ordered a Doritos nacho surpreme and 20 wings. Everything was hot, fresh, and the way I ordered it. Always great service.

I love wise guys they always hook me up with really good food fast and nice employees especially Emily B

Wiseguys Never dissapoints I've been going their for years and I absolutely love their food. The staff is always very friendly, welcoming and engaging as always especially the manager Tommy. Definitely one of the top places I recommend for pizza here in Buffalo, New York read more

Finger and fries were outstanding. Was worth the drive in to give them a try. Got three sauces on the side, honey mustard (not generally a fan but it was freaking delicious), medium (good stuff), and Logan berry bbq (a little on the sweet side, but still good). Fries were cooked really well included lots of blue cheese and carrots. Def will be back in the future!! read more

I had the opportunity to try this pizza at work one day and holy crap - it was amazing! We live across the city and now we drive down to South Buffalo because it's so worth it. The pizza is always fluffy and thick-crusted. The sauce is great, as it has an element of sweetness. Their wings are also cooked perfectly every time and they have a great variety of sauces. A ton of thumbs up!!! read more

I made an order with WiseGuys Pizza for a customer through an online catering website. They loved the pizza, but I had added special instructions to add green olives to one of the pizzas, and all the pizzas delivered were sans green olives. Ezcater offered a discount off my next order to make up for the inconvenience which is appreciated.. although extra ezcater rewards points would be better. When making big catering orders, it might be better to call them directly rather than using a middleman. I think they also have better deals for large orders if you call direct. read more

I grew up in south buffalo and my parents used to buy pizza every Tuesday (because they had a $5 large special on Tuesdays) and when we moved to Angola we'd tell people about how good wise guys pizza was...well flash forward 20+ year and my husband and I just bought a house in West Seneca so my parents went out and ordered pizza to feed our help and we all agreed it's as good as we all remembered and we've been here less than a week and have already ordered twice our order was messed up the second time but they made it up to us and the pizza was worth it! read more

Excellent wings - arrived with ample blue cheese - and the pizza was outstanding. It was the final evening of our visit to Buffalo (february 2017) and at least five people suggested wise guys. We found they were patient on the phone as I asked about deals and what they were noted for. In a very short time - we found the delivery guy arriving with piping pizza and wingsThe sauce was classic Buffalo hot sauce - which is important because as "Buffalo style wings" have spread across the nation - not many people have really tasted true Buffalo wings. Also, the pie was so substantial that we had two pieces left (that never happens with our group of four). read more

Wise Guys Pizza - pie and wings from wise guys - Pizza Near Me - Buffalo, New York

So, I've written reviews on other sites about other places so I decided to check out reviews for this place before ordering. Noticed and thought to myself, "hey, I can order online - which is great because I hate talking to people." I see mixed reviews but, honestly - some of you are crazy picky to begin with. I figure I'll give it a try. I go back and place my order on the site and am surprised to see a picture. Holy elementary school blast from the dang past, I went to school with the owner many moons ago. I figure it can't be that bad. Hell in a hand basket, nothing is worse than Partners food, am I right?!? I place my order (a rather large one because my spawn can really friggin eat) and got texts that my order was received, when it was done etc. I was really surprised because my food was done, on the way, and delivered all within 45 mins from the time I placed my order til it was delivered - fastest I've ever seen. Food was very hot still and the driver was very kind and polite. In fact, he accidentally parked in my neighbors driveway and my hooligan neighbor comes out flipping shizz about it - the driver was still polite (personally, I would've told my neighbor where he could go - but in his defense, his wife is a witch and he ain't getting lucky so..yeah). I give them 4 out of 5 stars because I ordered mild wings and they were actually pretty buffalo hot. Had to rinse them off in the sink for the kids. Everything else was great. All in all, great job on your business, Jay. "Enron" Bonus: the driver was kinda cute, fyi read more

Break down: Pizza: 3* Wings: 3 Delivery: 4* The pizza here is stellar at least over the other pizza places in buffalo. Even with chefs doing pizza right down the street I'll always pick wise guys. They deliver on time and I have never really had a problem with them. I have never ordered anything but pizza from them so reviewing the restaurant as a whole would be a silly thing for me to do. So that's why I gave them 3 stars. Should you order from them? Yes. Would i recommend the wings? Yes. Would I recommend anything else off the large menu? I guess not seeing as I haven't had anything. If I could give half stars I would do three and a half. But just ever having pizza I rounded down on this one. read more

Bummer. First time there great. This time. Burnt wings. Raw pizza. Guess it balanced out. Enough to get it on the crap list. Never again. Forty bucks for this. No thanks. read more

I just ordered a large cheese, mushroom and black olive pizza. It was disgusting. It not only looked burnt, it tastes burnt. I paid almost $25.00 for this pizza. I've been ordering from Wiseguys for many years and this is the worst. It looks like the pizza was old, reheated and then delivered it to me. This was a nice a month treat for me and my granddaughter. I'm so disappointed. read more

We're pretty regular here (1-2 times a month) and almost always get the same thing - pizza and boneless wings. I religiously order their bbq sauce as a side to dip the wings and my pizza in. About half the time, they get it right. This is probably the 3rd or 4th time this year already that they forgot it. Some of the counter staff will double check the order before handing it over which I appreciate, while others just hand it over. The missing side of sauce usually happens when they don't check. We'll still frequent here but I guess I'll just need to take it upon myself to check my order before I leave, instead of the staff doing that. read more

After being told our personal pizza and chicken wing dip would only take 20 minutes, we waited for over a half hour for our food. Not only was the wait super long but the woman who gave us our food told us that we might want to microwave the chicken wing dip because it's probably still a little cold and she didn't want us waiting in there forever. Not very pleaSed with the service, especially with how pricey the menu items are! read more

Pizza is amazing to say the least get 2 slices and your getting a half a pie basically oh my god and the sauce is amazing super A+++++ in my book will order here for as long as i live in Buffalo read more

Really good pizza and wings definitely will order again. Pizza was a little dark is my only complaint. Very generous with the pepperoni, which you don't see often. read more

I come into your place once a week for dinner, Alexa Stankowski takes my order and she is why my wife and I come every week. She is a very nice young lady. Our orders are always done just how we want them, we will continue to dine at your place because of the service we receive. thank you, Alan Franco read more

Best pizza and wings in all of Buffalo. We have tried many pizzas and none compare to Wiseguys Shoul get 10 stars

One of the best pizzas around - got the cheese and pepperoni small - was enough for 1 person, maybe 2. This was cross between Bocce and Imperial - maybe even better ! Would go again ! read more

Literally gave me everything I wanted in a pizzeria and more! Firstly they let me order online which I LOVE. so many different options, awesome. Reasonably priced, always a plus. Gave me the option of square slices ! On top of all of that the pizza got here and the delivery guy was SO nice, even when are dogs ran up to him haha. And lastly the icing on the cake the pizza was FABULOUS keep doing what you're doing and we'll keep ordering from you!! :) read more

Great place n crystalyn fixed our order very pleased n a free meal on them ty crystal

After reading the reviews from my Yelp brothers and sisters, I had to give WiseGuys a shot. I grabbed a large Cheese and Pep pizza along with some wings, mild. I have to tell you, this pizza was worth the hilariously bad drive and all out vehicular war that I fought in, post Buffalo Bills game from Orchard Park to South Buffalo. The service was spot on and not like many of the pizza places that I call, who ultimately hate the fact that you want pizza from them - a pizza place. They do show you the pizza before you take it, which I assume is to make sure you are getting the pizza you ordered and to also blow that heavenly greasy steam in your face so you drool all the way home. The chicken wings were good, crispy and plump. They were not mouth dropping but you are not trading a bad chicken wing for good pizza. No, you get two really good items at the same place. No sacrifice, here. Prices are in line and the location reminds us that whatever we buy there ultimately ends up in large portion back to the community. I like that and you should too. read more

Not consistant at all. Had a messed up order every one out of 3. Gone down the street to Antone's. Have not had one problem yet.

Had a call from the manager today I was shocked to say the least he called because he seen my post here and I have to say the customer service is probably the best I ever had he was very apologetic about my last order and gave me a credit towards more food. Amazing never had this happen before! read more

This is quickly becoming my favorite pizzeria to order from. Not for the pizza sadly because mineos will always be my fav but for their sides, tacos, and subs! I ordered a sub a few nights ago and unfortunately it wasn't made the right way but when I called they did deliver one to me for free, the correct one. I enjoy their chicken finger tacos a lot. read more

The sauce and pepperoni on this pizza are excellent! I use to get this pizza all the time when I lived in the neighborhood. When I moved out 6 or so years ago I remember the pizza was not as good. After having it again today I can tell you that the old delicious pizza I remember is back. Worth the trip to taste this great pizza in south buffalo. They have a few booths if you want to eat in. read more

My second favorite pizza joint in Buffalo NY. The sauce is sweet and so delicious. The cheese is gooey and thick. The dough is perfectly pressed and the toppings are always A1. Only reason for 4 stars and not 5 is the inconsistencies of the place. Some days you'll get a perfect pie. Somedays it's sloppily made. The wings are generally good if you order them extra crispy. The flavors they have are amazing as well. Staff is always super generous and the girl working the counter is always really nice. read more

Pizza was sooo delicious today. The pizza has always been great but maybe it was the added touch of the sesame on the crust..wow.

After writing a review last week, I was pleasantly surprised with the quick response I received from Jay at Wiseguys. Jay was very disappointed to hear of the experience I had, apologized and compensated for the luncheon. He went out of his way to make things right. He was grateful that I shared my experience. Thank you Jay, I will be ordering again.Shari read more

I recently realized I haven't posted a review of a Pizzeria in a while (which is almost as inconceivable as the Bills winning the Superbowl, considering how much Pizza I eat) so I wanted to post one for WiseGuys. Warning in advance: this post is a little long, so I apologize and hope you keep reading..but I just couldn't condense something as important as a WNY Pizzeria review! As I've mentioned in another review, I discovered 2 things that are hard to do when it comes to food in WNY: Stand out as one of the best places to get a fish fry and stand out as one of the best places to get pizza & wings. The reason is because there are so many places that do it so well around here, it's actually hard for a restaurant to stand out from the crowd as one of the best. There are SO many awesome delicious Pizzeria's in WNY, I would be posting reviews non-stop for a month if I tried to do them all (there are some stinkers too...but I'll save them for another time). South Buffalo is serious when it comes to their Pizza. Woe be unto you if you try and get into a discussion at any bar on who has the best pizza in South Buffalo. South Buffalonians are nothing if not loyal to their Pizzeria. Some love Abbott Pizza, some love Blasdell Pizza, some are true to Imperial Pizza, some really like Leonardo's.....and some are huge fans of Wise Guys. Which one is your favorite honestly depends on several factors (since they're all super good): Do you like thick-doughy crust, or thinner crisp crust? Do you like a thick/sweet sauce, or thinner more traditional sauce? Do you like the small little pepperoni or the large/wide kind? I could go on and on...but you get the point. WiseGuys is located on Seneca St in South Buffalo (near Mineral Springs Rd) and it's been there for a quite a while. I know there is another Wise Guys on Hertel in Buffalo, but I don't know if they are owned/operated by the same people. This post is on the one in south Buffalo. Every time I've gone in to pick up an order the dining area is immaculate. Tables, floor, countertop are all clean. The dining area (about 6-8 tables) is decorated with lots Sabres & Bills memorabilia (Jerseys, hats, autographs etc). The guys that work there are always nice and friendly too. They have a nice menu with lots of Pizza, specialty pizza's, lunch specials, subs, hoagies, salads, sides, and wings. And they have a pretty impressive list of specialty sauces to put on the wings if you want to try something besides hot/med/mild. On my most recent visit, I ordered a large Pizza with cheese, mushrooms, onions, garlic crust and an order of fried ravioli. The Pizza was outstanding. The crust was perfect (for me): not too thick and doughy, but soft & fresh with the bottom crisp. The cheese was that perfect golden browned color, the sauce is on the sweet side but not too sweet or sugary tasting. The mushrooms were fresh (I could tell they were not from a can) and the onions were slivered and nice and thin. All of the ingredients were generous and tasted great. Oh and the crust....good lord. It was delicious. Crisp, golden brown, garlicky. I almost forgot to mention the side order of ravioli I ordered. Those little pillows of heaven were good too. Although I suspect they weren't "fried" as the menu said. They tasted baked to me, which is better in my opinion. They were crunchy, hot, the cheese inside was melted and good (it's a ricotta-like cheese filling). I would order them again. The pizza was about $16.00 and the ravioli were $4.99 (for 6). So for around $22 we had food for 4 people to watch football on Sunday. If you're in the South Buffalo, Lovejoy, Blasdell, West Seneca, Cheektowaga area and you haven't tried here yet, I would give them a shot. These culinary gangsters know what they're doing. p.s. I also wanted to mention something that I thought was pretty cool...to show their appreciation and give back to the community for the holidays they have a promotion where you can nominate someone who you feel is worthy or needing (you write their name & contact number down on a card) and once a week they will draw a name and give that person a free pizza. Pretty nice huh? read more

One of the best pizzerias on Seneca st I've had since moving to south buffalo. The service is friendly and fast. Delivery is also fast and food is hot as it should be! I recommend going here if you're looking for a quick bite to eat. Good prices and wide selection of food, I'll definitely be back more often for great food and service! read more

Great Place to eat! The customer service is outstanding. I come from The Tonawanda's to South Buffalo just for the pizza! I tried so many different places and i found the right place! Always fresh! read more

Their pizza is amazing. Even reheated, it's wonderful. Editing my review of this place. Holy hell! How often is it that you find a place willing to actually take in the feedback and then go above and beyond to improve? These people actually listen to their customers! I stand by what I said before regarding their pizza. It is phenomenal! Their smalls could easily feed two starving people. Their quesadillas are huge! The apple calzone was not only huge but absolutely perfect. Again, even reheated, it was fantastic. When ordering fried dough, ask them to bake the cinnamon and sugar into it. It tastes like heaven. Their tacos taste like unicorn farts! One of our friends is lactose intolerant and can't have heavy cheeses like cheddar. Wiseguys offers up loaded cheese fries without cheddar, replacing it with mozz which is far more palatable. They're the only place that actually offers this. I hope this place continues to succeed and be awesome. We need this sort of customer service and variety of food in this area. Especially on really late nights when everything else is closed to delivery. read more

Food is great here, would recommend! They load everything on toppings, and great customer service. Would recommend specialty pizzas.

I absolutely love the pizza from wise guys! Very rarely do the pizzas taste bad. I order pizza for the place I work for, and I love it. The owner Jay is a very nice guy and helps out alot. They are really good with delivering the pizza in time with reasonable prices read more

Simple and to the point pizza. Ordered a pie on Super Bowl Sunday and was available to pick up in just over a half hr which is pretty impressive considering it must be one of the busiest days for a pizza place. Also really enjoyed the sweet sauce! Will defiantly try again and maybe some wings next time read more

Easily the best pizza in South Buffalo. The chicken fingers, wings, and subs are amazing too!

WiseGuys for the customer service win! I am pregnant and was craving pizza, and ordered their specialty white pizza and something got mixed up order wise and they had made the wrong pizza... whoops! My husband had walked over to get it when he found out, and they made us a new pizza and delivered it for no charge AND gave us a gift certificate. They are such great people! read more

I received a call from a manager tonight asking about my order after they saw my Yelp review. He was very apologetic and understanding of our issues. Also offered a credit for what we spent that night. We are willing to try again. I was very surprised by the call and I have to say it was very stand up of the manager to address the issues we had in a positive manner. read more

Great pizza!! Probably in my top 5 of all time. The cheese, sauce and crust were perfect. I just ordered a large cheese and 10 wings (mild) and it was plenty of food for 2-3 people. The wings were a bit dry, but still tasted good. Tommy also had great customer service when I got there to pick it up. read more