The food is always top notch for a small rustic diner in Allamuchy just off exit 19 from I-80 in NJ. Service can slow down when they are busy, but we think that the food is worth the wait. read more

Except for Stefanie the staff had no idea what to do. It was a hot day and place was crowded. We unfortunately had the table right by the door. People piled in on top of us. Instead of clearing tables so people could sit the staff just stared at them. The door was left open and it was so hot inside. I kept getting up to shut it when people left. After waiting 40 minutes for our food my husband didn't even get what he ordered. When telling our waitress she just said I thought it looked wrong. Waitress never came to refill drinks or ask how we were doing. Stefanie who was not our waitress helped us. Won't be back!! read more

We stopped at this rustic diner on our way through town. The service was good and our food came out quickly. My chicken salad was pretty basic and didn't come with any sides. The rest of my group seemed to enjoy their sandwiches. read more

Allamuchy Diner - Chicken Salad Sandwich - Diners Near Me - Hackettstown, New Jersey

Stopped here for a quick bite while driving though. Had an expansive menu full of lots of entering options. I had the French toast sandwich which was really good and I had never seen anything like it. Everyone else liked their food as well. The service was good and the vibes inside were cozy but comfortable. Would recommend. read more

Allamuchy Diner - French toast sandwich - Diners Near Me - Hackettstown, New Jersey

Such a cute little cozy diner! Conveniently located right off the highway Allamuchy Diner offers hometown vibes and great food. I stopped by for breakfast and was not disappointed. Erica our server was so sweet and service was quick! I enjoyed the two eggs, which I had scrambled covered in cheese with sausage and hashbrown that came as a big portion for a great price at around $12! I'll be back for more! read more

Allamuchy Diner - Diners Near Me - Hackettstown, New Jersey

Short & sweet here. Great, char- broiled burgers & decent fries. I mean that real, honest- to - god, just - off - the - grill flavor. You can get a smashed burger just about anywhere, but real Char Broiled is like an endangered species. Also, the waitresses are real sweethearts. A lot of other creative breakfast/lunch/dinner items on menu. If I ordered everything that struck my fancy, I'd be as big as a house. No Coke, Pepsi. Oh yeah, super convenient EZ on/off RT 80. Why stop for crappy fast food, when you can elevate the experience? read more

This place is easy to get to from exit 19. On route 80 3 minutes Worth it 100%. I cant wait to try out their breakfast that everyone raves about So i went back for the second time i can honestly say the food i had was really good. I had the Spanish chicken and my wife had the turkey dinner we were both impressed The cook came to my table and introduced himself he really showed how much he cares about the people who come to his restaurant? I told him a him little about myself and said i asked him about his back ground in the restaurant business When i told him how good his food was and how much i love the diner you can see the smile of a proud man. They really work hard and they have really good food. I recommend the beef stew. The beef stew is excellent beyond excellent but the other food is good and I'm gonna continue going there and try all that all the dishes. I'm very intrigued by their menu. It's not a big menu. It's not a menu that looks like a book. It's a simple menu with chef specials and I'm impressed by their knowledge and food. I love places that name their restaurant or diner after the town that they have their business and it shows they want to be part of the community and they're proud of that community and the way they act the way they are in their personality. They show their love for all the town of allamuchy You never know who will show up at this place or this location in the future read more

See all

I just had sausage and eggs at 7:00pm. This rustic, quaint diner has a massive menu that they serve allConveniently located right off Rt. 80. I can't believe I haven't been here sooner. Great food and reasonably priced. Stephanie and Arianna will see to it that you will enjoy great service. This will be my new go to place when I leave work. I strongly recommend this establishment. read more

Great food and atmosphere. If you in area sh may not be your place. It's time to relax and injoy your company.

Worth a trip and supporting. A historic building in allamuchy and just off 80 exits. Good variety of offerings and staff is very welcoming. read more

Awesome club sandwich and the sweet potato fries were CRISPY which is not the case at most places. Husband enjoyed his burger as well.

Newly opened diner with a nice menu. We have tried it twice. Food is very good - we have enjoyed the Greek salad with chicken (large portion) & Chicken salad platter. Coffee & iced tea are good; soda options are very limited as owner is still get that set up. Service is a little sketchy hence the reason I took a star off. We walked in & saw 4 waiters/waitresses standing around while a dirty table was sitting there. When my husband ordered his coffee, waitress brought it without milk or a spoon so he had to ask. Ordering my salad was challenging; waitress did not know what it was & I had to show her the menu & when I asked for no olives, she didn't understand me until I told her 3 times to take them off & luckily my salad did not have olives. I would definitely go back & I hope the service improves. Owner is cooking so he needs someone experienced to run the front of house. read more

Allamuchy Diner - Excellent Greek Salad - Diners Near Me - Hackettstown, New Jersey

Knowing the Allamuchy Diner had been highly reviewed for their outstanding breakfasts, we chose our first visit to be an early dinner to challenge their menu. Cozy indeed, seating quite limited, so we were fortunate to get a center table. Service efficient and friendly, and the fare did not disappoint! Many times I measure the quality of the kitchen by the fries served. Shortcuts are most evident here, and again the Allamuchy Diner served up first rate Sweet Potato fries, fresh, hot, crisp on the outside, cloud-like fluffy on the inside. It would be very telling on how the rest of the casual meal would go. We opted for sandwiches, and they were carefully prepared, generous in portion, and again, fresh! Obviously quality ingredients with a homemade touch! Look for my next review for the breakfast, I'm sure we'll be back to sample that strong suit soon. Go here. read more

Great little spot! Hidden gem! Stephanie was kind and accommodating. Would come back again.

I saw good reviews on this place so we gave it a go. First the parking was on the street not sure if there was a lot but if there was it needs a sign to state "diner parking".The service was good a very nice young lady was super.The food quality was good it tasted great no problems. The amount of food not great no sides included with our sandwich ? not good at the price point they charge. The place is small and to be honest its a breakfast lunch type of place don't go for dinner its not on a restaurant level it looks more like a deli or take out bakery. All things considered i give this place a 3 out of 5 stop here for breakfast or a bite for lunch but thats it. To improve expanding is needed or move to a new location also more food was needed sides for all items at these prices should be offered. read more

Allamuchy Diner - French toast ham and egg sandwich. - Diners Near Me - Hackettstown, New Jersey

Awesome breakfast! Highly recommend all the staff is friendly. The corn beef hash with eggs over medium and hashbrowns was really tasty and came out very hot! read more

Allamuchy Diner - Diners Near Me - Hackettstown, New Jersey

The food came pretty quick, but service was so bad. Our waiter checked on us at the very end long after all of our waters were empty and we were done eating. We had to get up and grab salt, pepper, ketchup and hot sauce. And we also saw other patrons do the same, so this was not a one off. The atmosphere is pretty cozy, but nothing about this place (portions were okay for cost) would compel us to come back. Expected more since this place has pretty good reviews and is a local diner. read more

All I can say is Wow. Best Breakfast ever! I'm usually disappointed in how Belgium Waffles are made but these are exactly how I liked them. My husband had the Scramble Egg Special with Blue Cheese it was amazing too! The prices to me are to be expected. Can wait to go back. read more

First time visiting. Food was fantastic. I had the special. Fajitas with chicken and shrimp. My husband had the pork giabott. My dad has flounder francaise. Everything was served nice and hot and fresh. We will definitely be going back. read more

Food was flavorful but waited way too long for it, two other tables served ahead of us and we didnt get anything complicated. Given nothing more than an apology, maybe a free drink next time? And one of the waitresses talked the whole time we were there, loud enough that we had trouble focusing on our own conversation. Won't be back. Thankfully don't live all that close. read more

Such a gem! Great food, friendly, convenient, clean. We loved it! French toast (which we had for dessert) was amazing!!

I picked up dinner from this place two Thursdays ago stopped in. Alex is The counter person. He is so nice so helpful. I had ordered the fish special over brown rice. . My husband had chicken wrap and I got grilled cheese for my son with French fries. My meal was enough for 3 people. There was so much food read more

Used to be a great place for a quiet meal but now they're blasting politics on the radio. Who you vote for is not my business but I don't enjoy my eggs with a side of proselytizing (on either side). There was also a customer's dog in the dining room which is a health hazard. There are other diners. read more

I always loved their breakfast especially the turkey bacon which always came out crispy and the tea was freshly brewed. This time, not so much. They changed their tea which is now a teabag and they changed their mugs. The service was terrible. No good morning. We got do you want drinks. No smile, nothing. When our order came, the eggs were lukewarm and bacon was soggy. No butter on toast. I had to ask for butter and when it came it was hard as a rock. I was so looking forward to breakfast but this time I was so disappointed. It will take a while for me to go back. The diner was busy. But no excuses for service and quality of food. Just get back to basics. Good Service and Hot Food. read more

Stopped in for lunch. Sat quickly and was amazed at the menu. Loads of choices! Got the Brooklyn sandwich. Wow! No leftovers. Can't wait to come back again. You can eat three meals a day here and it's at a great spot right off Rt 80. read more

Not hard to find, the atmosphere is very charming. Very Clean and... Great Food & Excellent Service!!! You will be amazed read more

Excellent food. Reasonable prices. Superb service. We have been there twice in the last week and will certainly become regulars. Rustic, comfortable, hometown ambiance. read more

We live locally and we are so excited that this place is open and that all are so nice and accomodating! We all loved our food and we brought our own wine! Portion sizes were very good for the price and everyone there including the other patrons were all so friendly! Mikey our server was very sweet and attentive. The owner came over and greeted us as well! We will definitely be going back! read more

you guys HAVE to try the hash browns! literally so delish! I wish I took a pic of the food but it just looked so good and I was hungry hehe!

First time visit today. My children and I all enjoyed our meals. Everything was fresh and the service was great! We live in the area and will return for sure!! read more

This is a cute diner in Allamuchy. The burgers were excellent cooked perfectly, juicy and the bun was tasty. I will definitely go back to try a special. read more

very cute cozy country maybe 8-10tablez/booths. good fresh food and sized portions at reasonable price. great find!!

Great diner food close to home! We had the Brooklyn Sandwich with Onion Rings and Tuna Melt with Fries. Both were delicious! Great service in an old general store with vintage decor. Would definitely recommend! read more

Allamuchy Diner - Brooklyn Sandwich with Onion Rings - Diners Near Me - Hackettstown, New Jersey

Had been here when it was the General Store and returned not realizing it had been recreated as a Diner. Atmosphere is the same with a general store vibe. Stayed and had the bacon cheeseburger with a side of fries extra crispy. Wife had fried egg, hash browns and bacon. Service was super friendly and the food was excellent. Great burger, perfectly cooked, fries were some of the best I have had and my wife's breakfast was very fresh tasting. Music played in the back round but we could still hear each other. Very chill vibe during the week around 2ish. Will definitely be returning to try out some other favorites. read more

The service is so slow and chaotic! We literally sat for 10 minutes no coffee, nothing!! Two tables came in after us got their coffee and then another!! It was literally ridiculous! We just up and left and we saw another table leave as well. I wish I could say that was the first time we had this experience there! Every time you wait and everyone avoids you til they can get to you! Ive been in the food industry my whole life, a quick Im sorry someone will be with you shortly goes a long way!! Its a shame! The place is in walking distance! They just lost what could have been regular customers! read more

Delicious breakfast and super attentive service! I had a veggie omelet and all the veggies were fresh. The service was super friendly and attentive too! Couldn't ask for more! read more

I've been here to eat and have ordered out. Both excellent experiences! Dining in, we had wonderful service and loved both meals that we had. Ordering out, food was great again. Fresh food and awesome food choices. Can't wait to either dine in or order out from here again! read more

I had breakfast here with my wife on my birthday. There was a good number of choices. The food was above average, and I thought the prices were pretty good compared to some other places. The environment was nice, creative and old timey. The only improvement could have been checking in more if we needed anything. I would have liked a refill on my coffee and people providing good service will usually notice and ask you, but I won't subtract a star for that. I can see myself returning when going out to dinner, and maybe we'll bring our kids next time. read more

The food and service were top notch. Perfectly cozy & quant. Great spot! Try the patty melt.