Tucked away in Gravenstein Hwy sits a pizza place that one can overlook. I decided to venture out to try a new pizza and see what it was all about. I was taken away by the decor, the pool table, and a small arcade. This is definitely a place that you come and hangout with some friends. The staff is friendly and knowledgeable about their pizza, and they really took care of me when I told them it was my first time there. They told me that they serve New York style and Detroit style pizza. I'll have to try Detroit someday, but for now I focused on New York style. I ordered a spicy sausage pizza and a pepperoni which had hot honey. I only ever had hot honey in Los Angeles, so I was hoping it would be delicious. The spicy sausage pizza was delicious, flavors were balanced and I tasted everything they laid out. The pizza is thin so it's definitely New York style and the crust was so crispy and light. The thing I love about New York style pizza is just how edible the crust are. I feel like you can just have them as breadsticks and I would buy them. The hot honey pizza was an out of the world flavor. If I had to pick one pizza for anyone to try it's this New York Pepperoni with hot honey. This is an amazing balance of sweet and savory. The first bite really took my tastebuds on a ride and I was ready for another. The pepperoni pizza wasn't too greasy and the honey just really brought the flavor altogether. I had hot honey in LA, now I'm glad to say, I don't need to go to LA for that. If you have a desire for pizza, look no further than Acre Pizza! read more

See all

We stalled in here on way to Sebastopol, it was a nice place for a quick lunch. Food: 4/5 My boys and I got a slice of pizza, my wife got a Ceasar salad with chicken added. We thought the food was good. The pizza had a sourdough crust and was really good. The salad was fresh and had a good dressing. Customer service: 5/5 We had great customer service from the staff that was working. They were polite, quick and had the restaurant cleaned up nicely. Ambiance: 5/5 They had a few pinball machines reasonably priced (50 cents a game) and a pool table that was free to play. It was nice to play a game with the boys after enjoying our food. They also had plenty of seating between indoors and their outdoor patio. Price: 2.5/5 I thought it was a little over priced, but I know this is pretty normal for eating out at a place like this. The pizza was about $8-9 a slice, the salad it was $19 ($14 +$5 for the chicken). The total for 3 slices and a salad was about $50. Overall, it was good and we had a nice time eating here on our family outing. read more

See all

It was our first time here, and we came as a group of four. The first thing we noticed almost immediately was how hot it was inside, despite there being three air conditioners in the room. None of them were on, even though it was 78 degrees outside. Weird... The pizza was mediocre at best. We ordered a sausage and mushroom pizza (pretty simple). Apparently, adding mushrooms cost an extra 3$. Our friends got the Detroit pepperoni pizza, which was also just ok. Both pizzas lacked flavor. I would say the prices don't match the quality. The service was ok, nothing outstanding. We could barely even notice any af the workers since they were quiet and not very friendly/talkative. The only good thing was the drink from Parliament Brewery. I don't think we will be back. read more

Acre Pizza - Detroit pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cotati, California

See all

PRO TIP: BE SURE TO ASK THEM TO HOLD THE HAIR WHEN ORDERING SO IT DOESN'T END UP IN YOUR FOOD!!!!! My salad had a disgusting long hair in it (see pic). Ended up throwing all the food away after losing my appetite to the extra "garnish" discovered in my food. Emailed Acre to inform them of the experience. Courtney the "Admin Director" apologized and said she'd refund us. After providing her our order details and the card # twice she stopped responding and never refunded us like she said she would! Shit food and even worse customer service to make up for it! read more

See all

Love stopping here on my way to visit my parents. You basically get two slices for the price of one. Plain cheese is perfect thin NY style. Some of the best ranch dressing I've ever had. The Roman style is a real treat--I love the crust!!! The mushroom w blue cheese is unbelievable. Best pizza in the area, don't bother w Physic Pie--this is just as good and much better bang for the buck. read more

Acre Pizza - Pinball!!! - Pizza Near Me - Cotati, California

First time at the Cotati location. Parking lot made it do easy to pick up an order togo. Pizza is good. Nice chewy texture of dough. Good quality ingredients. My only complaint is that it is really expensive. $48.00 for a vegan pizza for take out. read more

Acre Pizza - Broccolini pizza. Made it vegan. - Pizza Near Me - Cotati, California

Very flavorful! Make sure to order the hot honey with it! It's very cute with outside patio to enjoy. They have a pool table to play as well. read more

Acre Pizza - Detroit Cheese with bacon and potato - Pizza Near Me - Cotati, California

Thank you for hosting Super Bowl '26! It was great being here in a comfortable and hospitable environment, with amazing pizza! Different varieties that are unique with rich ingredients. The moist rice crispies are the cherry on top after, recommend. I especially want to show cred to The front man Blake ‍ read more

First coffee and then the Roman pizza, Acre has a habit of giving us something great and then taking it from us. I will not be lured here as regularly as I was before. The Roman pizza just hits differently. read more

Acre Pizza - This is false advertising. Acre no longer has the Román style of pizza. Sad! - Pizza Near Me - Cotati, California

Originally planned on going to Tony's at Graton, but they don't allow kids, so we went here, and I was glad to try a different (and definitely quality) place. It's a lighter crust for the NY and Detroit. Less airy or bubbly than I'm used to, but still soft and fluffy. The edges of the Detroit are crispy, but not as well done as maybe a traditional style. But, maybe that helps keep it fluffy and tender. I'm glad we could try this place and will come here next time I'm in the area read more

Super friendly staff,the high lite for me was the cheesy bread pizzia appetizer!!!loaded with cheese, I tried a couple of the fancy square slices,mushroom and also pepperoni with hot honey,they were both tasty!I also got a large pepperoni round style, it was good but I wish I would have got the square instead!!!over all nice place good food and decent prices read more

Acre Pizza - Large pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Cotati, California

See all

What I ordered: -Detroit Style Ranch [4.5/5] -NY Half Meat Lover/Half Spicy Sausage [3/5] _ I visited Acre Pizza on Sunday afternoon for lunch and opted for takeout. Since I didn't go inside, I can't comment on the ambiance. I'd heard that orders can take up to 30 minutes, so we called ahead to place our order. The worker who took our call was exceptionally kind and patient. We ordered a New York-style pizza, half meat lovers and half spicy sausage which were good. The standout, however, was the Detroit-style ranch pizza. It was my first time trying Detroit-style pizza, and it exceeded my expectations. The crust was nearly as thick as focaccia bread, and the toppings were incredibly flavorful. read more

Acre Pizza - New York Style Meat Lover / Spicy Sausage - Pizza Near Me - Cotati, California

See all

Acre Pizza is da bomb. They deserve the accolades they've earned. I love their deep dish!! We got the chicken pesto Detroit style pie and it was delicious to the last bite, especially paired with a local Henhouse brewski. This newer location is a cool little spot, complete with outdoor seating, pool and some arcade games. The workers are kind and looked like they enjoyed their job, slangin' pizzas and making days. Thanks, Cotati Acre!! read more

Acre Pizza is always good with fresh pizza. You can never go wrong with a solid local spot. Be sure to grab the ice cream sandwich sandwiches too, they're always a nice treat. read more

We go to Acre for their weekly trivia. They have many options to suit the whole family with their pizza by the slice. The slices are huge and worth the cost. The service is always great and usually pretty quick. It's a great family establishment. read more

Terrible service.... First off, It took us five minutes to order Seccond, they acted annoyed we ordered a pizza an hour before they closed. There was a woman working that seemed to give her coworkers a hard time. We heard her nagging them while we were trying to enjoy our meal. read more

Always fresh and ready! Great location to go with their amazing pizza options and the service is on point. You might want to grab a table outside and enjoy the day or evening. read more

My neighbor & I were anxious to try Acre Pizza as it is down the street from us and we love the pizza at their Petaluma location. I really wanted to give a fabulous review, but unfortunately my first visit wasn't a wow experience. The service was meh- not welcoming by any means. The prices are a tad high, but what isn't these days? The total for a pizza (that feeds 2-3 people) and the salad came to $48. The salad we had was really tasty with lots of goodies in it. Sadly, the pizza lacked flavor. It looked great and I liked the crust, but was quite bland- even after adding Parmesan & pepper flakes. My friend and I both agreed that likely there was not much cheese on it. I would like to give this restaurant another chance as it is local. Fingers crossed will have a better experience. read more

See all

Awesome pizza place kinda in the middle of nowhere, outside of Cotati, going towards Sebastopol on 116. They have an outside patio to sit and the inside is very big and open with windows all around so it's a nice ambience to hangout enjoy your day watch the cars go bye and there's farm lands around the back as well. There was actually a chicken hanging out last time I was there I love chickens, so that was cool, I guess it doesn't really belong there though they were trying to find it's home. The workers were very friendly and efficient. The food was obviously very good or I would not have given four stars. They even serve pizza by the slice which is fine and they had a pretty nice solid menu. I'm not sure if there was beer wine or liquor because I was kind of in a hurry. Just grabbing some food to go home. I do plan to go back there though and eat with my family bc it seemed like a good kid friendly place especially on the patio where my toddler can wander a bit and look around while we wait for our food. read more

Came here for restaurant week and a great bargain. Cotati location is new and very nice. Pizza was awesome. A hidden gem in cotati. read more

Acre Pizza - Caesar salad - Pizza Near Me - Cotati, California

See all

Pizza is very good and different since I got the Detroit pizza. Best deep dish type of pizza I have ever had. The pizza was airy but thick and the sauce was amazing. We also got the meatballs and it was great, but when ordering online it said it would be ready by 7pm, though we ended up getting a text message that it was ready at 6:30pm, so we ended up not getting there fast enough and the meatballs were not warm. The pizza was warm, but not the meatballs. Then when ordering the meatballs it comes with volcano bread and for some reason the bread was very hard to chew. I give 5 star still though because this is a pizza place and the pizza was amazingggg! Service was okay as they were busy and it seemed as if only one person was helping pick up orders and taking people on register, therefore we waited a few minutes to get our food. The actually restaurant was cute and had a great patio area with cornhole! Food is expensive, but worth it. For meatballs and pizza it ended up being around 42 dollars. I would definitely come here with friends or family and hang out at the restaurant. read more

Acre Pizza - Meatballs with volcano bread - Pizza Near Me - Cotati, California

See all

Tried to come with a group for pizza, drinks, and trivia. All of the tables outside were taken 45 minutes before trivia started, each with only one person holding the table. Despite being a group of six ready to order, the restaurant made no attempts to accommodate us. Instead they allowed people to wait and hold tables for their groups arriving later even if they weren't ordering anything. We would have stayed but had a dog with us so couldn't change our plans to sit inside. This place should make it easier to spend money or at least limit other people from taking tables unless they ordered food or drinks. Pizza was good when I ate at another location at least. read more

Why 5 stars? Great location and spacious inside. The Greek salad was big enough to share, fresh, and delicious. The thin crust pizzas were tasty, crisp, and crave-able. Anytime I'm in the area this is an option. read more

I found this place to have the best pizza in the area! Spencer at the register has great customer service skills. Ambiance is a nice and relaxing. read more

$70 for two pizzas and they won't even give you a side of ranch. Rude employees and always takes much longer than estimated ready time. Pizza is ok, gluten free is decent and the only reason we go here. The salads are terrible, old romaine with literally 5 croutons, way over priced for what it is. read more

Amazing Detroit style New York style yummy Nice place , clean and indoor and outdoor seating. read more

See all

Ordered the Detroit Pepperoni pizza. It was excellent. It sure seemed to be very authentic based on my little bit of research of this type of pizza. A bit expensive but it was sure tasty. The marinara sauce was an excellent and was poured in two lines along the pizza just like the authentic pizza. Also had a craft beer. They have about 5 different beers to choose from. The location is great. It's very clean inside and the service was excellent. As we were leaving, it was nice to hear a thank you for coming from the manager, which I think all places should do as you're spending hard earned $$$ to dine at their establishment. We will definitely return and try another of their many pizzas to choose from. read more

Great pizzeria with a cool variety of pies, including Detroit-style thick crust and vegan options. I'm partial to the classic NY pepperoni, which is absolutely perfect. You can also buy a slice (which is really two slices), which is how I get my fix. Otherwise, I'd probably eat a whole pie! Outside patio is great too. read more

I had such a wonderful experience at the New Cotati location of Acre. The outdoor space was expansive (and had outdoor heaters!) and the inside space was clean, large, and perfect for the vibe of great food in a pretty casual setting (bring your coworkers, parter, friends, kids, or any combination.) You could grab a quick slice and a drink, or wait a few minutes for a wonderful freshly made pie (or volcano bread, which is my recommendation.) One thing that really set this restaurant apart was the staff. Literally I have never had a better experience in a restaurant. They were so friendly, and it is obvious that they have extremely high standards for customer service. Not only do I recommend Acre (in Cotati) I will probably go there again next week... and probably the week after :) read more

Acre Pizza - Volcano bread (with prosciutto) which comes with a marinara side. A mexican coke and an Acre chopped salad. - Pizza Near Me - Cotati, California

We decided to hive Acre a try based on the great reviews. We ordered the Detroit style pepperoni pizza which was about $28 to go. I was told it would be ready in about 20 mins. Unfortunately when I came back 20 mins later it was not ready yet. 30 mins later it was still not ready yet. When I finally got my pizza I jaw fell to the floor. $30 and I was handed a personal size box. Literally the pizza was 4 slices!!! Granted I should've read the size before ordering but damn I have never had a pizza this small for $30! Are you kidding me?! It was definitely not enough for my fam of 4 but we were not going to wait another 30+ mins and another $30 in the hole. The pizza itself was good don't get me wrong, but not for $30 for 4 slices. This is hands down the most expensive pizza we have ever ordered since we would need 2 to feed 4. Just beware before ordering Detroit I think I definitely would have gotten the thin crust if it meant it was a normal pizza size. read more

Acre Pizza - Detroit Pepperoni ($27+) - Pizza Near Me - Cotati, California

I want to update my previous review. Acre took the negative feedback to heart from the trivia players, and they have worked hard to improve their customer service. We are now enjoying our trivia nights there. Their pizza is tasty, and the salads are good. It is a bit pricey, but what isn't these days. Solid 4 stars now. read more

I know I am late to the party but wow, Acre puzza, is really really good. The 72 hour fermented dough (I asked ) is delicious and so darn flavorful. Chewy and crisp...even Dave Portnoy would approve of the no flop undercarriage. The cheese was a very unique and tasty blend. Tomato sauce was spicy and lightly applied...as it should be. I had the NY pepperoni and my wife the mushroom. I've had the Detroit and it's also tasty. Lots of specials . Service is great and they have solid selection of beer. Wine was meh. Salads looked good as well. Great service and value. Very clever and not overly bedazzled inside. read more

See all

I went there one Sunday and was truly disgusted in seeing houseflies all over their pizza. This establishment definitely violated health code. I would highly advised people be careful because it was not a pleasant sight. I have never gone back. read more

My recent visit to Acre Pizza was an exercise in frustration and patience. The evening began with a seemingly simple task: getting our ordered pizzas to our table. However, the staff managed to turn this into a comedy of errors that left me questioning the competence of the entire operation. To start, our server dropped our food at the wrong table. Rather than promptly rectifying the mistake, the staff opted for a silent approach and decided to place a new order without informing us. It was only when we proactively inquired about our missing pizza that the truth came to light - an unnecessary delay and an aggravating revelation. The lack of communication and accountability on the part of the staff was disheartening. Waiting an additional 30+ minutes for the replacement pizza only added insult to injury. While I can appreciate a good pizza, the overall service left much to be desired. Despite the deliciousness of the pizzas, the experience was marred by the incompetence displayed by the staff. It's evident that there is a need for retraining and better communication protocols within the establishment. Perhaps they could learn a thing or two from their Petaluma location which we order from frequently - five stars for you Petaluma! read more

This just recently went up as my favorite local pizza place. I'm always kind of slow to try out new pizza restaurants because there are always so many, but I am so happy I tested them out. I'm now a Detroit-style pizza convert and can't stop ordering it. Great staff, very nice outdoor seating. It's going on the S-tier list. read more

I love this place but they've forgotten to put basil the past couple times i've paid $2 extra for it. i just want my basil man

I've been to acre Pizza in The Barlow and in Petaluma-- the pizza has unique taste.always good. You do not need a lot of toppings on it for the taste delicious.... And the price is livable. It's my family go to pizza place now. read more

The food at this location is really good and the customer service is on point. If you want a delicious pizza with good service go to acre Pizza. read more

I love the NY pizza, it's nice and thin, full of flavor. I can't typically eat pizza because the red sauce on other pizzas give me heart burn, too acidic. The sauce on this pizza does not. My family and I played pinball and the pool table is free to play. Pinball runs $1 on two machines, and .50 on another. My 12 year old and 16 year old granddaughters got their first introduction to pinball and they loved it. A great place, in door and outdoor for a couple hr outing, getting kids out of the house and away from their cell phones. We had a great time. The only reason I didn't do 5 stars is because I agree, the place is too warm inside, and they leave the door open which brings in all the flies. They should resolve that, recommendation is to install fans if no air-conditioning or turn on the airconditioning, and keep the doors shut to keep the flies out, or install a mesh screen to walk through. Other than that, my new fav pizza place! A bit pricy, bit most pizza is now days, prefer to pay a little more for a good pizza and a fun place to go. read more

Recently ordered for pick-up from Cotati location. As we arrived in the lot, the notification came in that our order was ready... right on time. As I entered, there were two visible staff members that both acknowledged my presence either verbally or with a nod and a smile. There was one person ahead of me at the pick-up counter. Their interaction with the staff member was friendly and efficient. On my turn, the staff member confirmed the order as we exchanged pleasantries. I was walking out with my hot order shortly thereafter. As I walked back to the car I noticed the picnic tables under the covered patio. I thought that it would be a good place to enjoy some pizza and beer with a couple of your favorite people. (They have trivia night on Thursday!) After a couple of minutes, we were back home. I went straight for a slice. Yum! We got the NY Summer Solstice + Zoe's Pepperoni. How does one even describe it? Crust was soft and slightly crispy. And the flavors... oh the flavors! This was our first time trying Acre and it won't be our last! It's already earned a top spot in our periodic local pizza rotation. Thanks Cotati Acre! May you live long and prosper! read more