Everything was perfect. I could drink the sauce they put on that sandwich.... Tangy, sweet, smooth.... It works. I live on the Hill and there are no shortages on sandwich places. It's nice to have them back in the neighborhood. Recipes might have changed over the years but it is still a solid sandwich. The service was spot on. Seamless ordering and my food was on my table within 7 minutes from ordering. The owner came and checked on me as did the cashier. Don't forget to get a piece of cheesecake read more

See all

We went to this Amighettis when we were in town visiting family. Amighettis has always been so good and a real STL institution. Evidently not any more, however. We ordered a full Amighettis special to share and our daughter ordered a half special plus a side salad. She ordered a grilled cheese for her son. We got our full special fairly quickly even though it appeared as if the person who waited on us quit after she took our order (not sure, but she left hurriedly with her purse on her arm). Our daughter finally got her half sandwich but only after we went up to the counter to get it. We were finished eating our sandwich by this time. The grilled cheese was sitting there several minutes later and so we went up to get that too. It wasn't even grilled. It was two pieces of bread with a minimal amount of cheese and was barely melted. Not hot at all. Her son wouldn't even eat it. It was disgusting. We left before even getting the side salad. There was one person taking orders after the other person left and the line to order was nearly to the door when we were leaving. It's really too bad. Amighettis was always such a treat and someplace we liked to visit when in town. We won't be back again. read more

Amighetti's has bagels!!! They are tasty, "real" bagels and at 10:30am on Sunday morning there was still a great selection. CWE is no longer a "bagel desert"! read more

Original and the best! Like no others. This is the place. Also, other very good options here. read more

I think most people might agree that a sandwich isn't a sandwich without good bread and that's what people went to Amighetti's s for was their homemade chewy sesame bread that you had to have to pull a little bit with your teeth... so with that being said, I was so disappointed when the bread was soft with no texture at all. It would be great if they found a bakery on the hill that would make them a bread similar because the fillings are still fabulous! read more

I had the chicken Parmesan and my wife had the tortellini. My meal was OK however, it seem like the chicken had been cooked most of the day. The penne pasta did not seem to be thoroughly cooked and the red sauce resembled an over-the-counter sauce like Ragu. My wife's tortellini and sauce, lacked seasoning, and seem to be a little bland in flavor. Not what I expect after paying $55. Regarding the service, you order at a counter and it was delivered to your table. unless you are going to order a sandwich, the flavor may be better. If you're going to order a plate meal like we did, I would recommend another restaurant. read more

The sandwiches are so good that I had to return within a week because my husband, who was not with me in my 1st visit, wanted to enjoy an Amighetti's special. He has always loved their sandwiches. He did notice the bread was different than the original bread. Original bread was more crusty. I however like the new bread! To each their own right! This visit I tried the little bit of Italy sandwich with salami and olives on cheese garlic bread. I had them omit the onions cause I don't eat them. It was good but way too salty. Like maybe used garlic salt instead of powder?? The staff were friendly but not enough of them. It took us almost 30 minutes to get sandwiches to go. The gal apologized profusely and anyone could see that she was doing th e best she could but with only 3 people there on Friday dinner hour it was too much. This is one issue they must work on to help ensure a thriving business. read more

This location is on the edge of The Hill and is a homecoming of sorts. Location just across the street in Southwest Garden I tried a pick two option with a side. I even had a slice of cheese cake from Hanks which has a counter as a partnership in the same restaurant. My food was great. The tortellini Alfredo with peas was one of the best pasta dishes I have ever had in my life. I had a half meatball sandwich and a order of T-Ravs which are a staple around St. Louis. The Toasted Raviolis were a bit hallow, fortunately I filled the void with the sauce. The meatball sandwich was good too. The layout of this location is fun and feels like a friendly place to meet friends for lunch or a meal. The staff was very accommodating, fixing my friends order after it came to the table (which earned this review it's 5th star!). Unsure if I should find Hanks cheese cake and review it separately. But I'll do it justice here too. You order the cheesecake at the same counter as your food from Amighettis. I had a plain slice of cheesecake and place this in the top 5 slices I have ever had in my life! Bravo I will be back, most of the sandwich shops on The Hill have a narrow menu (mostly sandwich based). This joint has a much bigger menu and better hours. Kudos!! Oh, also a huge win is the soda fountain. They have two self serve stations. One for Coke products and one for Pepsi. To make everyone happy! read more

Amighettis - Hank's cheese cake display - Italian Near Me - Saint Louis, Missouri

See all

This is a class A establishment! I went on a weekday afternoon for lunch, and to pick up a package of cheesecakes. It is located in a beautiful modern building with lots of windows and tables to enjoy your meal. I was greeted as I walked in - the staff is so welcoming! I got an Amighettis special, which is the best, in my opinion. I like a lot of the veggies, and I usually ask for extra, but not at Amighettis - they always add enough! I also got a "big dill" pickle. They can cut them in half or fourths, or leave them whole! The pickle is outstanding, by the way! Then it was time for me to choose the Cheesecake flavors that I wanted. I thought I might just get a 4 pack, but then I looked at the case, and they told me what was available in the minis. Every one of them sounded so good! The staff saw that it was too hard for me to choose between all of them, so they wisely guided me to the dozen pack, and I am thrilled to have enough for days! So, to recap - the space is clean, cool, and modern. The menu is full of classic choices and is customizable to your preferences. The desserts are downright impressive and are always worth perusing when you visit! The friendly and warm staff is what makes a visit to Amighettis my top pick for sandwiches in St. Louis! read more

The food, the location, the service and again the food absolutely amazing!! The St. Louis Hill staple has returned with a vengeance and with back up (Hanks Cheesecake). The restaurant which was once a hardware store is perfectly decorated with gorgeous wood work on the ceiling. The place is large enough for at least 50 guests yet feels small and personable. The cheesecake is on display in the back of the restaurant and there were too many options to count. I had the pleasure of trying a variety of things meatballs, brussel sprouts, Amighetti's salad, hot sandwich and spaghetti. Everything was perfect I couldn't have found anything wrong if I wanted to. The staff was friendly and helpful. Mr. Favazza has brought back this local gem and paired it perfectly with another local favorite. Sweet treats and good eats, what more could you ask foyumm read more

See all

I've never been before so I called to ask when they closed (Yelp and Google hours differed), when the kitchen closed, and if I needed reservations. The woman on the phone was irritated, but we came anyway. It was totally empty. We stood in front of the menu board for a long time before anyone came from the kitchen to help us. We ordered toasted cheese ravioli, Italian salad, salmon sandwich, and a lasagna with meat sauce. We paid, sat down, and the food arrived all at once shortly. Each ravioli was disappointingly empty. I don't know if that's what happens to cheese toasted ravs, but it didn't look great. The salad was a bit flavorless. My lasagna tasted good but the pasta was rather thick. My daughter enjoyed her sandwich. Service wasn't really there. The space is nicely renovated. It was an okay experience but we probably wouldn't come back. read more

See all

Drove in from Wildwood and they had lost my order. Asked me if I wanted them to remake them. As opposed to donating $22.76???? WTF. In the end the sandwiches were poor at best. read more

Today was my first visit and I'm sad to say that I left disappointed. The bread on my chicken parmesan sandwich was very tough, which made it difficult to eat. It also wasn't flavorful at all. Pistachio cannoli was pretty good, but not enough to make me want to eat here again. read more

New space is wonderful! Bright and spacious. Dine in and pick up call in orders on the side. You can also just pop in thru the back side door for a slice of Cheesecake. Service at the back counter was super fire and helpful! I ordered 3 hot sandwiches to take; Chicken Parm, Beef and Gravy, and Italian. It was durring lunch time so there was a little extra wait which was to be expected. My name was called and my bagged sandwiches and chips were brought to me. My drive was 7 minutes away...From The Hill to Soulard. We opened the foil wrapped sandwiches and all of the top buns were hard as a rock! (Insert eye roll). Sandwiches use to be toasted but I guess they are NUKED to the life is zapped out of them, so they would literally have to be consumed immediately or minute by minute they harden to a cement cinder block! Had they not been NUKED to death this would have been a different review. I contemplated 2 stars but the customer service received at the Cheesecake counter wouldn't have been justified. I'll eventually give them another try. read more

Cool restaurant in an old hardware store. Everyone was friendly and notuch of a wait. I got the spaghetti Amighetti and loved it. They've got a bunch of Hank's Cheesecakes. I'm definitely getting that next time. read more

Amighettis - Inside - Italian Near Me - Saint Louis, Missouri

Love the meatball sandwiches and the side of pasta with it. Miss the store in the hill

Best subs in the world. Used to eat them for lunch 50 a long time ago... Still miss them. (They're still there, I'm not) read more

Amighetti's has good sandwiches. I love eating their Amighetti's Special sandwich with my large, cold soda. Their Hanks Original Cheesecake is so scrumptious. The employees were very friendly and helpful when my aunt asked about their cheesecake flavors. The interior of this place is relaxing and big for customers if they decide to dine in this place. We will come back to this place to order sandwiches for occasional visits. read more

Oh my goodness!! They have the best sandwiches. And the pasta salad is very good. We always have a sandwich there and bring one home for later. read more

I visited the new location in The Hill today with some co-workers and had a really great experience. Before visiting, I reached out to see what sort of vegan options were available. The owner, Anthony, was super helpful with making recommendations and everything I ended up ordering was absolutely delicious. I work really close to this location and look forward to coming back very soon. read more

Had the German Chocolate cake - best I've EVER had!! Staff is wonderful. Give gotta try this! Quiet (we were there for an early lunch on a Thursday) neighborhood establishment. read more

Delicious food. Wonderful service. The manager does such a great job. She really cares about the brand.

Each slice of bread is 3inch big with one slice of meat. Overated price for a 90% bread sandwich. I would suggest going to other sandwich show in the area. It use to be good. But as of late it's very bread heavy and overpriced. read more

Amighetti's Special - Mmm, that was good! Nice new space. I want to try the cannoli next time.

AMAZING. We wanted to go somewhere on the hill that was child friendly due to our ever moving 2 year old. Boy did Amighettis not disappoint. Multiple times the staff would come to our table JUST to play with our kid. Oh and the food was AMAZING! Even our picky eater went to town on the spaghetti! 10/10 read more

Didn't really like the sandwiches with nothing else to say!! got carryout don't know about and ambience that's all I got to say!

Not a good experience from any angle. Ordered pick up for 5:45 and arrived at 5:50. Bag was handed to me but upon inspection was missing a salad and drink. Counter person asked the woman making salads to correct the order on the fly, which she did. While I waited, I took a small plastic cup from the register and filled it with a soda as the drink was part of the children's meal I ordered. Salad lady approached me and asked if I wanted to pay for a soda or take water for free. I explained that the soda was part of my purchase and she immediately backpedaled, saying she was offering a free soda for the order errors. Nice try, but you said what you said. I paid $50 for some sandwiches, ma'am. I don't need to steal a Sierra Mist. Anyway, half of the sandwiches were soaking wet: the bread, the cheese, and lettuce were drenched and impossible to eat. Small salad was fine and the sandwich with the kid's meal was good. Insulting AND bad food? Hard pass. read more

Great first time there. Soups are killer. Cannot wait to have a sandwich and some cheese cakes

This place is a disaster. The music is turned up, I assume (!) to the highest volume possible. All the hard, unimpeded surfaces amplify that and then you have the customer chit-chat and the attempt of employees to take orders. I have no idea if the food is any good because the counter person and I could not communicate. The manager was 5 feet away engaged in a similar miscommunication with an older couple. read more

The food was good. Very similar to the old location on the hill, but the bread is not as good.

One star, Got the chicken salad sandwich.....hardly anything on the sandwich which was $12 bucks....also got a small salad with chicken and there was no chicken they just gave me a prepacked tiny salad for $9.50 missing the $2.99 chicken I purchased. The lady at the counter was new and she couldn't do the job and they just left her there struggling. The manager coughed a couple times into her hand then was handling food. I'll never go here again...small overpriced food at a poorly run restaurant. read more