I've been coming here since I was a kid, and it still means a lot to me. While some reviews focus on the negatives, my experiences have been consistently positive. The pizza has a nostalgic, unique flavor you won't find at big chains. It's a classic neighborhood spot with character and history, and the staff has always been kind in my visits. If you appreciate a longtime local place with heart, it's definitely worth checking out. *ps will honor competitors coupons ! read more

Alfy's Pizza - Half pepperoni / pineapple and cheese - Pizza Near Me - Marysville, Washington

Been going to Alfy's since I was a kid. Love it! I miss the Everett one. I have to drive 30 minutes to Marysville but it's worth the drive. I know a lot of people who drive to the Monroe and Marysville one over 30 minutes just to get it. Salad bar is great pizza is great. They have games for kids. Great place for a sports team party or small birthday. read more

Alfy's Pizza - Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Marysville, Washington

They evidently changed their sauce. First bite was not good. No one in our group liked it. Called to complain and no manager on duty. Something diffinely wrong. Will never go back to Alphy's Marysville. We all had violent stomach cramps. I wish I drove it back to the store as the employee could have cared less on our complaint. read more

Met our family today at Alfy's! First of all, Ella was amazing- her Customer Care is outstanding, even when she was helping multiple people at the same time. Her smile and patience never wavered. The salad bar was fresh and the pizza was delicious We played air hockey and other video games. What a great day! Thank You, Alfy's! read more

I left my jacket and the cashier lady brought it outside to me before we left and I had a lot of fun in the game room.

The fact that Alfys doesn't get more recognition blows my mind. The cheese quality and ingredients are unmatched, this is the taste of my childhood! The ranch is so good, it makes it just that much better. It makes me so sad that less and less restaurants are open, and I truly, truly hope this one sticks around. The people are kind and know what EXTRA CHEESE looks like :) absolute heaven. read more

Alfy's Pizza - Half double cheese half double pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - Marysville, Washington

What happened to this place? Pizza taste like the sauce is burnt when I call to complain they said they are using different supplier so now they know why nobody comes back taste terrible I will never go back bye bye alfys read more

I grew up with Alfy's and I think the pizzas some of the best! Plus, they always have a salad bar fully stocked!

The salad bar and bread sticks were delicious., nothing to brag about. VERY CLEAN. The service however, was NOT GOOD. Although I hardly rate service as Terrible,.. the ladies that work there, are downright rude. I totally get that the restaurant business is difficult, but this took it to another level. I really hope that these ladies take a deep breath and know this job is just a job, not a life changer. read more

The chicken wings were meaty but not crispy. Service was poor--the two guys working seemed grumpy and unwelcoming. The pizza was okay, but not anything special. Unfortunately, I won't be going back. read more

It's the people oh yeah and the food that makes me keep coming back. The service if great, they give you that little bit of extra of anything to make you happy. I want to thank them all ! read more

Prices are through the roof 16 bucks a person for a salad bar and 25 bucks for a medium pizza??? No wonder you are going out of business..I used to love you guys but not going to spend $100 + dollars at f-ing Alfa's read more

I just visited the Marysville location on 5/24/2025 for the second time and the last time. My roommate ordered unlimited salad bar and I ordered the single visit salad bar. The salad bar is ok but not stellar. My roommate also ordered a medium cheese pizza and I chimed in to make a thin crust. The cashier seemed scattered but they were also getting slammed. We got our salads and sat down. The pizza came out in a timely fashion but was a regular crust pizza. I brought it back to the cashier and told her that I ordered a thin crust not a regular crust. She proceeded to get a little crusty with me and said I didn't order a thin crust, I did because that's the only kind I like and it's less bloating on my stomach. She proceeded to scroll through her orders and discovered that she did put regular crust down. She then ran to the back like a little tattletale and told, who I'm assuming was the manager the situation. The chick came back out and basically said, oh well. This is the wrong answer. I've been a general manager, I've worked in high end restaurants and customer service and this is not what you do. What should have happened is, they should have fired up another pizza, written the pizza they messed up off and given it to their staff. That's what I would have done. Bad customer service! To top off the experience, once I got home I got bad diarrhea and their food was the only food I consumed that day. read more

Absolutely horrendous customer service. My family and I can in for pizza and an all you can eat salad bar. We paid for our pizza, then my daughter and I went to go through the salad bar. I thought I would get all you can eat so my daughter and I could share. As we were going through and had our salad on the plate just about to get dressing, a lady comes up, older brunette with shoulder length hair I'm assuming she was the manager. Anyway she comes ip and proceeds to tell me that my daughter has a pizza plate. I then tell her oh that's because we bought that all you can eat so we can share. I looked at her and told her OK we'll pay for it when I'm done. She grabs the plate out of my daughter's hand and dumps the salad in the garbage. I then asked her if she was serious. She said oh yes, I'm very serious My pizza was coming to the table and then I'm telling my husband what happened and she proceeds to tell us that we have to get our food to go.. I paid for the extra salad and I'm absolutely blown away at the awful customer service skills and the audacity! As I was paying for the 2 nd salad I asked the cashier for the managers info and she told me she couldn't give out names! We ate our food and left read more

I used to come here all the time but the service isn't great, they became sticklers over everything I grabbed a breadstick while waiting on our food which took awhile but then they acted like it was a crime to have a free breadstick when my girlfriend had the unlimited salad bar, in general a terrible experience over absolutely nothing I will not be returning or recommending this place going forward, goodluck with everything read more

Has a great salad bar and service staff are always very polite and accommodating. There pizzas are decent and have great specials on Thursdays. read more

So our baseball team had an end of season party at this Alfy's pizza. We placed our order ahead of time to make sure our food would be ready during the party, and they happily put in. The service seemed rather on point for this visit compared to previous visits which was a nice change. the pizza was decent but a bit over priced. I did really enjoy the salad bar as it had lots of options and seemed very clean. The space we had our party was a nice size for party kept everyone together yet far enough apart so we were not squished together. Overall the party was a success and food was decent and we had an enjoyable time. read more

See all

The pizza is always great, they make the best Hawaiian pizza with the thin round Canadian bacon and not the julienned. The salad bar was fresh, nothing wilted or warm. read more

Delicious, hot and reasonably priced! We love this location but wished they delivered to our home only 6 miles from them. ???? read more

Just wanted a Salad bar, it was real nice!!! All the toppings l love, everything was Very Fresh, I'll be going back soon!! read more

Alfy's Pizza - Perfect salad and garlic breadsticks!!! - Pizza Near Me - Marysville, Washington

Love Alfy's pizza! Family owned and been around for years. Real ingredients. One of a few pizza places that doesn't make me feel sick after eating it. read more

Alfy's Pizza - Alfy's Special. - Pizza Near Me - Marysville, Washington

We called weeks in advance to reserve the party room by the arcade for my son's birthday. We get there about 45 minutes early the day of to decorate and greet our guests when then they arrive and they were irritated and annoyed and laughed at us saying "you are an hour early" I said well the room is empty and we just want to decorate and set things up. She huffed back to talk to who I assume was her supervisor. She came back and said well your time is at noon but I guess since you are here it is fine. She showed us to the room and it was not the party room we had requested by the arcade and had small booths everywhere. I had brought table cloths for longer tables. She told my husband "you can move the tables as long as you put them back". So I started putting a few together to put my tablecloths on. An older lady then came back and started raising her voice and said we "aren't supposed to move the tables and if we don't follow the rules we will get fined" Are you kidding me? They had also told my ex husband on the phone when we booked the room that we could come early to decorate since we are the first party of the day. I was not happy and my 12 year old son (it was his party) was getting upset and saying "this is supposed to be a happy day" Horrible customer service and made a huge deal out of what had should have gone happily and smoothly. We will never go back. read more

I've had a generally great experience going here and consider myself a regular on pick up pizza. The pizza itself is fantastic and the staff are lovely. Get your pizza lightly sauced and it'll be so damn good read more

This was the worst experience that I have ever had. Customer Service was I'll take your order at 7:02 pm for a pitcher of beer and 2 all you can eat salad bars. We start breaking down our salad bar at 7:30. At 7:20 they started breaking down the salad bar. We rushed over to get more salad. At 7:30-7: 45, they are obvious that they want us to leave, they were loud and they turned off the music. Then a woman came over and said, "we close our dining room at 7:30. We had to drink our pitcher of beer and leave. We were charged an 8.00% (3.28) service charge. F you, the worst customer service. Way to go, you'll be out of business very soon!! We will never return again!! My post is a Zero star!! RUDE read more

Alfy's Pizza - A service charge in bad taste - Pizza Near Me - Marysville, Washington

My families favorite pizza! Staff is friendly and the restaurant is clean. Also love it for the kids sports teams:)

We didn't come in during a busy time. The service was good and the food came out quickly. Pizza and breadsticks were pretty good. The arcade was nothing fancy: air hockey table, foosball, basketball shooting game, out of order race car game, and some fighting games. Bill for a large pepperoni pizza, all you can eat salad bar, 2 kid drinks, and 2 water glasses was $27. Probably won't be back but it was a good outing with the kids. read more

Alfy's Pizza - Arcade - Pizza Near Me - Marysville, Washington

See all

I called in advance to ask if they had any senior discounts, or any other kind of discount specials. The employee I talked to said they had a 15% (?) senior discount on anything at any time; but what was better was for me to use a 35% discount on any pizza during the 11 am - 2 pm lunch time window. So, I went there during that time window, and first asked (a different employee, who was at the counter) if the lunch special discount was still going on, and the employee said yes. So I ordered a small Alfy's Special pizza. When my order had been calculated on the check-out system, I was told a total that seemed too high, given the price of the pizza listed on the menu. I asked about why the price was that high, and I was first told that the 25% discount for lunch had indeed been taken off - and I interrupted at that point to say that I was told on the phone that the lunch discount was 35%. She said "No, only 25%". ... But just for the record, I later used the dinner price for the pizza, ($15.99) and the lunch price for the pizza ($13.49 - which is what I was charged), and calculated that that only corresponds to a 15.63% discount. So both employees told me a discount that wasn't true! Then the counter employee said there was also a "service fee". Because I had not been told about that, I asked what that was, and she said that the fee is explained in words at the bottom of the menu. That's true, but that statement is not something that catches a customer's eye when they order something. I'm guessing most people see a price listed next to each menu item, and assume that that price is what they will pay (plus the usual addition of sales tax, of course). (FYI: The statement says that the fee is something to offset the fact that employee hourly wages have gone up because of the WA state minimum wage laws.) So, my small pizza cost me over $15, even after the lunch discount was applied. Once I got home, I went to the Alfy's web site. It does NOT have the long text explanation of the fee that the store menu had. The web site says: "All guest checks incur a 8% service charge. For our statement, please review the menu(s) below." But I checked EVERYTHING related to the menus listed below, and elsewhere on the web site, and there was NO statement! I also started a test online order. If a person does this: after you've already chosen the items you want to order, and after you then go to check out, the cart check-out window lists a line item called "taxes and fees". That window also contains a small round icon with an "i" on it. You have to know to click on that to get some info about the "taxes and fees". If you do that, you get the following statement below the individual fee amount: "Set by restaurants to help cover operational costs." That statement is totally useless for explaining to you why the fee is there. Shouldn't "operational costs" just be figured into the price of the products or services sold? That's the way businesses usually do it. (And Alfy's should do that too.) Now, to sum it all up, I have two problems with my recent experience at Alfy's: 1) The lunch discount I got (15.63%) was different than what I was told it was going to be over the phone (35%) and at the counter (25%). I'm not sure I would have decided to go there for only a 15.63% discount (considering that it used to be a 50% discount before Covid19 stopped the dine-in service. Even the 35% figure was making me think twice. Hopefully the employees on the phone and at the counter did not tell me the wrong figure intentionally. I'd like to think they probably didn't (they both seemed nice). But they really should have known the correct figure to tell people over the phone, and then at the counter. This incident may or may not have caused my to stop going to this Alfy's location in and of itself. ... But now on to: 2) What I have the major issue with is the 8% "service fee". The way this fee is handled and disclosed is misleading (and probably intentionally misleading). I believe that businesses should always pay a fair "living wage" to their employees, so they don't have to rely on tips to make a decent amount of money. And if places need to raise employee wages because of minimum wage laws, they should just factor that in as one of their expenses, and set the menu prices accordingly. That way the price for an item that a customer sees on the menu accurately reflects what they will be paying (other than the state sales tax that has always needed to be added.) This practice of adding on a special "service fee" (whether it's here at Alfy's, or at any other restaurant, fast food place, or fast-casual place) is something I object to. And I will no longer patronize any place that does this. So Alfy's, in general, is a chain that I will never go to again. I'm giving this place 2 stars instead of 1 star because the pizza actually tasted pretty good. And the employees were nice. read more

Bought two carry out pizzas, one was perfect, one had burnt crust on the bottom about the color of chocolate. I called Alphy's from home about the problem and they checked with the guy who boxed the pizza. He said it was fine. Well, okay then--but he doesn't have to eat the pizza. They offered to knock $5 off the total retroactively. Even so, the tomato sauce tasted like ketchup, and the cheese stopped 2-1/2 " from the edge of the crust. I'm not overly picky about food, but that was not a satisfying experience. We used to like Alphy's, so I don't gleefully write this complaint, and there is no reason to go back. read more

I have gone to Alfy's in Everett quite a few times & enjoyed the unlimited salad bar. I went to the Alfy's in Marysville on 4/23/25. It was after lunchtime about 2-3 in the afternoon. I wanted to try their unlimited salad bar. To my disappointment I noticed the special greens lettuce was empty so I asked if they could refill? No, they were out! Ok! went and grabbed the bagged iceberg lettuce instead. I filled my plate with what choices they did offer. I have to say I have worked in the deli business 22 years & maintained many High quality & choice salad bars! So, I notice the standard of this salad bar. The pasta salad should of been pulled, no labels on the salad dressings! I was disappointed. So I did choose the offerings that looked fresh. I was full. When paying at first, I chose to give a 15% tip. I know the food industry is hard work. I went up to the counter to ask for a to go cup for my remaining soda & was told, "we have no to go cups"! So your customers cannot buy soda drinks to go? Weird!! Needless to say, I will not return! When i choose to eat somewhere & spend my money it is again disappointing to pay for poor service & subpar food especially when it is a treat you give yourself! I decided to tip afterwards not before I eat now. read more

Staff was extremely rude. I was attempting to partake in the arcade and the staff was rude, talking about the restrooms are for customers only and ran to get a manager who was even more rude and short than the first staff member. The place looked dirty and smelled funny too. Don't eat here, don't even try to give them money because they don't care about the public. Rude staff, will never eat their overrated pizza. read more

I love Alfy's and always have! As others have mentioned, it's a Snohomish county staple that must be preserved. The crust, sauce, and cheese are so good and unique. read more

Called in a to go order of two large pizzas and both were excellent. Garlic chicken is amazing as was the pepperoni. The person who took the order and the person at the counter for pickup were very friendly. read more

My friend and I went for the Monday senior salad bar. The woman behind the counter was rude. A senior salad bar and soda for me came to over $10. I've been eating at Alfys salad bar for years, especially Mondays. I know costs are rising, but $10? When I was there a few weeks ago, I came in at 3:00 and wanted the salad bar. She said they only have the salad bar for seniors until 2:00. Its always been all day on Mondays. This woman was just plain rude both times. I looked at the menu and didn't see anywhere that the salad bar was only til 2:00. When I was there about 6 weeks ago, a young woman was working and salad and soda came to under $6. She was very sweet. I have no complaints about the food, just the one woman and I'm finished with Marysville Alfys! No wonder they are all going out of business! read more

The best pizza in town. No contest. If I had to pick only one food to eat for the rest of my life it would be Alfy's, not joking. The cheese blend and the sauce are perfect and the crust is always soft but chewy. This is what I think of when I think "pizza", everything else is just a pale imitation. It IS expensive but if you order after 2pm on Wednesday, Friday, Saturday or Sunday they have a special which takes it back to ~$14 for a large after tax, which competes with Pizza Hut and Domino's, and it's a way tastier pizza than you'll get at those places. You can also get a U-Bake which is always half price and it tastes the same if you cook it at home. Alfy's has been my favorite pizza since I was a very small child, and it's still just as good as it always was. It breaks my heart to see the bad reviews on this page and to see them going out of business. I have literally never had a bad experience with anybody at these places, they have been normal pizza shop staff as far as I have seen. And I come here *often*, I was coming here once a week for a while. Hard working normal people just making food. I sincerely hope they stay open. read more

I have been to this place twice in the past month, I'm surprised at how many poor reviews there are. My experience was fine. They are busy and the management has no problem ruling with an iron fist, when kids are running around causing a disruption they get yelled at and asked where there parents are, kids then proceed to lie to parents saying they weren't running around. Next issue management tells them to leave. Not unreasonable in my opinion. I was glad as that customers dramatic departure made for a nicer experience as the parents could not seem to control there children. Food was great, but it can get rowdy pretty quick. Still one of my most preferred pizzas. read more

I'll be the first one to admit that when I get hungry and frustrated I am not the one you want to deal with. It was a hangry emergency, after driving around for 2 hours looking for an address that didn't exist, they brought me into alfy's Pizza. I got the Royal Alfie something or other, mostly cuz the company that I work for has Royal in the title. Yes that is how I pick what I'm having for lunch. I got a little scared after I ordered and read the reviews of the place. Many of them said that they were rude and had very bad customer service. But the girl that I was helped by was super awesome and got my food ready quickly and if I would have had time I totally would have stopped at the salad bar that looked delicious. The toppings were all very fresh and the dough was perfect....slightly crispy on the bottom and doughy on top it was amazing. I really enjoyed their pizza sauce as well a lot of places is super bland but this had flavor and seasoning in it all in all it was a great experience and I will definitely be going back if I am ever in town again read more

Alfy's Pizza - a pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Marysville, Washington

Loved going to the Silver Lake location because the pizza was great and people were super nice. This one in Marysville is the exact opposite. The staff and specially the blond lady is incredibly rude. I tried to raise an issue and her response was "find some other place to eat". Sad to see, the owners are not doing anything about all the negative reviews... loosing loyal customers everyday. Really sad... I used to look forward to eating at Alfy's but those days are gone and so is my business read more

What a dump and so rude. Stopped by for a pizza to take home and it smelled like mold and rotten food. Waited forever to get served, the place was totally empty. Manager was super rude to my son who just asked a question about types of crusts. How this place stays open I have no idea. There's tons of pizza places in Marysville, go somewhere else. read more

alfys pizza is my favorite joint. it's local, it's fresh, has good customer service, and it's delicious. all i need for a good pizza place! the only thing I could think negatively is the pricing, and even then I would say its better than most local pizza places. if your ever on a trip through the middle of Washington, this is DEFINITLY the place to go. Would recommend every time. read more

Pizza is not the same. Cold Different ingredients Customer not their Chicken wings are like rubber Chicken Gave delivery guy $20 tip on Christmas eve not even thank you Would ask for the money back what's the point. Next time its DiGiorno read more