750 Cucina Rustica

Uncle Jerry's is such a unique spot--it shares its location with a deli, which just adds to the…read morecharm. It has that true mom-and-pop, local favorite feel that makes you want to keep coming back. Being located right in downtown Cary gives it even more character. The deep dish pizza is fantastic, with a really interesting twist of hot honey that takes it to another level. It's different in the best way. If you're planning to dine in, make sure you give yourself plenty of time. The line for a table can get long, but the staff works incredibly hard to seat everyone as quickly as possible. If you're in more of a rush, I'd definitely recommend carryout--it's absolutely worth the wait either way. A true local gem.

What's better than good pizza? Pizza made with fresh in-house ingredients and top tier service!…read moreFrom the dough to the meats, Uncle Jerry's ingredients are all fresh and made in house, they even have a butcher shop in the restaurant. As a first time diner, I wasn't sure what to expect but I was delighted to be introduced to a new, local, and fresher version of Lou Manati's. While not a local to Cary, IL it was definitely worth the almost 1 hour drive. To top it off, their staff was friendly, attentive, and created an authentic family vibe for you to dine with kids, friends, or family!

Wow! This pepperoni pizza was in a league of its own.

See all

Uncle Jerry's sweet sting

Gallo’s Pizza & Pasta

3.5(105 reviews)

0.2 mi

Their pizza is always a fan favorite. We had ordered 6 large pizzas for a bday party and it showed…read moreup perfectly on time and piping hot. It will continue to be our go-to for our get togethers.

I would surely give this place five stars, but due to my issue that you're going to read below I…read moregave them three. I've ordered from this place about 10 times since they took over the old Romanescos (I believe it was called). I apologize if I spelled it wrong I never ordered from there before. When it comes to thin crust pizza being that I grew up on the northwest side of Chicago. I prefer Tavern style. A lot of people don't know what that is anymore but true Chicago ones do. Where I grew up it was a big Italian neighborhood and that is the standard type of pizza to a Chicago ones. Not deep dish. I've been living out here for 21 years and although I still frequent the city for certain foods as well as Ben making pizza from scratch which is time-consuming, I hadn't found a halfway decent authentic Chicago tavern style pizza out here up until a few years ago. Originally, I was ordering from Rosati's in Cary and I was somewhat impressed. Originally Rosati's was a family pizzeria that franchised their name and recipe off, but I've noticed that a lot of of their franchise locations as long as they hold true to the original recipe is pretty decent. Some aren't great. When I came to the one in Cary, I started noticing they started skimping on toppings so I stopped. I then tried the Pizza Stop right down the block from Rosati's. It's a pizza I'd like, love the crust however, they always always followed special instructions however, the sauce has a little too much garlic in it for me, which doesn't agree with me. Then, Gallos opened up. I tried them and was extremely impressed. The crust was crispy, the sauce is very tasty. And they initially followed my request for any toppings to be placed above the cheese rather than underneath. Why do I like toppings above the cheese? Because it cooks and crips more. When you're dealing with sausage, pepperoni, mushroom, onion, it just taste so much better. When it's buried underneath the cheese in my opinion, it's slimy, wet, and greasy. The last five times I ordered Gallo's and requested toppings above the cheese. It doesn't happen. It did initially but not anymore. Tonight I ordered a pizza requested toppings on top. I specifically told the kid on the phone that the last time I requested it it didn't happen and she told me that she would make sure it did. And to my disappointment after the fifth time it didn't happen. Once I received it, mushrooms were buried underneath. I called to advise and the young girl on the phone simply apologized and said "the next time I'll write your request down". My response back was "you should always write everybody's order and request down on a ticket". My guess is that she typed it into a computer on the register and figured it would magically happen. Again, I don't want to inflict lack of business to the people that own Gallows. But if they can't fulfill, simple requests, then I'll move on. I told the girl on the phone that there's a lot of places in the neighborhood that they have competition with. If they reply back acknowledging this review, they might say well we were busy that particular night but again it's been five times and there's times I order during the week when it's dead.

See all

Sausage and giardiniera pizza

La Pizza Via

4.5(205 reviews)

1.9 mi

6 month update: if I had to distill this place down to a word it would be consistency. They always…read moredeliver the same great customer service, the same clean and inviting dining room, and the same amazing fresh pizza. They have such a huge menu with so much to try and explore from sandwiches to wings to pasta dishes and even home made desserts, but the pizza is a staple and some of best NY and Detroit style I've ever had anywhere. Let alone in Illinois. I come here at least 2x a week and I'm always left more than satisfied. It's no wonder they've been voted the best in the area for almost a decade now. Dave Portnoy should venture out and leave a review. I think he'd approve.

First time ordering and definitely not the last I drove 30 minutes to get the stuffed bread and…read morepizza absolutely delicious!!! Wish you had a chain in crystal lake it was so good!!!

Awards

Detroit style pizza mushroom sausage

See all

More awards

Pizza Stop

3.8(24 reviews)

1.0 mi

The food is usually right and tasty! One star off - I ordered the sausage sandwich which has…read moresausage grilled onions. It has an option to remove the onions, add mustard. I only chose add mustard yet I barely got any and I had zero grilled onions. Disappointing.

the manager is not customer oriented. she was yelling at me on the phone when I tried to dispute my…read morepizza order that i placed online and it placed 2 separate orders! she wouldn't even offer. a refund or partial or credit she kept yelling at me about what she seen in her system and wasn't allowing me to explain what happened online . I will never ever eat there again and the pizza was less than good. I do not recommend this place at all! if you want good customer service this is not the place to go.

See all

Wednesday Special 12 WINGS 12 TACOS $34.99

Tony V's II

3.6(79 reviews)

1.9 mi

pizza is very good...lots of cheese and sauce is good. Nice outdoor area. They have garage doors…read morethat open out to the patio.

Pizza was very good hot when picked up and far more reasonable pricing than anywhere in Caryread more

Western pizza

See all

Rosati's Pizza

2.1(80 reviews)

0.7 mi

Great pepperoni and sausage pizza. Delivery was fast and…read morepizza was hot. Thanksgiving Eve made simple.

we ordered a pizza from here and when we got the pizza there was a bug in our pizza. We called…read moreRosati's and they said there was nothing we can do and they also denied that there was a bug in our pizza and they said that the bug got in there at our house which is not true. The staff was absolutely rude and didn't offer us any pizza or anything. we will never be going there again.

See all

Dead End Bar & Grill

4.2(44 reviews)

1.0 mi

We checked out The Dead End on a recommendation for their pizza, and it absolutely lived up to the…read morehype--the pizza was incredible! The place has that pure small-town bar/tavern feel, which makes it really stand out. Everyone was super friendly, and it just had a welcoming, laid-back vibe from the moment we walked in. Seating is a bit limited, but they do their best to get you a spot as quickly as possible. While you're waiting, the drinks are solid and the beer is ice cold--so it's an easy place to hang out. And don't skip dessert--they make a homemade cheesecake that is amazing. We tried the key lime pie version, and it was the perfect flavor to end the night. If you're looking for great pizza and a true local tavern experience, this place is definitely worth checking out

love this place pizza is amazing as well as the garden salads and the ranch dressing is on point…read more I have yet to try other stuff. Will be back again soon!

18 inch thin crust sausage

See all

Galati's Hideaway

3.2(204 reviews)

0.9 mi

We stopped in on a Thursday night and had a solid experience overall. It was pretty quiet in the…read morebar area, which made for a relaxed atmosphere, and a good spot to unwind. We sat at the bar and service was a little on the slower side, but nothing that took away from the night. I had the beef sandwich, and my wife went with the burger...both were really good. They also have a Thursday burger special for $10, which is a great deal and definitely worth checking out. The draft beer is always cold, and they've got a strong case for one of the best sports bar setups in McHenry County....plenty of TVs and a great place to catch a game. Overall, it's a dependable go-to spot whether you're meeting up with a big group, hanging out with friends, or just can't decide where to go for dinner. A nice, easy choice with something for everyone.

Great restaurant and bar. Nice place to watch a game or hang out. Nice atmosphere and nice place as…read morea woman to get dinner if she's alone. There is a restaurant to the left side of the entrance and a banquet room upstairs. Food is always delicious. Today a girlfriend of mine split the Philly Steak Sandwich special. We also split the burger. It was much too much food for the both of us. Unfortunately I left my container behind with my leftovers! Shout out to Jess the bartender who has waited on me a few times. Friendly, great customer service and great bartender. Highly recommend!

Our wedding table

Cheeseburger and fries. Cheeseburger was great. Bun was toasted. Fries were fresh and hot. The coleslaw tasted homemade.

See all

Front of the building

Kelsey Road House

3.0(401 reviews)

3.0 mi

What a great Valentine's Day dinner. This was our 50th Valentine's Day together. I wanted it to…read morebe special. We've been to Kelsey's lots of times and have always enjoyed their basement holiday and event themes. I thought I had reserved a table in the ever popular basement, but it turns out that on this busy Valentine's Day I accidentally requested a regular table upstairs. But to me, on special occasions, only the basement will do. I asked what, if anything, was available in the basement. The hostess responded that all they had available was a table in this awkward little room. So she took us downstairs just past the bottom of the staircase. It turns out to be this secluded little private alcove just before you enter the bar area. It was the absolute best. And the food, steak frites and patty melt, was very very good. If you go, request Ed & Mary's Awkward Room in the basement!

A great family joint, especially in the summertime with the back lawn and pergola. Enjoying the…read morefree live music this summer.

Loved this

Unmelted nachos

See all

Chicken salad

Lou Malnati's Pizzeria

3.2(72 reviews)

0.7 mi

Called about ordering a pick up pizza was put on hold for 15 minutes finally gave up and ordered…read morefrom another place

Love Lou's! But this was a horrible miss and not even edible. Staff was nice so added a star, but…read morethis deserves zero.

It's Lous

See all

Lou Malnatis pizzeria - seriously has done an awesome job with curbside pickup! Thanks team Lou!

Why does Yelp recommend reviews?

Hundreds of millions of reviews are posted on Yelp, and our automated recommendation software works in the background to showcase the reviews that it …

16 reviews that are not currently recommended

The reviews below are not factored into the business's overall star rating.

Kat D H.

9 years ago

This is my second visit to 750 Cucina Rustica my first visit I went with a party of four and I ordered their lasagna and it was not to my liking. It had excessive amounts of cheese and was too soupy. Even after that experience I decided to give it another try. On our second visit my husband ordered the lasagna and just by looking at it when he cut into it I could tell it had improved greatly. I decided to try his lasagna and it was delicious. Nothing like the first time I tried it. My compliments to the kitchen. I decided to try the braciole special with the pasta and it was delicious as well. Our waitress was very attentive and friendly and delivered great service. The decor of the restaurant is very cozy and rustic. The one thing I will say was not to my liking on both of my visits was that a woman (owner/manager) walks around like a sergeant hovering over the tables. I felt like I was being supervised on how I ate. She also speaks to the rest of the staff in a belittling way. I feel like that is a lack of discipline on her part. I believe an owner/manager should be humble before anything because that is what draws in your clientele. I would love to return to try other items on the menu. Hopefully I won't have any more bad experiences. read more

Tina L.

6 years ago

750 Cucina Rustica is our favorite Italian restaurant, near and far. The food is authentically outstanding and the service is fantastic. The owners are amazing people, so friendly, interactive with their guest and cater to us every time we come in. We always feel as if they personally invited us into their home. The live music every Friday and Saturday night is especially wonderful, as the groups that they hire are perfect additions to the already comforting ambiance. I just can't say enough about this diamond in the heart of our village. We feel so blessed to have this Taste of Italy right here and ready to serve our next delicious dish and cocktail. Many thanks to their Manager, Chase, the servers and bar staff who do a spectacular job every day! Check 750 Cucina Rustica out! You will NOT be disappointed! read more

Matt L.

9 years ago

Well what can I say.... This restaurant is really a find. If your in downtown Cary and have a craving for good authentic Italian food, 750 is solid. I ate here last night and I am already craving the arancini which are a traditional sicilian riceball delicacy. The appetizer of beets with burrata was exactly like the one I had in Rome Italy. Unexpectedly for being in Caray Illinois this place is a foody's dream spot. We also had the pizza which was a hybrid of neopolitan / traditional italian american. It was crispy, flavorful, and full of great ingredients. The family is Italian and much of the menu was created by the family which are the same owners of ZAZA's lake Barrington. Service was excellent and the deserts are to die for. Try the bastoncini al formaggio! I can't wait to go back. read more

Deb C.

9 years ago

What a great restaurant and well located. The atmosphere is warm and comfortable. We tried several appetizers as we were in a large group and they were all great. The goat cheese was excellent. We had the opportunity to try a number of different entrees and we were impressed. The baked pasta was absolutely wonderful. I will have it again. The rissoto was great, as well Had a very solid wine list and a great selection of beers. Service was excellent! Everyone we came into contact was great. The bar area is really nice. Great place to have a group or you can start or end your evening there. I was impressed and will definitely be back. read more

Leyla W.

8 years ago

Great independent restaurants are hard to find in this area, and the place is filled with: charm, great food and service with authentic cuisine that is inviting and humble. The owner and hostess, Antonia, is really the gem! She genuinely welcomes her guests, checks in with every table and patron, and might even sing a song or tell a story of childhood in Italy. The manager, Chace, is warm, always available, and dedicated to the restaurant. There are a few stand outs: chicken limone, lasagna, meatballs and arancini . . . Simple dishes made cravable! For me and my family after visiting just a few times, it feels like a home to us too! read more

Jim B.

8 years ago

I love this place so much I come here every Sunday. Great wine list with quality and good value across the menu. I love the appetizers (fried calamari with lemon is my all time favorite from anywhere) and their pasta dishes are unique, original and very tasty. Never had anything like them. For me though the best thing on the menu is the rustecca pizza. I can't get enough of it. Heck, even the free bread is the best (comes with amazing olive dish). Mia rules and every Sunday the owners come and talk to me and say hello. It makes you feel valued. All while Sinatra quietly plays in the background. read more

Debbie I.

3 years ago

I worked at 750 when first opened in 2018. I bragged to a friend from Naples about the authentic flavors from old country. Let me say beyond disappointment. Our server was amazing (Darrel), manager less than adequate with I don't care attitudes. Pizza used to be good with the flavors of the old country and the calimaei was tasteless and rubbery. Very disappointed that you brought quality of your establishment from prior years to the now mediocre to poor quality foods. I might as well fine to Rosatis. read more

Nick F.

9 years ago

Casual and sophisticated ambiance, my buddy had the orecchiette Rustica and was a baked pasta in a spicy sauce with sausage and pancetta I'm glad he let me try it, I had the lasagna and probably comes close or is the best I had, great Italian wine and when it came to desert I would of liked a bigger selection, service was good but not great, I will definitely be back. read more

Sallie L.

9 years ago

Beautiful remodel and great menu. Staff was very accommodating and the owners are there to oversee the operations and are also friendly and stop by your table to greet you. My favorite are the arancini siciliani and any of the brick oven pizzas. Great food, staff, and atmosphere read more

Jenny S.

9 years ago

Love Cucina Rustica. Their margarita pizza is outstanding and their garden and Caesar salads are absolutely delicious. I like that you get olives with the bread when you first arrive. It is a nice touch. Cozy ambiance and knowledgeable staff. read more

Steven F.

6 years ago

Worst pizza I've ever had and it was badly burnt I didn't even ask for a refund but was told they can't do refunds. They said they would send me a gift card for my trouble but I never received it Stay away read more

Alex K.

9 years ago

Aboslutely amazing! The atmosphere was great! Really calm and relaxing. I bought a pizza and it was one of the best things i have tasted. Absoulutely love this place, i would reccomend this to all people. read more

Antoinette L.

2 years ago

If you are looking for a good place to grab dessert, Come for their Tiramisu. The rest of the food is always great but the star of the show is the Tiramisu for me. read more

Ella P.

9 years ago

Best. Italian. Restaurant. Ever. The food her was amazing and so we're the desserts!! Had the pizza and the chocolate truffle gelato. It was truly amazing. read more

Dan D.

7 years ago

Surprised and dippoiintred. Rude and condisending. Will never go here again.. Self-egranndizing butt holes. A shamfful representative of Cary. read more

B W.

5 years ago

As always, a 5 star experience. Never disappointed. Can't wait for them to open for lunch again.

750 Cucina Rustica - italian - Updated July 2026

People who viewed 750 Cucina Rustica also viewed

Florio's Italian

3.8

(37 reviews)

Spectacular. Hidden gem…read more Always excellent Italian. Service is great. The restaurant is beautiful.

Disappointing experience. The inside of the restaurant was very pretty but tables were way too…read moreclose together. The servers could barely get around our table because of how close it was to others tables. Our table was much too close to the area where servers get glassss for the tables. Servers kept squeezing by us and bumping us to get to the glasses. The restaurant was very busy and understaffed. Only 2 servers for the whole restaurant. They really need at least 3. Our server kept apologizing for the wait. We never got our bread. With the restaurant being new I figured a manager would come check on the customers. I never saw anyone do so at any of the tables including ours. The food was average. Not bad by any means but not worth the poor service for sure. Maybe they need to work out the kinks still because they're new but we were disappointed.

Goal Line Sports Bar & Grill

3.5

(102 reviews)

Service very friendly, atmosphere great energy. The French onion soup really good. The chilli was…read moregreat. The wings were good. The burger was cooked perfect, and toppings really good. The coleslaw was really good, not mayonnaisee at all. Overall really good.

cone here often for soccer. Today cane for England and Norway match. We were allowed to go inside…read moreby the outside lady, but the horrible old blonde hag was offensive- never been spoken too like ahe did. Her concern was we hadn't checked in but my wife had. She then refused to serve us, serving everybody else than us. Horrible person. Will never return.

Aliano's Ristorante

4.0

(367 reviews)

Came into this restaurant today with my aunt who's sick, it was good to get out for the first time…read morein a while. We had this AMAZING server angelina, she was full of smiles and very cheerful! great sense of urgency! and totally made our day after these hard few weeks!! Food was also outstanding!!! Will be returning for both the great hospitality, and food!!

Visited Aliano's to sit on their covered patio and enjoy dinner with music. We didn't wait long to…read morebe sat which was nice. They had a gentleman singing and playing acoustic guitar. The runners quickly brought us waters, complimentary bread, and a balsamic glaze/olive oil mixture to dip bread into. The menu had a great variety. I ended up sharing the Rigatoni Mama and my friend got the Homemade Manicotti. The pastas did take a while to come out but the patio was pretty packed. Once the pastas arrived, we did ask for some more bread which sadly came out a but stale. The first round was WAY better. My friend started cutting into her pasta and immediately found a hair baked in. We called our server over and they immediately took it away to remake. They offered a complimentary dessert but we kindly asked to comp the dish instead. The Rigatoni Mama was tasty and a good portion to share! With all the hardships, our server Hannah could not have been better. She navigated the situation calmly and professionally. She was very understanding and continued to bring a happy demeanor to our table. I could not be more impressed by her service level especially since the manager did not stop at our table to correct the situation.

The Village Squire North

3.2

(250 reviews)

Sunday at 2:00pm. Quick seating this time of day. Alexia L…read more Met us and super courteous (give her a raise!) Pork with mushroom gravy just right. Side perfectly done. Unfortunately there was no room for dessert Very under stated dining place. Oh.... And the popcorn when we sat down...

Village Squire Crystal Lake makes the best salmon dishes. Turkey club is great. Everything else is…read morereally good too.

Rookies All American Pub & Grill

3.1

(28 reviews)

Rookies has become our go to spot to watch sports and have dinner. We have been to almost all of…read morethem and this location, Crystal Lake, is my favorite. My kids absolutely love the chicken fingers. My husband loves the burgers and the pizza. We all enjoy the pretzel appetizer. Service is always great and there is always a tv in view so you won't miss any important games.

Visited for the first time today. Cute place - two stories with lots of tvs for watching sports…read more Service was great. Super friendly server. Popcorn is available which is a nice touch. We selected a couple of appetizers and iced tea so not too exciting but there were plenty of good items on the menu. Food was plentiful and prices were comparable. They have pizza too which I think I'd try on my next visit.

Squire On The Square

3.7

(51 reviews)

Good service. Wide variety on the menu. Nice atmosphere, family friendly. You can call ahead and…read moreget your name on the list , kind of convenient, as I do not think they take reservations.

Okay this is a tough one to write. Squire on the Square bar area was used in the movie Groundhog…read moreDay, so we really wanted to give it a try. The atmosphere is very cool, the place is quite big and good for large groups and family meals. The staff was so friendly, and I mean everyone. From the hostess who seated us and immediately told us that Happy Hour was ending in about 15 minutes and to order as soon as we could for any bottles of wine, beer or appetizers. I appreciate that. Our server came over to take our appetizer and drink order. We ordered a bottle of wine and an appetizer, the potato skins. She was so friendly and it was a pleasure chatting with her. The potato skins were delivered to our table and were actually delicious. They were crunchy and the cheese was perfectly melted and topped with bacon. While we enjoyed our potato skins, several servers and the restaurant manager stopped to check on us, which was so nice. Then it was time to order our dinner, and we were going a bit light. I chose to have a bowl of the soup of the day which was creamed corn soup. Mr. Bee decided to have the tuna tacos. Our dinner was delivered in a timely manner and this is where the disappointment came in. My soup was supposed to be cream of corn. it wasn't creamed, it was creamy, with pieces of chewy kernels. There was no seasoning, it tasted if it was just corn and milk or cream, not even any salt. I didn't finish it. Mr. Bee's tacos were odd. The tortillas weren't fried, just warmed and flimsy. The tuna was not like poke. It was shredded, cut, cooked through and not really appetizing. He ate some of the tuna out of the tacos, but nowhere finished his meal and I have never seen him not finish tuna tacos. So when I said this was hard to write, it is. The staff, from the hostess to the servers who jumped in and helped each other deliver food and clear plates to the restaurant manager who checked in twice, they were excellent. Where the downfall is is in the food. Nothing after the potato skins was seasoned, poke tuna tacos would be amazing and the creamed corn soup should have been pureed, with seasoning, maybe a little bacon on top. It was all just so bland and disappointing. So I am giving the staff five stars and the food earns two. It could be great!

The Village Squire

3.0

(166 reviews)

Loved the ambiance here, we went here off a whim after landing for a day of travel and it was…read morenothing aside from good vibes and good food. I've never seen a place that gives you popcorn as a sit down appetizer but I was here for it. Loved the server she was super engaging and friendly, highly recommend for your next medieval themed sit down.

Excellent spot for a true restaurant meal. They have lunch and dinner and a very nice bar area. It…read morewas an open roomy restaurant with several larger rooms and comfortable looking tables and seats. All natural wood with a Barvarian lodge type feel. It reminded me of the family style places we would go as kids with the folks for a big night out. When we walked in the place was comfortably full with many large parties and couples seated around the restaurant. Pretty impressive for a Wednesday early evening. Even the bar had a nice crowd. Outside there is a very nice sized patio for dining right on the Fox River. We sat at a nice large table next to a window looking over the Fox River. They start you off with a basket of fresh buttered popcorn. A nice start. I really don't think there is a bad table in the house the way they have it set up. The ambiance is excellent, homey, warm, and welcoming. I can see this place being a total holiday scene. The menu has all the traditional American fare and a page dedicated to authentic Greek fare. Cuisine only true Greek restaurant would serve. They also had an excellent separate Octoberfest menu with all the traditional German fare. A great choice for a chilly fall evening. Several parties had pizza on the table which honestly looked excellent. I imagine it's a bit a a neighborhood spot for the kids too. Our server Lily knew her stuff, and seamlessly guided us through our ordering. She explained all the items we asked about and seemed to really enjoy being there. Lily knew it was a Greek owned restaurant which for me is a huge UPS! I'm not Greek but having been in the industry myself for some years I know the quality and high expectations of any Greek owned restaurant. We started with a bowl of French Onion soup and Cream of Chicken soup. Both truly excellent and the real deal. Two Iced teas that came in what seemed to be some cool repurposed jelly jars. Excellent touch in the comfy factor. We split and Octoberfest meal of german sausage combo with red cabbage and sour kraut and potato pancakes. It was a great choice and a truly authentic plate of three different sausages all cooked to perfection. Complete with sour cream and applesauce. All in all an excellent meal with an excellent server Lily. I will most definitely be back in the next few weeks. It's totally worth the drive from Chicago.

Dead End Bar & Grill

4.2

(44 reviews)