Excellent pizza! Plenty of options! Portions are huge! Friendly staff! Sooooo goooddd

I love Amalfi. I lived close by and got ready to order pizza there often and was never disappointed. Having a neighborhood pizza spot - and a GREAT ONE - was the best. read more

Just passing through on way to MD. stopped last week and returning for another carry out pizza. Creative combinations. crust just the right thickness. thinner then most but not too thin. trying the stuffed pizza this time. two layers! plenty of room and tables if you want to eat in. Fast too. they say 15 min. pizza ready in 5 read more

Amalfi Pizza - great pizza - Pizza Near Me - Newark, Delaware

See all

Terrible experience. Order online and get an order number. They send an email saying the order will be ready in 30 minutes. My wife goes to pick up and is told it will be an additional 30 minutes because "that pizza takes an hour to cook." Just having the order number is not enough to pick up the pizza, they need a picture of the order and what was ordered and god knows what else. We will never order from these disorganized and obnoxious people again. Avoid this place, go somewhere where they care about customer service. read more

Loved it, great food I have no complaints. I ended up getting the meat lovers pizza the grand mom and wings. Side salad was nothing to fancy simple but over all an amazing place read more

Ordered their stuffed pizza, took it back to the hotel. There was so much grease dripping through the cardboard I put a plastic bag under it to protect the table. I took one bite, spit it out, threw the whole thing away, and reordered takeout at another restaurant. read more

Huge servings! Great folk! Very home style and welcoming feel to the place! Doesn't look like a lot from the outside, but worth giving it a shot! I had their new tortellini special and it was worth the money! read more

The place is bomb!!!! Amazing service, on top of that amazing food! We were visiting family and stopped by to get a slice but ended up getting a whole pie! Literally best New York pizza without taking a drive to New York to get a slice! I saw a couple of people's plates also and the food was very nice and smelled great! Now whenever we visit we buy two pies to take home! read more

See all

Best garlic knots for miles around. At the price of 4 for $1 they are truly a steal. They always feature interesting and unique pizza choices like Philly Cheesesteak or Vodka pasta pizza. For a healthier option, try the chicken Cesar wrap. With grilled chicken and delicious home made chips it makes the perfect lunch! Also featuring traditional Italian dishes like chicken Parmesan and homemade gnocchi, Amalfi is a great casual takeout Italian option. read more

Heard that it was a great place to stop by for food so went in for a take out pizza to give it a try. I went with a standard pepperoni, mushroom, olive, and onion pizza. I tend to get a similar pizza when I try a new place so I can see how it compares to other pizza places I have been before. First off I was told that they were out of mushrooms since a delivery was late. it was around 1300 or so, so they had been open for a bit and had not solved this ingredient problem. But I pushed on and got my pizza anyway san mushrooms. I got home with my pepperoni, olive, and onion pizza to find that my "pepperoni" pizza was mistakenly topped with peppers. Unfortunately green peppers are the pizza topping I dislike the most so this was a unfortunate problem. After picking the peppers off I am now left with an olive onion pizza. Not quite the best lunch. The sauce was average without a heavy complexity. The dough was well made with a good resistance to it but perhaps a little underbaked with the lunch rush. The staff were very nice and friendly. Judging by the other reviews perhaps I had an atypical experience. At some point I will go back and give it another try and see how things are and post an update. read more

Amazing place, huge portions. Split an entre seriously! Amazing service, menu. So glad we stopped in based on the other reviews. Great value read more

Amalfi Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Newark, Delaware

My friend and I came here at around 6pm, unknowing that it was closing soon (certain day of the week). Chairs were up and employees were cleaning but they still let us order from what pizza they had left. They saw we were a little disappointed in ourselves for coming in last minute and not having the selection we hoped, so the owner so nicely gave us each an extra slice of whatever we chose for free. Good people. read more

Every time I get lunch from here with my co workers im super satisfied with the portions and have left overs for dinner too. The smiley is my favorite sandwich. I almost wish it was smaller though because I can barely fit it in my mouth. Tasty place though. read more

Leaving Delaware, I thought I would grab a quick bite before hitting the road and along comes a "$4 for two slices" sign. If that wasn't lucky enough, it was some fantastic pizza! This is the kind of pizza you can't get down south. Call it NY style if you want, but this Delaware pizza shop was awesome ! read more

it was disappointing place to dine in. they failed to provide customer service. When i called the pizza place and was told to hold for 30 minutes. read more

Personal Favorites: Eggplant, Tortellini, definitely Calamari Style: Italian Ambiance: Average Pizza Place Service: It is kind of self-service but Staff is pretty nice. Note: Amalfi is one of the best in the area for pizza. They don't do delivery except you order lot:) Like $75 a lot. read more

The best pizza by far! Fried calamari is better than anywhere I ever had . Great selection read more

See all

I love coming here for lunch. The slices are piled high with great toppings, and there some good, creative combos too. Today, I had a slice piled high with sauce, cheese, sausage (whole pieces, not crumbled), and peppers. Their sandwiches are also good, and seem to take on the mantra that "everything is better covered in sauce and cheese," which is of course true. It's also pretty reasonably priced. 2 fancy slices will fill you up, and I can eat a lot, and only cost you $6. The only downside is that everything seems very salty. It doesn't taste salty, but every time I eat here I find myself crazy thirsty for the rest of the day. read more

My cohort and I, when we have get togethers, usually get Amalfi. The double pepperoni pizza is a huge favorite of ours.

Yesterday, I had Almafi's cater a party I had for my residents. Most of my residents are older so I requested the Chicken Marsala to be cut in small pieces instead of whole breasts. It was perfect! My residents were thrilled with the entire meal. The Caesar Salad was delicious and they were willing to substitute any type of pasta instead of spaghetti for the Pasta Marsala. We will be using Almafi's again. read more

Their food is always great, I love their cold sandwiches and their pizza is just amazing. The only reason they're not getting 5 stars from me is because it seems like every single employee there is nice except that one girl that takes orders and rings people up. So rude. I'm not the kind of person who won't leave a tip, but I honestly feel like an idiot every time that girl throws a receipt and a pen on the counter and just walks away from me and I'm standing there and writing on a tip for her. It will be hard but I will have to stop tipping her, I guess. I work hard for the money I make and I always make sure to make my customers feel welcome, I don't see why she can't do the same. read more

I work near there and it's usually my Friday stop. Yesterday my husband placed an order and I picked up. I went to the counter and the girl was extremely rude from the start., I wasn't sure if he placed the order online or by phone. I gave her the order number that he texted me and she said we don't use numbers. I gave the name and items ordered and she literally looked for 10 seconds and said we don't have that order and moved onto the next person. I went outside and called my husband. He sent me screenshots with the number that he was given by the female who took the order. I called that number and the rude girl at the counter answered. I walked back up to her and gave her his name and order again and told her that this the number that he called and $29 was taken from his card from here. I told her the name and order again and she magically found my order in the same place that she had looked 10 minutes earlier. And I know that it was there the entire time because the order was placed to be picked up at 5:15p and I arrived at 5:35pm because I got off work late. She handed me the order and said here with a nasty tone. I love the food there but last night the service was horrible! Funny part is that a co worker heard me talking about going there and she said that the service has been horrible lately. I replied that I've never had an issue but I've also never seen that employee there either. I gave 1 star because of the rude service but the food is always 4-5 stars. Sad that 1 employee can ruin it. read more

Really good Italian food! I got lost and ran into this place and my dad and I decided to try it. Both our sandwiches were really good. We had the chicken parmesan which I loved and we had the meatball sandwich which my dad thought was better. Overall a really great place to have some very good Italian food. read more

Hands down one of the best pizza places in Newark, Delaware. They always have a variety of pizza, desert, sandwiches and side options on the counter. If you dine in your hostess also brings you a plethora of bread and a side salad. They also have a student discount of 10% off of your entire order. Definitely try this place if you're craving Italian. read more

Amalfi Pizza - {Vodka pasta is to die for and the portions are so generous! Definitely worth coming back!} - Pizza Near Me - Newark, Delaware

Called my order in for a medium pizza, half cheese-half pepperoni. I was told that it would be ready in approximately 20-25 minutes. When I arrived in about 30 minutes the pizza wasn't even in the oven yet. Of course I waited for another 20 minutes or so; in the meantime I inquired about the cost of the Italian ice cups. The cashier girl obviously assumed I was only purchasing one (1) icee and therefore felt the need to tell me about the $6.00 minimum debit card purchase policy. Fact is, I wanted to and did, in fact, buy 5 of them. After finally getting home with my pizza and Italian ice I discovered that the pizza was half cooked and looked extremely unappealing. There was a large glob of cheese sitting in the middle of the pie and pepperoni was carelessly strewn on it. THE ABSOLUTE WORST PIZZA EVER!!!! I was terribly disappointed about the quality of the pie; the outer crust was half baked and the bottom was soft and greasy. In short, I ended up throwing the pizza in the garbage can. That was my first time patronizing this business, and I seriously doubt if I'll ever return. I'm a big stickler for quality service, and they failed miserably. Back to Pizza Hut!!! read more

Excellent, authentic Italien food at good prices. I love their home-style soups. Their pizzas are great too and you can select among about a dozen varieties by the slice. The small place can become rather busy at lunch time. read more

Amalfi Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Newark, Delaware

Quick last minute decision to grab some grub has turned into my new "go to" for pizza! Great selection here. I just tried chicken Cesar salad pizza and can't get over how yummy it is. Wish they had late night hours and delivery! The dining area was a mess. I'm not holding that against them as its lunch time and they could be short staffed. The folks next to us both ordered the chef salad and I believe a family of four could've eaten off one of them! 18.00 and change bought us four slices of gourmet pizza and two drinks. Full as a tick! #bestpizza read more

Amalfi Pizza - Tomato and ricotta next to the chicken Cesar slice. Sorry the pic quality stinks! - Pizza Near Me - Newark, Delaware

See all

Awesome pizza, the New Yorker is my favorite but so is My Grandmothers and the Meatlovers pizza. It is hard to decide when every pizza is so good. read more

We have eaten here many, many times! The food is so good! And you get a lot of food for your $. The employees are oh, so nice and service is great! You won't regret coming here to have pizza, salads, soup, fried calamari, pasta dishes, etc. If you order the penne vodka with prosciutto ($15), you'll have enough good for 2-3 meals! read more

This is easily my favorite pizza in Newark if not Delaware. The only exception I would say is for wood fired pizza, I see that as a separate category. This is New York style (not comparing to NY pizza). They use fresh ingredients like garlic, tomatoes, veggies & it's consistently good every time. read more

This pizza is the best in the area I recommend getting a fresh pie if you are going to order more than a few slices. My favorite is their white pizza but their BBQ chicken and then chicken Alfredo come in second and third. It gets really busy at lunch so if you are ordering by the pizza I recommend calling ahead and getting take out. It can be crowded and get a little loud if you dine in. read more

Amalfi Pizza - Chicken Alfredo pizza :) so good! - Pizza Near Me - Newark, Delaware

This place has everything you could imagine . I have not ordered anything I didn't like from here. You may have to wait but it is well worth it . They have the best sausage and peppers sub read more

Family and friends had dinner there Saturday night. Daughter is on a GF diet and we ordered her the Gluten free pizza. She said it was the best one that she has ever had...she has tried ALOT of GF pizza so that is saying something Overall the food was good..everyone loved the "tomato pie" they put on the table before you order too! read more

I miss their pizza the most about Delaware, and this location specifically. Buffalo chicken and if we are balling out a tiramisu - fuego Diego, love everyone there. Houston pizza is trash fam read more

Extremely friendly service and best pizza with so many varieties to choose from!!! Excellent cheesesteaks!!! The menu is huge, can't wait to try something else! My new favorite place!!! read more

I had one of the best cheese steaks at this place, the bread/roll was so fresh as was the steak, veggies and cheese; it was like heaven on a bun . The only draw back I could see was the seating is limited and it can get crowded quickly but take out works just as well for food this good. read more

For a little shopping center pizza place, this place is amazing! Like 25 kinds of pizza available by the slice. Their grandma's pizza is fantastic! I order pizza for 100 people here a few times a year for work and it's always on time. read more

I love to get take away here. Everything is good from the pizza pie to the pasta and the portions are generous as well as delicious! I find them to be friendly and fast. I couldn't pick a favorite because it's all so good! read more

Was craving some pizza so ordered from here. Got a half veggie pizza and half cheese pizza. Pizza was delicious, probably the best I've had here in Delaware. Got it to go but staff was friendly when we picked it up. The garlic knots were pretty good too. All in all, a pretty solid place. Will try some of their pasta next time because the pictures of it look super tempting. read more

The pizza is good but don't overlook their entrees. Tonight we had the Seafood Dinner which is shrimp, scallops & crab with red sauce over capellini. Wow was it good - the crab was nice & sweet and gave the sauce a wonderful flavor. Before Covid, in addition to the regular menu they also had great nightly specials which were alway great. We can't wait to be able to return to dine-in eating. read more